Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 09-1946-EL-RDR
CASE DESCRIPTION: DUKE ENERGY OHIO INC
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 2/1/2023
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
02/07/2022 Motion to Extend Protective Order for Yankel Testimony and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Debbie L. Gates on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc., D'Ascenzo, Rocco O. Mr., Vaysman, Larisa, Kingery, Jeanne W., and Akhbari, Elyse.
02/07/2022 Motion to Extend Protective Order for OCC Exhibits and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Debbie L. Gates on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc., D'Ascenzo, Rocco O. Mr., Vaysman, Larisa, Kingery, Jeanne W., and Akhbari, Elyse.
09/22/2020 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. To Extend Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Tammy M Meyer on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc. and D'Ascenzo, Rocco and Vaysman, Larisa.
09/22/2020 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. To Extend Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Tammy M Meyer on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc. and D'Ascenzo, Rocco and Vaysman, Larisa.
01/31/2020 Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Tammy M Meyer on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc. and D'Ascenzo, Rocco and Vaysman, Larisa.
05/06/2019 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and memorandum in support to Extend Protective Order electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Rocco D'Ascenzo and Watts, Elizabeth H.
05/06/2019 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Rocco D'Ascenzo and Watts, Elizabeth H.
01/31/2018 Notice of withdrawal of Amy B. Spiller as counsel for Duke Energy Ohio (Part 2 of 3) electronically filed by Mrs. Debbie L. Gates on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio Inc., Rocco O. D'Ascenzo and Ms. Elizabeth H. Watts.
12/21/2017 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and D'Ascenzo, Rocco O and Spiller, Amy B and Watts, Elizabeth H.
12/21/2017 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and D'Ascenzo, Rocco O and Spiller, Amy B and Watts, Elizabeth H.
08/11/2016 Motion and memorandum in support of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Rocco D'Ascenzo.
08/11/2016 Motion and memorandum in support to Extend Protective Order electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Rocco D'Ascenzo.
04/10/2015 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Rocco D'Ascenzo.
04/10/2015 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Rocco D'Ascenzo.
06/17/2014 Revised Tariff Pages, PUCO Tariff No. 19, Duke Energy Rider DR-IKE electronically filed by Mrs. Julie A. Lee on behalf of Laub, Peggy Mrs. and Duke Energy Ohio.
02/11/2014 Update for PUCO Electric Tariff No. 19 filed by P. Laub on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.
12/03/2013 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to extend protective order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Rocco D'Ascenzo.
11/26/2013 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Extend Protective Order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B.
09/16/2013 Notice of withdrawal of Counsel submitted by Assistant Attorney General Stephen A. Reilly on behalf of the Staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio. electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
03/26/2013 Service Notice
03/26/2013 Attorney Examiner Entry granting the motion for protective order, electronically filed by Vesta R Miller on behalf of Christine M.T. Pirik, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
05/30/2012 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.and memorandum in support, to Extend Protective Order electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Watts, Elizabeth H.
05/30/2012 Motion of Duke Energy, Ohio, Inc. for Leave to File Instanter a Motion to Extend Protective Order and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Watts, Elizabeth H.
05/01/2012 Supreme Court Document The following decision, announcement or notice of action by the Supreme Court of Ohio with respect to this case is provided solely for the information and convenience of the reader, and should not be construed as a part of the record of this case before the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, and may be subject to formal revision before it is published in the Ohio Official Reports. The Court’s opinions from 1992 to the present are available online from the Reporter of Decisions at http://www.sconet.state.oh.us/ROD/. On April 5, 2012, in a 5-2 decision, the Court affirmed the Commission’s order. [Until this opinion appears in the Ohio Official Reports advance sheets, it may be cited as In re Application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., Slip Opinion No. 2012-Ohio-1509.] electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
04/06/2012 Notice of withdrawal of counsel and substitution of counsel, Mark Yurick from the law firm of Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, formerly Chester, Wilcox & Saxbe, LLP filed by M. Yurick.
