DIS - Case Record for 05-1057-EL-CSS Skip to main content

Case Record For:

05-1057-EL-CSS

File a Public Comment
Case Title: ORMET PRIMARY ALUMINUM CORP AND ORMET ALUMINUM MILL PRODUCTS CORP VS SOUTH CENTRAL POWER COMPANY AND OHIO POWER COMPANY
Status: CL-CLOSED
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: CSS-Complaint on service or safety
Date Opened: 8/25/2005
Date Closed: 7/27/2009
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
07/27/2009Case action form closing case effective 7/27/09.1
08/27/2008Entry on rehearing adopting in its entirety the supplemental agreement; that Ormet's motion to withdraw its application for rehearing is granted.5
08/27/2008Service Notice6
08/20/2008Joint motion of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation filed by C. Vince, Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company for acceptance of supplemental agreement filed by M. Resnik; Ormet's motion to withdraw its application for rehearing filed by C. Vince.9
01/03/2007Updated House Bill map reflecting the settlement agreement adopted by the Commission in this proceeding, this map is more explicit than the map filed on November 17,2006 and should be substituted, filed on behalf of American Electric Power Company by M. Resnik.2
11/21/2006Entry nunc pro tunc amending the supplemental opinion and order of November 8, 2006 to strike the sixth ordering paragraph as set forth in this entry.2
11/21/2006Service Notice6
11/21/2006Stipulation and recommendation filed by M. Resnik on behalf of American Electric Power.19
11/17/2006Updated HB maps reflecting the overlap filed by P. Lawrence on behalf of AEP Ohio.2
11/09/2006Transcript w/exhibits of hearing held before Hearing Examiner Gregory Price on October 26, 2006.24
11/08/2006Service Notice5
11/08/2006Supplemental opinion and order granting intervention by Columbus Southern Power and OCC; that the Stipulation be adopted; that the request to reallocate their service territories be granted; that approved revised quadrangle maps be filed within 14 days; that the electric services agreement between AEP Ohio and Ormet is approved.11
10/30/2006Letter commending the PUCO for judiciously dealing with the issues presented in this service complaint and urges PUCO to act quickly in approving this agreement, filed by T. Strickland.1
10/26/2006Motion to intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of OCC by J. Small.7
10/24/2006Service Notice5
10/23/2006Transcript of hearing held before Hearing Examiner Gregory Price on October 5, 2006.(concluded)36
10/20/2006Entry ordering that a hearing be scheduled for October 26, 2006, at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission, hearing room 11-E, 180 E. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio 43215. (GP)3
10/20/2006Stipulation and recommendation filed by PUCO staff.17
10/17/2006Entry ordering that the request for a suspension of the briefing schedule be granted. (GP)3
10/17/2006Service Notice5
10/06/2006Corrected Notice of Appeal filed on behalf of South Central Power Company by T. Lodge. (S.C. No. 06-1866)7
10/06/2006Notice of appeal of South Central Power Company filed by T. Lodge.7
10/04/2006Supplemental testimony of J. Craig Baker on behalf of Ohio Power Company filed by M. Resnik.7
10/03/2006Prefiled supplemental testimony of Whitfield A. Russell on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by E. Depp.12
10/03/2006Supplemental testimony of Ajit C. Kadakia submitted on behalf of South Central Power Company filed by T. Lodge.70
10/02/2006Prefiled supplemental testimony of Whitfield A. Russell on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by E. Depp.(FAX)12
09/28/2006Service Notice5
09/28/2006Entry granting Ohio Energy Group's motion for limited intervention. (GAP)3
09/22/2006Direct testimony of J. Craig Baker on behalf of Ohio Power Company.33
09/15/2006Response to memorandum contra motion for limited intervention filed by K. Boehm on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.9
09/14/2006Response to Ormet's memorandum contra motion for limited intervention, filed on behalf of Ohio Energy Group by K. Boehm. (FAX)10
09/13/2006Service Notice5
09/13/2006Second entry on rehearing that the application for rehearing filed by South Central Power Company be denied.5
09/11/2006Prefiled direct testimony of John W. Teitz on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.8
09/11/2006 Prefiled testimony of W. Russell on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation, Ormet Aluminum and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.30
09/08/2006Prefiled direct testimony of John W. Teitz on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by B. Sullivan. (FAX)8
09/08/2006Prefiled testimony of Whitfield A. Russell on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by B. Sullivan.31
09/08/2006Testimony of Louis Vitale filed by C. Flahive on behalf of South Central Power Company.13
