Skip to main content

Case Record For:

12-1230-EL-SSO

File a Public Comment
Case Title: OHIO EDISON COMPANY/ CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING COMPANY/TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY
Status: CL-CLOSED
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: SSO-Standard Service Offer
Date Opened: 4/13/2012
Date Closed: 8/8/2016
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
08/08/2016Case action form closing case with an effective date of 8/8/16 filed by Staff. 1
07/08/2016Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Stephen M Howard on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.3
07/06/2016Notice of Appearance of Scott R. Dismukes, Daniel Clearfield and Sarah Stoner of Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott LLC electronically filed by Mr. Scott R. Dismukes on behalf of Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC and Clearfield, Daniel Mr. and Stoner, Sarah Ms.2
07/05/2016Notice of withdrawal Withdrawal of Counsel, Matthew R. Cox electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R Cox on behalf of Council of Smaller Enterprises (COSE).3
06/06/2016Judgement Entry, here on appeal from the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, was considered in the manner prescribed by law. On consideration thereof, the order of the commission is affirmed, consistent with the opinion rendered herein. It is further ordered that a mandate be sent to and filed with the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio filed by Chief Justice Maureen O'Connor. 1
05/31/2016Notice of withdrawal of Counsel and Substitution of Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Michael J. Settineri on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy Inc.3
05/31/2016Notice of withdrawal of Counsel and Substitution of Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Michael J. Settineri on behalf of Exelon Generation Company LLC.3
05/27/2016Notice of withdrawal of Counsel and Designation of New Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Michael J. Settineri on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.5
05/12/2016Notice of Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel of Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Dylan Borchers.2
05/03/2016Notice of Change of Address for counsel for the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, effective May 9, 2016. electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.3
09/10/2015Notice of Sierra Club to be withdrawn as party to these cases filed by Tony G. Mendoza on behalf of Sierra Club. (FAX)1
09/04/2015Notice of withdrawal of Christopher J. Allwein as counsel electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council.3
09/04/2015Notice of withdrawal of Christopher J. Allwein as counsel electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of SIERRA CLUB3
08/27/2015Letter of Notification of Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jennifer L. Spinosi on behalf of Direct Energy Business, LLC and Direct Energy Services, LLC.3
06/18/2015Notice of Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Robert Dove on behalf of The Natural Resources Defense Council.3
05/29/2015Notice of Change in Contact Information for Michael K. Lavanga, Counsel for Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.2
05/29/2015Notice of Change in Contact Information for Garrett A Stone, Counsel for Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.2
05/28/2015Notice of change in contact information for Garrett A. Stone filed by M. K. Lavanga. (FAX)3
08/15/2014Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Yost, Melissa Ms.3
07/23/2014Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.3
04/29/2014Revised tariff P.U.C.O. No. 8 compliance changes for Riders ELR, OLR and Summary Rider electronically filed by Ms. Tamera J Singleton on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and Mikkelsen, Eileen M.9
04/29/2014Revised tariff P.U.C.O. No.11 compliance changes for Riders ELR, OLR and Summary Rider electronically filed by Ms. Tamera J Singleton on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and Mikkelsen, Eileen M9
04/29/2014Tariff compliance changes for Riders ELR, OLR and Summary Rider electronically filed by Ms. Tamera J Singleton on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Mikkelsen, Eileen M9
03/28/2014Notice of withdrawal of Joseph E. Oliker filed by F. Darr on behalf of McNees, Wallace & Nurick LLC.4
03/28/2014Notice of appearance and substitution of counsel of record for the City of Akron7
01/28/2014Notice of withdrawal of counsel of Nolan Moser and substitution of counsel of record of Trent A. Dougherty filed by N. Moser on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council2
10/15/2013Notice of substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association2
10/15/2013Notice of withdrawal electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of J. Thomas Siwo, Bricker & Eckler LLP.3
10/07/2013Notice of withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Cathryn N. Loucas on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council.3
04/29/2013Supreme Court transmittal papers filed. S.C. # 13-51329
04/29/2013Service Notice15
04/01/2013Notice of Appeal of the Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by Mr. Nicholas A. McDaniel on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.47
03/29/2013Supreme Court Appeal No. 13-0513 filed on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.11
01/30/2013Service Notice15
01/30/2013Second entry on rehearing stating that the applications for rehearing be denied as set forth in this entry.34
