Skip to main content

Case Record For:

16-0743-EL-POR

File a Public Comment
Case Title: Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company
Status: OPEN-OPEN
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: POR-EE AND PDR PROGRAM PORTFOLIO PLANS
Date Opened: 4/15/2016
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
03/27/2020Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s Application for Rehearing electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Rocco D'Ascenzo and Vaysman, Larisa M.14
02/26/2020Finding & Order that the Commission finds that a wind-down of the statutorily required energy efficiency programs shall commence on September 30, 2020, and those programs shall terminate on December 31, 2020 electronically filed by Docketing Staff.21
02/26/2020Service Notice14
01/17/2020Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Wolfe on behalf of PUCO Staff.3
01/14/2020Notice of withdrawal of Colleen Mooney electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.10
12/18/2019Return mail - GE Aircraft - RTS / UTF Entry 10/23/191
12/16/2019Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Mr Robert M Endris on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.9
12/16/2019Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Wolfe on behalf of PUCO Staff.3
12/09/2019Motion to Modify FirstEnergy’s 2020 Energy Efficiency Plan to Eliminate Charges to Consumers for Utility Profits, Request for Expedited Treatment and Memorandum in Support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.10
12/05/2019Comments Letter of consideration for comments filed on Dec. 3 by Shauni Nix, Executive Director, Ohio Energy Project regarding energy efficiency education. electronically filed by Mrs. Shauni Nix on behalf of Ohio Energy Project and Shauni Nix.2
12/03/2019Request for approval of late comments filed by A. Brink on behalf of The National Housing Trust.10
12/03/2019Comments regarding why energy efficiency education programs should continue electronically filed by Mrs. Shauni Nix on behalf of Ohio Energy Project.41
12/02/2019Letter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Mr Robert M Endris on behalf of Ohio Power Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.2
11/26/2019Certificate of Service filed by K. Bojko on behalf of the Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group.3
11/25/2019Comments of the Kroger Company electronically filed by Mrs. Angela Whitfield on behalf of The Kroger Company.9
11/25/2019Comments of Ohio Power Company electronically filed by Mr. Steven T Nourse on behalf of Ohio Power Company.11
11/25/2019Correspondence filed by Sen. Sandra Williams in Response to Commission Request for Public Comment electronically filed by Ms. Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Sandra Williams.2
11/25/2019Comments electronically filed by Mr. Nick Hromalik on behalf of Midwest Energy Efficiency Alliance.5
11/25/2019Comments by The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Tracy J Greene on behalf of Healey, Christopher.23
11/25/2019Comments of the Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mr. Shaun P Lyons on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group .10
11/25/2019Comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.13
11/25/2019Comments of The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dylan F. Borchers.12
11/25/2019Comments of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Mr Robert M Endris on behalf of Ohio Power Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.11
11/25/2019Comments by Advanced Energy Economy electronically filed by Ms. Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Advanced Energy Economy.17
11/25/2019Comments by The Environmental Law & Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, and Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Ms. Caroline Cox on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council.10
11/25/2019Comments of the Energy Resources Center located at the University of Illinois at Chicago electronically filed by Mr. Graeme Miller on behalf of Energy Resources Center and Mr. Graeme Miller.6
11/25/2019Comments electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.11
11/25/2019Business Comments regarding appropriate steps to be taken with respect to energy efficiency programs once the statewide cap of 17.5 percent, set by Am. Sub. House Bill 6, has been met. electronically filed by Ms. Mel Mackin on behalf of Ceres and 2G Energy and Air Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI) and Heat is Power Association and Ameresco, Inc. and Building Performance Association (BPA) and Capstone Turbine and Combined Heat and Power Alliance and Cree Lighting and ElectraTherm and Energy Management Solutions, Inc. and Enginuity Power Systems and GEM Energy and Ingersoll Rand and Integral Power LLC and Ironclad Energy Partners and Johns Manville and Midwest Cogeneration Association (MCA) and National Association of Energy Service Companies (NAESCO) and National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) and Ormat Technologies and Primary Energy and Recleim LLC and Schneider Electric and Uplight.6
11/25/2019Business Comments regarding appropriate steps to be taken with respect to energy efficiency programs once the statewide cap of 17.5 percent, set by Am. Sub. House Bill 6, has been met electronically filed by Mr. William Sherman on behalf of 2G Energy Inc. and Capstone Turbine Corporation and ElectraTherm and Enginuity Power Systems and GEM Energy and Heat is Power Association and Integral Power LLC and Ironclad Energy Partners and Midwest Cogeneration Association and Ormat Technologies and Primary Energy Recycling Corporation.4
11/25/2019Comments on Energy Efficiency Programs electronically filed by Mr. Thomas R. Hays on behalf of NOAC.4
11/19/2019Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Wolfe on behalf of PUCO Staff.3
11/04/2019Judgment entry filed. S.C. #2018-03792
10/23/2019Entry that the Commission requests comments from interested persons regarding the appropriate steps to be taken with respect to energy efficiency programs once the statewide cap of 17.5 percent, set by Am. Sub. House Bill 6, has been met electronically filed by Docketing Staff.4
