DIS - Case Record for 13-0652-EL-ORD Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 13-0652-EL-ORD
CASE DESCRIPTION: COMMISSION'S REVIEW OF ITS RULES FOR THE ALTERNATIVE ENERGY PORTFOLIO STANDARD
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 11/21/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
06/29/2020 Case Action Form closing case with an effective date of 06/29/20 electronically filed by Kelli C. King on behalf of Anna Sanyal, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
03/25/2020 Service Notice
03/25/2020 Attorney Examiner Entry Ohio Adm Code Chapters 4901:1-39 and 4901:1-40 be effective 3.36.20; pending RPS compliance cases with a Staff Report proceed as Rules. electronically filed by Mrs. Kelli C King on behalf of Anna Sanyal, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
12/06/2019 Notice of withdrawal of Christopher A Walker and Jack A Van Kley electronically filed by Mr. Christopher A Walker on behalf of Union Neighbors United and McConnell, Robert Mr. and McConnell, Diane Mrs. and Johnson, Julia F. Ms.
11/26/2019 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Notice of Appearance of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Lucas A. Fykes on behalf of Whitt Sturtevant LLP.
10/04/2019 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Designation of Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
09/23/2019 Notice of change of address for John Finnigan.
09/19/2019 Service Notice (Return Mail Resent)
09/12/2019 Return Mail Fourth Entry on Rehearing returned to sender refused unable to forward.
09/12/2019 Return Mail Fourth Entry on Rehearing : Return to sender not deliverable as addressed unable to forward.
08/28/2019 Fourth Entry on Rehearing that the Commission denies the applications for rehearing filed by Industrial Energy Users-Ohio, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council, and the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Docketing Staff.
08/28/2019 Service Notice
06/24/2019 Return Mail: Third Entry on Rehearing, Union Neighbors Unit, not deliverable as addressed, unable to forward.
06/21/2019 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by the Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.
06/05/2019 Service Notice.
06/05/2019 Third Entry on Rehearing ordering that the parties' May 10, 2019 applications for rehearing be granted for further consideration.
05/20/2019 Notice of withdrawal Notice of Withdrawal/Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr Robert M Endris on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.
05/20/2019 Ohio Power Company's and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s Memorandum Contra Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's Application for Rehearing electronically filed by Mr. Steven T Nourse on behalf of Ohio Power Company and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/20/2019 Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company to Applications for Rehearing by Conservation Groups and the Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Mr Robert M Endris on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.
05/10/2019 Second Application for Rehearing electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund and Environmental Law and Policy Center.
05/10/2019 Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's Application for Rehearing and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Frank P Darr on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
04/10/2019 Service Notice
04/10/2019 Second Entry on Rehearing granting in part the applications for rehearing filed by Ohio Power Company and the Dayton Power & Light Company; Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company; Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., Environmental Law & Policy Center, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council, and the Ohio Environmental Council and denying the applications for rehearing filed by Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. and the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
02/20/2019 Return Mail for Citizens Colation, Joseph Meissner - Entry on Rehearing dated 02/06/19 "Return to Sender, Attempted - Not Known, Unable to Forward".
02/06/2019 Service Notice
02/06/2019 Entry on rehearing granting the parties' for further consideration of the matters specified in the application for rehearing.
01/28/2019 Memorandum Contra of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. to Rehearing Applications electronically filed by Bethany Allen on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
01/28/2019 Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company to Applications for Rehearing by Conversation Groups and the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Ashlee E Waite on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company and Endris, Robert M Mr.
01/28/2019 Conservation Groups' Memorandum Contra Rehearing Applications by the Ohio Electric Distribution Utilities electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.
01/28/2019 Memorandum Contra Electric Distribution Utilities' Applications for Rehearing by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.
01/28/2019 Memorandum Contra of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio to Applications for Rehearing electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
01/18/2019 Application for Rehearing by Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. electronically filed by Bethany Allen on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.
01/18/2019 Application for Rehearing by Conservation Groups electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center and Natural Resources Defense Council and Ohio Environmental Council and Environmental Defense Fund.
01/18/2019 Notice of Appearance of Counsel by the Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Madeline Fleisher on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Cente.
01/18/2019 Application for Rehearing of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
01/18/2019 Application for Rehearing by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Healey, Christopher Mr.
01/18/2019 App for Rehearing of Ohio Power Company and The Dayton Power & Light Company electronically filed by Mr. Eric B. Gallon on behalf of Ohio Power Company and The Dayton Power & Light Company.
01/04/2019 Return mail for Citizens Coalition - "Return to Sender, Attempted - Not Known, Unable to Forward".
12/31/2018 Return Mail for Environmental Defense Fund (John Finnigan) - "Return to Sender, Not Deliverable as Addressed, Unable to Forward".