01/08/2013Notice of change of contact information electronically filed by Mr. Joseph Clark on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC and Direct Energy Source, LLC dba Vectren Source.2
01/07/2013Initial Comments electronically filed by M. Howard Petricoff on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.15
11/08/2012Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Asim Z. Haque filed on behalf of Ice Miller LLP by C. Miller.1
11/07/2012Notice of withdrawal of counsel electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Bricker & Eckler LLP.3
09/12/2012Service Notice15
09/12/2012Entry on Rehearing that the applications for rehearing be granted for further consideration of the matters specified in the applications for rehearing.3
09/07/2012Reply Memorandum by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.6
09/04/2012Memorandum contra motion to strike by the office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Mr. David A. Kutik on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.11
08/30/2012Reply memorandum by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Yost, Melissa R. Ms.10
08/30/2012Motion to strike and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.8
08/27/2012Memorandum contra of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. to application for rehearing of July 18 opinion and order filed by M. Lavanga.16
08/27/2012Memorandum Contra to motion to take administrative notice by the Office of the Ohio Consumer's Counsel electronically filed by Mr. David A. Kutik on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.12
08/27/2012Memorandum contra applications for rehearing electronically filed by Mr. David A. Kutik on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.56
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing by the Sierra Club electronically filed by Mr. Todd M Williams on behalf of Sierra Club.12
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing electronically filed by Mr. Justin M Vickers on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.17
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Citizen Power electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.172
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by Barth E. Royer.25
08/17/2012Motion and memorandum in support to take Administrative Notice by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.33
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing and Memorandum in Support of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.34
08/17/2012Application for Rehearing and memorandum in support of The Retail Energy Supply Association, Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Stephen M Howard.19
07/30/2012Exhibits for transcript held on Tuesday the 12th day of June 2012 at Cleveland City Hall, Cleveland Ohio before Commissioner Todd Snitchler and Attorney Examiner Mandy Willey. 106
07/30/2012Notification of Change of Contact Information electronically filed by Mr. Joseph Clark on behalf of Direct Energy.2
07/18/2012Service Notice13
07/18/2012Opinion and order that the Stipulation, as modified by the Commission be adopted and approved; the companies file proposed tariffs and take steps necessary to implement the Stipulation. Dissenting opinion of Commissioner Cheryl Roberto that the Companies have not met their burden and therefore she would reject the ESP.65
07/17/2012Transcript of PUCO Public Meeting June 12, 2012 held before Chairman Todd Snitchler, and AE M. Wiley, electronically filed by Mrs.Tami Mitchell on behalf of Bish & Associates.66
07/17/2012Transcript of Proceedings of Public Meeting June 4, 2012 electronically filed by Mrs. Tami Mitchell on behalf of Bish & Associates and Tami Mitchell.44
07/10/2012Transcript of hearing held June 7, 2012 before A.E. Elizabeth Stevens and Steve Lesser.96
07/05/2012Notice of removal of footnote 218 from the Companies' Reply Brief electronically filed by Ms. Kathy J Kolich on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.2
06/29/2012Reply brief of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. by M. Lavanga.33
06/29/2012Reply Brief electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club17
06/29/2012Reply brief electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC14
06/29/2012Reply brief of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by B. Royer.30
06/29/2012Joint Reply Brief of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Citizen Power electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.55
06/29/2012Reply Brief electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association and Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC18
06/29/2012Reply Brief of Environmental Law & Policy Center electronically filed by J. Vickers13
06/29/2012Reply Brief of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company in Support of Their Application to Provide For A Standard Service Offer in the Form of an Electric Security Plan electronically filed by MR. DAVID A. KUTIK.83
06/29/2012Reply Brief of the Ohio Energy Group (OEG) electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz on behalf of Ohio Energy Group.14
06/29/2012Joint Reply Brief electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition.34
06/29/2012Reply brief filed by C. Smith on behalf of Material Sciences Corporation.10
06/29/2012Reply brief of the City of Akron electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker.12
06/29/2012Reply Brief submitted on behalf of the Staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton.14
06/29/2012Reply Brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Ms. Vicki L. Leach-Payne on behalf of Randazzo, Samuel C. Mr.13
06/27/2012Corrected joint initial brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Citizen Power including cover letter, corrected brief and exhibits as one pdf electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.104
