DIS - Case Record for 99-1611-EL-ORD Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 99-1611-EL-ORD
CASE DESCRIPTION: MINIMUM COMPETITIVE RETAIL ELECTRIC
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 11/21/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________

Parties of Record

Attorneys

Applicant
 
DIRECT ENERGY BUSINESS LLC REG MGR *Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
RYAN HARWELL xxxxxxxxxx Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. xxxxxxxxxxx
910 LOUISIANA ST  155 East Broad Street Suite 2100
HOUSTON TX 77002 Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (281) 800-6157 Phone: 614-222-1331
Fax: 614-222-1337
 
 
GREEN MOUNTAIN ENERGY COMPANY NONE
JOHN BUI
300 W. 6TH STREET SUITE 900  
AUSTIN TX 78701    
Phone: (512) 691-6339
Fax: (512) 691-5363
 
 
MINIMUM COMPETITIVE RETAIL ELEC- NONE
TRIC   
       
 
Interested Party
 
ALEXANDER, BARBARA NONE
CONSUMER AFFAIRS CONSULTANT 15 WEDGEWOOD DRIVE  
WINTHROP ME 04364    
 
 
AMOCO ENERGY TRADING CORPORATION NONE
MR. CHARLES D. WALKER 550 WESTLAKE PARK BLVD.  
HOUSTON TX 77079-2627    
 
 
BARTON, KATHY L. NONE
364 EAST CHESTNUT   
LISBON OH 44432    
 
 
BASSETT, ELIZABETH PACKER NONE
SIMON DEBARTOLO GROUP 115 W. WASHINGTON ST/1320 E TOWER  
INDIANAPOLIS IN 46204    
 
 
BEST, JR., THOMAS NONE
39453 CRESTVIEW ROAD   
LEETONIA OH 44431    
 
 
BRIDGES, RONALD NONE
ADVOCACY REPRESENTATIVE (AARP) ONE SOUTH HIGH STREET  
COLUMBUS OH 43215    
 
 
BUCHANAN, RICHARD L. NONE
POWER SYSTEM SOLUTIONS 3571 S. SUNNYFIELD DR.  
COPLEY OH 44321-1949    
 
 
BUERGER, WILLIAM A. NONE
MIAMI VALLEY RESOURCES, INC. P.O. BOX 1819  
DAYTON OH 45401    
 
 
BURTON, NANCY E. NONE
376 EAST MARYLAND AVENUE   
SEBRING OH 44672    
 
 
C. SPENCE FAXON NONE
ENERGY ALLIANCES 8489 BLUE ASH BLVD.  
CINCINNATI OH 45236-1923    
 
 
CITY OF NORTH RIDGEVILLE NONE
 7307 AVON BELDEN RD  
NORTH RIDGEVILE OH 44039    
Phone: 440-353-0811
Fax: 440-327-8593
 
 
CURNUTTE, RICHARD PRESIDENT NONE
VOLUNTEER ENERGY SERVICES, INC. 790 WINDMILLER DRIVE  
PICKERINGTON OH 43147    
Phone: (614) 856-3128
Fax: (614) 856-3301
 
 
DANIEL E. SUSANY NONE
435 LINCOLN WAY   
LISBON OH 44432    
 
 
DEAN A. KIBLER NONE
10805 MECHANICSTOWN ROAD   
HANOVERTON OH 44423    
 
 
DEMSKY, MIKE NONE
DTE-COENERGY 150 W. JEFFERSON ST.  
DETROIT MI 48226    
 
 
DENISE L. EXINE NONE
394 PLYMOUTH PLACE   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
GARY SCHAEFER NONE
906 E. SIXTH STREET   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
GARY SCHAFER NONE
906 E. SIXTH STREET   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
GEOFFREY RICH NONE
853 SAND RIDGE ROAD   
BOWLING GREEN OH 43402    
 
 
GERALD A. REED NONE
ENERGEN INC. 520 S. MAIN ST. SUITE 2452  
AKRON OH 44311    
 
 
JACK M. GRINWIS NONE
7354 LACOSTA DRIVE   
HUDSON OH 44236    
 
 
JAMES R. LEVINE NONE
CPS UTILITIES 1801 E. NINTH ST. SUITE 1510  
CLEVELAND OH 44114    
 
 
JOHN C. GRISHAM NONE
105 MILL CREEK DRIVE   
BOARDMAN OH 44512    
 
 
JOHN E. MOLINDA NONE
STRATEGIC ENERGY LTD. TWO GATEWAY CENTER  
PITTSBURGH PA 15222    
 
 
JOHN E. RAMUS NONE
5608 BUTLER GRANGE ROAD   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
KENNETH L. MITCHELL NONE
E POWERCLUB, INC. 1801 E. 9TH ST. SUITE 1520  
CLEVELAND OH 44114    
 
