Date Filed | Summary | Pages |
04/30/2013 | Case Status form to close case filed by PUCO Staff. | 1 |
04/06/2012 | Notice of withdrawal of counsel and substitution of counsel, Mark Yurick from the law firm of Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, formerly Chester, Wilcox & Saxbe, LLP filed by M. Yurick. | 2 |
06/30/2011 | Notice of withdrawal of counsel filed by M. Idzkowski on behalf of OCC. | 2 |
01/26/2011 | Withdrawal of Matthew S. White from proceedings filed by J. Bentine on behalf of the Chester, Willcox and Saxbe Law Firm. | 2 |
05/03/2010 | Reply memoranda to Duke Energy of Ohio contra memorandum, motion to intervene in Case # 09-757-El-ESS and motion to appeal to intervene in Case # 09-1946-EL-RDR/ATA, still pending filed by A. Lane, consumer. | 10 |
04/23/2010 | Revised motion to intervene with service list, file by A. Lane. | 8 |
04/09/2010 | Corrected motion to intervene and request for public hearing filed by A. Lane. | 5 |
04/08/2010 | Motion to intervene filed on behalf of Albert E. Lane. | 5 |
03/08/2010 | Memorandum in opposition to Albert E. Lane's motion to intervene filed by A. Spiller and M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 8 |
03/08/2010 | Memorandum in opposition to Shirley Hayes' motion to intervene filed by A. Spiller and M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 7 |
03/03/2010 | Request of Shirley Hayes to be added as an intervenor in this case. | 1 |
03/02/2010 | Request that the attorney examiners accept late filed comments of A. Lane. | 2 |
03/01/2010 | Request PUCO to reactivate and merge all of PUCO docket # 08-709-El-AIR with PUCO docket # 09-1946-EL-ATA/RDR, and to be reinstated as an intervenor filed by A. Lane, consumer. | 15 |
11/13/2009 | Service Notice. | 7 |
11/13/2009 | Entry ordering OCTA's motion for protective order be granted. (KLS) | 3 |
10/26/2009 | Signed petition from local citizens regarding the request of Duke Energy, Ohio for the rate increase filed by S. Hayes. | 3 |
09/24/2009 | Signed petition from local citizens regarding the request of Duke Energy, Ohio for the rate increase filed by S. Hayes. | 3 |
08/12/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
08/12/2009 | Entry on rehearing stating that Albert E. Lane's application be denied. | 4 |
08/03/2009 | Correspondence letter regarding rate increase filed by S. Hayes, consumer. | 4 |
07/31/2009 | Memorandum contra the application for rehearing of Albert E. Lane by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz. | 9 |
07/31/2009 | Memorandum contra application of Albert E. Lane for rehearing filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 9 |
07/29/2009 | Notice of withdrawal of counsel filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC. | 3 |
07/21/2009 | Application for rehearing filed by A. Lane, intervenor and customer. | 23 |
07/14/2009 | Correspondence letter regarding rate increase filed by R. Williams, consumer. | 2 |
07/10/2009 | Revised tariff pages, PUCO Tariff No. 19, filed by D. Storck on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 130 |
07/08/2009 | Opinion and order stating that the stipulation be adopted in its entirety; the application of Duke for authority to increase its rates and charges for electric distribution service, and related applications considered herein, be granted to the extent provided in this opinion and order. | 20 |
07/08/2009 | Service notice. | 7 |
06/19/2009 | Exhibits for transcript docketed electronically for hearing held on June 17, 2009 before A.E. Scott Farkas. | 20 |
06/19/2009 | Transcript for Duke Energy hearing on June 17, 2009 before A.E. Soctt Farkas electronically filed by Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc.and V. Solas. | 126 |
06/15/2009 | Second supplemental testimony of William Don Wathen Jr., filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 7 |
06/10/2009 | Duke Energy Ohio's motion and memorandum in support to strike and motion in limine to limit cross examination of Duke Energy Ohio's witness filed by E. Watts. | 7 |
06/10/2009 | Memorandum, statement pro retaining all of Albert E. Lane's Correspondence filed by A. Lane. | 5 |
06/10/2009 | Letter updating the synopsis of the filing of June 6, 2008 and March 31, 2009 News Release by OCC, filed by A. Lane, intervenor. | 3 |
06/09/2009 | Updated update to synopsis filed June 6, 2009 and copy of OCC's news release of 3/31/2009 filed on behalf of Albert E. Lane. (FAX) | 3 |
06/09/2009 | Motion to strike and motion to limine and memorandum in support to limit cross examination of Duke Energy Ohio's witness filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by E. Watts. (FAX) | 9 |
06/08/2009 | Updated synopsis of intervener, Albert E. Lane. | 6 |
06/04/2009 | Request for a hearing in reference to the late-filing of Schedule A-1 filed by Duke Energy and request for the listed witnesses to appear at the hearing on June 17, 2009 filed by A. Lane, intervenor. | 4 |
06/03/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
06/03/2009 | Entry ordered that any party may request the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses concerning the schedule A-1, filed May 8, 2009, or the clarifying letter, filed on May 29, 2009. (SEF) | 4 |
06/02/2009 | Exhibit Attachment 1 to Duke Energy Ohio's Memorandum Contra Mr. Albert Lane's Correspondence and Motion to Strike electronically filed by Ms. Elizabeth H Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 5 |
06/02/2009 | Memorandum contra Mr. Albert Lane's correspondence and Motion to Strike electronically filed by Ms. Elizabeth H Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 8 |
06/01/2009 | Letter stating that OCC will not oppose the May 29th letter for the specific purpose of the Commissions' reliance, in its order on the numbers included in the A-1 Schedule that were not identified in the Stipulation filed by A. Hotz. | 3 |
