Skip to main content

Case Record For:

20-1502-EL-UNC

File a Public Comment
Case Title: IN THE MATTER OF THE REVIEW OF THE POLITICAL AND CHARITABLE SPENDING BY OHIO EDISON COMPANY, THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING COMPANY, AND THE TOLE
Status: OPEN-OPEN
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: UNC-Unclassified
Date Opened: 9/15/2020 3:02:14 PM
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
08/16/2022Request of the United States Attorney, Southern District of Ohio, to stay all discovery in these proceedings filed by Kenneth L. Parker, United States Attorney.2
08/11/2022Subpoena for various deposition materials from FirstEnergy Corp.’s former President and Chief Executive Officer, Charles Jones, as requested on July 7, 2022 electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.4
08/10/2022Motion for Clarification of PUCO Administrative Law Judge Gregory Price’s Withdrawal Letter, Motion to Treat Judge Price’s “Withdrawal” as a “Disqualification” under the Ohio Code of Judicial Conduct, Motion to Vacate Rulings by Judge Price That Predated His Withdrawal and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.20
07/07/2022Motion for Subpoena Duces Tecum for Former FirstEnergy President and CEO Charles Jones to Provide OCC with His Written Discovery Responses (Including Documents) and Videotapes, Audio Recordings and Written Transcripts of Any and All Deposition Testimony by Mr. Jones and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.13
07/07/2022Motion for the PUCO to Make Its Commissioners and Administrative Law Judges Subject to the Ohio Code of Judicial Conduct for Their Administration of Justice and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.24
07/05/2022Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Corey Lee on behalf of FirstEnergy Corp.98
06/30/2022Motion for a Subpoena Duces Tecum for FirstEnergy Corp. to Produce Videotapes, Audio Recordings, Written Transcripts and any other Records Media of Deposition and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers Counsel filed by Maureen R. Willis.94
06/22/2022Notice of Appearance of Counsel, Karin Nordstrom, on behalf of the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Chris Tavenor on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council.4
06/07/2022Reply to FirstEnergy’s Memorandum Contra OCC’s Motion to Strike by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.6
05/31/2022Memorandum Contra OCC's Motion to Strike electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.5
05/23/2022Reply in Support of Motion for Protective Order electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.5
05/16/2022Memorandum Contra to the FirstEnergy Utilities’ Motion for a Protective Order to Keep Secret the Oxford Audit Contract electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.12
05/16/2022Motion to Strike and memorandum in support by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.6
05/04/2022Service Notice.12
05/04/2022Entry selecting Marcum LLP to assist Staff in its review to determine whether the show cause demonstration submitted by Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company is sufficient to ensure that the cost of any political or charitable spending in support of Am. Sub. H.B. 6, or the subsequent referendum effort, were not included, directly or indirectly, in any rates or charges paid by ratepayers in this state electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
05/03/2022Transcript for hearing held on 04/20/22 at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 East Broad Street, Hearing Room 11-C, Columbus, Ohio before Attorney Examiners Ms. Megan Addison and Ms. Jacky St. John electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Spencer, Michael O. Mr.27
04/29/2022Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum in Support, electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.20
04/28/2022Notice of Appearance of Counsel by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.4
04/19/2022Reply Memorandum Concerning the Timing of the Production of Documents Produced to FERC electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.15
04/19/2022Reply Memorandum on FirstEnergy’s Delayed Disclosure of FERC-Audit Documents by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.8
04/15/2022Memorandum on FirstEnergy’s Delayed Disclosure of FERC-Audit Documents by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.26
04/15/2022Memorandum on Document Production Timeline electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.7
04/15/2022Supplemental Memorandum Concerning the Timing of the Production of Documents Produced to FERC electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.10
04/13/2022Service Notice.12
04/13/2022Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that parties adhere to the briefing schedule set forth in Paragraph 29 and ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled for April 20, 2022 at 10:00 a.m. in accordance with Paragraph 30 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.9
04/13/2022Transcript for Hearing held April 11, 2022 @ 11:00 am before Attorney Examiner Megan Addison and Jacky St. John, at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio,180 East Broad St., room 11C, Columbus, Ohio 43215 electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.14
04/08/2022Service Notice.12
04/08/2022Memorandum Contra the Application for Rehearing by OCC electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.20
04/08/2022Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a prehearing conference to take place at 11:00 a.m. on April 11, 2022, at the Commission offices electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.8
04/06/2022Service Notice.12
04/06/2022Entry denying the interlocutory appeal filed by Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Heather A. Chilcote on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.19
