DIS - Case Record for 20-1034-EL-UNC Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 20-1034-EL-UNC
CASE DESCRIPTION: In the Matter of the Determination of the Existence of Significantly Excessive Earnings for 2019 Under the Electric Security Plans
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 4/23/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________

Parties of Record

Attorneys
Applicant
 
CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING COMPANY KNIPE, BRIAN
FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
76 S MAIN STREET  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
AKRON OH 44308 AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5795
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
 
OHIO EDISON COMPANY KNIPE, BRIAN
BRAD BINGAMAN FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
76 SOUTH MAIN STREET  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
AKRON  OH 44308 AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5795
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
 
TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY KNIPE, BRIAN
FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
76 SOUTH MAIN ST  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
AKRON  OH 44308 AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5795
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
Attorney
 
none GLADMAN, MICHAEL R. ATTORNEY
JONES DAY
  325 JOHN H. MCCONNELL BLVD. 
    COLUMBUS OHIO  43215
Phone: 614-469-3939
Fax: 614-461-4198
 
 
none PRITCHARD, MATTHEW
MCNEES WALLACE & NURICK LLC
  250 WEST STREET, SUITE 550 
    COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-469-8000
Fax: 614-459-4653
 
 
none DENGLER, MARGARET M
JONES DAY
  325 JOHN H MCCONNELL BLVD STE 600 
    COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: (614) 469-3939
Fax: (614) 461-4198
 
 
none *Dove, Robert Mr.
KEGLER BROWN HILL RITTER CO LPA
  65 E STATE ST STE 1800 
    COLUMBUS OH  43215-4295
Phone: 614-462-5443 or 614-286-4
Fax: 614-464-2634
 
 
none LAVANGA, MICHAEL K
STONE MATTHEIS XENOPOULOS & BREW PC
  1025 THOMAS JEFFERSON ST NW STE 800 W 
    WASHINGTON CD  20007
Phone: (202) 342-0800
Fax: (202) 342-0807
 
 
none DORINGO, RYAN A. ATTORNEY
JONES DAY
  901 LAKESIDE AVENUE 
    CLEVELAND OHIO  44114
Phone: 216-586-3939
Fax: 216-579-0212
 
 
none Nugent, Michael
  6100 Emerald Parkway 
    Dublin Ohio  43016
Phone: 614-659-5000
 
 
none COHN, JODY KYLER
BOEHM, KURTZ & LOWRY
  36 EAST SEVENTH STREET, SUITE 1510 
    CINCINNATI OHIO  45202
 
 
none BRISCAR, JOSEPH R
STONE MATTHEIS XENOPOULOS & BREW PC
  1025 THOMAS JEFFERSON ST NW STE 800 W 
    WASHINGTON DC  20007
Phone: (202) 342-0800
Fax: (202) 342-0807
 
 
none BOEHM, KURT J. ESQ
BOEHM, KURTZ & LOWRY
  36 E SEVENTH STREET SUITE 1510
    CINCINNATI OH  45202
Phone: (513) 421-2255
Fax: (513) 421-2764
 
 
none OLIKER, JOSEPH E.
IGS ENERGY
  6100 EMERALD PARKWAY 
    DUBLIN OH  43016
Phone: 614-659-5000
 
 
none *Bingham, Deb J. Ms.
Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel
  65 East State Street, 7th Floor 
   Columbus OH  43215-4203
Phone: 614-466-1311
Fax: 614-466-9475
 
 
none *Sweeney, Karen A.
FirstEnergy
  76 South Main Street 
   Akron OH  44308
Phone: 330-761-7889
Fax: 330-255-1017
 
 
none *Whitfield, Angela Mrs.
Carpenter Lipps & Leland LLP
  280 North High Street, Suite 1300 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614-365-4112
Fax: 614-365-9145
 
 
none *Keaney, Mark T.
Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff LLP
  41 S High Street Ste 2600 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 223-9369
Fax: (614) 223-9330
 
 
none Mains, Rachael N.
Bricker Graydon LLP
  100 S Third St 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614 227-4851
Fax: 614-227-2390
 
 
none *Orahood, Teresa
Bricker & Eckler LLP
  100 South Third Street 
   Columbus OH  43215-4291
Phone: (614) 227-4821
Fax: (614) 227-2390
 
 
none *Scott, Tonnetta Y. Mrs.
Ohio Attorney General
  30 East Broad Street 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614-466-4395
 
 
none HEALEY, CHRISTOPHER
OHIO CONSUMERS COUNSEL
  65 E STATE STREET SUITE 700
   COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-466-9571
 
 
none *Bojko, Kimberly W. Mrs.
Carpenter Lipps LLP
  280 North High Street 280 Plaza Suite 1300
   Columbus  OH  43215
Phone: 614-365-4100
Fax: 614-365-9145
 
 
none *Spencer, Ken Mr.
Armstrong & Okey, Inc.
  222 East Town Street, 2nd Floor 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614-224-9481
Fax: 614-224-5724
 