06/01/2009 | Motion requesting delay on the deadline of June 4, 2009 hearing and request that the previously requested formal questions be answered before the hearing is set filed by A. Lane, intervenor. | 11 |
05/29/2009 | Entry ordering that any party may request the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses concerning the Schedule A-1 filed on May 8, 2009, or the clarifying letter filed on May 29, 2009, as set forth in this entry. (SF) | 3 |
05/29/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
05/29/2009 | Memorandum stating clarification on late filed exhibit docketed May 8, 2009, the settlement numbers represent the actual agreed to dollar amounts for rate base, current operating income, rate of return, etc. filed on behalf of Attorney General Staff by S. Reilly. | 6 |
05/27/2009 | Letter and petitions expressing concern over the rate increase sought by Duke Energy filed by S. Hayes. | 5 |
05/19/2009 | Correspondence regarding Duke Energy of North Carolina 49% owned subsidiary Crescent Resources & intervenor opponent position on Duke Energy of Ohio request for electric distribution rate increase filed by A. Lane. | 4 |
05/13/2009 | Correspondence letter objecting to Duke Energy Ohio's recent rate increase filed by L. Robbins. | 1 |
05/12/2009 | Response of A. Lane to the motion for admission of late filed exhibits by E, Watts on behalf of Duke Energy. | 1 |
05/08/2009 | Motion for admission of late filed exhibits and memorandum in support filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 5 |
05/05/2009 | Transcript of public hearing held March 24, 2009, in Liberty Township, Ohio before Commissioner V. Lemmie and AE S. Farkas. | 56 |
05/05/2009 | Proof of publication. (Hamilton County) | 2 |
05/04/2009 | Correspondence objecting to rate increase filed by Mrs. Wells. | 2 |
05/04/2009 | Correspondence letter filed by A. Lane. | 1 |
05/01/2009 | Correspondence filed by A.Lane. | 4 |
05/01/2009 | Proof of publication and affidavits filed by A. Schafer on behalf of Duke Energy. (Hamilton County) | 5 |
04/30/2009 | Motion for admission of late filed exhibit and memorandum in support of Duke Energy Ohio filed by E. Watts. | 33 |
04/29/2009 | Correspondence and signature petition protesting Duke Energy rate increase filed by Shirley Hayes. | 4 |
04/22/2009 | Letter in opposition to the proposed Duke Energy rate hike filed by consumer R. Carlson. | 3 |
04/13/2009 | Transcript of hearing held on March 31, 2009 before AE's J. Kingery and S. Farkas, electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Anderson, Rosemary Foster Mrs. | 22 |
04/10/2009 | Letter and petition expressing concern regarding Duke Energy rates increase request filed by S. Hayes and various consumers. | 5 |
04/08/2009 | Letter expressing concern over Duke Energy raising it's rates filed by M. Elias. | 2 |
04/07/2009 | Letter with attached petition expressing concern regarding Duke Energy rates increase filed by S. Hayes. | 4 |
04/07/2009 | Public Hearing held before AEs J. Kingery and J. Lynn on Thursday, March 19, 2009 in Cincinnati, Ohio. | 106 |
04/07/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the rate increase sought by Duke Energy filed by D. Luers. | 2 |
04/03/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the Duke Energy distribution charge filed by R. Ludeke. | 1 |
04/02/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the Duke Energy rate increase filed by C. Arnold. | 2 |
04/01/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the Duke's request for an increase filed by W. Blair. | 2 |
04/01/2009 | Letter from consumer regarding laws and authority to allow DP& L and Duke Energy of Ohio to recover storm costs from customers filed by C. Henthorn. | 1 |
03/31/2009 | Entry ordered that any party not present on March 31, 2009, may request the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses in support of the stipulation. (JWK) | 3 |
03/31/2009 | Transcript for hearing held March 16, 2009, at the Union Township Civic Center Hall in Cincinnati, Ohio before Chairman Alan Schriber. | 79 |
03/31/2009 | Testimony in support of settlement of Paul G. Smith on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 13 |
03/31/2009 | Prepared testimony of David R. Hodgden Capital Recovery and Financial Analysis Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 8 |
03/31/2009 | Stipulation and recommendation filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc; S. Reilly on behalf of Staff; A. Hotz on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel; M. Christensen on behalf of the People Working Cooperatively, Inc.; D. Hart on behalf of the Greater Cincinnati Health Council; C. Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy; T. O'Brien on behalf of the City of Cincinnati; M. Yurick on behalf of the Kroger Company; D. Boehm on behalf of the Ohio Energy Group and S. Howard on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 35 |
03/31/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
03/31/2009 | Notice of service filed by M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 4 |
03/31/2009 | Twelve-month actual data report, Schedules C-2 and E-4.3 filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 4 |
03/30/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the rate increase being sought by Duke Energy filed by T. Miller. | 1 |
03/30/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the rate increase the Duke Energy is seeking filed by L. Hodges. | 3 |
