DIS - Case Record for 89-0498-EL-COI Skip to main content

Case Record For:

89-0498-EL-COI

Case Title: CLEVE ELEC ILLUM/TOLEDO EDISON CO
Status: AR-Archived
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: COI-Commission inquiry
Date Opened: 3/27/1989
Date Closed: 6/3/1993
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
09/21/1994Entry ordering that the joint stipulation and recommendation filed on 8/15/94 and 8/18/94 (revised) is approved and adopted in its entirety as set forth; that the Companies's revised level of retail, annual jurisdictinal trust fund accruals and payment for the Companies' interests in Perry Unit #1, Davis-Besse Unit #1, and Beaver Valley #2 are included in CEI's and Toledo Edison's cost of service for ratemaking purposes and are reflected in current rates effective January 1, 1994; that this entry does not pre- clude the Commission from examining the estimation metho- dology and level of funding in any future proceeding in which the Companies request recovery of decommissioning costs. (4 pgs.)0
09/01/1994Calculations utilized to determine the revised nuclear decommissioning accruals and funding levels incorporated in CEI and Toledo Edison's joint stipulation and recom- mendation,filed on behalf of applicants by E. Mikkelsen. (7 pgs.)0
08/18/1994Joint stipulation and recommendation filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by T. Linnert; OCC by E. Robinson- McGriff; the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey-Gruber; IEC by L. Bell; and the City of Toledo by K. Bruce, submitted by E. Mikkelsen. (4)0
08/15/1994Joint stipulation and recommendation filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by T. Linnert, OCC by E. Robinson- McGriff, the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey-Gruber, and IEC by L. Bell. (5)0
10/15/1993Response of CEI to the City of Cleveland's statement and supplemental statement, submitted by M. Regulinski.0
09/24/1993Statement regarding response of Cleveland Electric Illum- inating Company to July 28, 1993 storm and the supplemental statement regarding response of Cleveland Electric Illum- inating Company to July 28, 1993 storm, filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by R. Bucklew, Jr.0
09/07/1993Response to the request of the City of Cleveland for a Commission ordered investigation, filed on behalf of CEI by M. Regulinski.0
08/16/1993Request for a Commission ordered investigation filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
08/12/1993Entry denying the companies' July 22, 1993 application for rehearing.0
08/11/1993Response and request for hearing filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
07/22/1993Application for rehearing and response to the Commission's entry dated June 24, 1993 that granted in part the applica- tion for rehearing by the City of Cleveland, filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
06/24/1993Entry granting the City of Cleveland's application for rehearing; that the companies' application for rehearing be denied in part and granted in part, as set forth in Findings 6 and 7.0
06/09/1993Memorandum contra to the application for rehearing filed by the City of Cleveland by C. Smith.0
06/03/1993Entry ordering that the annual service reliability per- formance target levels be approved.0
06/01/1993Application for rehearing filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
05/28/1993Application for rehearing and partial suspension of order and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
05/26/1993Submittal of information sent to signatory parties, filed on behalf of applicant by C. Smith.0
05/06/1993Entry ordering that, pursuant to the provisions of the October 22, 1992 joint recommendation, the Commission hereby finds that the retirements as of December 31, 1992 of Acme Cycles 5 and 6 and Lakeshore Units 14, 15, 16, and 17 do not result in a net ratepayer detriment.0
03/18/1993Annual service reliability targets filed on behalf of applicant by K. Turosky.0
02/22/1993Filing pursuant to stipulations by Centerior Energy Corporation, filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
