DIS - Case Record for 08-0690-TP-CSS Skip to main content

Case Record For:

08-0690-TP-CSS

File a Public Comment
Case Title: AT&T OHIO VS GLOBAL NAPS OHIO INC
Status: CL-CLOSED
Industry Code: TP-TELEPHONE
Purpose Code: CSS-Complaint on service or safety
Date Opened: 6/10/2008
Date Closed: 1/24/2011
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
01/24/2011Case Action Form closing case effective 1/24/11.1
09/10/2010Letter of Notification confirming disconnection of GNAPs Ohio from its network electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.3
06/09/2010Service Notice3
06/09/2010Opinion and order stating that Global NAPS Ohio should provide AT&T Ohio with the applicable payment within the time frame set forth; with respect to Count II, AT&T Ohio's complaint is moot; with respect to Count IV, AT&T Ohio's complaint is denied and that consistent with this opinion and order, the Commission Staff commence an investigation regarding respondent's compliance with Commission rules and regulations and applicable statutes.43
03/08/2010Letter in response to GNAPs' letter dated March 1, 2010. electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.4
03/01/2010Reply in response to AT&T's letter brief of February 24, 2010, filed by H. Davidow on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc.4
02/24/2010Correspondence letter regarding responses to letters from counsel for Global NAPs Ohio, Inc., electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.37
02/19/2010Memorandum order as supplemental authority, a decision of the federal district court for the District of Columbia, Paetec Telecommunications, Inc. v. CommPartners, LLC filed by H. Davidow on behalf of Paetec Telecommunications, Inc.13
02/10/2010Letter in reply to AT&T's letter brief objecting to the supplemental authority offered by Global NAP's and the AT&T's arguments that the proposed Maryland Public Service Commission's decision should be disregarded are meritless filed by H. Davidow.8
02/04/2010Correspondence to examiner Agranoff electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.4
02/03/2010Supplemental authority of a proposed order from the Maryland Public Service Commission for the Commission's consideration filed by H. Davidow on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc.28
11/20/2009Letter disagreeing with AT&T's letter of November 17, 2009 filed by H. Davidow.1
11/17/2009Certificate of service to Global NAPS Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.2
11/17/2009Correspondence in reply to Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. filing electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio3
11/12/2009Supplement to include a section of a transcript from a deposition of AT&T's witness, Mr. Cole filed by H. Davidow on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc.14
09/24/2009Global NAPs Ohio, Inc.'s notice of supplemental authority, electronically filed by Mr. Matt S White.25
09/22/2009Service Notice3
09/22/2009Entry granting the motion for protective treatment in accordance with Finding (2). (JA)2
09/17/2009Reply Brief of AT&T Ohio electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon.40
09/17/2009Reply brief of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Christine Schulenberg.36
09/17/2009Confidential document target for a supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret filed by M. Yurich on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. (65 pages)1
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 3 of 9)200
09/17/2009Motion for protective treatment and memorandum in support filed by M. White on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.7
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 6 of 9)200
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 9 of 9)167
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 7 of 9)200
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 4 of 9)201
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 2 of 9)201
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits filed on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. (PART 1 of 9)200
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (Part 5 of 9).200
09/17/2009Supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret with exhibits continued. (PART 8 of 9)201
09/17/2009Confidential document target for reply brief filed by M. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio. (33 pages)1
09/08/2009Transcript of hearing held on August 24, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff in Columbus, OH, Volume III electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Sloas, Valerie J. Mrs.59
09/04/2009AT&T Ohio's initial brief (Public Version) filed by M. Fenlon.39
09/04/2009Initial post-hearing brief continued. (Part 2 of 2)76
09/04/2009Initial post-hearing brief, public version, filed on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. (PART 1 of 2)200
09/04/2009Confidential document: Initial post-hearing brief filed on behalf of Global Naps Ohio Inc.1
09/02/2009Stipulation to strike portions of supplemental testimony of William Rooney electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.8
08/19/2009Confidential document: Testimony of Brad Masuret & Exhibits filed on behalf of Global NAP's Ohio, Inc. (468 pgs)1