03/30/2009 | Letter expressing concern over the proposed increase by Duke Energy filed by the Chadwicks. | 3 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Peter K. Baker, Reliability and Service Analysis Division, Service Monitoring and Enforcement Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 11 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Jeffery P. Hecker, Capital Recovery & Financial Analysis Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 5 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Judy Sarver Capital Recovery & Financial Analysis Division,Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 6 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Mary Alice Sutton, Accounting and Electricity Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 5 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Victor P. Gallina, Rates and Tariffs/Energy and Water Division, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 9 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Syeda A. Choudhury, Accounting and Electricity Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 7 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Trisha J. Smith, Accounting and Electricity Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 5 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of William Ross Willis, Accounting and Electricity Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 8 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Edrick J. Richardson, Accounting and Electricity Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 6 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Donald L. Howard, Rates and Tariff Division of the Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 10 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Louis Brown, Utilities Specialist, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 6 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Stephen R. Chaney, Capital Recovery and Financial Analysis Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 20 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Carlos J. Garcia, Accounting and Electricity Division of the Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 6 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Barbara Bossart, Capitol Recovery and Financial Analysis Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 7 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Lowell K. Miller, Facilities Operations Field Division, Service Monitoring and Enforcement Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 11 |
03/30/2009 | Prepared testimony of Joseph F. Buckley, Capital Recovery and Financial Analysis Division, Utilities Department, PUCO, filed by S. Reilly. | 9 |
03/27/2009 | Correspondence letter objecting to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by W. and R. Butts. | 1 |
03/26/2009 | Service Notice. | 7 |
03/26/2009 | Entry ordering that staff's motion for an extension of time and a request for an expedited ruling be granted. It is further ordered that staff file its testimony and electronically serve a copy of its testimony on all parties by no later than 5:00 p.m. on March 30 2009. (SF) | 3 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence requesting 27 opponent questions are answered from correspondence docketed on March 3, 2009 in this case, filed by A. Lane. (FAX) | 2 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by M. Reilly. | 1 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence letter protesting Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by A. Aleshire. | 1 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by Mrs. Conn. | 1 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed increase filed by P. Denney. | 1 |
03/26/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by M. Hollenbeck. | 3 |
03/25/2009 | Motion of the Staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio for an extension of time for filing its testimony and memorandum in support filed by S. Reilly. | 7 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Lierman. | 2 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by G. Ross. | 2 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Shaw. | 1 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by F. and A. Taylor. | 1 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by M. Karaus. | 2 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by V. Dawson. | 2 |
03/25/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by C. Haity. | 1 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by B. Brown. | 2 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by Dr. Comrey. | 1 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by Mr. Noelker. | 2 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by L. Hartman. | 2 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by J. Shapiro. | 1 |
03/24/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern over Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase and requesting public hearings be scheduled in the western part of Hamilton County filed by T. and M. Nicholl. | 1 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence letter strongly opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by T. McHugh. | 1 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concerns regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by C. Burns. | 1 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concerns regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by G. Henning. | 1 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence expressing concerns regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by L. Mussig. | 1 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern regarding Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by Ms. Hillenmeyer. | 2 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by B. Dunne. | 2 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by L. Gentry. | 2 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Pace. | 2 |
03/23/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by J. Reckers. | 2 |