06/26/2012Corrected joint initial brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Citizen Power electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.2
06/25/2012Initial brief filed by C. Smith of Material Sciences Corporation.15
06/22/2012Initial Brief of the Environmental Law and Policy Center electronically filed by Mr. Justin M Vickers on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.22
06/22/2012Initial Brief of the Environmental Law and Policy Center electronically filed by Mr. Justin M. Vickers on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center.22
06/22/2012Initial brief in support of ESP filed by M. Lavanga on behalf of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc.17
06/22/2012Joint initial brief by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Citizen Power electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.114
06/22/2012Initial brief of the Retail Energy Supply Association, Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by M. Howard Petricoff.33
06/22/2012Initial post-hearing brief electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.27
06/22/2012Initial brief electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club.27
06/22/2012Initial post-hearing brief electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M. Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.79
06/22/2012Joint initial post-hearing brief electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Ohio Schools Council.9
06/22/2012Letter of the City of Akron stating that does not intend to file a post-hearing brief but reserve the right to the brief reply electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker.2
06/22/2012Brief of the Ohio Energy Group electronically filed by Mr. Michael L. Kurtz.11
06/22/2012Post-hearing brief of EnerNOC, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Gregory J. Poulos.12
06/22/2012Joint initial post hearing brief electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition.30
06/22/2012Initial post-hearing brief electronically filed by Mr. Matthew J. Satterwhite on behalf of Ohio Power Company.4
06/22/2012Initial post-hearing brief of Exelon Generation Company, LLC and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. electronically filed by M Howard Petricoff.7
06/22/2012Brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Samuel C. Randazzo.11
06/22/2012Initial brief of Material Sciences Corporation filed by C. Smith. (FAX)14
06/22/2012Initial brief filed by B. Royer on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.41
06/22/2012Post-hearing brief submitted on behalf of the Staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton.17
06/22/2012Letter of notification that OPAE will not file a brief but reserves the right to file a reply brief electronically filed by Ms. Colleen L. Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.2
06/22/2012Correspondence reserving the right to file reply brief electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of OMA Energy Group.2
06/21/2012Service Notice13
06/21/2012Entry ordered, that the Consumer Advocates' request that their interlocutory appeal be certified to the Commission is denied.(ECS)6
06/18/2012Comments filed by Dennis Worthem, consumer.5
06/15/2012Letter in support of the extension of FirstEnergy's rate plan filed by R. Stiff on behalf of 405 Madison Limited.1
06/14/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's Memorandum Contra the Consumer Advocates' interlocutory appeal from the June 6, 2012, Ruling regarding administrative notice filed by David A. Kutik.15
06/13/2012Letter in support of FirstEnergy's request to extend their ESP filed by F, Weber on behalf of Lucas County Improvement Corporation.1
06/13/2012Letter in support of First Energy's proposal to extend their ESP filed by J. Beier Grant on behalf of the Ottawa County Improvement Corporation.1
06/11/2012Joint Consumer Advocates’ Interlocutory Appeal from the June 6, 2012 Attorney Examiner’s Ruling Regarding Administrative Notice electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.23
06/11/2012PUCO Exhibit Filing of hearing held 6/5/12. ( part 2 of 2 ) 122
06/11/2012PUCO Exhibit Filing of hearing held 6/5/12. ( part 1 of 2 ) 201
06/11/2012PUCO Exhibit Filing of hearing held 6/6/12.6
06/11/2012PUCO exhibit filing.124
06/11/2012Transcript of the Application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 06/08/12 - Composite Index electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.9
06/11/2012Transcript of the Application of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 06/08/12 - Volume IV - Rebuttal electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.158
06/08/2012Transcript of the Application of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 06/04/12 - Volume I before AE's G. Price and M. Willey electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.368
06/08/2012Transcript of the Application of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 06/06/12 - Volume III electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.179
06/08/2012Transcript of the Application of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company hearing held on 06/05/12 - Volume II electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Gibson, Karen Sue Mrs.274
06/07/2012Testimony (Rebuttal) of Eileen M. Mikkelsen electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.10
06/07/2012Testimony (Rebuttal) of Robert B. Stoddard electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M. Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.22
06/04/2012Correspondence errata sheet and exhibits pertaining to the testimony of Sierra Club witness Chris Neme electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club.9