03/29/2022Application for Rehearing and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.48
03/25/2022Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.3
03/25/2022Transcript for hearing held on 03/11/22 at 10:00 am, via Webex, before Attorney Examiners Ms. Megan Addison and Ms. Jacky St. John, electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Grubaugh, Valerie.67
03/21/2022Memorandum Contra FirstEnergy’s Interlocutory Appeal by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.21
03/16/2022Interlocutory Appeal Concerning Discovery of Non-Public Audit Materials Produced to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.208
03/09/2022Service Notice12
03/09/2022Entry directing the Staff to issue a request for proposals for audit services to assist Staff in its review to determine whether the show cause demonstration submitted by Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company is sufficient to ensure that the cost of any political or charitable spending in support of Am. Sub. H.B. 6, or the subsequent referendum effort, were not included, directly or indirectly, in any rates or charges paid by ratepayers in this state electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.25
03/04/2022Letter electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Gregory A. Price, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.2
03/02/2022Service Notice12
03/02/2022Transcript for Prehearing Conference before Gregory Price ,Megan Addison and Ms. Jacky St. John, Attorney Examiners at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio at 10;00a.m. on Thursday February 10, 2022 via webex electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson,Karen Sue Mrs.53
03/02/2022Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a prehearing conference for 10:00 a.m. on March 11, 2022, via Webex electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.5
02/18/2022Memorandum in Support of Disclosure of Documents electronically filed by Mr. Thomas V. Donadio on behalf of OMA Energy Group.20
02/18/2022Memorandum Renewing OCC’s 2021 Request for Disclosure of FirstEnergy Communications to FERC in Response to FERC’s Audit of FirstEnergy’s Lobbying, Donations, and Misallocated Expenses by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.19
02/18/2022Supplemental Memorandum electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.11
02/07/2022Correspondence by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.87
02/07/2022Reply to FirstEnergy’s Opposition to OCC’s Motion for the PUCO to Review Claims of Privileged Documents with an In Camera Review and Reply to FirstEnergy’s Opposition to OCC’s Motion to Require FirstEnergy Entities to File a Notice If They Anywhere Disclose Records That They Will Not Disclose to OCC Based on a Claim of Privilege by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.12
02/02/2022Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion to Accept Statement of Additional Authority Regarding OCC’s Motion for an Independent Auditor, Instanter by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.5
01/28/2022Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion for an In Camera Review electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.14
01/26/2022Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion to Accept Statement of Additional Authority electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.4
01/21/2022Service Notice.12
01/21/2022Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled in accordance with Paragraph 26. electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.8
01/18/2022Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel by The Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Ms. Janean R. Weber on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.4
01/14/2022Transcript for Hearing held January 10, 2022 @ 10:01 am before the Honorable Gregory Price, Megan Addison and Jacky St. John Attorney Examiners, at the Public Utility Commission of Ohio via Webex electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.24
01/13/2022Motion for an In Camera Review to Resolve the FirstEnergy Utilities’ Claim of a Privilege Against Responding to OCC’s Discovery and Motion to Require FirstEnergy Entities to File Notice If They Disclose Any Records That They Claim to Be Privileged, Motion for Expedited Ruling and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.40
01/11/2022Motion to Accept Statement of Additional Authority Regarding OCC’s Motion for an Independent Auditor, Instanter and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Alana M. Noward on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.35
01/07/2022Notice of Appearance electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.3
01/05/2022Notice of Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Trent A. Dougherty on behalf of Citizens' Utility Board of Ohio.3
12/30/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.2
12/28/2021Service Notice.12
12/28/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled in accordance with Paragraph 25 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
12/21/2021Notice of Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Matthew C. McDonnell on behalf of Citizens’ Utility Board of Ohio.3
12/14/2021Reply Comments electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.18
12/14/2021Reply Comments electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B. Goyal on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company, Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.76
12/14/2021Reply Comments of the Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Devin D. Parram.4
12/14/2021Reply Comments for Protection of FirstEnergy Utility Consumers by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.26
