Skip to main content
      
      
CASE NUMBER: 09-0512-GE-UNC
CASE DESCRIPTION: IN THE MATTER OF THE PROTOCOLS FOR THE MEASUREMENT AND VERIFICATION OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND PEAK DEMAND REDUCTION MEASURES
DOCUMENT SIGNED ON: 12/6/2019
DATE OF SERVICE: ________________________________________
01/07/2019 Case Action Form closing case with an effective date of 1/7/2019 electronically filed by Docketing Staff on behalf of Docketing.
01/07/2019 Ohio Energy Efficiency Technical Reference Manual prepared by Vermont Energy Investment Corporation electronically filed by Docketing Staff on behalf of Docketing.
01/07/2019 Case action form to reopen case as of 1/7/2019 electronically filed by Docketing Staff on behalf of Docketing.
02/15/2017 Case Action Form closing case effective 2/15/207 filed by S. Parrot.
05/12/2016 Notice of Withdraw and Substitution of Counsel of Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Matthew W. Warnock.
09/03/2014 Notice of Substitution of Counsel of Joel Sechler for Mallory Mohler electronically filed by Ms. Cheryl A. Smith on behalf of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association.
03/28/2014 Notice of withdrawal of Joseph E. Oliker filed by F. Darr on behalf of McNees, Wallace & Nurick LLC.
01/28/2014 Notice of withdrawal of counsel of Nolan Moser and substitution of counsel of record of Trent A. Dougherty filed by N. Moser on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council
10/15/2013 Notice of substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly W. Bojko on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association.
10/15/2013 Notice of withdrawal electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of J. Thomas Siwo, Bricker & Eckler LLP.
07/31/2013 Service Notice
07/31/2013 Entry ordering the applications for rehearing filed by IEU-Ohio and FirstEnergy be denied in their entirety; OCC's motion to intervene be granted; PWC's motion for leave to file its TRM proposal be granted; OPAE's motion for the pro hac vice admission of Robert Kelter be granted; the TRM filed by VEIC be updated by Staff and the Independent Program Evaluator and filed for Commission approval in a new docket.
04/18/2012 Notice of withdrawal of counsel and designation of counsel of record by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Patti Mallarnee on behalf of Serio, Joseph P.
02/03/2012 Letter stating of a change of address and firm affiliation for Mark A. Whitt, Christopher T. Kennedy and Melissa L. Thompson for each of the above referenced cases filed by M. Whitt.
12/07/2011 Public Comment Response regarding concerns about FirstEnergy's Energy Efficiency Incentives Program filed by Staff.
12/07/2011 Public Comment in regard to FirstEnergy's alleged behavior by concerned consumer Byron Lewis of BML Building Maintenance, LLC.
05/05/2011 Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Richard Reese filed on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Small.
04/14/2011 Notice of withdrawal of William T. Reisinger as counsel in the proceeding listed, Nolan Moser should be designated counsel of record filed by N. Moser on behalf of the Ohio Environmental Council.
03/09/2011 Notice of withdrawal of counsel Todd Williams on behalf of Ohio Environmental Council filed by W. Reisinger.
02/16/2011 Correspondence from Evergreen Economics requesting contracts with ECONorthwest be modified to reflect changes in key project personnel. electronically filed by Mr. Paul A. Laurent on behalf of PUCO.
02/16/2011 Correspondence from ECONorthwest notifying Staff of changes in key project personnel electronically filed by Mr. Paul A. Laurent on behalf of PUCO.
01/10/2011 Letter asking to be added to the service list filed by P. Deverakonda.
11/16/2010 Joint reply comments regarding the August 6, 2010, draft technical reference manual from Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, The Toledo Edison Company, Columbus Southern Power Company, Ohio Power Company, Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. The Dayton Power and Light Company and Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by C. Dunn.
11/16/2010 Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Joseph M. Clark in these proceedings filed by McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC by J. Oliker.
11/15/2010 Joint Reply Comments regarding the August 6,2010 Technical Reference Manual from Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, The Toledo Edison Company, Columbus Southern Power Company, Ohio Power Company, Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., The Dayton Power and Light Company and Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by C. Dunn. (FAX)
11/15/2010 Reply Comments of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy electronically filed by Mr. David C Rinebolt.
11/15/2010 Reply comments on draft technical reference manual by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, Citizens' Coalition, Citizen Power, Sierra Club of Ohio, The Natural Resources Defense Council, and The Ohio Environmental Council filed by OCC.