10/23/2019Service Notice12
10/21/2019Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Wolfe on behalf of PUCO Staff.3
09/23/2019Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Wolfe on behalf of PUCO Staff.3
06/21/2019 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by the Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.5
10/19/2018Letter of Notification regarding change of address and firm affiliation electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.3
09/12/2018Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Mr. Larry Sauer.3
04/11/2018Service Notice13
04/11/2018Supreme Court Transmittal Papers. (SC 18-0379)21
03/12/2018Notice of Appeal of appellants, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council. (SC #2018-0379)80
03/12/2018Notice of Appeal of Appellants, (SC# 18-379) Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.48
01/10/2018Service Notice13
01/10/2018Entry on rehearing ordering that the applications for rehearing filed by the Environmental Advocates and FirstEnergy be denied.8
01/04/2018Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel of Richard L Sites for The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Devin D. Parram.3
01/02/2018Memorandum Contra Applications for Rehearing Filed by FirstEnergy and Environmental Parties by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.18
12/21/2017App for Rehearing electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn-Lucco on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.22
12/21/2017Stipulated EE/PDR Plan electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn-Lucco on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.314
12/21/2017Application for Rehearing and Memorandum in Support by the Environmental Law & Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Ohio Environmental Council, and Environmental Defense Fund electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council and Environmental Law and Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund10
12/13/2017Notice of Change of Address by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Sauer, Larry Mr.3
11/21/2017Service Notice13
11/21/2017Opinion & Order approving the Stipulation and the Companies' revised 2017-2019 Portfolio Plans; that the NRDC's motion for protective order be granted for a period of 24 months; that FirstEnergy's motion to strike portions of OHA's briefs be denied; that FirstEnergy's motion to strike portion of OCC's brief be granted in part and denied in part, as set forth above; that joint motion of Staff and OCC to strike portions of the Company's initial and reply brief be granted; that the Companies take all actions consistent with the Stipulation and this Opinion and Order.30
11/16/2017Notice of withdrawal of Bricker & Eckler LLP as Counsel for the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dane Stinson.2
07/19/2017Comments electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund and Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.3
04/06/2017Reply Memorandum to Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's Memorandum Contra to OCC/Staff's Motion to Strike Portions of the Companies' Post Hearing Briefs electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.14
04/06/2017Reply in Support of Motion to Strike Portions of the Post-Hearing Briefs of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.10
04/03/2017Reply in Support of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's Motion to Strike Portions of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Post-Hearing Briefing electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.13
03/30/2017Memorandum Contra to OCC/Staff's Motion to Strike a Portion of the Companies' Post-Hearing Briefing of the Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.16
03/30/2017Reply in Support of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's Motion to Strike a Portion of the Ohio Hospital Association's Post-Hearing Briefing electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company14
03/27/2017Memorandum Contra Motion of FirstEnergy to Strike Portions of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel Post-Hearing Brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.10
03/24/2017Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel for EnerNOC, Inc. - Greg Poulos electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A Smith on behalf of EnerNOC, Inc.3
03/23/2017Memorandum Contra Motion to Strike by The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Parram, Devin D.12
03/15/2017Motion and memorandum in support to Strike Portions of the Post-Hearing Briefs of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company, submitted by Assistant Section Chief John Jones on behalf of the Staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio and Christopher Healey on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. electronically filed by Kimberly L. Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.19
03/10/2017Motion and Memorandum in Support of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company to Strike Portions of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel Post-Hearing Briefing electronically filed by Mr. Joshua R. Eckert on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company13
03/10/2017Motion and Memorandum in Support of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company to Strike a Portion of the Ohio Hospital Association's Post-Hearing Briefing electronically filed by Mr. Joshua R. Eckert on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company.11
03/08/2017Service Notice12
03/07/2017Attorney Examiner Entry ordering Mr. Kelter and Ms. Williams be permitted to appear pro hac vice and as co-counsel on behalf of ELPC and NRDC, respectively. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
03/03/2017Reply Brief electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.16
03/03/2017Reply Brief of OHA electronically filed by Mr. Devin D. Parram on behalf of Ohio Hospital Association.7
03/03/2017Post-Hearing Reply Brief of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company in Support of the Stipulation and Recommendation electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.54