01/30/2012 Service Notice
01/30/2012 Service Notice
01/30/2012 Entry granting motion to extend protective order, pertaining to Mr. Yankel's testimony until January 11, 2014; that, in accordance with Finding (10), any party wishing to extend protective treatment of Consumers' Counsel Exhibits 11-14 and Duke Exhibits 8 and 10 must file an appropriate motion at least 45 days in advance of the July 11, 2012, expiration date. (KLS)
11/28/2011 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to extend protective order and memorandum in support filed by A. Spiller. (original)
11/28/2011 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., for leave to file instanter, motion to extend protective order and memorandum in support filed by A. Spiller.
11/25/2011 Motion of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. for leave to file Instanter and motion to extend protective order and memorandum in support filed by A. Spiller. (FAX)
11/25/2011 Motion and memorandum in support of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to extend protective order filed by A. Spiller. (FAX)
06/06/2011 Service Notice
06/06/2011 Supreme Court Transmittal papers filed. (S.C. No. 11-767)
05/06/2011 Notice of Supreme Court Appeal 11-767 filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. by E. Watts.
03/24/2011 Revised tariff pages, PUCO Tariff No. 19, filed by J. Ziolkowski on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
03/09/2011 Service Notice
03/09/2011 Entry ordering the applications for rehearing filed by Duke-Ohio and OCC be denied, and Duke's motion for stay be denied.
02/22/2011 Memorandum contra Duke's application for rehearing by the OCC, filed by A. Hotz.
02/22/2011 Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s memorandum in opposition to the application for rehearing of the of the OCC, filed by E. Watts.
02/10/2011 Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC.
02/10/2011 Application for rehearing, memorandum in support and request for clarification or, alternatively, request for stay of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by A, Spiller.
01/26/2011 Withdrawal of Matthew S. White from proceedings filed by J. Bentine on behalf of the Chester, Willcox and Saxbe Law Firm.
01/11/2011 Service Notice
01/11/2011 Opinion and Order ordered that with the modifications set forth in this order to adjust is reasonable and should be approved.
09/22/2010 Correspondence in opposition of Duke Energy Ohio's rate increase to pay for storm damage filed on behalf of concerned consumer, P. Young.
09/22/2010 Correspondence in opposition of Duke Energy Ohio's rate increase to pay for storm damage filed on behalf of concerned consumer, R. Risch, Sr.
07/20/2010 Letter in opposition to the storm recovery rider in this case filed by R. Cureton.
07/12/2010 Correspondence in opposition of rate increase, filed by C. Breitenstein.
06/24/2010 Letter opposing Duke Energy's proposed bill fees filed by M. Mitchell, consumer.
06/21/2010 Reply brief of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by A. Spiller.
06/21/2010 Reply brief by the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz.
06/15/2010 Initial brief filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by A. Hotz.
06/15/2010 Merit brief filed on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. by A. Spiller.
06/15/2010 Post hearing brief of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio filed by S. Reilly.
06/09/2010 Confidential document: Exhibit 12-B filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC. (73 pgs)
06/09/2010 Confidential document: Exhibit 11-B filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC. (163 pgs)
06/09/2010 Confidential document: Exhibit 14-B filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC. (24 pgs)
06/09/2010 Confidential document: Exhibit 13-B filed by A. Hotz on behalf of OCC. (52 pgs)
06/09/2010 Correspondence in opposition of Duke Energy's request for rate increase filed by concerned consumer, L. Lincoln.
06/09/2010 Exhibit 13A filed on behalf of OCC by A. Hotz.
06/09/2010 Exhibit 12A filed on behalf of OCC by A. Hotz.
06/09/2010 Exhibits 14A filed on behalf of OCC by A. Hotz.
06/09/2010 Exhibits 11A filed on behalf of OCC by A. Hotz.
06/08/2010 Transcript of Duke Energy Ohio hearing Volume III held on 06/07/10 before K. Stenman and C. Pirik, electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Hennebert, Julieanna Mrs.
06/04/2010 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Indiana, Inc.
06/03/2010 Letter indicating that the Commission should say no to Duke Energy's request to increase rates filed by T. Mers.
06/03/2010 Letter indicating that their is no information for the public on the Commission's web site about a hearing for Duke's rate increase filed by J. Bishop.
