Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 10-2395-GA-CSS
CASE DESCRIPTION: THE OHIO CONSUMERS COUNSEL VS INTERSTATE GAS SUPPLY DBA COLUMBIA RETAIL ENERGY
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 11/26/2021
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
03/05/2019 Case action form closing cases with an effective date of 3/5/2019 filed by S. Parrot.
12/13/2017 Notice of Change of Address by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Sauer, Larry Mr.
02/05/2016 Notice of Withdrawal on behalf of Mark S. Yurick electronically filed by Mark Yurick on behalf of The Kroger Company and Orwell Natural Gas Company.
10/17/2014 Notice of Withdrawal of Zachary D. Kravitz electronically filed by Mark Yurick on behalf of Brainard Gas Corporation and Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corporation and The Kroger Company and Orwell Natural Gas Company and Republic Steel and Rudolph, James Mr. and Joseph Grant and Rudolph, Richard Mr. and Brown, Ron Mr. and Logan Hardin Neighbors United
11/26/2012 Redacted Copies of the Confidential Versions of the Joint Brief and Reply Brief electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
11/15/2012 Confidential release of 10-2395-GA-CSS of Redacted version of the Transcripts. effective 11/15/2012.
11/15/2012 Confidential release: Redated version of transcript filed on December 20, 2011 by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply Inc.
11/15/2012 Confidential Release: Redated version of the SMLA filed on November 14, 2011.
11/15/2012 Confidential release: Redated version of transcripts filed on December 20, 2011 filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate gas Supply Inc.
11/05/2012 Service Notice
11/05/2012 Attorney Examiner Entry granting supplemental motion for protective order. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Katie Stenman, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
09/20/2012 Redacted Service Mark License Agreement for Interstate Gas Supply Inc. filed by Z. Kravitz.
09/20/2012 Redacted public versions of Transcript for hearing held on November 7, 2011 before AE K. Stenman on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply Inc. filed by Z. Kravitz.
09/20/2012 Supplemental Motion for Protective Treatment for Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by Z. Kravitz.
09/20/2012 Confidential Document Target for IGS, Inc. of Supplemental Motion for Protective Treatment, Confidential Transcripts, and Service Mark License Agreement filed by S. Morrison.
09/20/2012 Redacted version of confidential excerpts of transcript, volume II, held before Ms. Katie Stenman, Attorney Examiner, on November 8, 2011.
09/06/2012 Service Notice
09/06/2012 Attorney Examiner Entry granting IGS to reexamine its proposed redactions to the SMLA and confidential transcript, complying with the Commission's directives. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Katie Stenman, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
08/28/2012 Correspondence electronically filed by Mr. Zachary D. Kravitz on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
08/23/2012 Response to OCC Letter informing Stand Energy of an ex-parte communication with the Hearing Examiner. electronically filed by John M. Dosker on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation.
08/23/2012 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s new proposed redacted versions of the Confidential Transcripts and Service Mark License Agreement electronically filed by Mr. Zachary D. Kravitz on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
08/21/2012 Correspondence Discussion with Attorney Examiner electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.
08/15/2012 Service Notice
08/15/2012 Opinion & Order that the motion for admission pro hac vice filed by John M. Dosker on January 24, 2012, be granted.
07/09/2012 Confidential document target for hearing transcript Volume 1 and 2 filed by Z, Kravitz on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
04/06/2012 Notice of withdrawal of counsel and substitution of counsel, Mark Yurick from the law firm of Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, formerly Chester, Wilcox & Saxbe, LLP filed by M. Yurick.
01/24/2012 Motion to appear pro hac vice on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by J. Dosker.
12/20/2011 Reply of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by Z.D. Kravitz
12/20/2011 Letter regarding exhibits A,B, and C filed under seal filed by Z. Kravitz on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply.
12/20/2011 Confidential document target: Exhibit-C filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc..
12/20/2011 Confidential document target: Exhibit-B filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
12/20/2011 Confidential document target; Exhibit-A filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply Inc.
