DIS - Case Record for 15-0245-EL-CSS Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 15-0245-EL-CSS
CASE DESCRIPTION: Karl Friederich Jentgen, et al. v. Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 5/2/2024
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
03/06/2019 Case Action Form closing cases with an effective date of 3/6/2019.
12/07/2016 Service Notice
12/07/2016 Entry on rehearing stating that the application for rehearing filed by the Jentgens be denied.
06/08/2016 Service Notice
06/08/2016 Entry on Rehearing ordering that the application for rehearing filed by the Jentgens be granted for further consideration of the matters specified in the application for rehearing.
06/08/2016 Updated journal date on Entry on Rehearing ordering that the application for rehearing filed by the Jentgens be granted for further consideration of the matters specified in the application for rehearing.
05/23/2016 Memorandum Contra of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated to Complainants' Application for Rehearing] electronically filed by Jeremy S. Young on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
05/13/2016 App for Rehearing electronically filed by Mr. Martin N Baba on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich Mr. and Jentgen, Jeffrey Joseph Mr. and Coker, Lisa Ann Mrs. and Jentgen, Michael Mohr Mr. and Jentgen, Philip John Mr. and Jentgen, Kristin Ann Ms. and Jentgen, James J. Mr.
05/13/2016 Notice of Appearance of Legal Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Martin N Baba on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich Mr. and Jentgen, Jeffrey Joseph Mr. and Coker, Lisa Ann Mrs. and Jentgen, Michael Mohr Mr. and Jentgen, Philip John Mr. and Jentgen, Kristin Ann Ms. and Jentgen, James J. Mr.
04/14/2016 Service Notice
04/14/2016 Opinion and Order stating the Jentgens filed a complaint against Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Inc., on January 30, 2015, contesting Ohio Edison Company's and American Transmission Systems, Inc.'s planned removal of trees and shrubs located on the Jentgens' property.
12/14/2015 Service Notice
12/14/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry ordering the Amended Stipulation of the signatory parties be adopted and the Stay issued on 02/11/2015 be modified to incorporate the terms of the Amended Stipulation and that the parties take all necessary steps to carry out the terms of the Stipulation - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
12/11/2015 Reply Respondents Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems Incorporated's Reply to Complainants' Post Hearing Brief electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
12/11/2015 Reply Brief of Complainants electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Thomas O'Brien.
12/11/2015 Notice of Appearance of Counsel on behalf of Complainants electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Thomas O'Brien.
11/30/2015 Amended Stipulation and Agreement electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
11/20/2015 Complainant's Post-Hearing Brief by Daniel Bindau on behalf of Complainants.
11/20/2015 Post-Hearing Brief of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated] electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/30/2015 Stipulation and agreement electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/23/2015 Confidential Document Target for exhibit filed by Armstrong and Okey on behalf of Ohio Edison and American Transmission Systems, Inc. (4 pages)
10/23/2015 List of exhibits filed by Armstrong and Okey on behalf of PUCO.
10/23/2015 Confidential Document Target for Transcript filed by Armstrong & Okey, Inc. on behalf of Ohio Edison and American Transmission Systems, Inc. (7 pages)
10/23/2015 PUCO exhibits filing for transcript submitted on 10/20/15..
10/23/2015 Transcript in the matter of Karl Friederich Jentgen vs. Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Inc. hearing held on 10/20/15 electronically filed by Mr. Ken Spencer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. and Ross, Carolyn D.
10/22/2015 Deposition (originally filed 10/20/2015) electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich and JENTGEN, JEFFREY JOSEPH (RETURNED MAIL) and COKER, LISA ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, KRISTIN ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, MICHAEL MOHR electronically filed by Ms. Donielle M Hunter on behalf of PUCO.
10/20/2015 Deposition Deposition of Katherine Bloss (05.15.13) electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich and JENTGEN, JEFFREY JOSEPH (RETURNED MAIL) and COKER, LISA ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, KRISTIN ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, MICHAEL MOHR (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, PHILIP JOHN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, JAMES J. (RETURNED MAIL).
10/20/2015 Deposition Deposition of Pat Failor (09.24.15) electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich and JENTGEN, JEFFREY JOSEPH (RETURNED MAIL) and COKER, LISA ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, KRISTIN ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, MICHAEL MOHR (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, PHILIP JOHN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, JAMES J. (RETURNED MAIL).
10/20/2015 Deposition Deposition of Pat Failor (09.26.13) electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich and JENTGEN, JEFFREY JOSEPH (RETURNED MAIL) and COKER, LISA ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, KRISTIN ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, MICHAEL MOHR (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, PHILIP JOHN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, JAMES J. (RETURNED MAIL).
10/19/2015 Deposition of Adrian Melendez electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Philip John (Returned mail) and Jentgen, James J. (Returned mail) and Jentgen, Karl Friederich and Jentgen, Jeffrey Joseph (Returned mail) and Coker, Lisa Ann (Returned mail) and Jentgen, Kristin Ann (Returned mail) and Jentgen, Michael Mohr (Returned mail)
10/16/2015 Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated's Memorandum in Opposition to Complainants' Motion in Limine electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/15/2015 Motion to Accept Adrian Melendez's Affidavit in Lieu of Testimony and Request for Expedited Hearing and Memorandum in Support filed by D. Binau on behalf of Complainants.