11/15/2010 Reply from Vermont Energy Investment Corporation to joint objections and comments to the August 6, 2010 draft technical reference manual from Ohio Electric Distribution Utilities and IEU, Ohio Gas Utilities, Ohio Consumers Counsel and other advocacy groups, and Opower, Inc. filed by C. Jenkins. (Part 1 of 3).
11/15/2010 Reply continued (Part 2 of 3).
11/15/2010 Reply continued (Part 3 of 3).
11/04/2010 Objections to the draft of technical reference manual filed by M. Sachse on behalf of OPOWER INC.
11/03/2010 Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's comments on the August 6, 2010 draft Technical Reference Manual, filed by S. Randazzo.
11/03/2010 Gas utilities joint comments and objections regarding draft Technical Reference Manual, filed by S. Seiple on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., M. Whitt on behalf of Dominion East Ohio and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
11/03/2010 OPower, Inc. objections to the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio with respect to the draft Technical Reference Manual, filed by M. Sachse. (FAX)
11/03/2010 Correspondence letter informing the Commission that OPAE will not file initial comments, electronically filed by Mr. David C Rinebolt on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.
11/03/2010 Joint objections of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association and The Ohio Hospital Association, electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association and Ohio Hospital Association.
11/03/2010 Comments on draft technical reference manual by the OCC, Citizen's Coalition, Ohio Poverty Law Center, Citizen Power, Sierra Club of Ohio, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Ohio Envornmental Council, filed by R. Reese on behalf of the OCC, J. Meissner on behalf of Citizens Coalition, M. Smalz on behalf of Ohio Poverty Law Center, T. Robinson on behalf of Citizen Power, H. Eckhart on behalf of Sierra Club Ohio Chapter and Natural Resources Defense Council, N. Moser on behalf of the OEC.
11/03/2010 Joint objections and comments to the August 6, 2010 draft Technical Reference Manual from Ohio Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, Toledo Edison Company, Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., Dayton Power and Light Company, and Industrial Energy Users-Ohio, filed by C. M. Dunn on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Toledo Edison Company, E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., J. Sobecki on behalf of Dayton Power and Light Company, M. Satterwhite on behalf of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company, S. Randazzo on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
10/29/2010 Notice of withdrawal and substitution of counsel for Dominion East Ohio, filed by P. Colbert on behalf of East Ohio Gas Company d/b/a Dominion East Ohio.
10/13/2010 Memorandum contra application for rehearing filed by J. Small on behalf of OCC.
10/06/2010 Notice of withdrawal of counsel, L. McAlister, filed on behalf of McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC by J. Clark.
10/05/2010 Application for rehearing and memorandum in support of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by S. Randazzo.
10/04/2010 Service Notice
10/04/2010 Entry ordering that interested stakeholders may file consensus filings and objections and replies as set forth in this entry.
08/26/2010 Motion to Admit Robert Kelter to Practice Pro Hac Vice Before the Commission and Notice of Substitution of Counsel electronically filed by Mr. Michael E Heintz on behalf of Environmental Law and Policy Center.
08/06/2010 Report, Draft Energy Efficiency Technical Reference Manual. electronically filed by Mr. Paul A. Laurent on behalf of PUCO.
07/29/2010 Service Notice
07/29/2010 Entry on rehearing ordered that the applications for rehearing filed by IEU-Ohio and FirstEnergy be granted.
07/29/2010 Entry ordered that this matter be scheduled for a workshop on August 10, 2010 at 1:00 p.m. at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th floor, Hearing Room 11-B, Columbus, Ohio, 43215; that staff distribute the draft TRM to parties of record by August 6, 2010. (RLS)
07/26/2010 Memorandum contra application for rehearing of the FirstEnergy Companies filed by J. Small on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
07/19/2010 Application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company for rehearing and memorandum in support filed by K. Kolich.
07/16/2010 Application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company for rehearing and memorandum in support filed by K. Kolich (FAX)
07/16/2010 Application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company for rehearing filed by K. Kolich.
07/12/2010 Memorandum contra application for rehearing filed by J. Small on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.
07/02/2010 Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed by S. Randazzo on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
06/16/2010 Service Notice
06/16/2010 Entry ordering the applications for rehearing filed by FirstEnergy, IEU-Ohio and OCC be denied.
04/28/2010 Service Notice
04/28/2010 Entry ordering that VEIC be authorized to proceed with Phases 3 and 4 of the project as set forth in finding (9).
03/17/2010 Service Notice
03/17/2010 Entry ordering that ECONorthwest be selected to perform the consulting activities set forth in this order; the electric utilities and ECONorthwest observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
03/12/2010 Motion of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy to Amend Comments Filed on July 24, 2009, and Amended Comments electronically filed by Mr. David C Rinebolt on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy
02/25/2010 Service Notice.