12/14/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel of Miranda Leppla electronically filed by Chris Tavenor on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council.11
12/14/2021Correspondence informing the Commission that Ohio Energy Group (OEG) has elected NOT to file Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.5
11/30/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Bethany Allen as Counsel and Substitution with Michael Nugent and Evan Betterton for Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. and IGS Solar, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Evan F. Betterton on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. and IGS Solar, LLC.7
11/29/2021Comments electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.41
11/29/2021Comments for Protection of FirstEnergy Utility Consumers by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.36
11/29/2021Correspondence declining to file Initial Comments but reserving the right to file Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.3
11/29/2021Initial Comments by the Citizens' Utility Board of Ohio electronically filed by Ms. Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Citizens’ Utility Board of Ohio.25
11/29/2021Correspondence declining to file Initial Comments and reserving the right to file Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.3
11/29/2021Notice that The Ohio Hospital Association will not be filing Initial Comments electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Devin D. Parram.2
11/29/2021Notice that Ohio Energy Group (OEG) has elected not to file Comments in the above-referenced docket electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.5
11/29/2021Ohio Energy Group (OEG) letter advising the Commission that it will NOT file Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.5
11/19/2021Reply and Memorandum in Support of OCC's Motion for an Independent Auditor to Investigate and Audit the Political and Charitable Activity of FirstEnergy Entities Related to Tainted House Bill 6 and Motion for the PUCO to Appoint a Committee Independent of the PUCO to Hire and Oversee the Independent Investigation and Audit by Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Tracy J. Greene on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.31
11/12/2021Memorandum Contra to OCC's Revised Motion for an Independent Auditor and Motion for the PUCO to Appoint an Independent Committee electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B Goyal on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.64
10/28/2021Service Notice12
10/28/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that the deadlines for filing initial comments and reply comments regarding the Companies’ response to the show cause order be set as November 29, 2021, and December 14, 2021, respectively, in accordance with Paragraph 20 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
10/27/2021Revised Motion for an Independent Auditor to Investigate and Audit the Political and Charitable Activity of FirstEnergy Entities Related to Tainted House Bill 6 and Motion for the PUCO to Appoint a Committee Independent of the PUCO to Hire and Oversee the Independent Investigation and Audit and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel [Please note this document was served on parties in its unredacted form on 10/26/2021. After serving parties an unredacted motion yesterday, we were advised that the document had been rejected for filing by PUCO Docketing. This revised document, with redactions on attachments 1, 3, and 4, is being filed at the direction of the PUCO ] electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Mrs. Maureen R. Willis.42
10/12/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council.10
09/24/2021Correspondence by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Mrs. Maureen R. Willis.2
09/24/2021Motion for Subpoena Duces Tecum for FirstEnergy Corp. To Produce All Discovery Documents That FirstEnergy Corp. was Ordered to Provide by The U.S. Chief District Judge in a Shareholder Lawsuit by Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Tracy J. Greene on behalf of Maureen R. Willis.28
09/23/2021Notice of Appearance electronically filed by Mrs. Shalini B Goyal on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.4
09/15/2021Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel on behalf the Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Devin D. Parram.3
09/13/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel's Request Interlocutory Appeal, Request for Certification to the PUCO Commissioners, and Application for Review electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.21
09/13/2021Transcript in the matter of the Ohio Edison Company hearing held 08/31/21 at 10:01 a.m. in the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, via Webex, before Attorney Examiners Mr. Gregory Price, Ms. Megan Addison, and Ms. Jacky St. John electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.58
09/07/2021Request Interlocutory Appeal, Request for Certification to the PUCO Commissioners, and Application for Review by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.39
08/30/2021Service Notice9
08/30/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that the prehearing conference be converted to a virtual conference in accordance with Paragraph 19 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
08/09/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Designation of Counsel of Record of Environmental Law and Policy Center electronically filed by Ms. Caroline Cox on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.7
08/06/2021Motion to Leave to File a Supplemental Response to the September 15, 2020 Show Cause Entry and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Michael R. Gladman on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.114