10/14/2015 Motion to Compel Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling and Memorandum in Support filed by D. Binau on behalf of Complainants.
10/13/2015 Motion in Limine, Request for Expedited Ruling and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of JENTGEN, PHILIP JOHN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, JAMES J. (RETURNED MAIL) and Jentgen, Karl Friederich and JENTGEN, JEFFREY JOSEPH (RETURNED MAIL) and COKER, LISA ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, KRISTIN ANN (RETURNED MAIL) and JENTGEN, MICHAEL MOHR (RETURNED MAIL)
10/06/2015 Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum of Chris D. Ahlum electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/05/2015 Motion for Subpoena filed by D. Binau on behalf of Complainants
10/01/2015 Direct Testimony of Stephen Cieslewicz on Behalf of the Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/01/2015 Direct Testimony of David Kozy, P.E. on Behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/01/2015 Direct Testimony of Patrick Failor on Behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/01/2015 Direct Testimony of Katherine M. Bloss on Behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
10/01/2015 Testimony of Chris D. Ahlum on behalf of complainants. (part 2 of 2)
10/01/2015 Testimony of Chris D. Ahlum. (Section 2 of 2) rescanned for better image quality.
10/01/2015 Testimony of Chris D. Ahlum on behalf of complainants (part 2 of 2).
10/01/2015 Testimony of Chris D. Ahlum on behalf of Complainants. (part 1 of 2)
09/18/2015 Service Notice
09/16/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry granting the motion for a continuance and scheduling this matter for hearing on 10/20/2015. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
09/15/2015 Response [Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated's Memorandum in Opposition to Complainants' Motion to Continue Hearing] electronically filed by Jeremy S. Young on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated
09/14/2015 Notice to Take Deposition of Steve Ciewselwicz electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich.
09/11/2015 Motion to Continue Hearing and Request for Expedited Ruling electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich.
07/28/2015 Notice of Deposition of Karl Jentgen electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.
07/17/2015 Service Notice
07/16/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry granting the partial motion to dismiss and scheduling this matter for hearing on 09/29/2015. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
07/16/2015 Service Notice
04/08/2015 Return mail.
03/13/2015 Reply to Complainants' Memorandum in Opposition to Respondents' Partial Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
03/13/2015 Service Notice
03/13/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry adopting the Stipulation and scheduling a settlement conference for 04/21/2015 at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad St., 12th Flr., Rm. 1247, Columbus, Ohio. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
03/06/2015 Stipulation and Agreement electronically filed by Jeremy S. Young on behalf of FirstEnergy Corporation.
03/06/2015 Complainants' Memorandum in Opposition to Respondents' (sic) Partial Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Philip John (RETURNED MAIL) and Jentgen, James J. (RETURNED MAIL) and Jentgen, Karl Friederich and Jentgen, Jeffrey Joseph (RETURNED MAIL) and Coker, Lisa Ann (RETURNED MAIL) and Jentgen, Kristin Ann (RETURNED MAIL) and Jentgen, Michael Mohr (RETURNED MAIL).
03/04/2015 Returned mail
03/02/2015 Notification of progress electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Jentgen, Karl Friederich and Jentgen, Philip John and Jentgen, James J. and Jentgen, Jeffrey Joseph and Cooker, Lisa Ann and Jentgen, Kristan Ann and Jentgen, Michael Mohr.
02/20/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry giving Complainants until 02/26/2015 to file a memorandum contra to the motion to lift the stay. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
02/20/2015 Service Notice
02/19/2015 Respondents' Partial Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
02/19/2015 Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated's Motion to Lift Stay electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
02/19/2015 Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated's Answer to the Complaint electronically filed by Mrs. Denise M. Hasbrook on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.
02/11/2015 Service Notice
02/11/2015 Attorney Examiner Entry granting the Complainants' request for an order staying removal of vegetation in accordance with Finding (3). - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
02/09/2015 Opposition to Complainants' Request for Emergency Order Preserving Status Quo electronically filed by Ms. Carrie M Dunn on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated.
02/02/2015 Complaint response letter and copy of brochure mailed to complainants', Mr. Jentgen, et al., c/o Mr. Binau.
02/02/2015 Complaint service letter and copy of complaint mailed to: Ohio Edison Leila Vespoli.
01/30/2015 In The Matter of the Complaint of Karl Friederich Jentgen, et al. v. Ohio Edison Company and American Transmission Systems, Incorporated electronically filed by Mr. Dan J. Binau on behalf of Karl Friederich Jentgen and Jeffrey Joseph Jentgen and Lisa Ann Coker and Kristin Ann Jentgen and Michael Mohr Jentgen and Philip John Jentgen and James J. Jentgen