12/20/2011 Joint reply brief of Complainants, The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Stand Energy Corp.(public version) filed by M. Warnock and A.B. McIntosh.
12/20/2011 Confidential document target; joint reply brief filed by M. Warnock on behalf of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Stand Energy Corp..
12/13/2011 Memorandum Contra submitted by Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council contra to Interstate Gas Supply, Inc's Motion for Protective Order filed by M. Warnock.
12/13/2011 Confidential Document Target of Exhibits A & B filed by M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
12/13/2011 Memorandum Contra the IGS motion for protective treatment filed by J. Dosker on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation.
12/13/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc's post hearing brief filed by Z. Kravitz.
11/29/2011 Confidential document target: Joint memorandum in opposition to IGS' motion filed by A. Brian McIntosh and M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Stand Energy Corporation.
11/29/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s motion for protective treatment and memorandum in support filed by Z. Kravitz.
11/29/2011 Joint memorandum in opposition to IGS' motion for summary judgement and joint post-hearing brief of complainants, The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian McIntosh and M. Warnock.
11/29/2011 Motion of the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council for filing a confidential, unredacted copy of the joint post hearing brief under seal filed by M. Warnock.
11/25/2011 REPLY OF THE NORTHEAST OHIO PUBLIC ENERGY COUNCIL TO INTERSTATE GAS SUPPLY’S MEMORANDUM CONTRA MOTION TO STRIKE, electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of NORTHEAST OHIO PUBLIC ENERGY COUNCIL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.
11/21/2011 Reply to Interstate Gas Supply's Memorandum Contra Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
11/18/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s memorandum contra NOPEC's motion to strike filed by Z. Kravitz.
11/14/2011 Exhibits : NOPEC EXS 2-4-5-5a-8 * ex 5a (Confidential -Scaled ) . NOPEC Exs 6 and 7 held before Ms. Katie Stenman, November 7, 2011.
11/14/2011 Exhibits filed for IGS EX. 1 before Ms. Katie Stenman, Attorney Examiner at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 East Broad Street, Room 11-5 Columbus, Ohio, Called at 10:00 a.m. on Tuesday, November 8, 2011.
11/14/2011 Transcript of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Interstate Gas Supply hearing held on 11/08/11 - Volume II before AE K. Stenman electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Jones, Maria DiPaolo Mrs.
11/14/2011 Transcript of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Interstate Gas Supply hearing held on 11/07/11 - Volume I before AE K. Stenman electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Jones, Maria DiPaolo Mrs.
11/14/2011 Confidential document target: NOPEC exhibit # 5A filed by NRS and IGS.
11/14/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s memorandum contra NOPEC's application for certification of interlocutory appeal from the November 2, 2011 attorney examiner's entry.
11/07/2011 Notice of appearance of additional counsel filed by Michael Todd McIntosh on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation.
11/04/2011 Notice of appearance of counsel, Sommer L. Sheely of Bricker & Eckler LLP filed by S. Sheely.
11/04/2011 Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's interlocutory appeal and memorandum in support from the November 2, 2011 Attorney Examiner's entry filed by M. Warnock.
11/04/2011 Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's motion to strike respondent Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s motion for summary judgement and memorandum in support filed by M. Warnock.
11/02/2011 Entry ordered, that IGS' motion to quash the subpoena filed by NOPEC on November 1, 2011 be granted, (KLS)
11/02/2011 Service Notice
11/02/2011 Proof of Service filed by A. Brian McIntosh
11/02/2011 Reply memorandum in support of motion to strike Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's memorandum in support filed by Mark A. Whitt.
11/02/2011 Entry ordered, that Stand's motion for leave to amend the joint complaint be denied. It is, further, Ordered, that the motions to strike NOPEC's memorandum in support filed by IGS, NiSource, and NRS are moot. (KLS)
11/02/2011 Pre-filed testimony of David Burig on behalf of the Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh. (original)
11/02/2011 Pre-filed Testimony of Larry Freeman on behalf of the Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh. (original)
11/02/2011 Pre-flied testimony of Mark T. Ward on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh. (orginal)
11/02/2011 Pre-filed testimony of Stacee L. Dover on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh. (original)
11/02/2011 Memoranda contra to motion for protective order, motion to quash and memorandum in support filed by M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
11/02/2011 Motion to compel and memorandum in support filed by M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
11/01/2011 Proof of Service filed by Teresa E. Orahood.