02/25/2010 Entry ordering that this matter be scheduled for a workshop on March 16, 2010, at 1:00 p.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th floor, hearing room 11-B, Columbus, Ohio 43215. (RLH)
02/09/2010 Reply to the Office of Consumers' Counsel regarding proposal of People Working Cooperatively, INC, filed by M. Christensen on behalf of People Working Cooperatively, INC.
02/03/2010 Service Notice
02/03/2010 Entry ordering that VEIC observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
02/01/2010 Memorandum contra People Working Cooperatively's motion for leave to submit a proposal filed by J. Small on behalf of OCC.
01/27/2010 Service Notice
01/27/2010 Entry ordering that the Staff issue a Request for Proposals, evaluate all responses received, and negotiate the detailed scope of work and pricing plan; the electric utilities, gas utilities, and Evaluator shall observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
01/15/2010 Motion for leave to submit a proposal to the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio and a memorandum in support. Filed by M. Christensen on behalf of People Working Cooperatively, Inc.
12/11/2009 Service Notice.
12/11/2009 Entry on rehearing ordering that the applications for rehearing filed by FirstEnergy, Industrial Energy Users-Ohio and the Ohio Consumers' Counsel be granted.
11/25/2009 Industrial Energy Users-Ohio memorandum contra application for rehearing of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by J. Clark.
11/16/2009 Application for rehearing of entry dated October 19, 2009 regarding protocols for the measurement and verification of energy efficiency and peak demand reduction measures by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Small.
11/16/2009 Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed by J. Clark on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
11/13/2009 Proposed predetermined values and protocols of the East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. filed by P. Colbert, E. Gallon, M. Whitt, E. Watts.
11/13/2009 Application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company for rehearing, memorandum in support filed by K. Kolich.
11/12/2009 Comments of the Dayton Power and Light Company filed by R. Griffin. (original)
11/10/2009 Comments to Appendix C, electronically filed by Ms. Ebony L Miller on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, The Toledo Edison Company.
11/10/2009 Comments concerning policy issues regarding cost and avoided cost for the total resource cost test in Ohio electricity programs submitted by Duke Energy Ohio, Inc., electronically filed by Carys Cochern on behalf of Watts, Elizabeth H.
11/10/2009 Comments of the Ohio Manufacturers' Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood.
11/10/2009 Comments on appendix C filed by M. Resnik on behalf of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company .
11/10/2009 Comments regarding appendix C of the Ohio Technical Reference Manual and the entry dated October 15, 2009 by J. Small on behalf of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel , A. Moore on behalf of Environment Ohio, N. Moser on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council, T. Robinson on behalf of Citizen Power, M. Heintz on behalf of Environmental Law & Policy Center, and H. Eckhart on behalf of The Sierra Club Ohio Chapter and Natural Resources Defense Council.
11/10/2009 Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company on Appendix C filed by R. Griffin. (FAX)
11/10/2009 Comments of the Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by J. Clark.
10/15/2009 Joint Proposed Protocols for the Measurement and Verification of Energy Efficiency and Peak Demand Reduction Measures, electronically filed by Ms. Ebony L Miller on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, The Toledo Edison Company and Columbus Southern Power Company, Ohio Power Company and The Dayton Power and Light Company and Duke Energy Ohio.
10/15/2009 Service notice.
10/15/2009 Finding and ordering ordering that the gas and electric utilities observe the requirements and determinations set forth in this entry; that interested persons file comments on Appendix C no later than November 10, 2009; that the gas utilities motion for expedited consideration and an extension for filing of proposed values and protocols to November 15, 2009 be granted.
09/30/2009 Service Notice.
09/30/2009 Entry ordering that Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) be selected to perform the consulting activities set forth in this entry; that the electric and gas utilities and VEIC observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
09/17/2009 Motion for extension and memorandum in support of the East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. (Expedited Ruling Requested) electronically filed by Paul A Colbert on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
09/10/2009 Service Notice.
09/10/2009 Entry ordering that the electric utilities' joint motion for expedited consideration and a 30-day extension of time to file values and protocols be granted. (KB)
09/08/2009 Comments of The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc,. and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. electronically filed by Mr. Mark A Whitt on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. and The East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio and Duke Energy Ohio and Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.
09/03/2009 Joint motion of Electric Utilities for expedited consideration and for 30 day extension of time to file values and protocols filed by R. Griffin on behalf of The Dayton Power and Light Company.