12/20/2018 Service Notice
12/19/2018 Finding & Order adopting the amended Ohio Adm.Code 4901:1-39-03 and 4901:1-40-01, -02, -06, -08, -09; that the existing Ohio Adm.Code 4901:1-39-01, -02, -04, -05, -06, -07, -08 and 4901:1-40-03, -04, -05, -07 be rescinded consistent with JCARR and LSC requirements; that the new versions of Ohio Adm.Code 4901:1-39-01, -02, -04, -05, -06, '07, -08, and 4901:1-40-03, -04, -05, -07 be adopted; that the new and amended rules be filed with JCARR, the Secretary of State, and LSC, in accordance with Divisions (D) and (E) of R.C. 111.15; the the final rules be effective on the earliest date permitted.
03/14/2018 Notice of Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Mark T Keaney on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
01/04/2018 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel of Richard L Sites for The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Devin D. Parram.
01/11/2017 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Michael J. Settineri on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.
10/28/2016 Correspondence to remove Sandy I-Ru Grace and add Cynthia F. Brady filed by M. Settineri on behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC.
05/27/2016 Notice of withdrawal of Counsel and Designation of New Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Michael J. Settineri on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.
05/12/2016 Notice of Withdraw and Substitution of Counsel of Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Matthew W. Warnock.
04/07/2016 Notice of Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Rebekah J. Glover on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.
09/30/2015 Request to be Added to Service List electronically filed by John F Stock on behalf of Campaign for American Affordable and Reliable Energy.
08/27/2015 Letter of Notification of Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jennifer L. Spinosi on behalf of Direct Energy Business, LLC and Direct Energy Services, LLC.
05/29/2015 Notice of Change in Contact Information for Michael K. Lavanga, Counsel for Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.
05/28/2015 Notice of change in contact information for Michael K. Lavanga and Garrett A. Stone filed by M. K. Lavanga. (FAX)
04/24/2015 Request to a Keenia Joseph and Christina Gelo to the Service List in the above referenced case numbers. filed by Christina Gelo.
10/15/2014 Entry ordering that the Staff propose amended rules containing an amendment to Ohio Adm. Code 4901:1-40-03 to eliminate the in-state requirement in its entirety in accordance with Finding (9).
10/15/2014 Service Notice
08/18/2014 Returned Mail (The Council on Northeast Energy).
08/12/2014 Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of SIERRA CLUB.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments Regarding the In-State Alternative Energy Requirement for 2014 by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Etter, Terry L.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments of the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council.
08/12/2014 Reply Comments electronically filed by JOSEPH CLARK on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.
07/31/2014 Comments (Initial) of the Retail Energy Supply Association electronically filed by Mrs. Gretchen L. Petrucci on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.
07/31/2014 Comments regarding the in-state requirement presented in 4928.64(B)(3) electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of SIERRA CLUB.
07/31/2014 Comments electronically filed by Mr. Scott J Casto on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
07/31/2014 Comments made pursuant to the Attorney Examiner's Entry electronically filed by Eric R Brown on behalf of The Dayton Power and Light Company.
07/31/2014 Comments of the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council.
07/31/2014 Comments electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.
07/31/2014 Comments (Initial) electronically filed by JOSEPH CLARK on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.
07/31/2014 Correspondence Regarding the Filing of Comments by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Etter, Terry L.
07/31/2014 Comments of Union Neighbors United, Julia F. Johnson, and Robert and Diane McConnell electronically filed by Mr. Christopher A Walker on behalf of Union Neighbors United and McConnell, Robert Mr. and McConnell, Diane Mrs. and Johnson, Julia F. Ms.
07/30/2014 Comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
07/29/2014 Comments made pursuant to the attorney examiner’s findings in the Matter of the Commission’s Review of its Rules for the Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard Contained in Chapter 4901:1-40 of the Ohio Administrative Code electronically filed by Mr. Steven Eisenberg on behalf of SRECTrade, Inc. and Mr. Steven Eisenberg.
07/23/2014 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.
07/14/2014 Service Notice
07/11/2014 Attorney Examiner Entry directing comments be filed by 07/31/2014 and reply comments by 08/12/2014. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
04/04/2014 Notification electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.
03/25/2014 Reply comments of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of the Environmental and Consumer Advocates electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council and Sierra Club and Natural Resources Defense Council and Environmental Defense Fund and Citizens Coalition.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Etter, Terry L.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of the Ohio Coalition for Combined Heat & Power electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Coalition for Combined Heat & Power.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of the Midwest Cogeneration Association electronically filed by Ms. Patrica F Sharkey on behalf of Midwest Cogeneration Association.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company electronically filed by Eric R Brown on behalf of The Dayton Power and Light Company.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments Of The OMA Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of Ohio Power electronically filed by Mr. Steven T Nourse on behalf of Ohio Power Company.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments on Proposed Rule Review of (REVISED): - Ohio Energy Efficiency Programs (Case No. 13-651-EL-ORD) - Ohio Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard (Case No. 13-652-EL-ORD) - Ohio Implement Am. SUB. S.B. 315 (Case No. 12-2156-EL-ORD) electronically filed by Mr. Clifford Haefke on behalf of Cuttica, John Mr.
