DIS - Case Record for 02-3210-EL-PWC Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 02-3210-EL-PWC
CASE DESCRIPTION: THE TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY AND AMERICAN TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS, INC VS. THE CITY OF TOLEDO
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 5/7/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
09/26/2003 Supreme court transmittal papers.
08/28/2003 Notice of appeal filed on behalf of City of Toledo, Ohio by K. Bruce.
07/01/2003 Entry ordering that Toledo's application for rehearing filed on June 13, 2003, be denied, that the suspension of the public way fees of Toledo, ordered in the Commission entry of February 13, 2003, be hereby terminated.
06/23/2003 Memorandum contra respondent's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of complainants by H. Liebman.
06/23/2003 Memorandum contra application for rehearing of City of Toledo, filed on behalf of Telecom complainants: AT&T Corp. by T. Thompson; WorldCom, Inc. by B. Royer; and LDMI Telecommunications by T. O'Brien.
06/20/2003 Memorandum opposing the City of Toledo's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of Verizon North by T. Lodge.
06/13/2003 Application for rehearing, filed on behalf of The City of Toledo by K. Bruce.
05/14/2003 Opinion & Order that the motion by the City of Cleveland for leave to file an amicus curiae brief in the telecom case, which brief was received and considered by the Commission along with all other amicus briefs received in this proceeding, be granted; that the just and reasonable public way fee and classification for the City of Toledo be as set forth in conclusion of law (10); that, inasmuch as the Commission anticipates the filing of applications for rehearing in this proceeding, the suspension of the public way fees of Toledo, under TMC Chapters 717 and 945, shall continue until otherwise by the Commission.
04/03/2003 Reply brief filed on behalf of XO Ohio by M. Dortch.
04/01/2003 Reply brief to amicus brief of City of Cleveland filed on behalf of complainants, AT&T Communications of Ohio by J. Thompson; WorldCom, Inc. by B. Royer; LDMI Telecommunications by T. O'Brien; and KMC Telecom III by B. Ferris;
04/01/2003 Post-hearing brief filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
04/01/2003 Entry denying the complainants' application for rehearing.
04/01/2003 Reply brief filed on behalf of XO Ohio by M. Dortch.
04/01/2003 Reply brief filed on behalf of telephone complainants: AT&T Corp. by T. Thompson; WorldCom, Inc. by B. Royer; LDMI Telecommunications by T. O'Brien; and KMC Telecom III by B. Ferris.
04/01/2003 Post hearing reply brief filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk and H. Liebman and American Transmission Systems, Inc. by D. Kutik.
03/26/2003 Transcript filed for hearing held March 12, 2003, (PD) (JK), 49 pgs., Submitted. (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
03/25/2003 Transcript and exhibits continued. (Part 2 of 4)
03/25/2003 Transcript and exhibits for hearing held March 11, 2003, (PD) (JK), 264 pgs., Con't. (PUCO-Columbus, OH) (Volume II) (Part 1 of 4)
03/25/2003 Initial post-hearing brief filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
03/25/2003 Post-hearing brief filed on behalf of Toledo Edison Co. and American Transmission Systems by H. Liebman.
03/25/2003 Amicus brief filed on behalf of Ohio Municipal League by C. Miller.
03/25/2003 Initial post hearing brief filed on behalf of XO Ohio by M. Dortch.
03/25/2003 Letter stating that OCC will not file a brief in this proceeding, but reserves the right to file a reply brief, filed by R. Tongren.
03/25/2003 Initial brief filed on behalf of Telecom Complainants; AT&T Communications of Ohio by S. Thompson; WorldCom, Inc. by B. Royer; LDMI Telecommunications by T. O'Brien; and KMC Telecom III by B. Ferris.