09/08/2006Testimony of Todd Pilcher filed by C. Flahive on behalf of South Central Power Company.10
09/08/2006Testimony of Ajit Kadakia filed by C. Flahive on behalf of South Central Power Company.11
09/08/2006Memorandum in response to motion for limited intervention filed by C. Flahive on behalf of South Central Power Company.4
09/08/2006Testimony of Patrick O'Loughlin filed by C. Flahive on behalf of South Central Power Company.68
09/07/2006Memorandum contra motion for limited intervention filed by John E. Selent on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.4
09/05/2006Memorandum contra filed by E. Depp on behalf of South Central Power Company.9
08/25/2006Application for rehearing and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of South Central Power Company by T. Lodge.69
08/25/2006Amended motion for limited intervention and memorandum in support to correct incorrect case numbers, filed on behalf of Ohio Energy Group by D. Boehm.8
08/23/2006Motion for limited intervention and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Ohio Energy Group by D. Boehm.8
08/14/2006Service Notice5
08/11/2006Entry ordered that the procedural schedule be adopted as set forth in Finding (4); that the evidentiary hearing shall commence on October 4, 2006, at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission Hearing Room 11-C, 180 E. Broad St. Columbus, Ohio 43215. (GAP)3
08/10/2006Service Notice5
08/09/2006Entry ordered; that the applications for rehearing filed by South Central Power Company and Ohio Power Company be denied; that Ohio Power's motion be denied.12
07/31/2006Reply memorandum to memoranda contra filed by South Central Power Company, Ohio Rural Electric Cooperatives and Ormet by M. Resnik on behalf of the Ohio Power Company.9
07/31/2006Memorandum contra Ohio Power's request for clarification or alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk. (original)6
07/28/2006Memorandum contra Ohio Power's request for clarification or alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk. (FAX)7
07/24/2006Memorandum of South Central Power Company in response to Ohio Power Company's application for rehearing filed by T. Lodge.27
07/24/2006Memorandum of Ohio Rural Electric Cooperatives in opposition to Ohio Power Company's request for clarification or, alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties filed by T. Lodge.8
07/24/2006Memorandum of South Central Power Company in opposition to Ohio Power Company request for clarification or alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties filed by T. Lodge.6
07/24/2006Memorandum contra Ohio Power Company's application for rehearing and request for clarification or alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties filed by J. Selent on behalf of Ormet Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.18
07/24/2006Memorandum contra South Central Power Company application for rehearing and request for clarification and Ormet's memorandum contra filed by J. Selent.14
07/14/2006Application for rehearing and request for clarification of South Central Power Company and memorandum in support filed by T. Lodge.21
07/14/2006Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Ohio Power Company by M. Resnik.11
07/11/2006Entry ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled for July 20, 2006, at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission, Hearing Room 11-C, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215. (GAP)3
07/11/2006Service Notice4
07/10/2006Request for clarification or, alternatively, motion to join indispensable parties of Ohio Power Company filed by M. Resnik9
06/30/2006Letter with respect to the electric utilities determining future viability of the Ormet Corporation in Hannibal, Ohio filed by C. Probst, Jr.1
06/28/2006Service Notice4
06/27/2006Entry stating that a prehearing conference be held, July 18, 2006, 10:00 a.m. hearing room 11-C, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215-3793(GAP).2
06/19/2006Letter with respect to the electric utilities case currently before the Commission with respect to Orment Corporation in Hannibal, Ohio filed by Senator C. Wilson Jr.1
06/14/2006Opinion and Order ordered that Ormet's motion to strike the post-hearing brief filed by IEU is denied; that a prehearing conference be scheduled for the purpose of establishing a procedural schedule for further proceedings in this case; that the motion to intervene filed by USW is denied in part and granted in part.15
06/14/2006Letter with respect to the electric utilities determining future viability of the Ormet Corporation in Hannibal Ohio filed by W. Burga, Ohio AFL-CIO.1
06/14/2006Service Notice4
05/10/2006Memorandum contra of Ohio Power Company motion to intervene and filing of statement of United Steel Worker filed by M. Resnik.4
04/27/2006Motion to Intervene and filing of an economic impact statement by the United Steelworkers and memorandum in support filed by N. Hawthorne.26
