|
04/20/2018
|
Case action form closing case(s) effective 04/20/2018 - electronically filed by Sandra Coffey on behalf of Megan Addison, Attorney Examiner, Public Utilities Commission of Ohio. |
|
12/22/2011
|
Supreme Court Document The following decision, announcement or notice of action by the Supreme Court of Ohio with respect to this case is provided solely for the information and convenience of the reader, and should not be construed as a part of the record of this case before the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, and may be subject to formal revision before it is published in the Ohio Official Reports. The Court’s opinions from 1992 to the present are available online from the Reporter of Decisions at http://www.sconet.state.oh.us/ROD/ - Slip Opinion (Aug. 25, 2011) [Cite as Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialties, L.L.C. v. Pub. Util. Comm., 129 Ohio St.3d 485,
2011-Ohio-4189.] electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio |
|
07/13/2009
|
Supreme Court Transmittal papers filed. (S.C. No. 09-1065) |
|
07/13/2009
|
Service Notice. |
|
07/02/2009
|
Joint motion to consolidate appeals filed by C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc.; by M. Dortch on behalf of Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialties, LLC; by T. O'Brien on behalf of Worthington Industries and Brush Wellman; by M. Hayden and J. Lang on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company; by S. Parrot on behalf of PUCO; by D. Grodhaus on behalf of The Calphalon Corporation. |
|
06/12/2009
|
Notice of appeal of appellant The Calphalon Corporation filed by D. Michael Grodhaus. (09-1065) |
|
04/15/2009
|
Service notice. |
|
04/15/2009
|
Entry ordering the complainants' joint application for rehearing be denied. Concurring opinion of Commissioner Paul A. Centolella. |
|
03/30/2009
|
Respondent's memorandum in opposition to complainants' joint application for rehearing filed by J. Lang on behalf of the Toledo Edison Company. |
|
03/20/2009
|
Complainants' joint application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Worthington Industries and Brush Wellman, Inc. by T. O'Brien, on behalf of Calphalon Corporation by D. Grodhaus, on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc. by C. Smith and on behalf of Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialty Materials, LLC by M. Dortch. |
|
02/19/2009
|
Service notice. |
|
02/19/2009
|
Opinion and order that this case be dismissed. |
|
09/26/2008
|
Reply brief of respondent, The Toledo Edison Company filed by J. Lang. |
|
09/26/2008
|
Joint reply of complainants filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Worthington Industries, Brush Willman, Inc. and Pilkington North America, Inc; D. Grodhaus on behalf of Calphalon Corporation; C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc.; and M. Dortch on behalf of Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialty Materials, LLC. |
|
09/24/2008
|
Service Notice |
|
09/24/2008
|
Entry ordered that the deadline for the filing of the reply briefs in this matters be extended to September 26, 2008. (CP) |
|
08/26/2008
|
Joint post hearing brief of the complainants filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Worthington Industries, Brush Wellman, Inc. and Pilkington North America, Inc.; by D. Grodhaus on behalf of The Calphalon Corporation; by C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc.; by M. Dortch on behalf of Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialty Materials, LLC. |
|
08/26/2008
|
Brief of Respondent, The Toledo Edison Company, filed by J. Lang. |
|
08/06/2008
|
Exhibits submitted for electronically filed transcript that was held on Wednesday, July 23, 2008 before Christine Pirik, Hearing Examiner. |
|
08/06/2008
|
Transcript of hearing held July 23, 2008 before Attorney Examiner C. Pirik, electronically filed by Mrs. Jennifer D. Duffer on behalf of Armstrong & Okey, Inc. |
|
07/23/2008
|
Joint stipulation of facts by and between Martin Marietta Magnesia Specialties, LLC filed by M. Dortch and The Toledo Edison Company filed by M. Hayden. |
|
07/21/2008
|
Motion to strike testimony of Anthony J. Yankel and memorandum in support filed by M. Hayden on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company. |
|
07/17/2008
|
Motion to consolidate plaintiff Martin Marietta Materials,LLC, case with cases involving common questions of law and fact currently pending before the Commission and memorandum in support filed by M.D. Dortch on behalf of complainant. |
|
06/27/2008
|
Service Notice. |
|
06/26/2008
|
Entry ordering that a hearing be scheduled for July 23, 2008, at 9:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th floor, hearing room C, Columbus, Ohio 43215 and that the parties comply with finding (6) regarding the burden of proof. (CMTP) |
|
06/19/2008
|
Letter stating that it serves as an erratum to the direct testimony of Paul Marusiak submitted on June 17, 2008 filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Complainant, Worthington Industries. |
|
06/18/2008
|
Direct testimony of Kevin L. Norris on behalf of Toledo Edison Company. (Original) |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of Steve Willer, C.P.M. filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Complainant, Brush Wellman, Inc. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of Paul Marusiak filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Complainant, Worthington Industries. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of William J. Wolter filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Complainant, Pilkington North America, Inc. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of Anthony J. Yankel filed by C. Smith on behalf of Worthington Industries, the Calphalon Corporation, Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Brush Wellman, Inc. and Pilkington North America, Inc. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of William K. Eddy filed by C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of Richard R Leggett filed G. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc. |
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of Kevin L. Norris on behalf of Toledo Edison Company. (FAX) |
|
06/17/2008
|
Joint stipulation of facts filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of Worthington
Industries, Brush Wellman, Inc., and Pilkington North America, Inc., by D. Grodhaus on behalf of Calphalon Corporation, by C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc., by M. Hayden on behalf of FirstEnergy Service Company.
