Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 08-1229-GA-COI
CASE DESCRIPTION: FIVE YEAR REVIEW OF NATURAL GAS COMPANY UNCOLLECTIBLE RIDERS
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 12/1/2020
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
03/04/2020 Notice of withdrawal of Stephen B. Seiple electronically filed by Cheryl A MacDonald on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
02/24/2020 Notice of withdrawal of Counsel of Joseph P. Meissner and/or Matthew C. Vincel field by K. Hollingsworth on behalf of The Legal Aid Society of Cleveland.
02/13/2015 Notice of Withdrawal as Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Andrew J Sonderman on behalf of Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corporation and Orwell Natural Gas Company and Waterville Gas & Oil Company
12/05/2012 Correspondence with change of address for Whitt Sturtevant, LLP filed by M. Whitt.
08/20/2012 Notification of Withdrawal of Melissa Thompson for the above-referenced cases filed by Andrew J. Campbell.
02/03/2012 Letter stating of a change of address and firm affiliation for Mark A. Whitt, Christopher T. Kennedy and Melissa L. Thompson for each of the above referenced cases filed by M. Whitt.
02/01/2012 Service Notice
02/01/2012 Entry denying OCC's application for rehearing.
01/23/2012 Memorandum contra application for rehearing filed by M. Thompson on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., B. Leslie on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
01/13/2012 Application for rehearing by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by J. Serio.
12/15/2011 Service Notice
12/14/2011 Finding and order stating that Staff shall comply with directives in Findings (18), (30), (45), (61), and (62); Vectren shall comply with the directives in Findings (30), (39), (51), and (60); and Dominion, Duke, and Columbia shall comply with the directives in Findings (51) and (60),
02/28/2011 Reply comments by the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network, the Consumers for Fair Utility Rates and United Clevelanders against Poverty filed by J. Meissner.
02/25/2011 Reply comments filed on behalf of the Citizens Coalition by J. Meissner. (FAX)
02/25/2011 Joint reply comments of Columbia Gas of Ohio by B. Leslie, East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio by M. Thompson and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. by A. Spiller.
02/25/2011 Joint reply comments by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by K. Verrett, The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, Cleveland Housing Network, and The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland by J. Meissner, Communities United for Action by N. Morgan and Ohio Poverty Law Center by M. Smalz.
01/28/2011 Initial comments of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio filed by M. Thompson.
01/28/2011 Initial comments of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. filed by M. Thompson.
01/28/2011 Comments of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by B. Leslie.
01/28/2011 Joint comments by Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Serio, Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, Cleveland Housing Network, and The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland by J. Meissner, Communities United for Action by N. Morgan, and Ohio Poverty Law Center by J. Maskovyak.
01/10/2011 Service Notice
01/10/2011 Entry ordering that OCC's motion for an extension of time be granted and the comments and reply comments on the audit report shall be filed by January 28, 2011, and February 25, 2011, respectively. (MW)
01/05/2011 Motion for extension of deadline for Initial and Reply Comments and request for expedited ruling by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel and memorandum in support filed by J. Serio.
12/13/2010 Memorandum contra application for rehearing by the OCC filed by M. Whitt on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy Business Services and by S. Seiple on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
12/09/2010 Confidential release of exhibit audit report filed on 5/3/2010.
12/03/2010 Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by l. Sauer.
11/16/2010 Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Joseph M. Clark and substitution of counsel, Gretchen J. Hummel for Ohio Gas Company.
11/03/2010 Service Notice
11/03/2010 Entry ordering that, in accordance with finding (11), the motions for protective order filed by Columbia and Duke be denied; that, on December 7, 2010, the Commission's docketing division release the unredacted pages of the audit report filed by NorthStar in this docket on May 3, 2010.
09/20/2010 Reply to Utilities' memorandum contra OCC's motion to compel discovery by the OCC, filed by L. Sauer.
09/09/2010 Memorandum contra the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's motion to compel discovery filed by M. Whitt on behalf of the East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc..
08/31/2010 Motion to compel discovery by OCC and memorandum in support filed by L. Sauer.
08/16/2010 Reply to memorandum contra OCC's motion to intervene filed by L Sauer on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
08/09/2010 Memorandum contra Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's motion to intervene and reply memorandum in support of motion to stay discovery filed by M. Whitt on behalf of East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy, Ohio, and by B. Leslie on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio.
08/02/2010 Memorandum contra motion to stay discovery by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.
07/30/2010 Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.
07/14/2010 Motion to stay discovery with memorandum in support filed by M. Whitt on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc; filed by A. Spiller on behalf of Counsel for Duke Energy Ohio Inc; filed by B. Leslie on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc.