06/04/2012Motion for Permission to Appear Pro Hac Vice of David M. Stahl electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC.7
06/04/2012Testimony corrections of witness Vincent Parisi filed by Barth E Royer on behalf of Interstate State Gas Supply, Inc.11
06/04/2012Direct Testimony of David I. Fein on Behalf of Intervenors Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Exelon Generation Company, LLC electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Exelon Generation Company, LLC18
06/04/2012Motion for Leave to Withdraw Testimony and to File Revised Testimony of David I. Fein and memorandum in support on Behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc.22
06/01/2012Service Notice12
06/01/2012Entry ordered that AEP Retail's motion to continue the hearing date and modify the procedural schedule is denied. (MLW) 6
06/01/2012Affidavit of Michael D. Dortch in support of Reply to FirstEnergy's Memo Contra Motions to Continue and Compel electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.7
06/01/2012AEP Retail Energy Partners LLC's Reply to FirstEnergy's Memo Contra Motion to Compel and Memo Contra Motion to Continue electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.11
06/01/2012Joint Motion for Continuance of the Evidentiary Hearing or, in the Alternative, Joint Motion for a Partial Continuance to Consider Customer Bill Impacts and Joint Motion for an Extension of the Time for Filing Testimony of Parties Not Signing FirstEnergy's Stipulation and Request for Expedited Ruling by Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Memorandum in support. electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.44
06/01/2012Notice of withdrawal of Mark A. Hayden electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.3
05/31/2012Confidential Treatment of Document: Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's (the ''Companies") Response to the Sierra Club's Request for Production No. 1 filed by D. Kutik on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company. 1
05/31/2012Notice of Appearance filed by Christopher Horn on behalf of The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumer Protection Association and Memorandum in Support. (FAX)2
05/31/2012Notice of Appearance electronically filed by Mr. Matthew J Satterwhite on behalf of Ohio Power Company.3
05/31/2012Notice of Appearance filed by Christopher Horn on behalf of The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumer Protection Association and Memorandum in Support. 2
05/31/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's memorandum contra AEP Retail Energy Partners LLC's motion to compel further responses to discovery filed by D. Kutik.13
05/31/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's Motion for a Protective Order and Memorandum in support filed by D. Kutik. 8
05/31/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company's memorandum contra AEP Retail Energy Partners LLC's motion to extend the procedural schedule filed by D. Kutik.27
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by D. Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of The Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of The Retail Energy Supply Association, filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of The Sierra Club filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's notice of deposition of the Retail Energy Supply Association, Direct Energy Services, LLC, and Direct Energy Business, LLC filed by D, Kutik.4
05/30/2012Motion to Compel and Request for Expedited Ruling and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.10
05/29/2012Motion of Robb Kapla to Appear Pro Hac Vice electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club.6
05/29/2012Motion to Continue Hearing Date, and to Modify Procedural Schedule, and Request for Expedited Ruling and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.13
05/23/2012Service Notice (Correction)31
05/21/2012Joint Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum in Support filed by Leslie A. Kovacik and Thomas R. Hays on behalf of NOAC and Matthew W. Warnock on behalf of NOPEC. 4
05/21/2012Confidential treatment of document: Direct testimony of Mark Frye filed by L. Kovacik, t. Hays and M. Warnock on behalf of NOAC and NOPEC. 1
05/21/2012Direct testimony of Vincent Parisi on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. 44
05/21/2012Direct Prepared Testimony of Teresa L. Ringenbach on Behalf of the Retail Energy Supply Association, Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association and Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.95
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of Chris Neme electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club.27
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of James F. Wilson on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.52
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of Wilson Gonzalez on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.59
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of David I. Fein on Behalf of Intervenors Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Exelon Generation Company, LLC electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc.50
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of Daniel J. Duann on Behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.19
05/21/2012Direct Testimony of Stephen E. Bennett on behalf of the Retail Energy Supply Association, electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.11
05/21/2012Testimony of Mark Frye electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition.24
05/17/2012Service Notice11