 
LOSCKO, SHERRI NONE
COMMERCIAL RATE SERVICES, INC. 2286 PARKRIDGE COURT  
GROVE CITY OH 43123-1818    
 
 
MAYOR DEANNA L. HILL NONE
CITY OF NORTH RIDGEVILLE 7307 AVON BELDEN ROAD  
N. RIDGEVILLE OH 44039    
 
 
MAYOR WALTER F. EHRNFELT NONE
CITY OF STRONGSVILLE 18688 ROYALTON RD.  
STRONGSVILLE OH 44136-5191    
 
 
NAOMI R. SEELY NONE
5551 BUTLER GRANGE ROAD   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
none STEWART, TODD
MALATESTA HAWKE & MCKEON LLP
  HARRISBURG ENERGY CENTER 100 NORTH TENTH STREET
    HARRISBURG PA  17101
 
 
REBECCA S. HARBOL NONE
1320 STEWART ROAD   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
ROSEMARY LACHER NONE
P.O. BOX 389 10563 STATE ROUTE 164  
LISBON OH 44432-0389    
 
 
SANDRA L. JACKSON NONE
45691 PINE HOLLOW ROAD   
ROGERS OH 44455    
 
 
SCOTT TOWNER NONE
RETAIL POWER SALES, INC. 20525 DETROIT RD. SUITE 2  
ROCKY RIVER OH 44116    
 
 
STEVEN MILLARD NONE
GREATER CLEVELAND GROWTH ASSN. 200 TOWER CITY CNTR/50 PUBLIC SQ  
CLEVELAND OH 44113-2291    
 
 
THOMAS E. STEWART NONE
OHIO OIL & GAS ASSOCIATION 1718 COLUMBUS ROAD SW/P.O. BOX 535  
GRANVILLE OH 43023-0535    
 
 
WALTON, P.E., CHRISTOPHER L. NONE
SANDS HILL COAL CO., INC. 38701 SR 160, P.O. BOX 650  
HAMDEN OH 45634    
 
 
WEINSTOCK, SUSAN (RETURNED MAIL) NONE
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
A.A.R.P.--STATE LEGISLATION DEPT. 601 E STREET, NW  
WASHINGTON DC 20049    
 
Intervenor
 
*Resnik, Marvin I (RETIRED) Mr.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXAmerican Electric Powe
  1 Riverside Plaza, 29th Floor 
    Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 716-1606
Fax: (614) 716-2950
 
 
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY COMPANY JACK, GARY
ALLEGHENY POWER
1310 FAIRMONT AVE.  1310 FAIRMONT AVENUE 
FAIRMONT WV 26555 FAIRMONT WV  26554
 
 
AMERICAN WIND ENERGY ASSOC. STARRS, THOMAS
KELSO STARRS & ASSOCIATES LLC
1101 14TH STREET NW 12TH FLOOR 14502 S.W. REDDINGS BEACH ROAD 
WASHINGTON DC 20005 VASHON WA  98070
 
 
BIRD, JACQUELINE F. NONE
OHIO DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT 77 S. HIGH ST. P.O. BOX 1001  
COLUMBUS OH 43266-0101    
 
 
BRAFFORD, DONALD M. P.E. NONE
JACK A. HAMILTON & ASSOCIATES, INC. BOX 471, 342 HIGH STREET  
FLUSHING OH 43977    
 
 
CITY OF BROOK PARK NONE
LARRY HESS 6161 ENGLE RD  
BROOK PARK OH 44142    
 
 
CITY OF CLEVELAND *Bentine, John Mr.
WILLIAM T. ZIGLI American Municipal Power, Inc.
601 LAKESIDE AVENUE  1111 Schrock Road Suite 100
CLEVELAND OH 44114 Columbus OH  43229
Phone: (216) 664-3922 Phone: 614-540-1111
 