03/03/2017Reply Brief electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.22
03/03/2017Reply Brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.17
03/03/2017Reply Brief electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.12
02/21/2017Initial Brief of the Environmental Law & Policy Center, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Ohio Environmental Council, and the Environmental Defense Fund electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.27
02/21/2017Initial Post Hearing Brief of OHA electronically filed by Mr. Devin D. Parram on behalf of Ohio Hospital Association.10
02/21/2017Post-Hearing Brief of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company in Support of the Stipulation and Recommendation electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.97
02/21/2017Initial Brief electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.20
02/21/2017Post-Hearing Brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.47
02/21/2017Post-Hearing Brief electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.16
02/21/2017Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
02/21/2017Initial Brief electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker on behalf of IGS Energy.11
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing Composite Index - Volumes I-V electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.8
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 01/31/17 - Volume V electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.100
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 01/27/17 - Volume IV electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.61
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 01/25/17 - Volume III electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.105
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 01/24/17 - Volume II electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.203
02/01/2017Transcript in the matter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 01/23/17 - Volume I at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH, hearing room 11-D, electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.173
02/01/2017PUCO Exhibit Filing, Vol I.169
02/01/2017PUCO Exhibit Filing. Vol III. 11
02/01/2017PUCO Exhibit Filing: volume II.165
01/27/2017Rebuttal Testimony of Edward C. Miller electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company.22
01/27/2017Rebuttal Testimony of Eren G. Demiray electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.15
01/25/2017Rebuttal Testimony of Chris Neme electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Defense Fund and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council.39
01/11/2017Notice of Amended Page Eighty-Nine of Exhibit B to the Stipulation and Recommendation electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company.7
01/11/2017Correspondence of The Ohio Hospital Association Regarding the Filing of Testimony electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Parram, Devin D.2
01/10/2017Supplemental Direct Testimony of Richard F. Spellman on Behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.101
01/10/2017Amended Testimony of Patrick Donlon Filed on Behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio. electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.18
01/10/2017Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.5
01/06/2017Reply to Companies Memo in Opposition to Motion to Compel electronically filed by Mr. Devin D. Parram on behalf of Ohio Hospital Association5
01/06/2017Brief in Opposition to OHA's Motion to Compel electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.23
01/04/2017Notice of Deposition of Richard F. Spellman electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
01/04/2017The Ohio Hospital Association's Motion to Compel and Request for Immediate Pre-Hearing Conference electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Parram, Devin D.54
01/03/2017Service Notice11
01/03/2017Attorney Examiner Entry ordering the hearing of this matter be continued to January 23, 2017, at 10:00 a.m. in Hearing Room 11-D. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
12/23/2016Notice of Amended Signature Page to Stipulation and Recommendation dated December 8, 2016 electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.7
12/14/2016Attorney Examiner Entry ordering the hearing of this matter be continued to January 23, 2017, at 10:00 a.m., in the offices of the Commission, Hearing Room 11-D, 11th floor, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
12/12/2016Notice of Substitution of Counsel and adding James Perko electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of multiple.3
12/09/2016Service Notice10
12/09/2016Attorney Examiner Entry continuing hearing to allow further time to review settlement provisions and scheduling a conference call for 12/13/2016 at 2:00 p.m. in accordance with Paragraph 6. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Richard Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio3
12/09/2016Testimony - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Edward C. Miller electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.21
12/09/2016Testimony - Amended Direct Testimony of George L. Fitzpatrick electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.33
12/09/2016Testimony - Amended Direct Testimony of Eren G. Demiray electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.9
12/09/2016Testimony - Amended Direct Testimony of Denise J. Mullins electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.26
12/09/2016Stipulation and Recommendation electronically filed by Ms. Erika Ostrowski on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.504
12/06/2016Notice of Appearance of Counsel on behalf of The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Parram, Devin D.3
12/05/2016Testimony of Patrick Donlon electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.14
11/22/2016Attorney Examiner Entry orders the hearing of this matter be rescheduled for December 12, 2016, at 10:00 a.m. in Hearing Room 11-C. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.2