05/17/2012Entry granting Direct Energy's motion to compel in part, and denied in part, in accordance with the findings above; that FirstEnergy provide Direct Energy with the information requested in Document Request Nos, 1-002 and 1-003 in accordance with Finding (12). (MLW)5
05/16/2012Service Notice11
05/16/2012Reply of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC to the Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company The Motion to Compel of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC16
05/15/2012Notice of addition of counsel for Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by V. Parisi. 5
05/15/2012Entry ordered that the motions to intervene of the parties listed in Finding (4) are granted; that the motion to intervene and request for leave to file the motion to intervene out of time filed by Cleveland Schools is granted; that the motions for admission pro hac vice of Michael K. Lavanga, Justin M. Vickers, and Theodore S. Robinson are granted. (MLW)3
05/14/2012Memorandum Contra by Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company's memorandum contra Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC's Motion to compel responses to discovery filed by David A. Kutik.13
05/09/2012Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice electronically filed by Mr. Justin M Vickers on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center6
05/09/2012Service Notice10
05/09/2012Motion and memorandum in support to Compel electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC21
05/09/2012Entry ordering that local public hearings in this proceeding be held as set forth in Finding (5) and FirstEnergy publish notice of the hearings as set forth in Finding (6). (MLW)4
05/07/2012Prefiled testimony of Robert B. Fortney Rates and Tariffs/Energy & Water Division Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.9
05/07/2012Prefiled testimony of Peter K. Baker Service Monitoring & Enforcement Department Reliability & Service Analysis Division Public Utilities Commission of Ohio. 10
05/03/2012Motion to Intervene, request for leave to file motion to intervene out of time and memorandum in support of The Cleveland Municipal School District filed by Barth E. Royer.9
05/03/2012Motion and memorandum in support of the PUCO Staff to accept testimony of Peter Baker and Robert Fortney on May 7th, 2012, filed by the William L. Wright and Staff of the PUCO.5
05/02/2012Supplemental Informational Filing electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.182
05/02/2012Service Notice10
05/02/2012Entry that the interlocutory appeal, motion for certification to the Commission, and application for review filed by OCEA is denied; that the procedural schedule is modified to require that testimony on behalf of non-signatory parties be due by 3:00 p.m. on May 21, 2012, and that the evidentiary hearing shall be rescheduled to commence on June 4, 2012, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th Floor, Hearing Room 11-A, Columbus, Ohio. (MLW)5
05/01/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland T. Mendelsohn, Cleveland Housing Network by L. Hernandez and The Consumer Protection Association filed by S. Harge. 9
04/30/2012Memorandum Contra by FirstEnergy Ohio contra to the Joint Movants' Request for Certification of an Interlocutory Appeal electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.9
04/30/2012Notice of Appearance of Counsel on behalf of Material Sciences Corporation filed by Craig I. Smith.5
04/30/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of The Citizens Coalition, filed by T. Mendelsohn on behalf of the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, S. Harge on behalf of Consumer Protection Association, and L. Hernandez on behalf of Cleveland Housing Network.(FAX)8
04/30/2012Motion for permission to appear pro hac vice of Theodore Robinson electronically filed by Mr. Theodore Robinson.9
04/30/2012Notice of the Substitution of Counsel by EnerNOC, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Gregory J. Poulos on behalf of EnerNOC, Inc.4
04/30/2012Letter urging the PUCO to take its time in considering the FirstEnergy Corp. ESP plan filed by Rep. Dennis Murray,Rep. Matt Lundy, and Rep. Mike Foley, House of Representatives, District 14.1
04/27/2012Motion and memorandum in support for Leave to Intervene of the Retail Energy Supply Association electronically filed by M Howard Petricoff on behalf of Retail Energy Supply Association.6
04/27/2012Service Notice30
04/27/2012Motion and Memorandum in support to Modify Procedural Schedule and Request for Expedited Ruling electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners LLC.11
04/26/2012Joint motion to extend procedural schedule and joint motion for continuance of the evidentiary hearing and request for expedited ruling by the Environmental Law and Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, the Ohio Environmental Council and the Sierra Club, electronically filed by L. Sauer.15
04/25/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Matthew J. Satterwhite on behalf of Ohio Power Company.8
04/25/2012Entry ordered, that FirstEnergy's motion for waivers be granted, in part, and denied, in part, as set forth in Findings (11) through (13); that FirstEnergy file supplemental information to its application, as set forth in Finding (11), within seven days.7
04/25/2012Motion and memorandum in support to Intervene by The Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Ms. Cathryn N. Loucas.8
04/25/2012Notice of substitution of counsel for Duke Energy Retail Sales, LLC respectful withdrawal of Dorothy K Corbett to be replaced by Jeanne W. Kingery in this proceeding filed by Jeanne W. Kingery.6
04/25/2012Service Notice29