03/28/2006Post hearing reply brief filed on behalf of Ohio Power Company by M. Resnik.17
03/28/2006Post hearing reply brief of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation, filed by J. Selent.27
03/28/2006Reply brief of South Central Power Company, filed by T. Lodge.23
03/27/2006Letter stating that Industrial Energy Users-Ohio will not file a Reply Brief in these proceedings, filed by L. McAlister.1
03/21/2006Reply in support of motion to strike post hearing brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio, filed on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corp. and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corp. by J. Selent. (original)7
03/20/2006Reply in support of motion to strike post hearing brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio, filed on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corp. and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corp. by J. Selent and B. Sullivan. (FAX)6
03/14/2006Memorandum contra Ormet's motion to strike post-hearing brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed on behalf of Ohio Power Company by M. Resnik.4
03/13/2006Memorandum contra Ormet's motion to strike the post-hearing brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by L. McAlister on behalf of IEU-Ohio.7
03/10/2006Motion to strike the post-hearing brief of IEU-Ohio, memorandum in support filed by J. Selent on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.8
03/09/2006Motion to strike post hearing brief and memorandum in support of Industrial Energy Users - Ohio, filed by J. Selent. (FAX)6
03/07/2006Post hearing brief filed by M. Resnik on behalf of Ohio Power Company.24
03/07/2006Initial brief filed by S. Randazzo on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.17
03/07/2006Post hearing brief of South Central Power Company filed by T. Lodge.52
03/07/2006Post hearing brief of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation filed by K. Kauffman.99
03/03/2006Entry ordered that reply briefs in this proceeding should be filed no later March 28, 2006. (GAP)2
03/03/2006Service Notice3
02/28/2006Transcript w/exhibits. (Part 2 of 2)115
02/28/2006Transcript w/exhibits held before G. Price, Attorney Examiner at 1:00 p.m. on February 14, 2006, at the offices of the Commission. (Part 1 of 2)100
02/01/2006Prefiled direct testimony of John W. Teitz, on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by E. Depp. (original)25
01/31/2006Prefiled direct testimony of John W. Teitz, filed on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by E. Depp. (FAX)23
01/31/2006Prefiled direct testimony of Ajit C. Kadakia, filed on behalf of South Central Power Company by T. Lodge.26
01/27/2006Stipulation, agreement and recommendation filed on behalf South Central Power Company by T. Lodge and on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by J. Selent. (Part 2 of 2)124
01/27/2006Stipulation, agreement and recommendation filed on behalf South Central Power Company by T. Lodge and on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by J. Selent. (Part 1 of 2)123
01/26/2006Entry ordered; that the procedural schedule for this proceeding be adopted as set forth in Finding (5); that the evidentiary hearing be scheduled for February 14, 2006, at 1:00 p.m., at the offices of the Commission, Hearing Room 11-C, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215. (GAP)3
01/26/2006Service Notice3
12/28/2005Reply to memorandum contra filed by E.Depp on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation.8
12/27/2005Reply to memorandum contra filed by E.Depp on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation. (FAX)9
12/23/2005Entry ordering that the procedural schedule for this proceeding be adopted as set fort in Finding (4);that the evidentiary hearing in this proceeding commence on February 7, 2006, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, Hearing Room 11-F, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215; that the South Central's motion to consolidate Case No. 05-1057-EL-CSS with Case No. 99-999-EL-PEB and 96-1000-EL-PEB be granted.4
12/23/2005Service Notice3
12/23/2005Entry ordering that the procedural schedule for this proceeding be adopted as set fort in Finding (4).;that the evidentiary hearing in this proceeding commence on February 7, 2006, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission Hearing Room 11-F, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215; that the South Central's motion to consolidate Case No. 05-1057-EL-CSS with Case No. 99-999-EL-PEB and 96-1000-EL-PEB be granted4
12/19/2005Memorandum Contra Ormet's motion to transfer back certified service territory to Ohio Power Company filed on behalf of Ohio Power Company by M. Resnik.9
12/19/2005Memorandum of South Central Power Co. in response to motion for the Commission to transfer Ormet back to the certified territory of Ohio Power Co filed by T. Lodge.4