11/01/2011 Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum in support filed by John W. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
11/01/2011 Pre-filed Testimony of Stacee L. Dover on Behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brain Mcintosh. (FAX)
11/01/2011 Pre-filed Testimony of David Burig of behalf of the Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh (FAX)
11/01/2011 Pre-filed Testimony of Larry Freeman on behalf of the Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brain Mcintosh (FAX)
11/01/2011 Pre-filed Testimony of Mark t. Ward on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by A. Brian Mcintosh. (FAX)
11/01/2011 Motion for Subpoena filed by A. Brian McIntosh on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation.
11/01/2011 Motion for subpoena filed by G. Krassen on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
11/01/2011 Direct Testimony of Vincent A. Parisi on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc filed by Sarah D. Morrison.
11/01/2011 Motion - Continue Part 2
11/01/2011 Motion to Quash Subpoena and memorandum in support filed by S.D.Morrison on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
11/01/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s motion for summary judgment and memorandum in support filed by S.D. Morrison. (part 1)
10/26/2011 Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's memorandum contra the motions to strike filed by M. Warnock on behalf of Nisource Corporate Services Co. and Interstate Gas Supply, Inc..
10/26/2011 Notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. witnesses filed by M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
10/20/2011 Second amended notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's witness filed by J.W.Bentine.
10/17/2011 A. Brian McIntosh's notice of appearance as additional counsel on behalf of of Stand Energy Corporation.
10/17/2011 Reply to memorandum contra filed Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. and Nisource Corporate Services, Inc. filed by J.M. Dosker on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation.
10/17/2011 Motion to strike Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's and memorandum in support filed by J.W.Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
10/14/2011 Stand Energy Corporation's reply to memorandum contra filed by Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. & Ni Source Corporate Services, Inc. filed by B. McIntosh. (FAX)
10/14/2011 Notice of appearance of Brian McIntosh as additional counsel on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation filed by B. McIntosh. (FAX)
10/11/2011 Motion and memorandum in support of Nisource Corporate Services Company and Nisource Retail Services Inc to strike Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's Memorandum in Support, filed by M.L. Thompson.
10/07/2011 Memorandum in support of Stand Energy Corporation's Motion for leave to file an amended complaint naming Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc and Nisource Corporate Services Inc filed by Thomas J O'Brien on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
10/07/2011 Memorandum contra of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. to Stand Energy Corporation's motion for leave to file an amended complaint filed by E. Gallon.
10/07/2011 Nisource Corporate Services Company's memorandum contra Stand Energy Cprporation's motion for leave to file amended complaint filed by M. Thompson.
10/06/2011 Memorandum contra Stand Energy Corporation's motion for leave to file an amended complaint naming Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc. and Nisource Corporate Services Inc. as parties filed by Zachary D. Kravitz on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply Inc.
09/28/2011 Service Notice
09/27/2011 Entry ordering that joint movants' request for an extension of the procedural schedule is reasonable and should be granted. (KLS)
09/23/2011 Joint Motion for Extension of the procedural schedule and request for Expedited ruling and Memorandum in Support filed by John W. Bentine, Joseph Serio on behalf of Office of Consumers' Counsel, Larry Gearhardt on behalf of Ohio Farm Bureau Federation, Thomas O'Brien.
09/22/2011 Motion for leave to file an amended complaint naming Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. and NiSource Corporate services, Inc. as parties and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation by J. Dosker.
09/14/2011 Stand Energy Corporation's Disclosure of witnesses filed by J. Dosker.
09/13/2011 The Office of the Ohio Consumer' Counsel's Witness List filed by L. Sauer
09/13/2011 Stand Energy Corporation's disclosure of witnesses filed by J. Dosker. (FAX)
09/13/2011 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s disclosure of witnesses filed by Z. Kravitz.