06/02/2010 Letter opposing the proposed Duke Energy rate increase filed by W. Thomas.
06/02/2010 Letter asking the PUCO not to let Duke or any other electric company get away with pushing all of it's financial responsibility off on it's customers filed by W. Fox.
06/02/2010 Letter with concern over the time of restoring service in outlying areas in S.W. Ohio filed by M. Owens.
06/02/2010 Service Notice
06/02/2010 Entry ordered that Duke's interlocutory appeal be denied and the attorney examiners's denial of the motion to quash is affirmed.
05/28/2010 Memorandum contra Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Duke Energy Indiana application for review and interlocutory appeal by the Ohio Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz.
05/27/2010 Exhibits for hearing held May 25, 2010 before AE's Katie Stenman and Christine Pirik.
05/27/2010 Letter expressing outrage over the fact that Duke wants to charge their customers for the next 3 years to help pay for damage caused September 2008, filed by J. Benhase.
05/27/2010 Transcript Volume II of Duke Energy Ohio hearing held on 05/26/10. electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Hennebert, Julieanna Mrs.
05/27/2010 Letter expressing concern over having to pay for an outage and not the people in Indiana filed by P. Mattan.
05/27/2010 Letter expressing concern over the poor maintenance affecting Duke Energy since Hurricane Ike filed by S. Mckinley.
05/27/2010 Second filed (Pubic Version) direct testimony of Anthony J. Yankel filed by A. Hotz on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/27/2010 Transcript of Duke Energy Ohio hearing held on 05/25/10. electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Hennebert, Julieanna Mrs.
05/27/2010 Confidential target of response to Mr. Mehrings testimony at page 9 lines 8-20 filed by B. Clippinger on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. ( 142 pags )
05/27/2010 Confidential target of response to staff DR-39-001 filed by B. Clippinger on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. ( 4pgs )
05/27/2010 Exhibits continued. (Part 2 of 2)
05/27/2010 Exhibits for hearing held May 26, 2010 before Katie Stenman and Christine Pirik. (Part 1 of 2)
05/27/2010 Corrected certificate of service filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/27/2010 Exhibit 8 A, (public version), filed by B. Clippinger on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/27/2010 Revised certificate of service filed by M. Idzkowski on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/27/2010 Exhibit 10 A (public version) filed by B. Clippinger on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/26/2010 Exhibits 1, 2, and 3 from the deposition of Anthony J. Yankel.
05/26/2010 Application for review and interlocutory appeal, memorandum in support filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Duke Energy Indiana, Inc.
05/24/2010 Return of service filed by A. Hotz on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/24/2010 Return of service for C. Verich, filed by A. Hotz on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/24/2010 Notice that the transcript of the deposition of Anthony Yankel, confidential portion has been filed on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, at the request of A. Spiller.
05/24/2010 Confidential target sheet, filed by Armstrong & Okey Inc. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.(10 pages)
05/24/2010 Deposition of Anthony Yankel. electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/21/2010 Motion and memorandum in support to quash the subpoena duces tecum of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and request for expedited treatment on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc by E. Watts.
05/20/2010 Motion for subpoena duces tecum and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by A. Hotz.
05/20/2010 Motion for subpoena duces tecum and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by A. Hotz.
05/20/2010 Motion for subpoena duces tecum and memorandum in support filed by A. Hotz on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/18/2010 Prepared testimony of Jeffrey Hecker, PUCO Staff exhibit.
05/18/2010 Confidential document target: Direct testimony of Anthony J. Yankel. (90 pages)
05/18/2010 Direct testimony of Anthony J. Yankel on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
05/18/2010 Motion for protective order and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz.
05/17/2010 Direct testimony of Kevin C. Higgins on behalf of the Kroger Company.
05/14/2010 Duke Energy Ohio's notice to take deposition of Anthony Yankel witness for the Ohio Comsumers' Counsel, upon oral examination and request for production of documents filed by D. Kuhnell.
05/11/2010 Supplemental direct testimony of James E. Mehring on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc..
