Skip to main content

Case Record For:

16-0253-GA-BTX

File a Public Comment
Case Title: Duke Energy Ohio
Status: OPEN-OPEN
Industry Code: GA-GAS
Purpose Code: BTX-Application for a Certificate/ Gas or Electric
Date Opened: 3/8/2016
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
08/24/2017Administrative Law Judge Entry granting Duke's motion to suspend the procedural schedule until otherwise ordered by the Board. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Sarah Parrot, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.4
08/24/2017Service Notice10
08/23/2017Motion for suspension of procedural schedule and memorandum in support by Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and request for expedited treatment electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.5
08/22/2017Kenwood Mall, LLC's List of Concerns for Cross-Examination. electronically filed by Mr. Richard B Tranter on behalf of Kenwood Mall, LLC.3
08/22/2017Correspondence BRE DDR Crocodile Sycamore Square, LLC's List of Concerns for Cross-Examination. electronically filed by Mr. Richard B. Tranter on behalf of BRE DDR Crocodile Sycamore Plaza, LLC.3
08/21/2017Correspondence Regarding Cross-Examination Issues List electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker on behalf of IGS Energy.4
08/21/2017Correspondence Statement of Issues of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.3
08/21/2017Village of Evendale List of Potential Issues of Cross-Examination electronically filed by Mr. Micah E. Kamrass on behalf of Village of Evendale.3
08/21/2017Testimony of Columbia Township's List of Potential Issues For Cross-Examination of Witnesses at the Adjudicatory Hearing electronically filed by Mr. Mark G Arnzen on behalf of Columbia Township.12
08/21/2017Testimony of the City of Blue Ash, Ohio's List of Potential Issues For Cross-Examination of Witnesses at the Adjudicatory Hearing electronically filed by Mr. Mark G Arnzen on behalf of City of Blue Ash, Ohio.14
08/21/2017List of Issues of the City of Cincinnati and the Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County electronically filed by Mr. Mark T Keaney on behalf of City of Cincinnati and The Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County.5
08/21/2017List of Issues for Cross-Examination by NOPE-Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC electronically filed by James Yskamp on behalf of NOPE - Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC.8
08/21/2017Sycamore Township's List of Issues for Cross-Examination of Witnesses at the Evidentiary Hearing electronically filed by Mr. R. Douglas Miller on behalf of Sycamore Township, Hamilton County, Ohio and Weidman, Thomas J. Mr.9
08/21/2017List of concerns pertaining to cross examination filed by D. Stevenson on behalf of the City of Reading, OH. 3
08/21/2017List of issues for cross examination of witnesses at the evidentiary hearing filed by Brian W. Fox on behalf of the City of Maderia.(FAX)7
08/18/2017Notice of Deposition First Notice of Deposition of the City of Cincinnati and the Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County to Take Depositions of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Mark T Keaney on behalf of City of Cincinnati and The Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County.4
08/18/2017Notification - Amberley Village, Statement of Specific Concerns Pertaining to Cross Examination electronically filed by Mr. Kevin K. Frank on behalf of Amberley Village.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Amberley Village electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of 10149 LLC electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Coprop Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the Board of County Commissioner of Hamilton County, Ohio electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the Village of Golf Manor electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the Jewish Hospital -Mercy Health electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of BRE DDR Crocodile Sycamore Square, LLC electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the City of Deer Park electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the City of Reading electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of IGS Energy electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Kenwood Mall, LLC electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of NOPE-Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of RLB Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Pleasant Ridge Community Council electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the Village of Evendale electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Sycamore Township electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of Columbia Township electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the City of Madeira electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the City of Blue Ash electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
08/16/2017First Notice of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. to take Deposition Duces Tecum of the City of Cincinnati electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.7
06/28/2017Testimony for Public Hearing Held on June 15, 2017.468
06/28/2017PUCO Exhibit Filing: Sign In Sheets filed by Armstrong & Okey, LLC on behalf of PUCO Staff.6
06/28/2017Transcript for hearing held on June 15, 2017 electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Burke, Carolyn and Grubaugh, Valerie.315
06/22/2017Service Notice10
06/21/2017Administrative Law Judge Entry ordering Duke’s motion for waiver of Ohio Adm.Code 4906-3-09(A)(2) be granted; that the motions to continue the adjudicatory hearing are granted, in part, and denied, in part; and that the adjudicatory hearing be rescheduled to commence on September 11, 2017, at 10:00 a.m., in Hearing Room A, 11th Floor, at the offices of the Board. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Greta See, Administrative Law Judge.9
06/20/2017Memorandum Contra Motions to Continue electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.8
06/20/2017Motion for Continuance of the Adjudicatory Hearing, Expedited Ruling and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Richard B. Tranter on behalf of BRE DDR Crocodile Sycamore Plaza, LLC.10