02/10/1993Application and supporting data filed on behalf of applicant by D. Blank.0
01/26/1993Comments filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
01/22/1993Comments filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization by J. Meissner.0
01/21/1993Comments filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
01/21/1993Comments filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization by J. Meissner.0
12/21/1992Comments of the Centerior Energy Corporation on bahalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
12/18/1992Proofs of publication filed on behalf of applicant by C. Smith. (Henry, Wood, Williams, Lucas, Defiance, Summit, Ashtabula, Lorain, Cuyahoga, and Lake Counties)0
11/05/1992Transcript filed for hearing held 10/20/92, (WB), 52 pgs., Con't. (Toledo, Ohio)0
11/05/1992Transcript filed for hearing held 10/16/92, (JMB), 65 pgs., Con't. (Toledo, Ohio)0
11/04/1992Transcript filed for hearing held 10/15/92, (CG), 80 pgs., Con't. (Cleveland, Ohio)0
10/27/1992Transcript filed for hearing held 10/19/92, (WB), 9 pgs., Con't. (Cleveland, Ohio)0
10/22/1992Entry approving the joint recommendation filed 10/5/92; granting the intervention rights of the signatory parties; approving the accounting measures in cases 92-1747-EL-AAM and 92-1748-EL-AAM; closing and dismissing case 91-551-EL- AAM and 91-552-EL-AAM; and inviting all parties in case 89-498-EL-COI to file comments on the Staff's analysis of Centerior's implementation of the CRESAP management audit recommendations within 60 days of the date of this entry and reply comments within 90 days.8
10/22/1992Entry approving the joint recommendation filed 10/5/92; granting the intervention rights of the signatory parties; approving the accounting measures in cases 92-1747-EL-AAM and 92-1748-EL-AAM; closing and dismissing case 91-551-EL- AAM and 91-552-EL-AAM; and inviting all parties in case 89-498-EL-COI to file comments on the Staff's analysis of Centerior's implementation of the CRESAP management audit recommendations within 60 days of the date of this entry and reply comments within 90 days.0
10/14/1992Entry scheduling public meetings at 9:45 a.m. on 10/19/92 at the Cuyahoga County Administration Building, Cleveland, Ohio, and at 10:30 a.m. on 10/20/92 at One Government Center, Toledo Ohio; that notice of the public meetings be published by Centerior Energy as directed in Finding 4. (AE)0
10/06/1992Entry scheduling public meeting at 10:30 a.m. on 10/15/92 at Council Chambers, Cleveland, Ohio; scheduling public meeting at 10:30 a.m. on 10/16/92 at City Council Chambers, Toledo, Ohio; that notice of public meetings be published by Centerior Energy. (AE)0
10/05/1992Joint recommendation filed on behalf of Centerior Energy, OCC, IEC, the City of Cleveland, and the Greater Cleve- land Welfare Rights Organization by F. Lange, Jr.0
12/19/1991Entry adopting the joint recommendation filed 10/11/91.0
11/20/1991Letter stating that the City of Toledo supports the joint stipulation and recommendation filed by various ratepayer groups, and asking that the Commission consider the City of Toledo to be a singatory of the document, filed by T. Hoover and M. White.0
10/11/1991Joint recommendation filed on behalf of CEI by F. Lange, Jr; OCC by J. Van Heyde; the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber; Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization by J. Meissner; Toledo Edison by F. Lange, Jr.; and IEC by L. Bell.0
09/03/1991Tariffs, PUCO No. 7, 34th sheet 1, 24th sheet 2, 18th sheet 2A, 2nd sheet 2B, 8th sheet 40, 4th sheet 41A, 8th sheet 42, 4th sheet 43A, 8th sheet 44, 4th sheet 45A, 8th sheet 46, 4th sheet 47A, 3rd sheet 47C, 2nd sheet 47F, 7th sheet 48, 3rd sheet 49A, 2nd sheet 54C, 2nd sheet 54D, 2nd sheet 54E, 2nd sheet 54F, 2nd sheet 54G, 2nd sheet 54H, 2nd sheet 54I, 2nd sheet 54J, 13th sheet 86, filed on behalf of applicant by C. Fullem.0
08/08/1991Quarterly report for quarter ending June 1991, filed on behalf of applicants by C. Smith.0
