Skip to main content

Case Record For:

07-0796-EL-ATA

File a Public Comment
Case Title: OHIO EDISON COMPANY/CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING COMPANY/TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY
Status: OPEN-OPEN
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: ATA-Application for tariff approval
Date Opened: 7/10/2007
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
06/08/2020Notice of withdrawal of Counsel Thomas W. McNamee electronically filed by Mrs. Kimberly M Naeder on behalf of PUCO.5
02/24/2020Notice of withdrawal of Counsel of Joseph P. Meissner and/or Matthew C. Vincel field by K. Hollingsworth on behalf of The Legal Aid Society of Cleveland.2
01/16/2020Notice of withdrawal of Colleen Mooney electronically filed by Colleen L Mooney on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.10
10/03/2019Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel and Designation of Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Matthew R. Pritchard on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.2
01/16/2019Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel for Samuel C. Randazzo and Designation of Counsel of Record electronically filed by Mr. Frank P. Darr on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.2
12/13/2017Notice of Change of Address by The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel electronically filed by Ms. Jamie Williams on behalf of Sauer, Larry Mr.3
05/03/2016Notice of Change of Address for counsel for the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, effective May 9, 2016. electronically filed by Kimberly L Keeton on behalf of Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.3
05/29/2015Notice of Change in Contact Information for Michael K. Lavanga, Counsel for Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.2
05/29/2015Notice of Change in Contact Information for Garrett A Stone, Counsel for Nucor Steel Marion, Inc. filed by M. Lavanga.2
05/28/2015Notice of change in contact information for Michael K. Lavanga and Garrett A. Stone filed by M. K. Lavanga. (FAX)5
05/28/2015Notice of change in contact information for Garrett A. Stone filed by M. K. Lavanga. (FAX)3
03/28/2014Notice of withdrawal of Joseph E. Oliker filed by F. Darr on behalf of McNees, Wallace & Nurick LLC.4
04/06/2012Notice of withdrawal of counsel and substitution of counsel, Mark Yurick from the law firm of Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, formerly Chester, Wilcox & Saxbe, LLP filed by M. Yurick.2
06/30/2011Notice of withdrawal of counsel for Ann M. Hotz filed on behalf of OCC by A. Hotz.2
04/20/2011Correspondence concerning change of address of Glenn S. Krassen. (FAX)2
11/16/2010Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Joseph M. Clark in these proceedings filed by McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC by J. Oliker.6
10/06/2010Notice of withdrawal of counsel, L. McAlister, filed on behalf of McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC by J. Clark. 5
08/01/2008Motion to withdraw application and memorandum in support filed by J. Burk on behalf of First Energy Service Company.10
07/31/2008Motion and memorandum in support to withdraw application filed on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk. (FAX)10
01/30/2008Recommendations concerning public hearings filed on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner. (Original)7
01/29/2008Recommendations concerning public hearings filed on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.(FAX)7
01/15/2008Notice of the withdrawal and substitution of counsel filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc.7
10/19/2007Reply comments of the Council of Smaller Enterprises filed by S. Millard.10
10/16/2007Letter on behalf of Midwest Independent Power Suppliers filed by F. Greenberg. (original)6
10/15/2007Response on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy filed by D. Rinebolt.9
10/15/2007Reply comments of The Ohio Energy Group filed by D. Boehm.12
10/15/2007Reply comments on behalf of The Cities of Maumee, Northwood, Oregon, Perrysburg, Sylvania and Toledo, The Village of Holland, the Board of Township Trustees for Lake Township, and The Board of County Commissioners, Lucas County (For The Unincorporated Areas of Lucas County), collectively referred to as The Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition ("NOAC") by L. Keiffer.14
10/15/2007Revised Reply Comments of The Energy Marketers and Suppliers electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc. and Constellation NewEnergy and Direct Energy and Strategic Energy, LLC and Integrys Energy Services, LLC34
10/15/2007Reply comments correction for page 12, filed on October 12, 2007 on behalf of OCC, by J. Small.2
10/15/2007Certificate of service filed by S. Millard on behalf of The Council of Smaller Enterprises.6
10/12/2007Reply comments of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc., electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc. and Constellation NewEnergy.81
10/12/2007Reply comments of the Energy Marketers and Suppliers, electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc. and Constellation NewEnergy and Direct Energy and Strategic Energy, LLC and Integrys Energy Services, LLC.28
10/12/2007Response to the PUCO staff comments dated September 21, 2007, filed by S. Kozey on behalf of Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator, Inc. 5
10/12/2007Reply comments of the cities of Maumee, Northwood, Oregon, Perrysburg, Sylvania and Toledo, the Village of Holland, the Board of Township Trustees for Lake Township, and the Board of County Commissioners, Lucas County (for the unincorporated areas of Lucas County) collectively referred to as the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, filed by L. Keiffer. (FAX) 14
10/12/2007Response of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy filed by D. Rinebolt. (FAX)9
10/12/2007PJM Power Providers Group Reply to Staff Comments on the FirstEnergy Companies' Proposed Competitive Bid Process, electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of PJM Power Providers Group.14
10/12/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of the Council of Small Enterprises filed by S. Millard. 3
10/12/2007Reply comments of the Ohio Energy Group filed by K. Boehm. (FAX)3
10/12/2007Comments of Citizen Power on the application of the FirstEnergy Companies filed by W. Gruber. 7
10/12/2007Motion for Leave to Intervene of the Electric Power Supply Association, electronically filed by Miss Nancy B. Bagot on behalf of Electric Power Supply Association.13
10/12/2007Correspondence Letter with comments and attachment electronically filed by Ms. Susan M Kelly on behalf of PJM Interconnection6
10/12/2007Reply comments filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and the Consumers for Fair Utility rates filed by J. Meissner. 11