03/20/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by K. Farrell. | 2 |
03/19/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by L. Barry. | 2 |
03/19/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. and J. Strickley. | 2 |
03/19/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by M. Perry. | 1 |
03/19/2009 | Notice of deposition of Patricia Kravtin filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 3 |
03/19/2009 | Notice of deposition of David C. Parcell filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 3 |
03/19/2009 | Revised notice of deposition of Neal Hensley filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 3 |
03/19/2009 | Petition opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by S. Hayes. | 4 |
03/18/2009 | Deposition signature pages and errata sheets for depositions filed on February 23 for Richard Harrell, Steve Adams, Donald Stork and James Dean filed on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association by S. Howard. | 10 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern over Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by C. and M Frederick. | 4 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter expressing concern over Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Fecke. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence expressing strong opposition to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by L. Barry. | 4 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by D. Hastings on behalf of Community Land Cooperative of Cincinnati. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern over Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Hall. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence protesting Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by F. Bonniwell. | 2 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by D. Jones. | 2 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by E. Davis. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by Mr. Freels. | 3 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by J. Beebe. | 3 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Seibel. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by J. Hardy. | 2 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern over Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Jones. | 2 |
03/18/2009 | Revised notice of deposition of David J. Effron filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by E. Watts. | 3 |
03/18/2009 | Notice of deposition of Neal Hensley filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by E. Watts. | 3 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence letter objecting to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by E. Crutchfield. | 1 |
03/18/2009 | Correspondence expressing opposition to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by T. Hunley. | 1 |
03/17/2009 | Correspondence letter protesting Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by S. Spiller. | 1 |
03/17/2009 | Correspondence letter objecting to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by C. Rundo. | 3 |
03/17/2009 | Correspondence letter protesting Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by T. Parker. | 1 |
03/17/2009 | Correspondence objecting to Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by K. Garcia. | 1 |
03/16/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed on behalf of C. and P. Cope. | 1 |
03/16/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by R. Buxton. | 1 |
03/16/2009 | Correspondence expressing concern of Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by T. Wilson. | 2 |
03/13/2009 | Proof of Publication. (Butler County, OH.) | 28 |
03/13/2009 | Notice of deposition of David J. Effron filed by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy. | 3 |
03/11/2009 | Correspondence objecting Duke rate increase filed by S. Souder. | 1 |
03/11/2009 | Correspondence objecting Duke rate increase filed by K. Hacker. | 1 |
03/11/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy rate increase filed by S. Mortenson. | 1 |
03/11/2009 | Proof of Publications. (Hamilton County) | 7 |
03/10/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
03/10/2009 | Entry on rehearing stating that OCC's application for rehearing be denied. | 5 |
03/04/2009 | Notice to take depositions upon oral examination and request for production of documents by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz. | 4 |
03/04/2009 | Letter posing twenty seven (27) questions regarding the rate increase of Duke Energy Ohio, filed by A. Lane. | 9 |
03/03/2009 | Correspondence in opposition to Duke Energy's request for rate increase filed on behalf of concerned consumer, M. Rice. | 1 |
03/03/2009 | Service Notice | 7 |
03/02/2009 | Entry ordering that local public hearings in these proceedings be held as set forth in finding 7; that notice of the local public hearings be published by by applicant. (SF) | 4 |
03/02/2009 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Ohio's request for rate increase filed on behalf of concerned consumer, J. Anzalone. | 2 |
03/02/2009 | Correspondence opposing the Duke Energy rate increase filed by C. Stone, Sr. | 2 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Kevin C. Higgins on behalf of the Kroger Company. | 46 |
02/26/2009 | Summary of the major issues and objections to the Staff Report submitted by the Kroger Company filed by M. White. | 8 |
02/26/2009 | Letter in opposition to Duke charging customers for repairs due to storm damage filed by consumer, R. Hughes. | 2 |
02/26/2009 | Supplemental direct testimony of Paul G. Smith on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 10 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to the staff report of investigation submitted by Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by E. Watts. | 12 |