08/03/2021Service Notice.10
08/03/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that a prehearing conference be scheduled in accordance with Paragraphs 17, 18, and 19 electronically filed by Heather A. Chilcote on behalf of Gregory A. Price, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
07/29/2021Service Notice.9
07/29/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering the deadlines for filing initial comments and reply comments be stayed indefinitely electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.6
07/23/2021Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company’s Memorandum of Non-Opposition To OCC and OMAEG’s Joint Motion To Indefinitely Stay the Comment Schedule or, in the Alternative, To Extend the Comment Schedule for 120 Days electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company.54
07/21/2021Reply to FirstEnergy's Opposition to OCC's Motion for an In Camera Hearing to Resolve FirstEnergy's Claim of an Alleged Privilege Against Responding to OCC's Discovery by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Patricia J Mallarnee on behalf of Willis, Maureen Ms.6
07/21/2021Reply to FirstEnergy's Opposition to OCC's Motion for an In Camera Hearing to Resolve FirstEnergy's Claim of an Alleged Privilege Against Responding to OCC's Discovery by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Patricia J Mallarnee on behalf of Willis, Maureen Ms.6
07/20/2021Service Notice10
07/20/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that the deadlines for filing initial comments and reply comments be extended by an additional 10 days to July 30, 2021 and August 13, 2021, respectively electronically filed by Heather A. Chilcote on behalf of Michael L. Williams, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio6
07/19/2021Joint Motion to Indefinitely Stay The Comment Schedule or, In The Alternative, To Extend the Comment Schedule for 120 days and Request for Expedited Ruling by Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel and The Ohio Manufacturers’ Association Energy Group and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Tracy J. Greene on behalf of Maureen R. Willis.12
07/14/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumer's Counsel's Motion for In Camera Hearing on the Fifth and Seventh Sets of Discovery electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.5
07/14/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion for In Camera Hearing on the Sixth Set of Discovery electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.6
07/13/2021Transcript for hearing held on 06/30/21 at 2:00 p.m., via Webex, before Attorney Examiner's Mr. Gregory Price, Ms. Megan Addison and Ms. Jacky St. John electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Mrs. Karen Sue Gibson.37
07/09/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion to Compel Responses to the Fifth and Seventh Sets of Discovery electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.26
07/09/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion to Compel Responses to the Sixth Set of Discovery electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.20
06/29/2021Motion to Compel Responses to Fifth and Seventh Sets of Discovery and Request For Expedited Ruling on Motion to Compel and Motion for In-Camera Hearing by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R. Mrs.64
06/29/2021Motion to Compel Responses to Sixth Set of Discovery and Request For Expedited Ruling on Motion to Compel and Motion for In-Camera Hearing by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R. Mrs.77
06/23/2021Service Notice10
06/23/2021Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a prehearing conference on June 30, 2021, at 2:00 p.m. electronically filed by Ms. Mary E Fischer on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.6
05/13/2021Service Notice.10
05/13/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that the deadlines for filing initial comments and reply comments be extended by an additional 60 days to July 20, 2021 for initial comments and August 3, 2021 for reply comments; that the filing of additional requests for discovery in this proceeding be stayed for 60 days from the issuance of this Entry; and, that a prehearing conference be held, on a date to be established by subsequent entry, to hear arguments on and address the issues raised in the motions to compel discovery filed on April 28, 2021 electronically filed by Heather A. Chilcote on behalf of Gregory A. Price, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.12
05/05/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion to Compel Responses to Fourth Set of Discovery electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.14
05/05/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Motion to Compel Responses to Third Set of Discovery Requests electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.16
05/03/2021Memorandum Contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Request for Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.23
04/29/2021Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.3
04/28/2021Motion to Compel Responses to Fourth Set of Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.56
04/28/2021Motion to Compel Responses to Third Set of Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.75
04/27/2021Interlocutory Appeal, Request for Certification to Commissioners and Application for Review by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Mrs. Maureen R. Willis.20
04/22/2021Service Notice.10
04/22/2021Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that interested parties file initial and reply comments regarding the Companies’ September 30, 2020 response to the show cause order by May 21, 2021, and June 4, 2021, respectively, and granting the motion to intervene filed by OEG electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Jacky Werman St. John, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.5