03/14/1991Entry denying the application for rehearing filed by City of Cleveland and the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization.0
03/11/1991Letter in response to the letter of Mr. Langdon Bell, counsel for IEC, which responds to the City of Cleveland's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
03/07/1991Memorandum contra the application for rehearing of the City of Cleveland filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by F. Lange, Jr.0
03/07/1991Memorandum contra to the application for rehearing of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and Citizen Intervenors filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by F. Lange, Jr.0
03/05/1991Communication to customers in English and Spanish filed on behalf of CEI by W. Ridmann.0
03/05/1991Response to the City of Cleveland's application for rehearing filed on behalf of CEI by L. Bell.0
02/25/1991Application for rehearing filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
02/25/1991Application for rehearing filed on behalf of GCWRO and the Joint Citizen Intervenors by J. Meissner.0
02/14/1991Proofs of publication filed on behalf of applicant by C. Smith.0
02/04/1991Revised Appendix A filed on behalf of applicant, Toledo Edison Company, by W. Ridmann.0
01/31/1991Bill inserts; and final tariffs, PUCO No. 7, filed on behalf of applicants by W. Ridmann.0
01/30/1991Customer notifications; revised tariffs, PUCO No. 12, 41st sheet 1, 7th sheet 2, 17th sheet 4, 15th sheet 5, 32nd sheet 6, 3rd sheet 8.1, 6th sheet 33, 3rd sheet 33.1, 1st sheet 33.2, 4th sheet 34, 2nd sheet 45, 12th sheet 85, 3rd sheet 86.1, 3rd sheet 86.2, 11th sheet 87, 14th sheet 99, 12th sheet 101, 1st sheet 102, 13th sheet 103, 13th sheet 104, 2nd sheet 106, 13th sheet 107, 12th sheet 108, 13th sheet 111, 13th sheet 114, 12th sheet 120, 13th sheet 123, 9th sheet 124, 10th sheet 126, 8th sheet 130, 9th sheet 132, 10th sheet 133, 9th sheet 134, 10th sheet 135, 11th sheet 142, 4th sheet 155.1, and 4th sheet 220, filed on behalf of CEI by W. Ridmann.0
01/24/1991Opinion & Order adopting joint recommendation and closing case.0
01/24/1991Brief based on public hearings filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and the Joint Citizen Intervenors by J. Meissner.0
01/23/1991Transcript filed for hearing held 1/17/91, (RF), 75 pgs., Submitted. (Public Statements - Cleveland, Ohio)0
01/23/1991Supplemental brief filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
01/22/1991Supplemental brief filed on behalf of IEC by L. Bell.0
01/22/1991Transcript filed for hearing held 1/8/91, (JMB), 2 pgs., Submitted. (Public statements - Toledo, Ohio)0
01/07/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison Company by F. Lange, Jr.0
01/07/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of OCC by J. Pepper.0
01/07/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and the Joint Citizen Intervenors by J. Meissner.0
01/07/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
01/07/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of IEC by L. Bell.0
01/04/1991Entry ordering that a supplemental brief based on the local public hearing may be filed. (AE)0
01/04/1991Reply brief filed on behalf of the City of Toledo by K. Bruce.0
01/03/1991Initial brief filed on behalf of OCC by J. Pepper. (FILED 12/28/90)0
12/28/1990Post-hearing brief filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by F. Lange. Jr.0
12/28/1990Brief and request for reopening of the hearing filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
12/28/1990Brief filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and the Joint Citizen Intervenors by J. Meissner.0
12/28/1990Post-hearing brief filed on behalf of the City of Toledo by K. Bruce.0
12/27/1990Post hearing brief filed on behalf of IEC by L. Bell.0
12/27/1990Letter requesting that the PUCO provide full public disclosure of the recommendations which Centerior intends to implement; the savings tied to those specific recommendations; and the rationale for apportioning the 1991 CEI and Toledo Edison rate increases, filed on behalf of the County of Cuyahoga Commissioners by M. Boyle, V. Brown, and T. Hagan.0