02/26/2009 | Supplemental direct testimony of William Don Wathen Jr. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 40 |
02/26/2009 | Supplemental direct testimony of James E. Ziolkowski on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 7 |
02/26/2009 | Supplemental direct testimony of Roger A. Morin filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 14 |
02/26/2009 | Duke Energy Ohio's list of major issues filed by E. Watts. | 4 |
02/26/2009 | Supplemental direct testimony of Donald L. Storck filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. | 14 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to Staff Report and statement of major issues of the Greater Cincinnati Health Council filed by D. Hart. | 9 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to the Staff Report of Investigation of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy and summary of major issues filed by C. Mooney. | 10 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Scott J. Rubin on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. | 48 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of David C. Parcell on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. | 90 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to the Staff Report and summary of issues by People Working Cooperatively, Inc. filed by M. Christensen. | 3 |
02/26/2009 | Confidential document target: Objections to Staff Report Exhibit 8 filed by S. Howard on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. (17 pages)
| 1 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to the Staff Report in investigation and summary of major issues by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz. | 16 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of David J. Effron on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. | 72 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Patricia Kravtin submitted on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 185 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Edward Kozelek submitted on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. (part 2 of 2) | 61 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Edward Kozelek submitted on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. (part 1 of 2) | 180 |
02/26/2009 | Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association's summary of major issues filed by S. Howard. | 4 |
02/26/2009 | Direct testimony of Neal Hensley submitted on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 100 |
02/26/2009 | Motion for protective order and memorandum in support filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 8 |
02/26/2009 | Certificate of service filed by S. Howard on behalf of OCTA. | 3 |
02/26/2009 | Objections to the Staff Report by the Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association filed by S. Howard. | 67 |
02/25/2009 | Letter with corrections to previously filed documents filed by A. Lane.(FAX) | 6 |
02/24/2009 | Duke Energy Ohio's memorandum contra OCC's application for rehearing filed by E. Watts. | 34 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Donald Storck filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. (part 2 of 2) | 129 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Donald Storck filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. (part 1 of 2) | 181 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Richard Harrell filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 68 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Donald Storck (cont.) filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 26 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of David Yelton filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 83 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of James Dean filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 99 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of James Dean (cont.) filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 73 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Teresa Brierly filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 52 |
02/23/2009 | Motion for protective order and memorandum in support filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 8 |
02/23/2009 | Confidential document target: Deposition transcript with exhibits of James Dean and Richard Harrell filed by S. Howard on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.(480 pages) | 1 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Ulrich Angleton along with OCTA Deposition Exhibit Nos. 15-18 filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 150 |
02/23/2009 | Deposition of Steve Adams filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 33 |
02/23/2009 | Letter from consumer in opposition to Duke Energy's attempt to collect repair bills for the 08' windstorm filed by M. Guinn. | 2 |
02/23/2009 | Duke Energy Ohio's memorandum contra OCC's application for rehearing filed by E. Watts. (FAX) | 34 |
02/18/2009 | Letter from consumer regarding Duke Energy trying to recover the costs incurred as a result of the September 14, 2008 windstorm filed by B. Wair. | 3 |
02/13/2009 | Letter expressing displeasure over the cost of the Sept.14th wind storm being passed on to the consumers filed by J. Clark. | 2 |
02/13/2009 | Application for rehearing and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz. | 8 |
02/09/2009 | Notice to take depositions upon oral examination and request for production of documents by The Office of the Ohio Consumer's Counsel filed by A. Hotz. | 4 |
02/09/2009 | Correspondence letters protesting the decision to allow Duke Energy to bill its customers for the damage from the wind storm of 2008 filed by various consumers. | 33 |