 
CITY OF CLEVELAND SMALL, JEFFREY L.
WILLIAM T. ZIGLI OHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSEL
601 LAKESIDE AVENUE  65 EAST STATE STREET, 7TH FLOOR 
CLEVELAND OH 44114 COLUMBUS OH  43215-4203
Phone: (216) 664-3922 Phone: (614) 466-8574
 
 
CITY OF EASTLAKE NONE
CITY ENGINEER, TOM GWYDIR
35150 LAKESHORE BLVD   
EASTLAKE OH 44095    
 
 
CITY OF TOLEDO (RETURNED MAIL) PALMER ENERGY CONSULTANT BRUCE, KERRY
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
241 N SUPERIOR SUITE 250 ONE GOVERNMENT CENTER SUITE 2250
TOLEDO OH 43604 TOLEDO OH  43604
Phone: 419-539-9180 Phone: 419-245-1020
Fax: 419-245-1090
 
 
CONSOLIDATED NATURAL GAS JONES, BEVERLY
CNG TOWER
  625 LIBERTY AVENUE 
    PITTSBURGH PA  15222-3199
 
 
CONSTELLATION ENERGY SERVICES - NATURAL GAS LLC MIKULSKY, PHILLIP
DWAYNE PICKETT SENIOR VP DEVELOPMENT
355 E CAMPUS VIEW BLVD SUITE 150 WPS-ENERGY SERVICES, INC. 1088 SPRINGHURST DRIVE
COLUMBUS OH 43235 GREEN BAY WI  54304-5495
Phone: 614-844-4325
 
 
CRAVAT COAL COMPANY NONE
MICHAEL T. PUSKARICH, PRESIDENT 40580 CADIZ-PIEDMONT ROAD  
CADIZ OH 43907    
 
 
DAYTON POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY VINOLUS, ATHAN
TRIAL ATTORNEY
1065 WOODMAN DRIVE  DAYTON POWER & LIGHT COMPANY 1065 WOODMAN DRIVE
DAYTON OH 45432 DAYTON OH  45432
Phone: (937) 259-7348
 
 
DIRECT ENERGY BUSINESS LLC REG MGR *Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
RYAN HARWELL xxxxxxxxxx Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. xxxxxxxxxxx
910 LOUISIANA ST  155 East Broad Street Suite 2100
HOUSTON TX 77002 Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (281) 800-6157 Phone: 614-222-1331
Fax: 614-222-1337
 
 
DIRECT ENERGY BUSINESS LLC REG MGR *Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
RYAN HARWELL xxxxxxxxxx Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. xxxxxxxxxxx
910 LOUISIANA ST  155 East Broad Street Suite 2100
HOUSTON TX 77002 Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (281) 800-6157 Phone: 614-222-1331
Fax: 614-222-1337
 
 
DIRECT ENERGY BUSINESS LLC REG MGR NONE
RYAN HARWELL
910 LOUISIANA ST   
HOUSTON TX 77002    
Phone: (281) 800-6157
 
 
DOMINION ENERGY SOLUTIONS, INC SENIOR COUNSEL NONE
TEIRRA M EVERETTE
120 TREDEGAR STREET   
RICHMOND VA 23219    
Phone: 804-819-2698
Fax: 804-819-2182
 
 
ENRON CORP. MIGDEN-OSTRANDER, JANINE L.
OFFICE OF CONSUMERS' COUNSEL
FOUR HOUSTON CENTER 1229 LAMAR STREET, SUITE 1600 ***** RETIRED ***** SUITE 1800
HOUSTON TX 77010 COLUMBUS OH  43215-4209
Phone: (713) 853-6161 Phone: (614) 233-5120
 
 
FIRSTENERGY CORP. BURK, JAMES ATTORNEY-AT-LAW
LEILA VESPOLI FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
76 S. MAIN STREET  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
AKRON OH 44308 AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5861
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
 
GREATER CLEVELAND GROWTH ASSOC BELL, LANGDON D (RETURNED MAIL)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXBELL & ROYER CO.,
  33 SOUTH GRANT AVENUE 
    COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: (614) 228-0704
Fax: (614) 228-0201
 
 
GREATER CLEVELAND GROWTH ASSOC HANSEN, DAVID
V.P. GOVERNMENT & TRANSPORTATION
  200 TOWER CITY CENTER 50 PUBLIC SQUARE
    CLEVELAND OH  44113
 