05/28/2010 Reply of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. to the Memorandum contra of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by B. Leslie.
05/28/2010 Reply to the Ohio Consumers' Counsel's memorandum contra Duke Energy's motion for protective order filed by A. Spiller on behalf of Duke.
05/21/2010 Memorandum contra Columbia Gas and Duke's motions for protective order on behalf of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Serio.
05/07/2010 Revised unredacted pages for the report filed on May 3, 2010 filed by A. Anderson on behalf of NorthStar Consulting Group.
05/06/2010 Notice of withdrawal of counsel, David A. Kutik, Paul Colbert and Grant W. Garber and designation of new counsel, of record, Mark A. Whitt, filed on behalf of M. Whitt
05/05/2010 Motion for protective order and memorandum in support filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
05/03/2010 Confidential document: Review of the credit and collection policies and practices of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Duke Energy of Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio filed by NorthStar Consulting Group. (120 pages)
05/03/2010 Review of the credit and collection policies and practices of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Duke Energy of Ohio, and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio filed by NorthStar Consulting Group.
05/03/2010 Confidential document: Review of the credit and collection policies and practices of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Duke Energy of Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, filed by NorthStar Consulting Group. (170 PAGES)
05/03/2010 Motion for protective order filed by B. Leslie on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
03/29/2010 Service Notice
03/29/2010 Entry ordered that the companies' motion for an extension of time be granted and the auditor's report be filed by May 3, 2010. (CP)
03/10/2010 Joint motion for extension of time and memorandum in support filed by B. Leslie on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, and P. Colbert on behalf of East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, M. Whitt on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery Ohio, E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc..
03/08/2010 Notice of appearance of counsel filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio.
03/05/2010 Notice of withdrawal of counsel for Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. filed by L. McAlister.
09/30/2009 Service Notice.
09/30/2009 Entry ordering that NorthStar is hereby selected to perform the auditing activities in accordance with the provisions of RFP No. S 09-CC-1 and the findings of this entry; the companies enter into a contract with the auditor to perform required work and the cost of the audit is to be paid by the companies.
08/19/2009 Service Notice.
08/19/2009 Finding and order, ordering that in accordance with finding (9), the UEX rider mechanisms continue, until such time as the Commission orders otherwise; that each company that files a UEX rider report in May of each year, include in the report the information set forth in finding (12); that the RFP attached to this entry be issued and the proposals in response to the RFP be due by September 18, 2009; that in accordance with finding (16), Vectren, Dominion, Duke and Columbia bear the cost of the consulting services of the contractor chosen by the Commission; that the natural gas companies and the auditors shall observe the requirements set forth herein.
04/02/2009 Reply comments of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. to the comments of the office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by S. Seiple.
04/02/2009 Reply comments of Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corporation, Orwell Natural Gas Company and Waterville Gas & Oil Company filed by A. Sonderman.
04/02/2009 Reply comments be the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by J. Serio.
04/02/2009 Reply comments of the East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio filed by P. Colbert.
04/02/2009 Joint reply comments of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. and the Ohio Gas Company filed by J. Clark.
04/02/2009 Reply comments of the Ohio Gas Marketers Group filed by M. Petricoff.
03/24/2009 Service Notice.
03/23/2009 Memorandum contra OCC's motion to file comments out of time and motion for extension for time filed on behalf Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio by L. McAlister.
03/23/2009 Comments filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Serio.
03/23/2009 Entry ordering that OCC's initial comments on the staff report may be filed no later than March 23, 2009, and all commenters' reply comments may be filed no later than April 2, 2009. It is further ordered that commenters comply with finding (7). (JWK)
03/19/2009 Motion to file comments out of time and motion for extension of deadline for reply comments and request for expedited ruling filed on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Serio.
03/16/2009 Comments filed on behalf of Northeast Ohio Natural Gas Corporation by A. Sonderman.
03/16/2009 Initial comments filed on behalf of the Ohio Gas Company by J. Clark.
03/16/2009 Initial comments filed on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. by L. McAlister.
03/16/2009 Initial comments filed on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio by G. Garber.
03/13/2009 Comments of Waterville Gas & Oil Company filed by A. Sonderman.
02/26/2009 Service notice.
02/25/2009 Entry ordering comments on the staff report may be filed no later than March 16, 2009, and reply comments may be filed no later than March 26, 2009. (JK)
02/05/2009 Finding and recommendations of the Five-Year review of Natural Gas Company uncollectible riders filed by S. Puican, Co-Chief
11/14/2008 In the matter of the five-year review of natural gas company uncollectible riders.