05/11/2010 Direct testimony of Beth Clippinger on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc..
05/11/2010 Supplemental direct testimony of William Don Wathen Jr. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc..
05/03/2010 Correspondence letter and petitions opposing Duke Energy recouping any storm damage losses and that Duke Energy owes this consumer money due to losses after wind storm filed by S. Hayes, consumer.
05/03/2010 Reply memoranda to Duke Energy of Ohio contra memorandum, motion to intervene in Case # 09-757-El-ESS and motion to appeal to intervene in Case # 09-1946-EL-RDR/ATA, still pending filed by A. Lane, consumer.
04/27/2010 Memorandum in opposition of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.’s to Albert E. Lane's second corrected motion to intervene electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Watts, Elizabeth H.
04/27/2010 Notice to take deposition upon oral examination and request for production of documents for Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by A. Hotz on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
04/23/2010 Revised motion to intervene with service list, file by A. Lane.
04/20/2010 Correspondence opposing Duke rate increase to recover the losses of 2008 winter storm filed by R. Alward.
04/20/2010 Correspondence opposing Duke rate increase to recover the losses of 2008 winter storm filed by K. Carrier.
04/14/2010 Service Notice
04/14/2010 Entry granting the motion to intervene filed by Kroger and denying the requests by Mr. Lane that this docket be consolidated with 08-709 and that he be granted intervention; and denying the requests by Ms. Hayes for motions to intervene be extended to March 3, 2010 and that the instant case be consolidated with 08-709; and denying OCC's request to extend the procedural schedule to conduct an additional two months of discovery; that the parties comply with the discovery and motion deadlines set forth in findings (16) and (17). (KLS)
04/09/2010 Corrected motion to intervene and request for public hearing filed by A. Lane.
04/08/2010 Motion to intervene filed on behalf of Albert E. Lane.
03/26/2010 Response on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. with attachment A, the letter Duke Energy Ohio Inc. filed on March 25, 2010, filed by A. Hotz.
03/25/2010 Letter to inform the Commission as to whether all of the issues raised in the comments in this case had been resolved, filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.
03/08/2010 Memorandum in opposition to Albert E. Lane's motion to intervene filed by A. Spiller and M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
03/08/2010 Memorandum in opposition to Shirley Hayes' motion to intervene filed by A. Spiller and M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
03/03/2010 Request of Shirley Hayes to be added as an intervenor in this case.
03/02/2010 Request that the attorney examiners accept late filed comments of A. Lane.
03/01/2010 Request PUCO to reactivate and merge all of PUCO docket # 08-709-El-AIR with PUCO docket # 09-1946-EL-ATA/RDR, and to be reinstated as an intervenor filed by A. Lane, consumer.
02/23/2010 Comments of the Kroger Co. filed by M. White.
02/23/2010 Attachments for The Kroger Co.'s comments filed by M. White.
02/23/2010 Objections and comments of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz.
02/23/2010 Comments of the Staff of the Commission filed by W. Wright.
02/17/2010 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The Kroger Company by M. White.
02/09/2010 Entry ordering that motions to intervene shall be filed by February 23, 2010, comments by Staff and any other interested parties shall be filed by February 23, 2010, and that Duke shall inform the Commission by March 25, 2010, as to whether or not all of the issues raised in the comments have been resolved; that the motion to intervene filed by OCC be granted; that OCC's motion for expedited discovery is denied; that Case No. 09-1946-EL-ATA be now and hereafter designated as Case No. 09-1946-EL-RDR. (KLS)
02/09/2010 Staff requests an extension of time for filing comments to February 23,2010, filed by W. Wright.
02/09/2010 Service Notice
12/23/2009 Memorandum in opposition to the office of The Ohio Consumers Counsel motion for expedited discovery, filed by A. Spiller and M. Dortch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.
12/18/2009 Motion to intervene and motion for expedited discovery and request for expedited ruling and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by A, Hotz.
12/11/2009 Direct testimony of James Mehring on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
12/11/2009 Direct testimony of W. Wathen Jr. on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
12/11/2009 In the matter of the application of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc to establish and adjust the initial level of Rider DR.