11/22/2016Service Notice10
11/18/2016Service Notice10
11/18/2016Attorney Examiner Entry ordering a conference call be conducted on Monday, November 21, 2016 at 2:00 p.m. Electronically electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
11/15/2016Unopposed Joint Motion for Continuance electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.11
11/10/2016Amended Notice of Withdrawal of Its Objections to the Proposed Energy Efficiency and Peak Demand Reduction Program Portfolio Plan of Ohio Edison, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Direct Testimony of Gary Swanson electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.3
11/09/2016Notice of Deposition (Amended) John Seryak electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
11/09/2016Notice of Deposition (Amended) Chris Neme electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
11/09/2016Notice of Deposition (Amended) of Trish Demeter electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
11/04/2016Notice of withdrawal BY ENERGY MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. OF ITS OBJECTIONS TO THE PROPOSED ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND PEAK DEMAND REDUCTION PROGRAM PORTFOLIO PLAN OF OHIO EDISON, CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING COMPANY AND THE TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY AND THE DIRECT TESTIMONY OF GARY SWANSON electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.4
10/26/2016Service Notice9
10/26/2016Attorney Examiner Entry orders the hearing of this matter be rescheduled for November 21, 2016, at 10:00 a.m. in Hearing Room 11-D at the offices of the Commission; that the parties observe the procedural schedule set forth above; and that the motions of EMS, EDF/OEC, ELPC, OPAE, NRDC, OCC, IEU-Ohio, OMAEG, OHA, Kroger, EnerNOC, and IGS to intervene be granted. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.4
10/05/2016Notice Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Debra A Gaunder on behalf of Kroger.3
10/03/2016Errata to the Direct Testimony of Chris Neme with updated Exhibits (Public Redacted Version of Exhibits) electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of The Natural Resources Defense Council.84
10/03/2016Service Notice10
10/03/2016Amended Memorandum Contra the Companies’ Expedited Motion to Strike Portions of Intervenor Witnesses’ Filed Testimony and to Preclude Future Testimony Related to Previously Litigated Issues electronically filed by Ms. Miranda R Leppla on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.9
09/30/2016Joint Memorandum Contra Of The Ohio Manufacturers’ Association Energy Group And The Office Of The Ohio Consumers’ Counsel To The Ohio Edison Company’s, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company’s, And The Toledo Edison Company’s Motion To Strike Portions Of Intervenor Witnesses’ Testimony electronically filed by Debra A Gaunder on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group.12
09/30/2016Response to Companies' Motion to Strike Portions of Intervened Witnesses' Filed Testimony electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.4
09/30/2016Attorney Examiner Entry ordering Staff’s request to continue the hearing of Case No. 16-743-EL-POR be granted; and that a prehearing teleconference be scheduled for each of these cases on Wednesday, October 5, 2016, at 11:00 a.m. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
09/30/2016Memorandum Contra the Companies' Expedited Motion to Strike Portions of Intervenor Witnesses' Filed Testimony and to Preclude Future Testimony Related to Previously Litigated Issues electronically filed by Ms. Miranda R Leppla on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.9
09/30/2016Memorandum Contra to the Companies' Motion to Strike Portions of Chris Neme's Filed Testimony and to Preclude Testimony Related to those Issues electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of The Natural Resources Defense Council.25
09/29/2016Motion to Continue Indefinitely Procedural Schedule, Request for Expedited Treatment and memorandum in support filed by J. Jones, PUCO Staff.5
09/28/2016Notice of Deposition (Amended) of John Paul Jewell electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/28/2016Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents of Eren Demiray by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.5
09/28/2016Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents of George Fitzpatrick by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.4
09/28/2016Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents of Edward Miller by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.4
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of Richard Spellman electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of Gary Swanson electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of John Seryak electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of Chris Neme electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of John Paul Jewell electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Notice of Deposition of Trish Demeter electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.5
09/27/2016Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice of Samantha Williams electronically filed by Samantha Williams on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.6
09/23/2016Expedited Motion To Strike Portions of Intervenor Witnesses' Filed Testimony And To Preclude Future Testimony Related To Previously Litigated Issues and memorandum in support electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.94
09/13/2016Testimony Of John Seryak On Behalf Of The Ohio Manufacturers’ Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.20
09/13/2016Direct Testimony of John Paul Jewell on Behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.103
09/13/2016Direct Testimony of Gary A. Swanson, on Behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.23
09/13/2016Direct testimony of Trish Demeter on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund electronically filed by Mr. Trent A. Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.13
