DIS - Case Record for 17-2168-GA-CSS Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 17-2168-GA-CSS
CASE DESCRIPTION: SUBURBAN NATURAL GAS CO VS COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 4/18/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
09/01/2023 Case Action Form closing cases effective 9/1/23 electronically filed by Debbie S. Ryan on behalf of Patricia A. Schabo, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
06/14/2022 Notice of Withdrawal electronically filed by Ms. Valerie A. Cahill on behalf of Whitt-Sturtevant.
12/07/2020 Supreme Court Document in the matter of the complaint of Suburban Natural Gas Company vs Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc issued by Chief Justice Maureen O'Connor.
03/13/2020 Service Notice
03/12/2020 Supreme Court Transmittals. (SC# 19-1765)
03/05/2020 Notice of the Supreme Court of Ohio Case Announcements Motion and Procedural Ruling for 2019-1765 In re Complaint of Suburban Natural Gas Co. v. Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly M Naeder on behalf of PUCO.
03/04/2020 Notice of withdrawal of Stephen B. Seiple electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
01/17/2020 Service Notice
01/17/2020 Supreme Court Transmittals. (SC# 19-1765)
12/19/2019 Supreme Court Notice of Appeal field by Suburban Natural Gas Company. S.C. #19-1765.
11/26/2019 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Notice of Appearance of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Lucas A Fykes on behalf of Whitt Sturtevant LLP.
10/23/2019 Service Notice
10/23/2019 Second Entry on Rehearing that the Commission denies the application for rehearing filed by Suburban Natural Gas Company electronically filed by Docketing Staff.
07/24/2019 Notice of Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Shelli T. Clark on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
06/05/2019 Service Notice.
06/05/2019 Entry on Rehearing ordering that Suburban's May 13, 2019 motion for leave to file a corrected application for rehearing be denied; that Suburban's May 10, 2019 application for rehearing be granted for further consideration.
05/20/2019 Memorandum Contra to Application for Rehearing of Suburban Natural Gas Company electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
05/13/2019 Motion for Leave to File Corrected Application for Rehearing (Expedited Ruling Requested) and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Shelli T Clark on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
05/10/2019 Application for Rehearing electronically filed by Shelli T Clark on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
04/11/2019 Service Notice
04/10/2019 Opinion & Order stating that the complaint be decided in favor of Columbia and closed of record.
02/22/2019 Notice of Appearance of Counsel and Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Shelli T. Clark on behalf of Christopher T. Kennedy.
06/26/2018 Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion to Strike Exhibit A of Complainant's Reply Brief electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
06/19/2018 Memorandum Contra Motion to Strike electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
06/04/2018 Motion to Strike Exhibit A of the Complainant's Reply Brief and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
05/30/2018 Correspondence Regarding Exhibit A to its Reply Brief electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
05/29/2018 Post-Hearing Reply Brief electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
05/29/2018 Post-Hearing Reply Brief electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
05/25/2018 Service Notice.
05/25/2018 Attorney Examiner Entry denying the application for certification of interlocutory appeal electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio Attorney Examiner Sarah J. Parrot.
05/15/2018 Initial Post-Hearing Brief electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
05/15/2018 Initial Post-Hearing Brief electronically filed by Cheryl A. MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
05/15/2018 Post-Hearing Brief of Intervenors Delaware County Board of Commissioners and Delaware County Engineer electronically filed by Mr. Aric I. Hochstettler on behalf of Delaware County Board of Commissioners and Delaware County Engineer.
05/10/2018 Service Notice.
05/10/2018 Attorney Examiner Entry setting a revised briefing schedule. electronically filed by Ms. Mary E Fischer on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
04/19/2018 Public Exhibits Suburban 5, 32, 33, 34 and 40, Columbia Ex. 6 for deposition held on 3/13/18 (volume III) filed by Armstrong and Okey on behalf of PUCO Staff.
04/19/2018 PUCO Exhibit Filing: Proceedings Volume II, Suburban Exhibits 6 - 12, 14 - 17 and 22-30 filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of PUCO Staff.
04/19/2018 Public Exhibits Suburban 2 and Columbia Ex. 1, 2 and 4 for proceeding (volume I) held on 4/3/18 before Megan Addison and Patricia Schabo, Attorney Examiners, filed by Armstrong and Okey on behalf of PUCO Staff.
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Proceedings Volume II Highly Confidential Session filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (5 pages)
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Exhibits - Suburban Ex. 41-HC, 42-HC, 43-HC and 44-HC filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (40 pages)
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Exhibits - Suburban Ex 37-C, 38-C & 39-C filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (9 pages)
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Proceedings Volume III Highly Confidential Session filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (6 pages)
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Proceedings Volume III Confidential Session filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (9 pages)
04/19/2018 Confidential Document Target: Proceeding Volume II Confidential Session filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas. (15 pages)
04/19/2018 Transcript Volume III for hearing held on April 5th, 2018 at the PUCO, 180 East Broad Street, Room 11-A, Columbus, Ohio at 9:00 am electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Burke, Carolyn.