02/06/2009 | Deposition and exhibits of Jonathan McGee filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 114 |
02/06/2009 | Deposition and exhibits of Edward F. Kozelek filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 142 |
02/06/2009 | Service Notice | 6 |
02/06/2009 | Notice of the substitution of counsel by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by Staff. | 3 |
02/06/2009 | Letters from various consumers regarding the proposed Duke rate increase. | 16 |
02/06/2009 | Motion for admission pro hac vice of Paul A. Werner filed by S. Howard on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 4 |
02/05/2009 | Entry ordered that the prehearing conference in these proceedings be scheduled on March 17, 2009, at 10:00 A.M. at the offices of the Commission, Hearing Room 11-C, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215, ordered that the evidentiary hearing in these proceedings commence at 10:00 A.M. on March 31, 2009, at the offices of the Commission. (SH) | 5 |
02/04/2009 | Letters expressing concern over Duke Energy passing on the cost of September wind storms to customers filed by concern citizens. | 4 |
02/04/2009 | Letters stating that Duke Energy should not be allowed to pass on cost to consumers from the Windstorm of '08 filed by concern citizens. | 28 |
02/03/2009 | Objections to the entire staff report filed by Albert E. Lane. | 7 |
02/03/2009 | Letters opposed to the the decision to allow Duke Energy to charge back the cost of last years wind storms filed by concerned consumers. | 18 |
02/02/2009 | Letters expressing concern over the riders provided by Duke Energy filed by Concern Citizens. | 23 |
02/02/2009 | Reply to DE-Ohio's memorandum in opposition filed by P. Sherwood on behalf of tw telecom of ohio llc, | 7 |
01/30/2009 | Correspondence letters expressing concern over Duke to put riders on customers bill to pay for September post wind storm power restoration filed by Concern Citizens. | 20 |
01/29/2009 | Green card return mail. | 3 |
01/29/2009 | Green card return mail. | 2 |
01/29/2009 | Notice of rescheduling of deposition to Duke Energy Ohio filed on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association by S. Howard. | 6 |
01/29/2009 | Correspondence letters opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 23 |
01/28/2009 | Correspondence letters opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed on behalf of various consumers. | 27 |
01/27/2009 | Accounting report filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. by A. Schafer. | 2 |
01/27/2009 | Service Notice. | 19 |
01/27/2009 | Correspondence letters opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 55 |
01/27/2009 | Staff Report filed. | 153 |
01/26/2009 | Memorandum in opposition to the motion to intervene of tw telecom of ohio, llc filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by E. Watts. | 17 |
01/26/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 65 |
01/26/2009 | Revised notice of deposition duces tecum of Edward Kozelek filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 6 |
01/26/2009 | Revised notice of deposition duces tecum of Jonathon McGee filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Spiller. | 6 |
01/23/2009 | Correspondence letter opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 53 |
01/22/2009 | Correspondence letters in opposition of Duke Energy's proposed rate increase filed on behalf of various consumers. | 39 |
01/21/2009 | Correspondence letters opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 5 |
01/20/2009 | Correspondence letters opposing Duke Energy Ohio's proposed rate increase filed by various consumers. | 30 |
01/16/2009 | Correspondence opposing the electric rate increase filed by various customers. | 35 |
01/15/2009 | Correction of page 1 for filing submitted on January 13, 2009 by A. Lane. (FAX) | 1 |
01/14/2009 | Service Notice | 5 |
01/14/2009 | Finding ordering that the application by DEO-Ohio to modify accounting procedures to defer incremental O&M costs related to the September 14, 2008, wind storm service restoration expenses, with carrying costs, as set forth in findings (7) thru (12) is approved. | 4 |
01/13/2009 | Comments, motion to intervene and memorandum in support of A. Lane, a consumer residential customer of Duke Energy of Ohio. | 9 |
01/13/2009 | Notice of rescheduling of deposition to Duke Energy Ohio filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 7 |
01/09/2009 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by P. Sherwood on behalf of tw telecom of ohio, llc. | 5 |
01/09/2009 | Motion for admission pro hac vice of Pamela H. Sherwood and memorandum in support filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of tw telecom of ohio, llc. | 4 |
01/09/2009 | Memorandum contra Duke Energy Ohio's motion for approval to change accounting methods to defer and create a regulatory asset for collecting storm restoration costs from Ohio customers filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Small. | 9 |
12/31/2008 | Comments of A. Lane. | 8 |
12/24/2008 | Notice of withdrawal filed by J. Clark on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio. | 4 |
12/24/2008 | Notice of deposition duces tecum of Jonathon McGee filed by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 6 |
12/24/2008 | Notice of deposition duces tecum of Edward Kozelek filed by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 6 |
12/23/2008 | Notice of deposition to Duke Energy Ohio filed by S. Howard on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunication Association. | 6 |
12/22/2008 | Duke Energy Ohio's motion for approval to change accounting methods to defer and create a regulatory asset for storm restoration costs incurred during the test year and recovery mechanism for storm restoration costs filed by E. Watts. | 10 |
