DIS - Case Record for 95-1182-TP-CSS Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 95-1182-TP-CSS
CASE DESCRIPTION: STATE ALARM/AMERITECH OHIO
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 4/23/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
10/03/2013 Case action form closing case effective 10/3/2013.
02/25/2002 Notice of change in counsel filed by T. Rodgers on behalf of State Alarm, Inc.
12/19/2000 Issues list filed on behalf of State Alarm by J. Small.
12/19/2000 Issues list filed on behalf of Ameritech Ohio by C. Rawlings.
12/11/2000 Motion for extension to file issues list and proposal of meeting dates and memorandum in support filed on behalf of complainant by J. Small.
11/30/2000 Entry ordering that State Alarm's application for rehearing is granted in part and denied in part as discussed in this entry; that Ameritech's application for rehearing on the notice requirements for a central office cutover is granted as discussed in this entry and, in all other respects, Ameritech's application for rehearing is denied; that the parties comply with the directives of Finding 37.
12/03/1999 Letter, with attached motion to vacate stay order, filed on behalf of complainant, State Alarm, by J. Small. (9 pgs.)
09/20/1999 Reply to Ameritech Ohio motion for order scheduling a con- conference with Commission staff, filed on behalf of complain- ant, State Alarm, by J. Small. (5 pgs.)
09/01/1999 Motion for an order scheduling a conference between Ameri- tech Ohio, State Alarm, and Commission staff, and memorandum in support filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (7 pgs.)
08/03/1999 Comments stating dissatisfaction with the Ameritech Ohio report of investigation and with the remedial action taken, filed on behalf of State Alarm, Inc. by J. Bentine.
08/03/1999 Comments filed on behalf of State Alarm by J. Small. (26 pgs.)
08/03/1999 Comments filed on behalf of complainant, State Alarm, by J. Small. (26 pgs.)
07/30/1999 Reply of State Alarm, Inc. to memorandum contra motion for mediation, filed by J. Small. (6 pgs.)
07/23/1999 Memorandum of Ameritech Ohio contra motion of State Alarm for mediation to determine an appropriate payment plan, filed by C. Rawlings. (7 pgs.)
07/22/1999 Motion for extension to comment on Ameritech Ohio report and memorandum in support filed on behalf of complainant, State Alarm, by J. Small. (4 pgs.)
07/08/1999 Motion of State Alarm for mediation to determine an appro- priate payment plan and memorandum in support filed by J. Small. (20 pgs.)
06/23/1999 Report of investigation filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (22 pgs.)
05/19/1999 Entry granting the rehearing for the limited purpose of affording the Commission a short extension of time to more thoroughly consider and address the arguments raised in the parties' respective applications for rehearing; that the parties joint request for a 30-day extension of time is granted in accordance with Finding 5. (2 pgs.)
05/06/1999 Memorandum contra Ameritech's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of State Alarm by J. Small. (17 pgs.)
05/06/1999 Joint motion for extension of time filed on behalf of State Alarm by J. Small; and Ameritech Ohio by C. Rawlings. (3 pgs.)
05/03/1999 Correction to application for rehearing filed on 4/16/1999 on behalf of Ameritech Ohio by S. Rawlings.
05/03/1999 Memorandum of Ameritech Ohio contra State Alarm application for rehearing, filed by C. Rawlings. (15 pgs.)
05/03/1999 Correction to the memorandum in support of application for rehearing at page 8 thereof, filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by S. Rawlings. (1 pg.)
04/28/1999 Application for rehearing filed on behalf of State Alarm, Inc. by J. Small. (20 pgs.) (FILED 4/23/99 INCORRECTLY IN CASE NO. 96-1182-GA-AEC)
04/26/1999 Application of Ameritech Ohio for rehearing filed by C. Rawlings. (29 pgs)
03/26/1999 Opinion & Order that State Alarm's complaint for inadequate service is granted, in part, and denied in part; that Ameri- tech's requests to require State Alarm to establish an es- crown account as to the multiplex accounts and the non- multiplex accounts with Ameritech is denied; that State Alarm is directed to bring its accounts current or enter into payment arrangements within sixty days of this order or Ameritech may pursue available remedies to collect out- standing balances including, but not limited to, the dis- connection of service; that Ameritech conduct or cause to be conducted a complete and comprehensive analysis of the cir- cuits serving State Alarm; that Ameritech shall file a written report witin sixty days from this order, specifi- cally setting forth the results of the investigation; that State Alarm shall file within thirty days of receipt of the Ameritech report a written statement indicating whether it is satisfied with the remedial action taken and the results thereof. (42 pgs.) (ISSUED 3/25/99)
03/25/1999 Opinion & Order that State Alarm's complaint for inadequate service is granted, in part, and denied in part; that Ameritech's requests to require State Alarm to establish an escrow account as to the multiplex accounts and the non-multiplexed accounts with Ameritech is denied; that State Alarm is directed to bring its accounts current or enter into payment arrangements within sixty days of this order or Ameritech may pursue available remedies to collect outstanding balances including, but not limited to, the disconnection of service.