09/12/2011 Notice of appearance of counsel, Thomas J. O'Brien filed on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by T. O'Brien.
08/04/2011 Second amended notice of depositions duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel witnesses filed by J.W. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
06/24/2011 Amended notice of depositions, duces tecum, upon oral examination of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. by J. Bentine.
06/24/2011 Amended notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of Stand Energy Corporation's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply by J. Bentine.
06/20/2011 Amended notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. by J. Bentine.
06/20/2011 Amended notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's witnesses filed by Z. Kravitz.
06/17/2011 Service Notice
06/16/2011 Entry that the parties adhere to the procedural schedule set forth in Finding (4). (KLS)
05/13/2011 Notice of withdrawal of MXEnergy, Inc. filed by C. Dyas.
04/05/2011 Notice of Deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply by Z. Kravitz.
04/05/2011 Notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of Stand Energy Corporation's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply by Z. Kravitz.
04/05/2011 Notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of MX Energy, Inc.'s witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. by Z. Kravitz.
04/05/2011 Notice of depositions, duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's witness filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply. Inc. by Z. Kravitz.
04/05/2011 Notice of deposition, duces tecum, upon oral examination of the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's witnesses filed on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. by Z. Kravitz.
03/30/2011 Service Notice
03/23/2011 Entry ordering that a settlement conference be rescheduled to March 28, 2011, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission. (KS)
03/22/2011 Request for a continuance filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc..
03/21/2011 Notice of appearance of counsel; S. Daggett Morrison and Zachary D. Kravitz filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc..
03/16/2011 Notice of withdrawal of Border Energy, Inc. from this case due to the expenses associated with pursuing its claims against IGS filed by C. Flahive.
02/28/2011 Service Notice
02/28/2011 Entry ordered that a settlement conference be scheduled for March 24, 2011 at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission 180 East Broad Street, Room 1247, Columbus, Ohio 43215-3793, that MXenergy's motion to intervene be granted. (KLS)
01/26/2011 Withdrawal of Matthew S. White from proceedings and substitute Mark S. Yurick filed by J. Bentine on behalf of the Chester, Willcox and Saxbe Law Firm.
12/10/2010 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s reply to the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, et al's memorandum contra Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s partial motion to dismiss filed by J. Bentine.
11/30/2010 Memorandum contra Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s partial motion to dismiss filed by J. Serio on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, J. Dosker on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation, C. Flahive on behalf of Border Energy, Inc., G. Krassen on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, and L. Gearhardt on behalf of Ohio Farm Bureau Federation.
11/12/2010 Service Notice
11/12/2010 Answer and affirmative defenses for Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by J. Bentine.
11/12/2010 Partial motion to dismiss and memorandum in support for Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by J. Bentine.
11/10/2010 Entry ordering that IGS' motion for extension of time in which to file its answer be granted. (KLS)
11/08/2010 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support for MXenergy, Inc., filed by C. Dyas, Jr.
11/08/2010 Memorandum contra joint motion to consolidate cases filed by M. White on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
11/08/2010 Motion for extension of time to file an answer and memorandum in support filed by M. White on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
11/03/2010 Joint motion to consolidate cases and memorandum in support by the OCC, Stand Energy Corporation, Border Energy, Incorporated, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, and Ohio Farm Bureau Federation, filed by L. Sauer on behalf of the OCC, J. Dosker on behalf of Stand Energy Corporation, C. Flahive on behalf of Border Energy, Inc., M. Warnock on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, L. Gearhardt on behalf of Ohio Farm Bureau Federation.
10/22/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, M. Warnock.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Border Energy, Inc.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Stand Energy Corporation.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Border Energy, Inc.
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Ohio Farm Bureau Federation
10/21/2010 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to: Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.
10/21/2010 Complaint letter and copy of complaint sent to: Interstate Gas Supply dba Columbia Retail Energy.
10/21/2010 In the matter of the complaint of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, Stand Energy Corporation, Border Energy, Inc., Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Ohio Farm Bureau Federation vs. Interstate Gas Supply dba Columbia Retail Energy.