12/24/1990Letter stating that quarterly reporting information has been provided to the PUCO staff and signatory parties to the Stipulation and Recommendation with attached copies of cover letter and index provided with the quarterly information, filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
12/21/1990Entry scheduling local hearing at 1:30 p.m., City Council Chambers, Toledo, Ohio; local public hearing at 2:00 p.m. at the Lausche State Office Building, Cleveland, Ohio; notice of hearings be published by Toledo Edison and CEI as directed in Finding (3). (AE)0
12/18/1990Transcript filed for hearing held 12/13/90, (PD) (WB), 194 pgs., Vol. II, Submitted.0
12/18/1990Transcript filed for hearing held 12/12/90, (PD) (WB), 144 pgs., Con't., Vol. I.0
12/17/1990Letter requesting local public hearings in this case, filed on behalf of Western Reserve Alliance by B. Long.0
12/10/1990Entry ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled at 9:00 a.m. on December 12, 1990, and a hearing to begin immediately following the prehearing conference at the Commission offices. (AE)0
12/10/1990Correspondence letter supporting public hearings in this case, filed on behalf of Citizens of Cuyahoga County Ombudsman Office by G. Fleshood.0
12/07/1990Response of the members of the Audit Advisory Panel to the objections filed by the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and the City of Cleveland filed by F. Lange, Jr.0
12/03/1990Objections of The Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization and the Joint Citizen Intervenors to the joint recommendation and a request for a prehearing conference filed by J. Meissner.0
12/03/1990Objections and request for prehearing conference filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Ondrey Gruber.0
11/20/1990Entry scheduling a public hearing on 12/12/90 at 9:00 a.m. at the Commission offices. (AE)0
11/19/1990Letter stating that the City of Toledo supports the Joint Recommendation submitted by the Audit Advisory Panel and asks that the Commission consider the City of Toledo to be a signatory of the document, filed by M. White.0
11/05/1990Letter stating that the joint recommendation signed by IEC, OCC, and the companies has been submitted to and discussed with the Cities of Cleveland and Toledo and with Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights, filed on behalf of Centerior Energy by F. Lange, Jr.0
11/05/1990Joint recommendation filed on behalf of IEC by L. Bell, CEI and Toledo Edison by F. Lange, and OCC by J. Pepper.0
11/01/1990Volumes 1 thru 4 of the preliminary report filed on behalf of the Advisory Panel by L. Bell.0
09/14/1990Letters to Mr. Langdon D. Bell, Chairman of the Centerior Audit Panel, dated June 8, l990, and September l3, l990, and signed by John S. Levicki, filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Smith.0
08/27/1990Letter stating that quarterly reporting information has been provided to the Commission for quarter ending June l990, filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by C. Spencer.0
07/09/1990Additional information filed on behalf of the applicant by C. Spencer.0
06/22/1990Correspondence filed on behalf of the Audit Advisory Panel (AAP) by Blank stating that they will review the issues raised in the comments and report its findings and recommendations to the Commission.0
06/15/1990Reply to the preliminary findings and recommendations of CRESAP from the citizen intervenors filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Welfare Rights Organization, et. al. by J. Meissner.0
06/13/1990Comments to preliminary report of Audit Advisory Panel filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by W. Gruber.0
05/07/1990Conclusions, recommendations/savings summary, and the implementation plans of Cresap, filed on behalf of applicant by L. Bell.0
03/26/1990Minutes of the regular meedings of the Audit Advisory Panel filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison by L. Bell.0