04/19/2018 Transcript for hearing held on April 4, 2018 at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH 43215, hearing room 11-A, Volume II electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Burke, Carolyn.
04/18/2018 Transcript for hearing held on April 3, 2018 at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH 43215, hearing room 11-A, electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Burke, Carolyn.
04/16/2018 Memorandum Contra Suburban Natural Gas Co.'s Application for Certification of Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
04/09/2018 Application for Certification of Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
04/03/2018 Correspondence of National Gas & Oil Cooperative in Support of Concerns Raised by Suburban Natural Gas Co. electronically filed by Ms. Lija Kaleps-Clark on behalf of National Gas & Oil Cooperative.
04/02/2018 Motion to Strike Testimony of Suburban Natural Gas Co. and Memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/30/2018 Service Notice.
03/28/2018 Motion for Leave to File Direct Testimony of Robert M. Riley Out of Time and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Aric I. Hochstettler on behalf of Delaware County Board of Commissioners and Delaware County Engineer.
03/28/2018 Attorney Examiner Entry granting motions filed by Delaware County and Columbia Gas electronically filed by Ms. Mary E Fischer on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
03/28/2018 Exhibits 1-13 for Deposition Transcript of Jeffrey A. Thompson electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/28/2018 Deposition Transcript of Jeffrey A. Thompson electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/28/2018 Notice of Filing of Deposition Transcript for Jeffrey A. Thompson electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/23/2018 Motion for Leave to Supplement Testimony, memorandum in support and Request for Expedited Ruling electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/16/2018 Direct Testimony of David L. Pemberton, Sr. electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/16/2018 Direct Testimony of Andrew J. Sonderman electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/16/2018 Direct Testimony of Aaron Roll electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
03/16/2018 Motion for Protective Order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/16/2018 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by A. Hochstettler on behalf of Delaware County Board of Commissioners and Delaware County Engineer.
03/16/2018 Confidential Document Target for Prepared Testimony of Melissa L. Thompson filed by M. Stemm and Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc. (37 pages)
03/16/2018 Testimony of Melissa Thompson Attachments E through I and Attachments J through P (PUBLIC VERSIONS) electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/16/2018 Testimony of Melissa Thompson Attachment D electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/16/2018 Testimony of Melissa Thompson (PUBLIC VERSION) and Attachments A through C electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/16/2018 Testimony of Zach McPherson electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/01/2018 Service Notice
03/01/2018 Attorney Examiner Entry granting motion for continuance of the evidentiary hearing to 04/03/18 in accordance with Paragraph 6 with testimony to be filed no later than 03/16/2018 electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Patricia Schabo, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
02/28/2018 Joint Motion for Continuance electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company and Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
02/23/2018 Motion for Subpoena electronically filed by MARK A WHITT on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Co.
02/09/2018 Service Notice
02/09/2018 Attorney Examiner Entry granting Columbia's motion for ten-day extension, requiring discovery to be produced by 2/20/18. electronically filed by Ms. Mary E Fischer on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
02/07/2018 Motion of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. for Extension of Time to Respond to Suburban Natural Gas Co.'s Motion to Compel Discovery and for Expedited Ruling and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
01/31/2018 Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
01/29/2018 Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Cheryl A. MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
01/23/2018 Suburban Natural Gas Company Motion to Compel Discovery and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
01/22/2018 Memorandum Contra Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
01/05/2018 Motion to Dismiss and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
11/20/2017 Service Notice
11/20/2017 Attorney Examiner Entry directing testimony be filed no later than 03/02/2018 and scheduling evidentiary hearing for 03/13/2018 as stated in Paragraph 9 - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Patricia Schabo, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
11/13/2017 Answer to Complaint electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
11/06/2017 Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a settlement conference for November 13, 2017, at 10:00 a.m.; electronically filed by Vesta R Miller on behalf of Megan Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
11/06/2017 Service Notice
11/03/2017 Notice of Deposition - Revised by Agreement of the Parties electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
11/03/2017 Notice of Deposition - Withdrawn By Agreement of the Parties electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
11/02/2017 Notice of Deposition of Suburban Natural Gas Company electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
11/02/2017 Notice of Deposition of David L. Pemberton, Sr. electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
10/27/2017 Memorandum Contra Suburban Natural Gas Company's Motion for Interim Emergency Relief electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
10/23/2017 Complaint service letter and copy of complaint sent to; Stephen Seiple, Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
10/23/2017 Complaint response letter and brochure sent to; Mark Whitt, Suburban Natural Gas Company.
10/20/2017 Motion for Interim Emergency Relief and Request for Expedited Treatment and memorandum in support electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.
10/20/2017 In the Matter of the Complaint of Suburban Natural Gas Company against Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. and Request for Emergency Relief electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Suburban Natural Gas Company.