06/20/2017Motion for Continuance of the Adjudicatory Hearing, Expedited Ruling and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Richard B. Tranter on behalf of Kenwood Mall, LLC.10
06/19/2017Memorandum Contra Motions for Continuance electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.8
06/15/2017Service Notice10
06/15/2017Administrative Law Judge Entry granting the petitions to intervene and notices of intervention filed by the entities listed in Paragraph 5 - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Sarah Parrot, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.4
06/14/2017Motion for Continuance of the Adjudicatory Hearing and Request for an Expediting Ruling and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by James Yskamp on behalf of NOPE - Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC.7
06/13/2017Joint Motion for Continuance of the Adjudicatory Hearing and Request for Expedited Ruling electronically filed by Mr. Mark T Keaney on behalf of City of Cincinnati and Amberley Village and The City of Blue Ash and The Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County and The City of Deer Park and The City of Madeira and The City of Reading and Columbia Township and Sycamore Township and The Village of Evendale and The Village of Golf Manor.9
06/12/2017Motion for Waiver and request for expedited treatment - Second Notice electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.7
06/09/2017Proof of Pub Mailings and Newspaper Proof of Publication electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.12
05/31/2017Staff Report of Investigation electronically filed by Mr. Matt Butler on behalf of Staff of OPSB.71
05/31/2017Service Notice12
05/30/2017Petition for Leave to Intervene and Memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. R.L. Kent Bucciere on behalf of Coprop Inc..6
05/23/2017Petition for leave to intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. R.L. Kent Bucciere on behalf of RLB Inc.6
05/18/2017Proof of Publication electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.4
05/12/2017First Set of Interrogatories of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by D. Miller (" (FAX)15
05/11/2017Continued Supplemental Information of Duke Energy Central Corridor Pipeline C314V (Part 3) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.14
05/11/2017Continued Supplemental Information of Duke Energy Central Corridor Pipeline C314V (Part 2) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms. 46
05/11/2017Supplemental Information of Duke Energy Central Corridor Pipeline C314V (Part 1) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.56
05/05/2017Proof of Publication - Initial Notice electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.10
05/04/2017Petition for Leave to Intervene electronically filed by Mr. Richard B Tranter on behalf of Kenwood Mall, LLC17
05/04/2017Correspondence Letter to Ohio Power Siting Board Regarding Delivery of Application to Amberley Village, Ohio electronically filed by Ms. Emily Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Spiller, Amy B. Ms. and Kingery, Jeanne W. Ms.2
05/01/2017Petition for Leave to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. R.L. Kent Bucciere on behalf of 10149 LLC. 7
04/21/2017Petition for Leave to Intervene and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Richard B Tranter on behalf of BRE DDR Crocodile Sycamore Plaza, LLC.15
04/13/2017Administrative Law Judge Entry orders hearings in this matter be scheduled at the times and places designated in Paragraphs 11 and 12; that notices of the application and hearings be published by Duke in accordance with Paragraph 14; that Staff file its report of investigation pursuant to Paragraph 16; and that all parties file their issue(s) lists and expert and factual testimony in accordance with Paragraph 16. Entry electronically filed by Debra Hight on behalf of Greta See, Administrative Law Judge.6
04/13/2017Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in Support electronically filed by Mr. Joseph E. Oliker on behalf of IGS Energy.9
04/13/2017Service Notice9
04/12/2017Petition for Leave to Intervene of The Jewish Hospital electronically filed by Mr. Devin D. Parram on behalf of The Jewish Hospital.7
04/12/2017Notice of Intervention by David Kubicki, President of the Board of Trustees on Behalf of Columbia Township electronically filed by Mr. Mark G. Arnzen on behalf of Columbia Township.9
04/11/2017Notice of Intervention for the City of Deer Park electronically filed by Mr. Andrew J. Helmes on behalf of City of Deer Park.8
04/10/2017Notice of Intervention of the City of Reading electronically filed by Mr. Patrick G.Ross on behalf of City of Reading.4
04/05/2017Notice of Intervention by Ron Hirth on behalf of The Village of Golf Manor, Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Terrence M. Donnellon on behalf of The Village of Golf Manor and Hirth, Ron Mr.8
04/03/2017Notice of Intervention by Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County, Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Roger E. Friedmann on behalf of Board of County Commissioners of Hamilton County, OH.4
04/03/2017Amberley Village motion to intervene electronically filed by Mr. Kevin K. Frank on behalf of Amberley Village.7
03/31/2017Notice of Intervention by Thomas J. Weidman on Behalf of Sycamore Township, Hamilton County, Ohio electronically filed by Mr. R. Douglas Miller on behalf of Sycamore Township, Hamilton County, Ohio and Weidman, Thomas J. Mr.7
03/31/2017Notice of Intervention By City Manager David Waltz on Behalf of The City of Blue Ash, Ohio electronically filed by Mr. Bryan E. Pacheco on behalf of City of Blue Ash, Ohio.8
03/31/2017Notice of Intervention of the Village of Evendale electronically filed by Mr. Micah E Kamrass on behalf of Village of Evendale.4
03/31/2017Notice of Intervention of the City of Cincinnati electronically filed by Mr. Mark T Keaney on behalf of City of Cincinnati.4
03/30/2017Notice Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s official notification of compliance filing. electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Kingery, Jeanne W and Spiller, Amy B146
03/28/2017Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by G. Laux on behalf of Pleasant Ridge Community Council. (original)11
03/24/2017Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by G. Laux on behalf of Pleasant Ridge Community Council.(Fax)10