12/05/2008 | Notice of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association to take depositions of Duke Energy Ohio representatives filed by S. Howard. | 4 |
12/02/2008 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of the Greater Cincinnati Health Council filed by D. Hart | 7 |
11/14/2008 | Motion for admission pro hac vice of Gardner F. Gillespie filed on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association by S. Howard. | 4 |
11/13/2008 | Notice to deposition of Donald L. Storck filed on behalf of the Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association by S. Howard. | 6 |
10/31/2008 | Notice of withdrawal of counsel of Daniel J. Neilsen filed by J. Clark on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio. | 2 |
10/29/2008 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy's rate increase filed by E. Dimarzio. | 2 |
10/23/2008 | Letter opposing the proposed rate increase of Duke Energy filed by G. Volkart. | 1 |
10/17/2008 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by S. Howard on behalf of The Ohio Cable Telecommunications Association. | 5 |
10/10/2008 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy Company's request to increase rates filed on behalf of concerned consumer, W. Hopfensperger. | 1 |
10/06/2008 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy proposed rate increase filed by R. George. | 2 |
09/19/2008 | Letter expressing displeasure with Duke Energy's lack of concern in correcting the problem that has arisen filed by J. Ripke. | 2 |
09/15/2008 | Service Notice | 4 |
09/12/2008 | Entry ordering that the motion for consolidation, filed by Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. be granted and that Case No. 06-718-EL-ATA be consolidated with Case Nos. 08-709-EL-AIR, 08-710-EL-ATA, and 08-711-EL-AAM. (JK) | 2 |
09/10/2008 | Service Notice | 4 |
09/10/2008 | Entry ordering that the application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. be accepted for filings as of July 25, 2008 and that the proposed newspaper notice submitted be approved. | 3 |
09/03/2008 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of People Working Cooperatively, Inc. by M. Christensen. | 5 |
08/20/2008 | Correspondence opposing Duke Energy rate increase filed by G. Smith. | 1 |
08/13/2008 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of The City of Cincinnati | 4 |
08/12/2008 | Service Notice | 3 |
08/12/2008 | Entry ordering that a technical conference be held on August 21, 2008, at 2:00 p.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad St. 11th Floor, Hearing Room 11-E, Columbus, Ohio 43215. (JK) | 2 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of James E. Mehring on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 18 |
08/08/2008 | Confidential document: Direct testimony of C. Kiergan filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (22 pgs) | 1 |
08/08/2008 | Confidential document: Project Financial Model Report filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (48 pgs) | 1 |
08/08/2008 | Motion for a protective order and memorandum in support filed by P. Colbert on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 5 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Christopher D. Kiergan on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 23 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of John J. Spanos on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 17 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Richard G. Stevie on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 14 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Donald L. Storck on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 20 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of William Don Wathen, Jr. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 42 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of James E. Ziolkowski on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 27 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Sandra P. Meyer on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 15 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Roger A. Morin on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 126 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Paul G. Smith on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 17 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Peggy A. Laub on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 82 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Stephen R. Lee on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 8 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Todd W. Arnold on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 23 |
08/08/2008 | Direct Testimony of Keith G. Butler on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 7 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Carl J. Council, Jr. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 12 |
08/08/2008 | Direct testimony of Stephen G. De May on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 18 |