09/02/2009 Joint motion of electric utilities for expedited consideration and for 30 day extension of time to file values and protocols filed by R. Griffin on behalf of The Dayton Power and Light Company. (FAX)
08/03/2009 Joint comments concerning proposed measures submitted by Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company; Ohio Edison Company, the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company; Duke Energy Ohio and Dayton Power and Light Company filed by S. Nourse on behalf of American Electric Power Service Corporation, K. Kolich on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company, A. Spiller on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio and R. Griffin on behalf of Dayton Power & Light Company.
07/31/2009 Service Notice.
07/31/2009 Notice of revised time and agenda for TRC Workshop to be held on Wednesday, August 5, 2009 at 10:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m. electronically filed by Richard M Bulgrin on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
07/30/2009 Notice of August 5, 2009 workshop electronically filed by Richard M Bulgrin on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.
07/29/2009 Signed certificate of service for the joint comments filed 7/24/09 filed by P. Colbert. (FAX)
07/27/2009 Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company on Appendix A of Commission entry, filed by R. Griffin.
07/27/2009 Comments of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company on Appendix A filed by K. Kolich.
07/24/2009 Joint comments of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association and The Ohio Hospital Association, electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association and Ohio Hospital Association.
07/24/2009 Comments regarding Appendix A to Entry dated June 24, 2009 by the Ohio Consumer and Environmental Advocates, filed by J. Small, Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, R. Stanfield, Natural Resources Defense Council, T. Robinson, Citizen Power, N. Moser, The Ohio Environmental Council, A. Gomberg, Environment Ohio, and N. Ford, Sierra Club Ohio Chapter.
07/24/2009 Joint comments regarding Appendix A to the Commission's June 24, 2009 Entry, electronically filed by Paul A. Colbert on behalf of The East Ohio Gas Company d/b/a Dominion East Ohio and Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. and Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc. and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
07/24/2009 Comments of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company on Appendix A filed by K. Kolich. (Fax)
07/24/2009 Comments of the Dayton Power and Light Company on Appendix A of Commission Entry, filed by R. Griffin. (Fax)
07/24/2009 Comments of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy regarding Appendix A of the entry of July 8, 2009, electronically filed by Mr. David C. Rinebolt.
07/24/2009 Comments of Duke Energy Ohio in response to Appendix A questions on policy issues that may affect the approach and scope of a technical reference manual filed by E. Watts.
07/24/2009 Industrial Energy Users-Ohio's comments on Appendix A filed by L. McAlister.
07/24/2009 Comments of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company filed by S. Nourse.
07/16/2009 Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company filed by R. Griffin. (original)
07/15/2009 Comments on Appendix B of the Commission's June 24, 2009 Entry electronically filed by Ms. Kathy J Kolich on behalf of Ohio Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.
07/15/2009 Motion and memorandum in support to intervene and comments filed by J. Small on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumer's Counsel.
07/15/2009 Initial Comments of the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Mr. Nolan M Moser on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council.
07/15/2009 Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company filed by R. Griffin. (FAX)
07/15/2009 Service Notice.
07/15/2009 Joint comments of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association and The Ohio Hospital Association electronically filed by Teresa Orahood on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Association and Ohio Hospital Association and T. O'Brien.
07/15/2009 Comments on Appendix B filed by L. McAlister on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.
07/15/2009 Comments of Duke Energy Ohio to Appendix B questions on policy issues that may affect the approach and scope of a technical reference manual filed by E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio.
07/15/2009 Initial Comments of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company filed by M. Resnik.
07/15/2009 Joint comments regarding Appendix B filed by G. Garber on behalf of East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio, E.Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., M. Whitt on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc., and E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
07/15/2009 Comments of the Ohio Department of Development regarding the June 24, 2009 entry, Appendix B filed by C. Jones and J. Stoneking.
07/14/2009 Service Notice.
07/14/2009 Entry ordering that the gas utilities' motion be granted in part and denied in part as set forth in this entry. (PD)
07/10/2009 Motion for extension and memorandum in support filed by P. Colbert on behalf of East Ohio Gas Company dba Dominion East Ohio; E. Gallon on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.; M. Whitt on behalf of Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, Inc.; E. Watts on behalf of Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
07/08/2009 Entry ordering that the Commission's staff shall issue a request for proposal, evaluate all responses received and negotiate the detailed scope of work and pricing plan; the electric utilities, gas utilities, and the consultant shall observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
07/08/2009 Service Notice
06/24/2009 Service Notice
06/24/2009 Entry ordering that the electric and gas utilities shall observe the requirements set forth in this entry.
06/16/2009 In the matter of protocols for the measurement and verification of energy and peak demand reduction measures.