 
GREENMOUNTAIN.COM CO. NONE
JASON S. GIFFORD
3815 S. CAPITAL OF TEXAS HWY #100  
AUSTIN TX 78704-6635    
 
 
JENNIFER L. FRANK NONE
1320 STEWART ROAD   
SALEM OH 44460    
 
 
MERLE MULLET NONE
HOLMES LIMESTONE COMPANY P.O. BOX 295  
BERLIN OH 44610    
 
 
MID-ATLANTIC POWER SUPPLY ASSOC. NONE
   
       
 
 
NEWENERGY MIDWEST, LLC (RETURNED MAIL) NONE
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
KENNETH J. WALSH, MANAGER 29 SOUTH LASALLE ST. SUITE 900  
CHICAGO IL 60603-1505    
 
 
none VINOLUS, ATHAN
TRIAL ATTORNEY
  DAYTON POWER & LIGHT COMPANY 1065 WOODMAN DRIVE
    DAYTON OH  45432
Phone: (937) 259-7348
 
 
none BIRD, JACQUELINE
DIRECTOR, OHIO COAL DEVELOPMENT
  242 FEDERAL PLAZA WEST SUITE 401
    YOUNGSTOWN OH  44503-1604
 
 
none DORTCH, MICHAEL D. ATTORNEY
KRAVITZ,BROWN & DORTCH, LLC
  65 E. STATE STREET STE 200
    COLUMBUS  OHIO  43215
Phone: 614-464-2000
Fax: 614-464-2002
 
 
none NONE
   
       
 
 
none GAINER, JAMES
CINERGY CORPORATION
  139 EAST FOURTH ST. P.O. BOX 960
    CINCINNATI OH  45201-0960
 
 
none JACOBS, ELLIS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
  LEGAL AID SOCIETY OF DAYTON 130 WEST 2ND STREET, SUITE 700
    DAYTON OH  45402
Phone: (937) 228-8088
 
 
none JACOBS, ELLIS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
  LEGAL AID SOCIETY OF DAYTON 130 WEST 2ND STREET, SUITE 700
    DAYTON OH  45402
Phone: (937) 228-8088
 
 
none HOTZ, ANN M.
ATTORNEY AT LAW
  XXXXXXX RETURN MAIL XXXXXXXXOFFICE OF CONSUMERS' C 10 W. BROAD STREET, SUITE 1800
    COLUMBUS OH  43215
 
 
none GRUBER, WILLIAM
ATTORNEY AT LAW
  2714 LEIGHTON ROAD 
    SHAKER HEIGHTS OH  44120
 
 
none STARRS, THOMAS
KELSO STARRS & ASSOCIATES LLC
  14502 S.W. REDDINGS BEACH ROAD 
    VASHON WA  98070
 
 
OHIO CITIZEN ACTION NONE
614 W. SUPERIOR AVE. SUITE 1200  
CLEVELAND OH 44113-1306    
 
 
OHIO COAL ASSOCIATION NONE
MICHAEL T.W. CAREY, PRESIDENT
17 S. HIGH STREET   
COLUMBUS OH 43215-3413    
 
 
OHIO COUNCIL OF RETAIL MERCHANTS *Bentine, John Mr.
American Municipal Power, Inc.
JOHN C. MAHANEY, JR., PRESIDENT 50 W. BROAD ST, SUITE 2020 1111 Schrock Road Suite 100
COLUMBUS OH 43215 Columbus OH  43229
Phone: 614-540-1111
 
 
OHIO ENERGY LEADERSHIP COUNCIL (OELC), FKA INDUSTRIAL ENERGY USERS-OHIO *Randazzo, Samuel C. Mr.
PETER TURNER XXXXXXXXXX
28601 CHAGRIN BLVD., SUITE 600  XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX 
WOODMERE OH 44122 Columbus OH  43215
 
 
OHIO ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL NONE
1145 CHESAPEAKE AVE I   
COLUMBUS OH 43212    
Phone: (614) 487-7506
Fax: (614) 487-7510
 
 
OHIO GROCERS ASSOCIATION NONE
THOMAS S. JACKSON, PRESIDENT/CEO 3280 RIVERSIDE DRIVE, SUITE 10  
COLUMBUS OH 43221-1748    
 
 
OHIO MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION NONE
ERIC L. BURKLAND, PRESIDENT
33 NORTH HIGH STREET   
COLUMBUS OH 43215-3005    
 