10/05/1998 Reply of Ameritech Ohio to memorandum contra of State Alarm filed by C. Rawlings. (7 pgs.)
09/25/1998 Memorandum contra motion of Ameritech for an order requiring State Alarm to establish an escrow account, filed by J. Small.
09/25/1998 Memorandum contra motion of Ameritech for an order requiring State Alarm to establish an escrow account filed by J. Small (10 pgs)
09/09/1998 Motion for an order requiring State Alarm to establish and maintain an escrow account and memorandum in support filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (9 pgs.)
10/30/1997 Reply brief filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (38 pgs.)
10/30/1997 Post-hearing reply brief of State Alarm, Incorporated filed by J. Small. (26 pgs.)
10/09/1997 Post-hearing brief filed on behalf of complainant by J. Bentine. (72 pgs.)
10/09/1997 Initial brief filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (32 pgs.)
09/03/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/20/97, (GS), 98 pgs., Submitted. (Volume VIII) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
09/03/1997 Composite Index, Volumes I through VIII, July 28, 31, August 1, 4, 5, 6, 19 and 20, 1997, filed. (6 pgs.)
09/03/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/19/97, (GS), 116 pgs., Con't. (Volume VII) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/20/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/6/97, (GS), 185 pgs., Con't. (Volume VI) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/20/1997 Subpoena to Stephen Doug Snyder filed. (2 pgs.)
08/19/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/5/97, (GS), 116 pgs., Con't. (Volume V) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/19/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/4/97, (GS), 102 pgs., Con't. (Volume IV) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/15/1997 Rebuttal testimony of Donald Shury, SAS Exhibit SR, filed by J. Small. (8 pgs.)
08/15/1997 Rebuttal testimony of Thomas E. Baytos, SAS Exhibit BR, filed by J. Small. (16 pgs.)
08/15/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 8/1/97, (GS), 139 pgs., Con't. (Volume III) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/14/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 7/31/97, (GS), 169 pgs., Con't. (Volume II) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
08/11/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 7/28/97, (GS), 131 pgs., Con't. (Volume I) (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Stephen Doug Snyder filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (108 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Donald Deptula filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (51 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Linda Mills filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (43 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Dale Metyk filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (227 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Ken Allen filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (60 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of Georgia Dabner filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (132 pgs)
07/24/1997 Deposition of John Garsteck filed on behalf of applicant by J. Small. (44 pgs)
07/24/1997 Subpoena issued to Ronald Juhasz by Attorney Examiner, G See (1 pg)
07/24/1997 Subpoena issued to Diane Koller by G. See, PUCO staff (1 pg)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 15 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 14 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 13 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 12 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 11 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 10 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript and exhibits cont'd. (Part 9 of 16)
07/23/1997 Testimony w/exhibits cont'd. (Part 8 of 16)
07/23/1997 Testimony w/exhibits cont'd. (Part 7 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript w/exhibits cont'd. (Part 6 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript w/exhibits cont'd. (Part 5 of 16)
07/23/1997 Transcript w/exhibits cont'd. (Part 4 of 16)
07/23/1997 Testimony and exhibits cont'd. (Part 3 of 16)
07/23/1997 Testimony and exhibits cont'd. (Part 2 of 16)
07/23/1997 Direct Testimony and exhibits of Donald Shury (SAS Exhibit S); Diane Koller (SAS Exhibit K); Ronald Juhasz (SAS Exhibit J); William Edelstein (SAS Exhibit E); Thomas Baytos (SAS Exhibit B); and Brenda Dull (SAS Exhibit D), filed on behalf of complainant by J. Small. (Part 1 of 16)
07/23/1997 Testimony and Exhibits cont'd (Part 16 of 16)
07/22/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 7/8/97, (GS), 5 pgs., Con't. (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
07/21/1997 Testimony of Dale Metyk filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (46 pgs.)
07/21/1997 Testimony of Georgia Dabner filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (23 pgs.)
07/21/1997 Testimony of Stephen Doug Snyder filed on behalf of respon- dent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (14 pgs.)
07/21/1997 Testimony of John Garsteck filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (12 pgs.)
07/21/1997 Testimony of Donald Deptula filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (10 pgs.)
07/03/1997 Entry ordering that the hearing be continued until 10:00 a.m. on July 28, 1997. (AE) (2 pgs.)
06/25/1997 Subpeona duces tecum filed on behalf of the PUCO staff by G. See. (2 pgs.)
05/13/1997 Entry scheduling a hearing at 10:00 a.m on July 8, 1997, at the Commission offices; that Ameritech's motion to dismiss 95-1182 is denied and State Alarm's motion to dismiss 96-858 is also denied; that State Alarm's request to intervene in 96-858 is granted; that State Alarm's motion to amend its complaint in 95-1182 is granted; State Alarm's motion to assess costs incurred to reply to Ameritech's second motion to dismiss in 95-1182 is denied. (AE) (6 pgs.)