08/05/2008 | Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by A. Hotz on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel. | 8 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 8, Supplemental Information (C) (5) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 2 of 3) | 125 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 8, Supplemental Information (C) (5) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 1 of 3) | 147 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 8, Supplemental Information (C) (5) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 3 of 3) | 135 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 4, 5 & 6, Schedule S-4.2 filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 3 of 6) | 190 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 4, 5, & 6, Schedule S-4.2 filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 2 of 6) | 201 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 9, Supplemental information (C) (6) filed by R. D' Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 2 of 4) | 194 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 9, Supplemental information (C) (6) filed by R. D' Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 3 of 4) | 141 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 9, Supplemental information (C) (6) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 4 of 4) | 122 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 9, Supplemental information (C) (6) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 1 of 4) | 179 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 10, Supplemental information (C) (7) through (C) (25) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 4 of 4) | 108 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 10, Supplemental information (C) (7) through (C) (25) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 3 of 4) | 181 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 10, Supplemental information (C) (7) through (C) (25) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 2 of 4) | 175 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 10, Supplemental information (C) (7) through (C) (25) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Section 1 of 4) | 175 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 4, 5, & 6, Schedule S-4.2, part 1 of 3; filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (section 6 of 6) | 104 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 4, 5, & 6, Schedule S-4.2, part 1 of 3; filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (section 5 of 6) | 151 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 4, 5, & 6, Schedule S-4.2, part 1 of 3; filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (section 1 of 6) | 200 |
07/25/2008 | Application,Volume 4, 5, & 6, Schedule S-4.2, part 1 of 3; filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (section 4 of 6) | 200 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 7, Supplemental information (C) (1) through (C) (4) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 3 of 3) | 152 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 7, Supplemental information (C) (1) through (C) (4) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 2 of 2) | 150 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 7, Supplemental information (C) (1) through (C) (4) filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 1 of 3) | 200 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 2, Schedule E filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 3 of 3) | 154 |
07/25/2008 | Application; Volume 3; Schedule F; Schedule S-1; Schedule S-2; Schedule S-3; Schedule S-4.1 filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 146 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 2, Schedule E filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 2 of 3) | 150 |
07/25/2008 | Application, Volume 2, Schedule E filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. (Part 1 of 3) | 200 |
07/25/2008 | General application, Volume 1, Schedules A through D filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by R. D'Ascenzo. | 144 |
07/25/2008 | Application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by R. D'Ascenzo. | 14 |
07/25/2008 | Motion to consolidate cases and memorandum in support filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 4 |
07/25/2008 | Motion to approve form of notice and Schedule S-3 filed by R. D'Ascenzo on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. | 44 |
07/24/2008 | Service notice. | 3 |
07/23/2008 | Entry ordering the test period of the applicant, Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., shall begin January 1, 2008, and end December 31, 2008, and that the date certain shall be March 31, 2008; that the appropriate method for making any changes to the date certain or test period shall be the filing of a new notice of intent to file an application for an increase in rates and withdrawal of the pending application; that the request for waivers made by Duke are granted as set forth in this entry. | 4 |
07/18/2008 | Motion for intervention and memorandum in support of the Kroger Company, Inc. filed by M.S. Yurick, Esq. | 6 |
07/09/2008 | Motion of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy to intervene, memorandum in support and motion to practice Pro Hac vice before the Commission filed by D. Rinebolt. | 8 |
07/01/2008 | Motion for leave to intervene and memorandum in support filed by D. Boehm on behalf of the Ohio Energy Group. | 5 |
06/30/2008 | PFN tariff page PUCO No. 19, original sheet No. 70 which was omitted filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Schafer. (Original) | 2 |
06/27/2008 | PFN tariff page PUCO No. 19, original sheet No. 70 which was omitted filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio by A. Schafer. (FAX) | 2 |
06/25/2008 | Motion to set test period under R.C. 4909.15(C) and for waiver of certain filing requirements under OAC 4907-7-01 and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. by A. Spiller. | 9 |
06/25/2008 | Prefiling notice continued. (Part 2 of 2) | 180 |
06/25/2008 | Prefiling notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. for an increase in electric distribution rates. (Part 1 of 2) | 201 |
06/25/2008 | In the matter of the application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. for an increase in electric distribution rates. | 1 |