 
OHIO PARTNERS FOR AFFORDABLE ENERGY *Rinebolt, David C Mr.
RINEBOLT, DAVID C Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy
P.O. BOX 1793  186 South Front Street Suite 301
FINDLAY OH 45839-1793 Columbus OH  43215-4766
Phone: 419-425-8860 Phone: (614) 975-8692
Fax: 419-425-8862
 
 
OHIO POWER COMPANY *Resnik, Marvin I (RETIRED) Mr.
SELWYN J. DIAS XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXAmerican Electric Powe
700 MORRISON ROAD  1 Riverside Plaza, 29th Floor 
GAHANNA OH 43230 Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 716-1000 Phone: (614) 716-1606
Fax: (614) 716-2950
 
 
OHIO PUBLIC INTEREST RESEARCH GROUP (OHIO PIRG) NONE
MARIA WEIDNER
36 W. GAY STREET SUITE 315  
COLUMBUS OH 43215-2840    
 
 
OHIO VALLEY COAL COMPANY NONE
DAVID L. BARTSCH, P.E. 56854 PLEASANT RIDGE ROAD  
ALLEDONIA OH 43902    
 
 
OXFORD MINING COMPANY, INC. NONE
CHARLES UNGUREAN, PRESIDENT 544 CHESTNUT ST., P.O. BOX 427  
COSHOCTON OH 43812-0427    
 
 
PALMER ENERGY COMPANY INC PRES NONE
MARK R FRYE
5577AIRPORT HWY STE 101  
TOLEDO OH 43615    
Phone: (419) 539-9180
 
 
SCHOOLPOOL KEATING, VAN ESQ.
DIRECTOR OF MANAGEMENT SERVICES
  OHIO SCHOOL BOARDS ASSOCIATION 8050 N.HIGH ST. SUITE 100
    COLUMBUS OH  43235-6482
 
 
SHELL ENERGY SERVICES CO. L.L.C. (RETURNED MAIL LAWRENCE, GREGORY ESQ.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX MCDERMOTT, WILL & EMERY
ONE SHELL PLAZA SUITE 4100, 910 LOUISIANA ST. 600 THIRTEENTH STREET, N.W. 
HOUSTON TX 77002 WASHINGTON DC  20005
Phone: (713) 241-8941 Phone: (202) 756-8330
Fax: (202) 756-8087
 
 
SOLAR ENERGY INDUSTRIES ASSOC. STARRS, THOMAS
KELSO STARRS & ASSOCIATES LLC
  14502 S.W. REDDINGS BEACH ROAD 
    VASHON WA  98070
 
 
SUPPORTING COUNCIL OF PREVENTATIVE EFFORT JACOBS, ELLIS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
  LEGAL AID SOCIETY OF DAYTON 130 WEST 2ND STREET, SUITE 700
    DAYTON OH  45402
Phone: (937) 228-8088
 
 
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY FOR ECONOMIC NONE
DEVELOPMENT, CAROLINE SAHLEY PH.D 7650 CHIPPEWA RD. SUITE 306  
BRECKSVILLE OH 44141    
 
 
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY FOR ECONOMIC NONE
DEVELOPMENT, CAROLINE SAHLEY PH.D 7650 CHIPPEWA RD. SUITE 306  
BRECKSVILLE OH 44141    
 
 
UNICOM ENERGY SERVICES, INC. MAYER, JAMES ESQ.
TAFT, STETTINIUS & HOLLISTER LLP
THOMAS J. RUSSELL, ESQ. 125 CLARK STREET ROOM 2535 1800 FIRSTAR TOWER 425 WALNUT STREET
CHICAGO IL 60603 CINCINNATI OH  45202
 
 
UNICOM ENERGY, INC. NONE
THOMAS J. RUSSELL, ESQ. 125 CLARK ST. ROOM 2535  
CHICAGO IL 60603    
 
 
UNICOM ENERGY, INC. MAYER, JAMES ESQ.
TAFT, STETTINIUS & HOLLISTER LLP
THOMAS J. RUSSELL, ESQ. 125 CLARK ST. ROOM 2535 1800 FIRSTAR TOWER 425 WALNUT STREET
CHICAGO IL 60603 CINCINNATI OH  45202
 
*Indicates that filer has agreed to be automatically served via electronic mail.