03/25/2003 Transcript and exhibits continued. (Part 4 of 4)
03/25/2003 Transcript and exhibits continued. (Part 3 of 4)
03/24/2003 Memorandum contra the Application for Rehearing of Toledo Edison and ATSI, filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
03/24/2003 Transcripts and exhibits continued. (Part 3 of 3)
03/24/2003 Transcripts and exhibits continued. (Part 2 of 3)
03/24/2003 Transcripts and exhibits filed for hearing held March 10, 2003, (PD) (JK), 239 pgs., Continued. (PUCO-Columbus, OH) (Part 1 of 3)
03/14/2003 Application for rehearing filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Co. and American Transmission Systems, Inc. by H. Liebman and J. Burk.
03/11/2003 Volume II of the deposition transcript of Luther Earl Wilkinson filed by H. Liebman.
03/10/2003 Stipulation concerning testimony of respondents witness, Lisa L. Wernert filed by City of Toledo by K. Bruce, Worldcom, Inc., by B. Royer and T. Thompson, AT&T Corp. by D. Trabaris and B. Kahn, LDMI Telecommunications by S. Bloomfield and KMC Telecom III, Inc. by B. Ferris.
03/10/2003 Stipulation concerning testimony of complainant AT&T's witness, Sally Briar; filed on behalf of City of Toledo by K. Bruce, AT&T Corp. by B Kahn and D. Trabaris , Worldcom, Inc., by J. Sanders and S. Thompson,LDMI Telecommunications by S. Bloomfield; KMC Telecom III, LLC by B. Ferris
03/07/2003 Deposition of Donald A. Brennan on behalf of the City of Toledo by K. Bruce.
03/05/2003 Rebuttal testimony of Dr. Debra J. Aron on behalf of the Toledo Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Inc. filed by H. Liebman.
03/04/2003 Entry ordering that SBC Ohio be granted intervention in case nos. 02-3207-AU-PWC and 02-3210-El-PWC, Verizon North be granted intervention in case no. 02-3207-AU-PWX, Ohio Telecom Association's request for intervention be denied, Ohio Municipal League's request for intervention be denied, ordered that the schedule for filing of direct expert testimony be modified, the city of Cleveland's request for intervention be denied, Toledo's motion to dismiss AT&T Communications of Ohio Inc. as a complainant in case no 02-3207-AU-PWX be denied, ordered that Toledo's motion to dismiss TCG Ohio, Inc., as a complainant in case no 02-3207-AU-PWC be granted and that TCG Ohio, Inc. be granted intervention in case no. 02-3207-AU-PWC. (JK)
03/04/2003 Service notice filed.
03/03/2003 Memorandum of the Toledo Edison Company and American Transmission System, Inc. contra the motion of the Ohio Municipal League to intervene, filed by J. Burk.
02/28/2003 Letter regarding the LMK-4 attachment which was inadvertently omitted, on behalf of applicant, by K. Bruce.
02/27/2003 Testimony of Scott B. Sibley filed on behalf of The City of Toledo.
02/27/2003 Direct testimony of Lisa L. Wernert on behalf of City of Toledo, Ohio.
02/27/2003 Direct Testimony of Lisa Marie Kowalski on behalf of City of Toledo, Ohio.
02/27/2003 Direct Testimony of Thomas B. Kroma on behalf of respondent City of Toledo.
02/27/2003 Testimony of Patrick R. O'Brien on behalf of the City of Toledo.
02/27/2003 City of Toledo's notice of deposition with duces tecum, filed by K. Bruce.
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 8)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 7)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 6)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 5)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 4)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 3)
02/27/2003 Depositions and exhibits continued. (Part 2)
02/27/2003 Depositions of the following persons and exhibits filed on behalf of respondents, Toledo Edison Co. and American Transmission System, Inc. by H. Liebman: 1) Luther Earl Wilkinson; 2) Peter L. Gerken; 3) Scott B. Sibley; 4) Lisa M. Kowalski; 5) John E. Bibish; 6) Patrick R. O'Brien; 7) Thomas Kroma; and 8) Lisa L. Wernert. (Part 1)
02/21/2003 Direct testimony of Dr. Debra J. Aron filed on behalf of complainants by H. Liebman.