 
none *Greene, Tracy J. Mrs.
Ohio Consumers' Counsel
  65 East State St. 7th Floor
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614-466-9547
Fax: 614-466-8574
 
 
none *Betterton, Evan F. Mr.
IGS Energy
  6100 Emerald Parkway 
   Dublin OH  43016
Phone: (904) 305-4584 or (614) 6
 
 
none O'BRIEN, ANGELA
  65 EAST STATE STREET, 7TH FLOOR 
   COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-466-9531
 
 
none *Fischer, Mary E. Ms.
Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
  180 E. Broad St.  
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 466-6843
 
 
none *Michael, William J. Mr.
Ohio Consumers' Counsel
  65 East State Street 7th Floor
   Columbus OH  43015
Phone: 614-466-1291
 
 
none *Chilcote, Heather A.
Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
  180 East Broad Street 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 466-0644
 
 
none *Oliker, Joseph E. Mr.
IGS Energy
  6100 Emerald Parkway 
   Dublin OH  43016
Phone: 614-659-5069
 
 
none *Cohn, Jody Kyler Mrs.
Boehm, Kurtz & Lowry
  36 E. Seventh St. Ste 1510 
   Cincinnati OH  45202
Phone: (513) 421-2255
Fax: (513) 421-2764
 
 
none *Pritchard, Matthew R. Mr.
McNees Wallace & Nurick
  250 West Street Suite 550
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: 614-719-2840
Fax: 614-469-4653
 
 
none *Lavanga, Michael K. Mr.
Stone Mattheis Xenopoulos & Brew, PC
  1025 Thomas Jefferson St., NW 8th Floor West Tower
   Washington DC  20007
Phone: 202-342-0800
Fax: 202-342-0807
 
 
none *Kurtz, Michael L. Mr.
Boehm, Kurtz & Lowry
  36 E. Seventh St., Suite 1510
   Cincinnati OH  45202
Phone: (513)421-2255
Fax: (513)421-2764
 
 
none BOEHM, KURT J. ESQ
BOEHM, KURTZ & LOWRY
  36 E SEVENTH STREET SUITE 1510
   CINCINNATI OH  45202
Phone: (513) 421-2255
Fax: (513) 421-2764
 
 
none *King, Kelli C.
PUCO
  180 E. Broad St. 
   Columbus OH  43215
Phone: (614) 466-0461
 
 
none *Nugent, Michael A. Mr.
IGS Energy
  6100 Emerald Parkway 
   Dublin OH  43016
Phone: 614-659-5065
 
 
none ALEXANDER, N. TREVOR
BENESCH FRIEDLANDER COPLAN & ARONOFF LLP
  41 S HIGH ST STE 2600 
   COLUMBUS OH  43215-6164
Phone: 614-223-9363
Fax: 614-223-9330
 
 
none KNIPE, BRIAN
FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
   AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5795
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
 
none *Boehm, Kurt J. Mr.
Boehm, Kurtz & Lowry
  36 E. Seventh Street Suite 1510
   Cincinnati OH  45202
Phone: (513)421-2255
Fax: (513)421-2764
 
 
Ohio Edison Company NONE
N. Trevor Alexander
76 South Main Street   
Akron Oh 44308    
Phone: (330) 384-5795
 
 
The Ohio Hospital Association MAINS, RACHAEL N. ATTORNEY
BRICKER GRAYDON LLP
  100 S THIRD ST 
   COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: (614) 227-4851
 
 
The Ohio Hospital Association BORCHERS, DYLAN F.
BRICKER GRAYDON LLP
  100 S THIRD ST 
   COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-227-4914
Fax: 614-227-2390
 
 
The Ohio Hospital Association PARRAM, DEVIN D.
BRICKER GRAYDON LLP
  100 S THIRD ST 
   COLUMBUS OHIO  43215
Phone: (614) 227-8813
Fax: (614) 227-2390
 
 
WYGONSKI, JONATHAN NONE
CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND LLP 280 NORTH HIGH STREET, SUITE 1300  
COLUMBUS OH 43215    
Phone: 614-365-4100
 
Intervenor
 
INTERSTATE GAS SUPPLY INC NONE
BETHANY ALLEN
6100 EMERALD PARKWAY   
DUBLIN OH 43016    
Phone: 614-659-5000
 
 
NORTHEAST OHIO PUBLIC ENERGY COUNCIL KRASSEN, GLENN S. ATTY AT LAW
BRICKER & ECKLER LLP
31360 SOLON ROAD SUITE 33 1350 EUCLID AVE STE 650 
SOLON OH 44139 CLEVELAND OH  44115
Phone: 440-248-1992 Phone: 216-523-5405
Fax: 216-523-7071
 
 
NUCOR STEEL MARION, INC BRISCAR, JOSEPH R
STONE MATTHEIS XENOPOULOS & BREW PC
912 CHENEY AVENUE  1025 THOMAS JEFFERSON ST NW STE 800 W 
MARION OH 43302 WASHINGTON DC  20007
Phone: (202) 342-0800
Fax: (202) 342-0807
 