03/26/1990Copy of cover letter and index for quarterly report filed on behalf of CEI and Toledo Edison Co. by C. Spencer.0
02/05/1990Copy of letter to the Cleveland Consumer Advisory Panel with attachment filed by L. Bell. (FILED 2/1/90)0
02/01/1990Correspondence of the Cleveland and Eastern District Consumer Advisory Panels chairman filed by L. Bell.0
01/31/1990Minutes of the Audit Advisory Panel 1/15/89 meeting filed on behalf of applicant by L. Bell.0
01/25/1990Revised tariffs PUCO No. l2 filed on behalf of applicant by R. Ziegler.0
01/25/1990Revised tariffs PUCO No. 7 filed on behalf of applicant by R. Ziegler.0
01/22/1990Billing messages filed on behalf of Toledo Edison by R. Ziegler.0
01/22/1990Billing messages filed on behalf Cleveland Electric Co. by R Ziegler.0
01/17/1990Entry approving the calculation of the normalized 1988 level of operation and maintenance expense for CEI and Toledo Edison in the amount of $676.3 million.0
01/12/1990Copy of cover letter and index provided with the quarterly information which was provided on 11/16/89 filed on behalf of applicant by c. Spencer.0
12/26/1989Minutes of The Audit Advisory Panel filed on behalf of applicant by L. Bell.0
11/30/1989Response of Centerior Service Corporation to the pleading filed by the Greater Cleveland Welfare Riights Organization on November 8, 1989 by F. Lange, Jr.0
11/29/1989Copy of letter sent to the Ligal Aid Society sending work papers filed on behalf of the applicant by F. Lange, Jr.0
11/28/1989Letter filed on behalf of the applicant stating that it did not receive the Reply filed on behalf of the Legal Aid Society and that they will file their reply in a timley fashion filed by F. Lange, Jr.0
11/22/1989Minutes of the Audit Advisory Panel filed by L. Bell.0
11/08/1989Reply to the motion of the audit advisory panel for the approval of a normalized 1988 level of operations and maintenance expense filed on behalf of the Greater Cleveland Rights Organization by J. Meissner.0
10/27/1989Entry ordering any interested persons file comments on or before November 13, 1989. (AE)0
09/25/1989Minutes of the regular meeting of the Centerior Audit Advisory Panel filed by L. Bell.0
09/22/1989Exhibit A, filed by F. Lange, Jr., on behalf of applicant.0
09/19/1989Motion of the audit advisory panel for approval of a normalized 1988 level of operations and maintenance expense filed by L. Bell/Industrial Energy Consumers and K. Rosselet OCC/ and Centerior Service Corporation.0
08/30/1989Revisions to Pages 403 and 403-A of the 1988 Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company FERC Form 1, provided in the first quarter of 1989, filed by Wm. Ridmann.0
08/30/1989Minutes of the Centerior Management Audit Advisory Panel's meeting of July 21, 1989, as approved at the panel's AUgust 25, 1989 meeting, filed by L. Bell.0
08/24/1989Letter filed by C. Spencer on behalf of applicant, with copies of a cover letter and index provided with the quarterly information.0
08/14/1989Minutes of the May 26th and June 16th meetings of the Audit Advisory Panel filed by L. Bell on behalf of The Centerior Audit Advisory Panel.0
07/05/1989Copy of cover letter and index provided with the quarterly information as requested filed by C. Spencer on behalf of applicants.0
06/28/1989Corrected copy of Appendix C to the Stipulation and Recommendation filed by Wm. Ridmann on behalf of applicant.0
06/07/1989Minutes of the April 21st meeting of the Audit Advisory Panel filed by L. Bell.0
05/03/1989Motion to Intervene filed by J. Pepper on behalf of OCC.0
04/25/1989Minutes of the panel's meetings of 2/21/89 and 3/31/89, to be considered for subdocket "A" filed by L.Bell on behalf of applicant.0
03/28/1989Entry requiring CEI, Toledo Edison, staff and other interested parties to file data, information, or pleadings which have to do with complainances with the terms of the Stipulation, in Subfile A and B.0
03/27/1989In the Matter of the Commission's consideration of matters related to the stipulation approved in recent cases involv- ing The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company. (THIS CASE WAS FORMERLY 89-464-EL- COI)0