02/20/2003 Letter stating that Kerry Bruce, counsel for respondent, has agreed that complainants' direct expert testimony may be filed on February 21, 2003, filed on behalf of complainants by H. Liebman.
02/14/2003 First set of interrogatories and requests for production of documents directed to the City of Toledo, filed on behalf of XO Ohio by R. Smith.
02/13/2003 Entry granting Toledo's motion for an extension to file its answers; that Toledo's motion to dismiss MCI Communications as a complainant in Case No. 02-3207 be granted; that no action be taken at this time with regard to Toledo's motion to dismiss AT&T Communications or TCG Ohio as complainants in Case No. 02-3207; granting Toledo's motion to dismiss Count V in Case No. 02-3207; granting Toledo's request to dismiss the claims brought pursuant to Sections 4905.26 and 4909.34 in Case No.02-3210; granting Toledo's request to dismiss Counts IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, and XI in Case No. 02-3210; denying the remainder of Toledo's telecom motion to dismiss and electric motion to dismiss; that the fee provisions of Toledo Ordinance 375-02 are suspended until otherwise ordered by the Commission; granting the motion for admission pro hac vice of T. Scott Thompson and James W. Tomlinson in Case No. 02-3207; that ICG Telecom be dismissed as a party in Case No. 02-3207.
02/13/2003 Memorandum in support of motion to intervene filed on behalf of the Ohio Municipal League by C. Miller.
02/13/2003 Motion to intervene filed on behalf of the Ohio Municipal League by C. Miller.
02/13/2003 Service Notice.
02/07/2003 Reply memorandum on the motion to dismiss of the City of Toledo, filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
02/03/2003 Service Notice.
01/31/2003 Entry ordering that the complainants and intervenors filed their direct testimony by February 19, 2003, and their rebuttal testimony by March 5, 2003; that Toledo Edison file its direct testimony by February 26, 2003; that the complainants and intervene file their rebuttal testimony by March 5, 2003; scheduling a hearing at 10:00 a.m. on March 10, 2003, Hearing Room 11-D, Commission offices, that Time Warner Telecom of Ohio and XO Ohio are granted intervention in Case No. 02-3210 EL-PWC; that Toledo's motion for extension of time to file reply memorandum until February 7, 2003 is granted. (JWK)
01/30/2003 Motion for extension of time to file reply memorandum and memorandum in support with request for expedited ruling filed on behalf of the City of Toledo by K. Bruce.
01/30/2003 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of SBC-Ohio by M. Mulcahy.
01/29/2003 Notice of Deposition with duces tecum filed on behalf of Toledo Edison Co., and American Transmission Systems, Inc., by H. Liebman.
01/21/2003 Memorandum Contra Motion to Dismiss filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and American Transmissions Systems, Inc. by J. Burk.
12/31/2002 Answer filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
12/31/2002 Motion to dismiss and memorandum in support filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce.
12/27/2002 Respondent City of Toledo's motion for extension of time to file answer with request for expedited ruling filed by K. Bruce.
12/26/2002 Motion for extension of time to file answer with request for expedited ruling and memorandum in support filed on behalf of respondent, City of Toledo, by K. Bruce. (Fax)
12/19/2002 Entry ordering that the docketing division serve a copy of the complaint upon the city of Toledo. The city of Toledo shall have until December 30, 2002, to file an answer to the complaint.
12/19/2002 Service Notice
12/18/2002 Motion to intervene memorandum in support filed by J. Heston.
12/10/2002 Complaint letter and copy of complaint mailed to The City of Toledo Department of Public Utilities,. Kerry Bruce.
12/10/2002 Complaint letter and copy of complaint mailed to The City of Toledo Department of Public Utilities, Leslie A. Kovacik.
12/09/2002 In the matter of The Toledo Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Inc. complainants vs. The City of Toledo.