04/14/2021Addition to Service List electronically filed by Ms. Caroline Cox on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.7
04/05/2021Transcript for hearing held on 03/25/21 at 10:04 am, via Webex, before Attorney Examiners Mr. Gregory Price, Ms. Megan Addison and Ms. Jacky St. John electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Carolyn Burke.58
03/24/2021Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Evan F. Betterton on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.5
03/09/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.3
03/04/2021Service Notice.10
03/04/2021Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a prehearing conference for 3/25/21 at 10:00 a.m. and granting the motions to intervene filed by OCC, OHA, OMAEG, OEC, IGS, NRDC, OPAE, IEU-Ohio, ELPC, NOAC, and CUB electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.6
03/01/2021Second Amended Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents by Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Tracy J Greene on behalf of Willis, Maureen R.6
02/18/2021Reply of the Environmental Advocates to the FirstEnergy Utilities' Memorandum Contra the Amended Motion to Expand the Scope of the Commission's Review of FirstEnergy's Political and Charitable Spending electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council.16
02/11/2021Memorandum Contra the Amended Motion of ELPC/OEC to Expand the Scope of the Commission's Review electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.14
02/10/2021Letter Regarding Deposition by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.2
01/28/2021Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dylan F. Borchers.3
01/27/2021Amended Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.5
01/27/2021Amended Motion of the Environmental Advocates to Expand the Scope of the Commission's Review of FirstEnergy's Political and Charitable Spending and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council.22
01/21/2021Motion to Intervene by the Citizens’ Utility Board of Ohio and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Ms. Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Citizens’ Utility Board of Ohio.8
01/19/2021Transcript for hearing held on 01/07/21 before Mr. Gregory Price, Ms. Megan Addison, and Ms. Jacky St. John, Attorney Examiners, at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, via Webex, electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.45
12/30/2020Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Update on Additional Efforts to Resolve its Motion to Compel and its Consumer Discovery Objected to by FirstEnergy electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.3
12/30/2020Correspondence Regarding the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Discovery Requests electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.3
12/29/2020Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Notice of Appearance of Counsel by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.4
12/21/2020Memorandum Contra Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.13
12/15/2020Interlocutory Appeal: Request for Certification to Commissioners and Application for Review by Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.20
12/11/2020Service Notice.8
12/10/2020Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a prehearing conference on 01/07/21 at 10:00 a.m. and ordering the parties reengage in discussions to resolve the discovery dispute and file a letter with the Commission by 12/30/20 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.5
11/24/2020Notice of Change of Firm Affiliation electronically filed by Ms. Kari D Hehmeyer on behalf of Alexander, Trevor Mr.3
11/23/2020Notice of Appearance and Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Ryan A. Doringo on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.4
11/17/2020Memorandum Contra OCC's Motion to Compel Responses to Discovery electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.19
11/10/2020Revised Motion to Compel Responses to Discovery and Memorandum in Support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.104
11/10/2020Letter Regarding the Revised Motion to Compel by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.2
11/09/2020Reply in Support of Motion for Protective Order electronically filed by Mr. James F. Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.20
11/06/2020Motion to Compel Responses to Discovery and memorandum in support by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.83
11/02/2020Memorandum Contra to Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's Motion for a Protective Order electronically filed by Ms. Miranda R Leppla on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council.14
11/02/2020Memorandum Contra FirstEnergy's Motion for Protective Order to Deny Discovery Information for OCC by Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Mrs. Maureen R. Willis.24
11/02/2020Memorandum Contra to Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's Motion for a Protective Order electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.13
11/02/2020Memorandum Contra Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's Motion for Protective Order of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.17
10/28/2020Reply in Support of The Ohio Hospital Association's Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dylan F. Borchers.10
10/27/2020Reply in Support of The Ohio Hospital Association's Motion to Intervene filed by D. Borchers on behalf of The Ohio Hospital Association. (FAX)10
10/22/2020Reply to The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.21