09/13/2016Direct Testimony of Richard F. Spellman on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Gina L Brigner on behalf of Mr. Christopher Healey.99
09/13/2016Confidential document target - Direct Testimony of Chris Neme filed on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council by R. Dove. (140 pages)1
09/13/2016Motion and memorandum in support for a protective order filed on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council by R. Dove.5
09/13/2016Testimony of Chris Neme (Redacted Public Version) electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of The Natural Resources Defense Council.45
08/01/2016Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company5
07/25/2016Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Robert Kelter electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.6
07/21/2016Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.4
07/07/2016Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel by Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.3
06/28/2016Attorney Examiner Entry ordering the procedural schedule be amended as set forth; and that the hearing of this matter be rescheduled for October 11, 2016, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th Floor, Hearing Room 11-D, Columbus, Ohio. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Richard M. Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner.3
06/28/2016Service Notice7
06/27/2016Motion For Continuance and Request for Expedited Treatment and Memorandum in Support filed on Behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio electronically filed by Ms. Tonnetta Scott on behalf of PUC.6
06/17/2016Notice of Filing Errata electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.64
06/15/2016Reply to FIRSTENERGY’S MEMORANDUM CONTRA for INTERVENTION electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.9
06/14/2016Objections to the proposed energy efficiency and peak demand reduction program portfolio plan of Ohio Edison, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Electric Company electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.7
06/14/2016Objections of The Kroger Company electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A. Smith on behalf of The Kroger Co.13
06/14/2016Objection to Energy Efficiency and Peak Demand Reduction Program Portfolio Plans by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.54
06/14/2016Objections of the Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Ms. Danielle G Walter on behalf of OMAEG.12
06/14/2016Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker on behalf of IGS Energy.7
06/14/2016Motion to Intervene of EnerNOC, Inc. and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Joel E. Sechler on behalf of EnerNOC, Inc.7
06/14/2016Objection to the Application electronically filed by Colleen L. Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.4
06/08/2016Memorandum Contra Energy Management Solution, Inc.'s Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Kathy J Kolich on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company.11
06/03/2016Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Energy Management Solutions, Inc.9
05/23/2016Service Notice6
05/23/2016Attorney Examiner Entry directs that the stipulated procedural schedule and expedited written discovery response time set forth in Paragraphs 10 and 11 are to be adopted pursuant to Paragraph 15 and denies ELPC/NRDC's motion to modify the stipulated procedural schedule. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Megan Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
05/18/2016Reply in Support of Motion to Modify Stipulated Procedural Schedule electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.5
05/18/2016Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.4
05/17/2016Motion To Intervene and Memorandum in Support of The Kroger Co. electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A. Smith on behalf of The Kroger Co.7
05/16/2016Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Matthew W. Warnock.5
05/11/2016Memorandum Contra Motion to Modify Stipulated Procedural Scheduled Filed by The Environmental Law & Policy Center and The Natural Resources Defense Council electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.6
05/10/2016Motion to Modify Stipulated Procedural Schedule and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council.9
05/09/2016Motion To Intervene and memorandum in support of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.7
05/06/2016Motion to Intervene of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Ms. Vicki L. Leach-Payne on behalf of Pritchard, Matthew R. Mr. 8
05/05/2016Stipulated Procedural Schedule electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company.5
05/03/2016Service Notice3
05/02/2016Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a technical conference for May 9, 2016; electronically filed by Vesta R Miller on behalf of Megan Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.4
04/29/2016Limited Objection to the Utility's Proposed Schedule by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.94
04/29/2016Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.8
04/27/2016Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of The Natural Resources Defense Council.10
04/22/2016Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.6
04/20/2016Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support of the Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.8
04/19/2016Joint Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support of the Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.8
04/15/2016Testimony of Eren G. Demiray electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
04/15/2016Testimony of Edward C. Miller electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.31
04/15/2016Testimony of George L. Fitzpatrick electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.29
04/15/2016Testimony of Denise J. Mullins electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company.20
04/15/2016In the matter of the Application electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company. 483