04/25/2012Motion for admission pro hac vice of Michael Lavanga filed by M. Lavanga on behalf of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. 8
04/24/2012Request for Interlocutory Appeal by Environmental Law and policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, Sierra Club and the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.17
04/23/2012Testimony (SUPPLEMENTAL) of William R. Ridmann electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company.15
04/23/2012Reply to FirstEnergy's Memorandum Contra Regarding the Joint Motion to Bifurcate Issues by the Environmental Law and Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and Sierra Club electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.19
04/23/2012Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J Allwein on behalf of The Sierra Club.9
04/23/2012Joint motion to strike and memorandum in support for FirstEnergy's reply by the Environmental Law and Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel and the Sierra Club electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.12
04/20/2012Motion and memorandum in support to intervene on behalf of Duke Energy Retail Sales, LLC filed by A. Spiller 10
04/20/2012Motion and memorandum in support on behalf of Duke Energy Commercial Asset Management, Inc by A. Spiller. 10
04/20/2012Memorandum contra by AEP contra to FirstEnergy's motion for waiver of rules and motion to expedite consideration of this case electronically filed by Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners, LLC.9
04/20/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Michael D. Dortch on behalf of AEP Retail Energy Partners LLC.7
04/20/2012Joint motion and memorandum in support of Direct Energy Services, LLC, Direct Energy Business, LLC and IGS Energy, Inc. to partially strike FirstEnergy Ohio Utilities' memorandum contra and reply to Movants' memorandum contra electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque.10
04/19/2012Entry ordering that the procedural schedule set forth in Finding (5) be observed by the parties; that all parties granted intervention in Case No. 10-388-EL-SSO be granted intervention in this proceeding and that all parties comply with the directives set forth in Finding (7). (MLW)4
04/19/2012Motion to Intervene of the OMA Energy Group electronically filed by Ms. Andrea P Govan on behalf of OMA Energy Group and McAlister, Lisa G. Mrs.6
04/18/2012Ohio Energy Group's motion to intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. David F. Boehm. 7
04/18/2012The Dayton Power and Light Company's motion to intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mrs. Angela N. Hogan.8
04/18/2012Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council's corrected motion to intervene electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council attorney.8
04/18/2012Memorandum contra the joint movants' motion to bifurcate & reply to movants' memoranda contra the motion for waivers electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison.Company10
04/18/2012Motion For Leave to Intervene and memorandum in support of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC10
04/18/2012Memorandum Direct Energy Services, LLC, Direct Energy Business, LLC, and IGS Energy, Inc.'s Corrected Joint Memorandum Contra Motion for Waive of Rules electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC13
04/18/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support by Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council Attorney.8
04/17/2012Joint motion to bifurcate issues and joint memorandum contra FirstEnergy's motion for waiver of rules by the Environmental Law and Policy Center, Natural Resources Defense Council, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.28
04/17/2012Motion To Intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Ms. Leslie A. Kovacik.4
04/16/2012Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Christopher J. Allwein on behalf of Natural Resources Defense Council..10
04/16/2012Motion for Leave to Intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by M HOWARD PETRICOFF on behalf of Exelon Generation Company, LLC and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc.8
04/16/2012Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Deb J. Bingham on behalf of Sauer, Larry S.10
04/16/2012Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by V. Parisi.8
04/16/2012Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Ms. Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.6
04/16/2012Direct Energy Services, LLC, Direct Energy Business, LLC and IGS Energy, Inc's Joint Memorandum Contra Motion for Waiver of Rules electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC.12
04/16/2012Notice of Appearance of Counsel on Behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Asim Z. Haque on behalf of Direct Energy Services LLC and Direct Energy Business, LLC6
04/13/2012Motion and memorandum in support for Waiver of Rules and Request for Expedited Treatment electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.7
04/13/2012Stipulation Attachment B-1 electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.76
04/13/2012Stipulation Attachments A-1, A-2, and A-3 electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.164
04/13/2012Direct Testimony of William R. Ridmann in Support of the Stipulation and Recommendation electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.23
04/13/2012Stipulation & Recommendation electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.58
04/13/2012In the matter of the application for Authority to Provide for a Standard Service Offer Pursuant to R.C. 4928.143 in the Form of an Electric Security Plan electronically filed by Ms. Laura C. McBride on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.11