Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 14-1610-EL-CSS
CASE DESCRIPTION: Carbo Forge, Inc., et al. vs FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 10/14/2019
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
12/27/2018 Case Action Form closing cases with an effective date of 12/27/18 electronically filed by Ms. Mary E. Fischer on behalf of Megan J. Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
12/15/2016 Service Notice
12/14/2016 Entry ordering that the joint request to dismiss this case be granted and this case be dismissed and closed of record.
12/12/2016 Notice of Substitution of Counsel and adding James Perko electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of multiple.
11/03/2016 Joint Motion of Dismissal electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. and Carbo Forge, Inc. and Wyandot, Inc., et al.
10/05/2016 Notice Withdrawal of Counsel electronically filed by Debra A Gaunder on behalf of Various Parties.
09/12/2016 Motion (Joint) for Continuance electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. and Carbo Forge, Inc. and Wyandot, Inc., et al.
08/22/2016 Notice Of Appearance And Substitution Of Counsel Of Complainants electronically filed by Debra A Gaunder on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc. et al.
08/18/2016 Complainants' Notice Of Deposition To FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A Smith on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc.
08/18/2016 Complainants' Notice of Deposition to FirstEnergy Solutions Corp electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A Smith on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed to Sun Chemical Corporation electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To Jay Industries, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To Mantaline Corporation electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To American Trim, LLC electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To McWane, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To Plaskolite, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To McDonald Steel Corporation electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed To Sauder Woodworking Co. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed to Henny Penny Corporation electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed to Carbo Forge, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed to Wyandot, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
08/16/2016 Notice of Deposition Directed to 3M Company electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
06/17/2016 Service Notice
06/17/2016 Attorney Examiner Entry scheduling a hearing for 09/13/2016 at 10:00 a.m. at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad St., Rm. 11-A, Columbus, Ohio. - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Bryce McKenney, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio
01/06/2016 Service Notice
01/06/2016 Entry ordering that FES' motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction be denied as set forth in finding (13); that complainants motion for assistance to prevent termination of service should be granted as set forth in finding (16).
10/02/2015 Notice Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Danielle M. Ghiloni on behalf of OMAEG and Trebel, LLC and EMC Development Company and MP2 Energy NE, LLC and Time Warner Cable Information Services (Ohio) and Time Warner Cable Business.
11/13/2014 Letter regarding complaint case filed by Peter Yuen on behalf of Noble Americas Energy Solutions, LLC.
10/14/2014 Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Mr. James F Lang on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
10/06/2014 Memorandum Contra FirstEnergy Solutions' Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Ms. Rebecca L. Hussey on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc., et al.
10/06/2014 Answer electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
09/23/2014 Correspondence in reference to Carbo Forge, Inc. et al. v. FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. electronically filed by Mr. Steven T Nourse on behalf of Ohio Power Company.
09/22/2014 Duke Energy Ohio's Comments regarding FES Motion to Dismiss electronically filed by Brenda S. Carnahan on behalf of Spiller, Amy B. and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
09/19/2014 Motion to Dismiss and memorandum in support electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
09/19/2014 Memorandum In Opposition To Motion For Assistance electronically filed by Mr. Nathaniel Trevor Alexander on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
09/15/2014 Complaint response letter and copy of brochure mailed to: Rebecca L. Hussey, attorney for complainants.
09/15/2014 Complaint service letter and copy of complaint mailed to: Mark A. Hayden ,FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.
09/12/2014 Confidential document target: Complaint and relief filed by K. Bojko on behalf of complainants. (372 pages)
09/12/2014 Motion and memorandum in support for Assistance to Prevent Termination of Service, Request for Relief, and Request for Expedited Ruling electronically filed by Ms. Rebecca L Hussey on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc., Wyandot, Inc., Plaskolite, Inc., American Trim, LLC., Whirlpool Corporation, Mcwane, Inc., Navistar Inc., Sauder Woodworking Company, McDonald Steel Corporation, Henny Penny Corporation, Lima Refining Company, Campbell Soup Supply Company, LLC., Cooper Tire and Rubber Company, Mantaline Corporation, Republic Steel, Jay Industries, Inc., Sun Chemical Corporation, and 3M Company.
09/12/2014 Motion for Protective Order and memorandum in support electronically filed by Ms. Rebecca L Hussey on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc., Wyandot, Inc., Plaskolite, Inc., American Trim, LLC., Whirlpool Corporation, Mcwane, Inc., Navistar Inc., Sauder Woodworking Company, McDonald Steel Corporation, Henny Penny Corporation, Lima Refining Company, Campbell Soup Supply Company, LLC., Cooper Tire and Rubber Company, Mantaline Corporation, Republic Steel, Jay Industries, Inc., Sun Chemical Corporation, and 3M Company.
09/12/2014 In the Matter of the Complaint of Carbo Forge, Inc. Wyandot, Inc. Plaskolite, Inc., American Trim, LLC, Whirlpool Corporation, McWane, Inc. Navistar, Inc. Sauder WoodWorking Co., McDonald Steel Corporation, Henny Penny Corporation, Lima Refining Company, Campbell Soup Supply Company, LLC, Cooper Tire & Rubber Company, Mantaline Corporation, Republic Steel, Jay Industries, Inc., Sun Chemical Corporation and 3M Company vs FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. for the alleged anticompetitive or unfair, deceptive, or unconscionable act or practices in this state electronically filed by Ms. Rebecca L. Hussey on behalf of Carbo Forge, Inc., et al.