|
|
06/17/2008
|
Direct testimony of David Buehler filed by D. Grodhaus on behalf of Calphalon Corporation. |
|
05/29/2008
|
Entry ordered that the parties' second joint motion to extend the date to file stipulations, and direct expert and non-expert testimony to June 17, 2008, be granted. (CP) |
|
05/29/2008
|
Service Notice |
|
05/23/2008
|
Second joint motion and memorandum in support to extend the date to file stipulations and expert testimony by the Consolidated Complainants-Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Worthington Industries, Brush Wellman Inc., Pilkington North America, Inc., The Calphalon Corporation, and by respondent-The Toledo Edison Company filed by C. Smith on behalf of Kraft Foods, T. O'Brien on behalf of Worthington Industries, Brush Wellman, Inc. and Pilkington North America, Inc., M. Hayden on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company and D. Grodhaus on behalf of The Calphalon Corporation. |
|
05/09/2008
|
Entry ordering the parties' joint motion to extend the date to file stipulations, and direct expert and non-expert testimony to June 3, 2008, be granted. (CP) |
|
05/09/2008
|
Service notice. |
|
05/01/2008
|
Revised notice to Toledo Edison Company to take deposition upon oral examination and request for production of documents by Kraft Global, Inc. (Kraft Foods) filed by C. Smith, (original) |
|
04/30/2008
|
Revised notice of deposition by Kraft Foods to Toledo Edison filed by C. Smith. (FAX) |
|
04/30/2008
|
Joint motion and memorandum in support to extend the date to file stipulations and expert testimony by the consolidated complainants-Kraft Foods Global, Inc., Worthington Industries, Brush Wellman Inc, Pilkington North America, Inc.,The Calphalon Corporation-and by respondent, the Toledo Edison Company filed by C. Smith, T. O'Brien, M. Hayden, and D. Michael Grodhaus. |
|
04/22/2008
|
Notice of deposition to Toledo Edison, the other parties and the Commission filed on behalf of Kraft Foods by C. Smith. |
|
04/21/2008
|
Notice to Toledo Edison Company to take depositions upon oral examination and request for production of documents under OAC 4901-1-16, OAC 4901-1-20 and OAC 4901-1-21 filed on behalf of Kraft Foods Global, Inc. by C. Smith. (FAX) |
|
04/07/2008
|
Entry ordering that the the amended complaints filed by Worthington and Calphalon are accepted; that the Brush Wellman, Pilkington, Worthington, Calaphon, and Kraft cases be consolidated; the parties adhere to the schedule and processes set forth in findings (10) and (11). (CP) |
|
04/07/2008
|
Service Notice |
|
04/03/2008
|
Answer filed on behalf of the Toledo Edison Company by M. Hayden. |
|
03/24/2008
|
First amended complaint filed on behalf of Calphalon vs Toledo Edison Company by M. Grodhaus. |
|
03/13/2008
|
Service notice. |
|
03/13/2008
|
Entry ordering a prehearing conference will be held on May 5, 2008 at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad Street, 11 th floor, hearing room F, Columbus, Oh. 43215. (CP) |
|
03/06/2008
|
Answer of The Toledo Edison Company filed by M. Hayden |
|
02/15/2008
|
Complaint response letter and copy of brochure mailed to: D. Michael Grodhaus, Attorney for complainant. |
|
02/15/2008
|
Complaint service letter and copy of complaint mailed to: Leila Vespoli, Toledo Edison Co. |
|
02/15/2008
|
In the matter of the complaint of the Calphalon Corporation vs. The Toledo Edison Company for the alleged unfair and unjust billing practices. |