08/19/2009Supplemental testimony and exhibits of Jeffrey Noack filed on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. 56
08/19/2009Transcript, Volume II, for hearing held August 5, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff, electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Sloas, Valerie J. Mrs.180
08/18/2009Confidential document: Direct testimony of James W. Hamiter & Rebecca M. Harlen and exhibits filed on behalf of AT&T Ohio. (59 PAGES)1
08/18/2009Exhibits for hearing held on August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff. (Part 5 of 5)54
08/18/2009Exhibits for hearing held on August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff. (Part 4 of 5)202
08/18/2009Exhibits for hearing held on August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff. (Part 3 of 5)192
08/18/2009Exhibits for hearing held on August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff. (Part 2 of 5)196
08/18/2009Exhibits for hearing held on August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff. (Part 1 of 5)222
08/18/2009Transcript for hearing held August 4, 2009 before AE J. Agranoff, electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Sloas, Valerie J. Mrs.159
08/17/2009Supplemental testimony and exhibits of Brad Masuret (Non-Confidential Public Version) on Behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Christine Schulenberg on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc.67
08/17/2009Stipulation to strike portions of the supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc., electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.12
08/13/2009Service Notice3
08/12/2009Entry scheduling a hearing to reconvene on Monday, August 24, 2009, at 10:00 a.m., in Hearing Room 11-G, at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215; that the briefing schedule is amended in accordance with Finding (4). (JSA)2
07/31/2009Motion to quash portions of subpoenas filed by AT&T and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Matt S White on behalf of Global Naps Ohio, Inc.9
07/30/2009Motion to strike portions of Global NAPs Ohio's direct and supplemental testimony electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.15
07/24/2009Correspondence concerning witnesses for AT&T Ohio, electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.4
07/24/2009Confidential document target for the supplemental testimony of Brad Masuret filed on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc. (66 pgs)1
07/24/2009Supplemental testimony of William J. Rooney, Jr. on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. filed by M. White.80
07/24/2009Supplemental testimony of Jeffrey Noack on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. filed by M. White.29
07/23/2009AT&T Ohio's motion to issue subpoenas and memorandum in support, electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.9
07/23/2009Service Notice.2
07/22/2009Entry ordering that AT&T Ohio's motion of July 10, 2009, be denied in accordance with Finding (7); that AT&T Ohio's motion of July 14, 2009, be granted in accordance with Finding (7); that AT&T Ohio file its motion to issue subpoenas to the specified interexchange carriers in accordance with Finding (7). (JA)8
07/21/2009Reply memorandum in support of motion to compel electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.11
07/21/2009Reply memorandum in support of request for leave to file motion to issue subpoenas electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.7
07/17/2009Memorandum contra AT&T Ohio's motion to issue subpoenas filed by M. White on behalf of Global Naps Ohio, Inc.5
07/17/2009Memorandum contra AT&T Ohio's motion to compel, filed by M. White on behalf of Global Naps Ohio, Inc.13
07/14/2009Motion and memorandum in support for leave to file a motion for subpoenas in the alternative electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.4
07/10/2009Motion to Compel electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.29
06/01/2009Supplemental subpoena duces tecum issued to Qwest Communications Company LLC filed by M. Yurick on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. 3
05/27/2009Motion to issue a subpoena and memorandum in support filed by M. Yurick, Esq. on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc. 8
05/14/2009Service Notice.2
05/13/2009Entry ordering that a hearing be held on August 4 and 5, 2009, at 10:00 a.m., in Hearing Room 11-G, at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215. It is further ordered that all substitute witnesses should be identified in accordance with Finding (7); that AT&T file its order of witnesses on or before July 24, 2009; that GNAPs Ohio may file supplemental direct testimony in accordance with Finding (7); that the motion pro hac vice is granted in accordance with Finding (9); that AT&T's motion for a protective order is granted in accordance with Finding (11). (JSA)5
04/10/2009Notice of withdrawal of motion for protective treatment filed by M. White on behalf of Global NAP's Ohio, Inc. 4
04/03/2009Motion for protective treatment and memorandum in support filed by M. Yurick, Esq. on behalf of Global NAP's Ohio, Inc. 15