12/09/2005Response to and memorandum contra the motion of South Central Power Company for administrative consolidation and request for expedited ruling filed by J. Selent.4
12/07/2005Letter indicating that Ohio Power support administrative consolidation of all proceedings and that will not respond in opposition to Ormet's November 29, 2005 motion within the time permitted by the Commission's rules filed by M. Resnik.2
12/06/2005Motion of South Central Power Company for administrative consolidation and request for expedited ruling and memorandum in support filed by T. Lodge.7
11/29/2005Motion to admit John E. Selent and Edward T. Depp Pro Hac Vice and memorandum in support filed by B. Sullivan on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corp. and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corp.4
11/29/2005Motion for the Commission to transfer Ormet back to the certified service territory of Ohio Power Company, and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation by J. Selent and B. Sullivan.161
11/14/2005Service Notice2
11/14/2005Entry ordered that a prehearing conference should be scheduled for December 1, 2005, at 2:00 p.m., at the offices of the Commission, hearing room 11-F, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215. (GAP)2
11/09/2005Letter stating that John E. Selent Esq., who was recently admitted pro hac vice by Commission order will serve as trial attorney on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Producers Corporation filed by B. Sullivan.1
10/28/2005Service Notice2
10/27/2005Entry denying the motions to dismiss of Ohio Power Company and South Central Power; that the motions for oral argument and expedited ruling filed by the Complainants be denied; that a prehearing conference be held on November 17, 2005, at 10:00 a.m., hearing room 11-C, at the Commission offices, 180 E. Broad St., Columbus, OH 43215; that the motion to intervene of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio be granted; that the motions for admission pro hac vice of Edward T. Depp and John H. Selent be granted. (GAP)7
10/21/2005Memorandum of South Central Power Company in response to motion for (I) Oral Argument (II) Expedited Ruling and (III) Prehearing Conference filed by C. Flahive.5
10/21/2005Reply of South Central Power Company to response of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation to South Central Power Company's motion to dismiss filed by R. Mone. Power Company.15
10/21/2005Reply memorandum to Ormet's memorandum contra filed by M. Resnik on behalf of Ohio Power Company.20
10/21/2005Memorandum contra Ormet's motions for oral argument, expedited ruling on motions for oral argument and to dismiss and for expedited prehearing conference filed by M. Resnik on behalf of the Ohio Power Company.5
10/14/2005Motion and memorandum in support of (i) oral argument; (ii) expedited ruling and (iii) prehearing conference filed by B. Sullivan on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.6
10/11/2005Response to and memorandum contra motions to dismiss of South Central Power Company and Ohio Power Company filed by B. Sullivan on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products.217
09/28/2005Response to and memorandum contra the motion to intervene of the Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by B. Sullivan on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.3
09/28/2005Motion to admit Edward T. Depp Pro Hac Vice and memorandum in support filed by B. Sullivan Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.3
09/20/2005Motion of Ohio Power Company to dismiss petition to transfer rights to furnish electric service and/or reallocate certified electric service territories; answer to complaints; and motion to dismiss complaint, memorandum in support filed by M. Resnik.11
09/20/2005Answer of South Central Power Company filed by C. Flahive.16
09/20/2005Motion of South Central Power Company to dismiss the complaint, memorandum in support filed by C. Flahive.77
09/13/2005Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by D. Neilsen on behalf of IEU-Ohio.10
08/31/2005Complaint service letter and copy of complaint to A. Kadakia of South Central Power Company.1
08/31/2005Complaint service letter and copy of complain mailed to S. Dias, Ohio Power Company.1
08/25/2005Motion to admit John E. Selent pro hac vice, memorandum in support, filed by B. Sullivan on behalf of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products Corporation.3
08/25/2005In the matter of the petition of Ormet Primary Aluminum Corporation and Ormet Aluminum Mill Products to transfer rights to furnish electric service and/or reallocate certified electric service territories and a complaint against South Central Power Company and Ohio Power Company for alleged unjust, unreasonable, and discriminatory proposed rates147