 
OHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSEL WESTON, BRUCE
65 E STATE ST 7TH FL  OHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSEL 65 E STATE ST 7th FLOOR
COLUMBUS OH 43215 COLUMBUS OH  43215-4203
Phone: 614-466-7964
 
 
OHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSEL ASSISTANT COUNSEL NONE
WILLIAM MICHAEL
65 E STATE ST 7TH FL   
COLUMBUS OH 43215    
Phone: (614) 466-1291
 
 
OHIO ENERGY GROUP NONE
36 E. SEVENTH ST. SUITE 1510  
CINCINNATI OH 45202    
 
 
OHIO ENERGY LEADERSHIP COUNCIL (OELC), FKA INDUSTRIAL ENERGY USERS-OHIO NONE
PETER TURNER
28601 CHAGRIN BLVD., SUITE 600   
WOODMERE OH 44122    
 
 
OHIO HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION BORCHERS, DYLAN F.
BRICKER GRAYDON LLP BRICKER GRAYDON LLP
100 S THIRD ST  100 S THIRD ST 
COLUMBUS OH 43215-4291 COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-227-2300 Phone: 614-227-4914
Fax: 614-227-2390 Fax: 614-227-2390
 
 
OHIO MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION ENERGY GROUP BOJKO, KIMBERLY W
KIMBERLY BOJKO CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND LLP
CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND LLP 280 NORTH HIGH STREET, SUITE 1300 280 NORTH HIGH STREET, SUITE 1300 
COLUMBUS  OH 43215 COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-365-4100 Phone: 614-365-4124
Fax: 614-365-9145
 
 
THE KROGER CO WHITFIELD, ANGELA PAUL
ANGELA PAUL WHITFIELD CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND LLP
280 NORTH HIGH STREET, SUITE 1300  280 NORTH HIGH STREET SUITE 1300
COLUMBUS OH 43215 COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: 614-365-4100 Phone: 614-365-4100
Fax: 614-365-9145
 
Party of Record
 
INTERSTATE GAS SUPPLY INC NONE
BETHANY ALLEN
6100 EMERALD PARKWAY   
DUBLIN OH 43016    
Phone: 614-659-5000
 
 
KROGER CO, ANGELA PAUL WHITFIELD NONE
CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND
280 PLAZA, SUITE 1300 280 NORTH HIGH STREET  
COLUMBUS OH 43215    
Phone: 614-365-4100
 
 
NOPEC INC ATTORNEY NONE
GLENN S KRASSEN
BRICKER & ECKLER LLP 1001 LAKESIDE AVE E SUITE 1350  
CLEVELAND OH 44114-1142    
Phone: (216) 523-5469
 
 
NORTHEAST OHIO PUBLIC ENERGY COUNCIL ATTORNEY STINSON, DANE
GLENN S KRASSEN BRICKER & ECKLER
BRICKER & ECKLER LLP 31360 SOLON RD STE 33 100 S THIRD ST 
SOLON OH 44139 COLUMBUS OH  43215
Phone: (216) 523-5469 Phone: 614-227-4854
Fax: 614-221-0479
 
 
NUCOR STEEL MARION, INC LAVANGA, MICHAEL K
STONE MATTHEIS XENOPOULOS & BREW PC
912 CHENEY AVENUE  1025 THOMAS JEFFERSON ST NW STE 800 W 
MARION OH 43302 WASHINGTON CD  20007
Phone: (202) 342-0800
Fax: (202) 342-0807
 
 
OHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSEL ASSISTANT COUNSEL WILLIS, MAUREEN R
WILLIAM MICHAEL
65 E STATE ST 7TH FL  65 EAST STATE STREET, 7TH FLOOR 
COLUMBUS OH 43215 COLUMBUS  OH  43215-4203
Phone: (614) 466-1291 Phone: 614-466-9567
 
 
OHIO EDISON COMPANY KNIPE, BRIAN
BRAD BINGAMAN FIRSTENERGY SERVICE COMPANY
76 SOUTH MAIN STREET  76 SOUTH MAIN STREET 
AKRON  OH 44308 AKRON OH  44308
Phone: 330-384-5795
Fax: 330-384-3875
 
 
OHIO ENERGY LEADERSHIP COUNCIL (OELC), FKA INDUSTRIAL ENERGY USERS-OHIO NONE
PETER TURNER
28601 CHAGRIN BLVD., SUITE 600   
WOODMERE OH 44122    
 
 
OHIO MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION ENERGY GROUP NONE
KIMBERLY BOJKO
CARPENTER LIPPS & LELAND LLP 280 NORTH HIGH STREET, SUITE 1300  
COLUMBUS  OH 43215    
Phone: 614-365-4100
 
 
OHIO PARTNERS FOR AFFORDABLE ENERGY NONE
ROBERT DOVE
65 E STATE ST., SUITE 1800   
COLUMBUS OH 43215-4295    
Phone: 614-462-5443
Fax: 614-464-2634
 
*Indicates that filer has agreed to be automatically served via electronic mail.