03/27/2009Memorandum Contra GNAPs Ohio's Motion for Reconsideration electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio7
03/23/2009Motion for reconsideration filed on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. by M. Yurick and H. Davidow. 4
03/17/2009Service Notice.2
03/16/2009Entry ordering that Global NAPs' motion to compel is granted in part and denied in part in accordance with the findings above; That AT&T provide Global NAPs with a privilege log in accordance with Finding (11); That a status conference shall occur on April 8, 2009, at 10:00 a.m. to discuss scheduling of an in camera inspection regarding the applicable documents; That to the extent not otherwise addressed, all other requests are denied. (JSA)12
03/11/2009Notice of withdrawal of request for arbitration filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow4
03/06/2009Additional information that was inadvertently excluded from Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.'s response to AT&T's reply to motion to compel which was filed on March 5, 2009 filed by M. Yurick.4
03/05/2009Response to AT&T's reply to motion to compel filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.17
02/26/2009Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.'s motion to issue subpoenas and memorandum in support filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow.14
02/25/2009Reply of AT&T Ohio to GNAPS motion to compel electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.15
02/20/2009Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.'s motion and memorandum in support to compel responses to respondent global NAPS' data requests to complainant AT&T Ohio filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow.22
02/18/2009Reply to AT&T Ohio's opposition to Global's request for arbitration filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc.10
02/12/2009Memorandum in opposition to GNAPs' request for arbitration electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio8
02/06/2009Request of Global Naps Ohio, Inc. for arbitration and memorandum in support filed by M. Yurick and H. Davidow.10
01/26/2009Memorandum Contra Global NAPs Ohio's motion to postpone hearing electronically filed by Ms. Mary K. Fenlon on behalf of AT&T Ohio.4
01/23/2009Motion of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc. to postpone hearing in this matter to conduct additional discovery and memorandum in support filed by M. Yurick.6
01/22/2009Exhibit for Patricia H. Pellerin Testimony electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.223
01/22/2009Exhibit for Patricia H. Pellerin Testimony electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.163
01/22/2009Exhibit for Patricia H. Pellerin Testimony electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.247
01/22/2009Exhibit for Patricia H. Pellerin Testimony electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.52
01/22/2009Confidential document: Exhibits 1 & 2 with attachments filed on behalf of AT&T Ohio by V. Engram. (71 pgs)1
01/21/2009Testimony of James W. Hamiter electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.21
01/21/2009Testimony of Patricia H. Pellerin electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.64
01/21/2009Testimony of William L. Cole, Rebecca M. Harlen and Yolanda L. Williams electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.30
01/21/2009Motion for protective order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio and M. Fenlon.7
01/21/2009Direct testimony and exhibits of James R. J. Scheltema filed on behalf of Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. by M. Yurick. 67
01/20/2009Motion for admission pro hac vice of Harry Davidow and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Global NAPS Ohio, Inc. by M. Yurick. 4
11/20/2008Entry ordering that a hearing be held on January 28 and 29, 2009, at 10:00 a.m., in hearing room 11-C, at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 and that the motion pro hac vice to allow Mr. Scheltema to participate in this proceeding is granted. (JSA)5
11/20/2008Service Notice2
08/22/2008Service Notice2
08/22/2008Entry ordering that the complaint sets forth reasonable grounds of going forward with complaint in accordance with Finding (3); that a prehearing conference be scheduled for September 8, 2008 at 1:30 p.m., Hearing room 11-B, at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio 43215; that the motion for admission pro hac vice is granted in accordance with Finding (6). (JSA)5
07/14/2008Answer to the complaint filed by M.S. Yurick and J. Scheltema on behalf of Global NAP's Ohio, Inc. 11
07/14/2008Motion for admission Pro Hac Vice of James R.J. Scheltema and memorandum in support M.S. Yurick Esq. on behalf of Global NAP's Ohio Inc. 4
06/25/2008Complaint service letter mailed to Global NAPs Ohio, Inc., James Scheltema.1
06/25/2008Complaint response letter and brochure mailed to AT&T Ohio, Mary Fenlon.1
06/10/2008In the matter of the complaint of AT&T Ohio v. Global NAPs Ohio, Inc. for the alleged violation of the parties interconnection agreement and for failure to satisfy the minimum requirements for maintaining certificates of service authority filed by Mary Ryan Fenlon. Electronically filed by Mrs. Verneda J. Engram on behalf of AT&T Ohio.75