10/21/2020Reply in Support of Ohio Environmental Council's Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Ms. Miranda R Leppla on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council.11
10/21/2020Reply of The Environmental Advocates to FirstEnergy's Memorandum Contra the Motion to Expand the Scope of the Commission's Review of FirstEnergy's Political and Charitable Spending electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Law & Policy Center.12
10/21/2020Reply in Support of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Michael A Nugent on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.11
10/21/2020Reply in Support of Natural Resources Defense Council's Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.10
10/21/2020Reply in Support of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy's Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.10
10/20/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of OHA electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.6
10/20/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of NOAC electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.7
10/20/2020Service Notice9
10/20/2020Attorney Examiner Entry ordering memoranda contra the motion for a protective order be filed by 11/2/20; vacating deadlines for filing comments re: response to the 9/15/20 Entry; and, scheduling of a prehearing conference to a date set by future entry. electronically filed by Ms. Mary E Fischer on behalf of Gregory A. Price, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.5
10/16/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.7
10/16/2020Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum in Suport electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.76
10/15/2020Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company to the Motion to Intervene by the Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Ms. Kari D. Hehmeyer on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.7
10/14/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of OPAE electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
10/14/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.7
10/14/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of OEC electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
10/14/2020Memorandum Contra to the Motion to Intervene of NRDC electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
10/14/2020Memorandum Contra the Motion of ELPC/OEC to Expand the Scope of the Commission's Review electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.17
10/13/2020Reply Memorandum In Support Of The Environmental Law & Policy Center's Motion To Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.10
10/09/2020Notice to Take Deposition and Request for Production of Documents by the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.5
10/07/2020Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support of The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dylan F. Borchers.5
10/06/2020Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel on Behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. electronically filed by Mr. Justin M Dortch on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.3
10/05/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support by the Northwest Aggregation Coalition electronically filed by Mr. Thomas R. Hays on behalf of NOAC.5
10/05/2020Memorandum Contra the Motion to Intervene by ELPC electronically filed by Mr. James F. Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.7
09/30/2020Response to Show Cause Entry electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
09/30/2020 Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.8
09/29/2020Motion of the Environmental Advocates to Expand the Scope of the Commission’s Review into the FirstEnergy’s Political and Charitable Spending and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council.14
09/29/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. electronically filed by Bethany Allen on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.8
09/29/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.7
09/29/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.7
09/29/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support by the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Ms. Miranda R Leppla on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council.9
09/28/2020Memorandum Contra Interlocutory Appeal, Request for Certification and Application for Review by OCC electronically filed by Mr. James F. Lang on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.18
09/23/2020Motion Ohio Energy Group (OEG) Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.6
09/21/2020Interlocutory Appeal, Request for Certification to the Commission, and Application for Review and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Willis, Maureen R Mrs.135
09/21/2020Motion to Intervene by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Mrs. Maureen R. Willis.113
09/21/2020Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Robert Kelter electronically filed by Mr. Robert Kelter on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.6
09/18/2020Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support of the Motion to Intervene electronically filed by Ms. Caroline Cox on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.8
09/15/2020Service Notice2
09/15/2020Attorney Examiner Entry ordering that the Companies comply with the directive contained Paragraph 5 of this Entry and ordering that comments and reply comments regarding the Companies’response be filed in accordance with Paragraph 6 electronically filed by Heather A Chilcote on behalf of Gregory A. Price, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.4
09/15/2020In the Matter of the Review of the Political and Charitable Spending by Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company electronically filed by Docketing Staff.2