04/28/1997 Transcript filed for hearing held 4/14/97, (GS), 5 pgs., Con't. (PUCO-Columbus, OH)
03/28/1997 Memorandum contra motion of Ameritech for a protective order filed on behalf of complainant, State Alarm, by J. Small. (4 pgs.)
03/26/1997 Response to notice regarding confidentiality and request for final prehearing conference filed on behalf of respon- dent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (3 pgs.)
03/25/1997 Notice regarding confidentiality filed on behalf of com- plainant by J. Small. (10 pgs.)
03/24/1997 Reply to Ameritech's memorandum contra motion to amend complaint, filed on behalf of complainant by J. Small. (13 pgs.)
03/20/1997 Memorandum of Ameritech Ohio contra "Complainant's motion for leave to amend Complaint" and supplemental memorandum in support of Ameritech Ohio motion to dismiss complaint filed by C. Rawlings. (16 pgs.)
03/11/1997 Complainant's motion for leave to amend complaint and memorandum in support filed by J. Small. (15 pgs.)
02/13/1997 Reply memorandum on behalf of Ameritech Ohio filed by C. Rawlings.
02/07/1997 Memorandum contra of State Alarm to Ameritech's second motion to dismiss filed by C. Rawlings on behalf of Ameritech Ohio.
01/28/1997 Service Notice
01/23/1997 Motion to dismiss complaint and memorandum in support filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (6 pgs.)
01/21/1997 Entry granting the parties' request for an extension of the discovery period until February 28, 1997; scheduling a hear- ing at 10:00 a.m. on April 14, 1997, at the Commission offices. (AE) (2 pgs.)
01/14/1997 Joint motion to extend discovery and memorandum in support filed on behalf of complainant by by J. Small; and respon- dent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (3 pgs.)
11/25/1996 Entry ordering that the parties request for an extension of the discovery period until January 15, 1997 is granted and that a prehearing/case management conference be scheduled for December 11, 1996. (AE) (2 pgs.)
11/08/1996 Report of State Alarm, Inc. concerning discovery progress, filed by J. Small. (5 pgs.)
11/07/1996 Joint motion to extend discovery and memorandum in support filed on behalf complainant, State Alarm, by J. Small; and respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings. (3 pgs.)
09/22/1996 Service Notice
09/09/1996 Report of State Alarm, Inc. concerning Discovery progress filed July 9, 1996 submitted by J. Small.
07/09/1996 Report of State Alarm, Inc. concerning discovery progress filed July 9, 1996 submitted by J. Small.
07/09/1996 Report of State Alarm, Inc. concerning discovery progress filed July 9, 1996 submitted by J. Small.
05/08/1996 Report of State Alarm, Inc. concerning discovery progress filed May 9 1996 filed by J. Bentine.
04/15/1996 Transcript filed for hearing held 4/9/96, (GS), 6 pgs., Con't. (PUCO-Columbus, Ohio)
04/11/1996 Entry ordering that all parties request for a continuance of the hearing is granted; the hearing will be continued until further noitice; that the parties submit the dis- covery status reports and conclude discovery by 11/30/96 in compliance with Finding 3. (AE) (2 pgs.)
04/04/1996 Joint motion to continue hearing filed by J. Small on behalf of State Alarm, Inc. and C. Rawlings on behalf of Ameritech Ohio.
03/04/1996 Legal Notice sent to: Youngstown Vindicator (Mahoning Co) Certified Mail.
02/21/1996 Entry scheduling a settlement conference at 10:00 a.m. on 3/5/96 at the Commission offices; if this matter can not be resolved informally, an evidentiary hearing will be scheduled for 10:00 a.m. on 4/9/96 at the Commission offices; that Ameritech's motion to dismiss complaint is denied. (AE)
02/15/1996 Reply memorandum filed on behalf of respondent, Ameritech Ohio, by C. Rawlings.
02/05/1996 Memorandum contra to motion of Ameritech to dismiss complaint, filed on behalf of Complainant by J. Small.
02/05/1996 Memorandum contra to motion of Ameritech to dismiss com- plaint, filed on behalf of complainant by J. Small. (8 pgs.)
01/23/1996 Correction to page 3 of Ameritech Ohio's motion to dismiss complaint filed January 17, 1996, filed by C. Rawlings.
01/17/1996 Answer filed by C. Rawlings on behalf of Ameritech Ohio.
01/17/1996 Motion of Ameritech Ohio to dismiss complaint C. Rawlings.
12/28/1995 Complaint letter and copy of complaint mailed to: Jon F. Kelly, Ameritech Ohio. (1 pg.)
12/27/1995 In the matter of the complaint of State Alarm, Inc. (vs) Ameritech Ohio relative to the alleged unjust, unreasonable, and inadequate telephone service. (9 pgs.)