03/24/2014 Reply comments electronically filed by Helen Sweeney on behalf of IGS Energy.
03/24/2014 Reply comments of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga. (FAX)
03/24/2014 Reply Comments of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
03/24/2014 Reply Comments on Proposed Rule Review of: - Ohio Energy Efficiency Programs (Case No. 13-651-EL-ORD) - Ohio Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard (Case No. 13-652-EL-ORD) - Ohio Implement Am. SUB. S.B. 315 (Case No. 12-2156-EL-ORD) electronically filed by Mr. Clifford Haefke on behalf of Cuttica, John Mr.
03/24/2014 Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's Reply Comments electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
03/07/2014 Service Notice
03/07/2014 Attorney Examiner Entry grants motions by the EDUs and MAC and gives all stakeholders until 03/24/2014 to file reply comments. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Richard Bulgrin, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
03/04/2014 Motion (Joint) for Extension of Time to File Reply Comments and for Expedited Review electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Duke Energy Ohio and The Dayton Power and Light Company and Ohio Power Company.
03/04/2014 Motion for Leave to File Instanter electronically filed by Ms. Patrica F Sharkey on behalf of Midwest Cogeneration Association and Sharkey, Patricia.
03/04/2014 Initial Comments of the Midwest Cogeneration Association; Proposed Ohio Public Utility Commission Regulations for CHP/WER Energy Efficiency Program electronically filed by Ms. Patrica F Sharkey on behalf of Midwest Cogeneration Association and Sharkey, Patricia
03/03/2014 Comments by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Etter, Terry L.
03/03/2014 Comments of the Environmental and Consumer Advocates electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center and Ohio Environmental Council and Sierra Club and Natural Resources Defense Council and Environmental Defense Fund and Citizens Coalition.
03/03/2014 Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy's Comments electronically filed by Mr. David C Rinebolt on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.
03/03/2014 Comments on Proposed Changes to Ohio Administrative Code Chapters 4901:1-39 and 4901:1-40 electronically filed by Ms. Kathy J Kolich on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.
03/03/2014 Comments of the Ohio Coalition for Combined Heat & Power electronically filed by Mr. Trent A Dougherty on behalf of Ohio Coalition for Combined Heat & Power
03/03/2014 Comments Of The OMA Energy Group electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of OMA Energy Group.
03/03/2014 Initial Comments of Ohio Power Company electronically filed by Mr. Matthew J Satterwhite on behalf of Ohio Power Company.
03/03/2014 Comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
03/03/2014 Comments of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. K. Lavanga.
03/03/2014 Comments of PJM Environmental Information Services filed by Evelyn R. Robinson on behalf of PJM Environmental Information Services.
03/03/2014 Comments: Alliance for Industrial Efficiency discuss CHP and WER incentives. electronically filed by Betsy Gardiner on behalf of Alliance for Industrial Efficiency.
03/03/2014 Comments of the Heat is Power Association on draft rule changes to Ohio's Alternative Energy Resource Standard (AERS) and Energy Efficiency Resource Standard (EERS). electronically filed by Ms. Susan Brodie on behalf of Heat is Power Association.
03/03/2014 Comments, electronically filed by Mr. Clifford Haefke on behalf of Energy Resources Center and Mr. John Cuttica.
03/03/2014 Comments of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Watts, Elizabeth H. Ms.
03/03/2014 Comments of The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Thomas O'Brien
03/03/2014 Comments of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. electronically filed by Mr. Scott J. Casto on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
03/03/2014 Comments of the Dayton Power and Light Company, electronically filed by Mr. Tyler A. Teuscher on behalf of The Dayton Power and Light Company.
02/27/2014 Comments of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. electronically filed by Mrs. Gretchen L. Petrucci on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply Inc.
01/30/2014 Service Notice
01/30/2014 Service Notice
01/29/2014 Entry ordering that all comments on the rules to be reviewed. Staff's proposed rule changes, and the corresponding business impact analysis be filed by February 28, 2014, and any reply comments by March 14, 2014.
10/07/2013 Notice of withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Cathryn N. Loucas on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council.
03/18/2013 Service Notice
03/15/2013 Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a workshop for 04/23/2013 at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission, Rm. 11-B, 180 E. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
03/13/2013 In the Matter of the Commission's Review of its Rules for the Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard Contained in Chapter 4901:1-40 of the Ohio Administrative Code.