03/21/2017Notice of payment of filing fee filed by E. Olive on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.4
03/03/2017Letter stating that sufficient information has been found to comply to begin its review for the application filed by PUCO Staff.4
03/03/2017Amended application filed by J. Kingery on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio. electronically filed by Mrs. Kristen Ryan on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Kingery, Jeanne W. Mrs. and Spiller, Amy B. Mrs.25
02/24/2017Amended application filed by J. Kingery on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.5
02/13/2017Supplemental Information for Amended Application - Part 2 electronically filed by Jeanne W Kingery on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.14
02/13/2017Supplemental Information for Amended Application - Part 1 electronically filed by Jeanne W Kingery on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.25
02/02/2017Proof of Pub Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s Notice of Publication of its Fourth Public Informational Meeting electronically filed by Mrs. Kristen Ryan on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and Kingery, Jeanne W. Mrs. and Spiller, Amy B. Mrs.4
01/31/2017Confirmation of fourth public informational meeting electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.2
01/20/2017Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 7 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.11
01/20/2017Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 6 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.73
01/20/2017Amended Application Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 5 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.19
01/20/2017Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 4 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.52
01/20/2017Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 3 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.56
01/20/2017Amended Application Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project, PUCO Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX (PART 2 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.13
01/20/2017Amended Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project (PART 1 OF 7) electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.101
01/06/2017Notice of Fourth Informational Meeting Plan electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.5
01/03/2017Correspondence of Duke Energy Ohio C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project Case No. 16-253-GA-BTX- supplemental ecological field survey results electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.8
10/31/2016Correspondence ODNR Informal Consultation Request electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.6
10/18/2016Correspondence Letter from Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. re ecological field surveys electronically filed by Dianne Kuhnell on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B. and Kingery, Jeanne W. 2
10/07/2016Correspondence confirming that Duke Energy Ohio is initiating efforts to conduct an informational meeting electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.2
10/06/2016Service Notice3
10/06/2016Administrative Law Judge Entry denying Duke's motion for waiver; electronically filed by Vesta R Miller on behalf of Jeffrey R. Jones, Administrative Law Judge, Ohio Power Siting Board.4
10/06/2016Correspondence from OPSB Executive Director Patrick Donlon regarding public information meetings pursuant to Ohio Adm.Code 4906-3-03(B) electronically filed by Mr. Matt Butler on behalf of Staff of OPSB.3
10/05/2016Reply of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., to Memoranda Contra Motion for Waiver electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.6
09/29/2016Correspondence Letter from the United States Department of the Interior, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.29
09/28/2016Memorandum Contra to the Motion for Waiver by Duke Energy electronically filed by James Yskamp on behalf of NOPE - Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC.9
09/28/2016Memorandum Contra to Duke's Motion for Waiver electronically filed by Mr. Brian W. Fox on behalf of City of Madeira by Mayor Melisa Adrien.4
09/28/2016Notice of Intervention electronically filed by Mr. Brian W. Fox on behalf of City of Madeira by Mayor Melisa Adrien.5
09/28/2016Petition for Leave to Intervene of NOPE - Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC electronically filed by James Yskamp on behalf of NOPE - Neighbors Opposed to Pipeline Extension, LLC.9
09/13/2016Application - Duke Energy Ohio (Part 7 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.11
09/13/2016Application Duke Energy Ohio (Part 6 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.67
09/13/2016Application Duke Energy Ohio (Part 5 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.19
09/13/2016Application Duke Energy Ohio (Part 4 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.52
09/13/2016Application Duke Energy Ohio (Part 3 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.50
09/13/2016Application Duke Energy Ohio (Part 2 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.13
09/13/2016Application of Duke Energy Ohio (Part 1 of 7) C314V Central Corridor Pipeline Extension Project electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.96
09/13/2016Motion for Waiver by Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.6
07/05/2016Proof of Pub 16-0253-GA-BTX - Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. proof of publication electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Kingery, Jeanne W and Spiller, Amy B.4
06/16/2016Correspondence including copies of letters to property owners and residents regarding the Central Corridor Extension Project. electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Kingery, Jeanne W and Spiller, Amy B.8
04/04/2016Proof of Pub Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.'s Proof of Publication electronically filed by Mrs. Adele M. Frisch on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. and Spiller, Amy B and Kingery, Jeanne W.4
03/29/2016Correspondence electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms.2
03/08/2016In the matter of the Pre-Application Notification Letter electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Kingery, Jeanne W Ms. and Duke Energy.3