10/12/2007Reply comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by L. McAllister. 14
10/12/2007Reply comments of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company, filed by S. Nourse. 32
10/12/2007Response to staff comments on FirstEnergy Companies' proposed competitive bid process filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of the Ohio Manufactures' Association and the Ohio Hospital Association. 7
10/12/2007Letter in response to the staff comments filed in this proceeding filed by F. Greenberg on behalf of Midwest Independent Power Suppliers. (FAX)5
10/12/2007Reply comments of Ohio Edison Company, the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Compay's filed by J. Burk.73
10/12/2007Reply comments of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, filed by A. Hotz. 20
10/12/2007Reply comments of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc., filed by J. Bentine, Esq.28
10/11/2007Reply comments filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and the Consumers for Fair Utility Rates filed by J. Meissner. (FAX)11
10/05/2007Comments of the Ohio Environmental Council, electronically filed by Mr. Nolan M Moser on behalf of the Ohio Environmental Council.5
09/21/2007Staff comments on FirstEnergy Companies' proposed competitive bid process filed by T. McNamee, PUCO Staff.24
09/18/2007Reply of Citizen Power to the Companies memorandum contra motion to intervene filed by W. Gruber.9
09/17/2007Reply to the Companies' memorandum contra Citizen Power's motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by J. Meissner on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumers for Fair Utilities Rates. (Original)7
09/14/2007Reply of Citizen Power to the memorandum contra motion to intervene of the applicant, filed by W. Gruber. (FAX)9
09/14/2007Service notice.18
09/14/2007Reply and memorandum in support to the memorandum contra Citizen Power's motion to intervene filed by J. Meissner on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and Consumers for Fair Utility Rates. (FAX)7
09/13/2007Entry ordering the September 12, 2007 entry be corrected nunc pro tunc, as set forth in Finding (2).2
09/12/2007Service notice.18
09/12/2007Entry ordering that Staff shall have until Friday, September 21,2007 to file its comments concerning the Companies' application and any proposals for alternative methodologies to the Companies' application; any interested persons shall have until Friday, October 21,2007 to file a response to the comments and/or alternative proposals to the Companies' application. (JS)2
09/11/2007Motion for an extension submitted on behalf of the staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, filed by T. McNamee.6
09/07/2007Reply memorandum in support of motion to intervene of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company filed by S. Nourse.9
09/06/2007Comments of the Ohio Energy Group filed by M. Kurtz. (original)23
09/06/2007Comments of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy filed by D. Rinebolt.13
09/05/2007Motion for Leave to Intervene and Preliminary Comments of Strategic Energy, LLC, electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Strategic Energy, LLC.14
09/05/2007Initial Comments of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc., electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc. and Constellation NewEnergy.26
09/05/2007Motion for Leave to Intervene and Preliminary Comments of Integrys Energy Services, Inc., electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Integrys Energy Services, LLC.14
09/05/2007Comments of the cities of Maumee filed by S. McAdams, Northwood filed by B. Ballenger, Oregon filed by P. Goldberg, Perrysburg filed by P. Gwyn, Sylvania filed by J. Moan, Toledo filed by L. Kovacik, the Village of Holland filed by P. Skaff, the board of township trustees for Lake Township filed by T. Hays, and the board of county commissioners, Lucas County filed by L. Keiffer, (for the unincorporated areas of Lucas County), collectively referred to as the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition("NOAC").11
09/05/2007Comments of the Ohio Energy Group filed by M. Kurtz. (FAX)18
09/05/2007Comments of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy filed by D. Rinebolt.13
09/05/2007Comments of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council filed by G. Krassen.11
09/05/2007Comments of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company by M. Resnik.11
09/05/2007Comments of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by L. McAlister.29
09/05/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Nucor Steel Marion Inc.12
09/05/2007Comments filed on behalf of PJM Power providers Group by G. Thomas.3
09/05/2007Initial comments of Nucor Steel, Marion, Inc. filed by J. Bentine.38
09/05/2007Correspondence stating that Ohio Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Toledo Edison Company will not be filing comments but reserves the right to file response to comments and/or proposals as provided by AE entry dated August 16, 2007 filed by T. O'Brien.1
09/05/2007Motion for admission pro hac vice of Garrett A. Stone and Michael K. Lavanga and memorandum in support filed by J. Benitne on behalf of Nucor Steel Marion, Inc.10
09/05/2007Initial comments of Direct Energy Services, LLC filed by D. Stinson.27
09/05/2007Initial comments by the office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by A. Hotz.29
09/05/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by D. Stinson on behalf of Direct Energy Services, LLC.7
09/04/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc. by B. Royer.8
09/04/2007Service notice.18
09/04/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by J. Meissner on behalf of The Neighborhood Environment Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland and The Consumers For Fair Utility Rates.9
09/04/2007Motion for extension of time to reply to the companies' memorandum contra motion to intervene filed by W. Ondrey Gruber on behalf of Citizen Power. (ORIGINAL)3
08/31/2007Entry ordering Citizen Power shall have until Friday, September 14, 2007 to file its reply. (JS)2
08/31/2007Motion for extension of time to reply to the companies' memorandum contra motion to intervene filed by W. Ondrey Gruber on behalf of Citizen Power.(FAX)2
08/31/2007Memorandum contra motion to intervene of Columbus Southern Power and Ohio Power Company filed by The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel.8
08/30/2007Notice of withdrawal as an intervenor by the Utility Workers Union of America, Local Number 270 filed by R. Fronek5
08/30/2007Motion for leave to intervene and memorandum in support of FPL Energy Power Marketing, Inc. filed by S. Huntoon.5
08/30/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, Cleveland Housing Network and The Consumers For Fair Utility Rates filed by J. Meissner. (FAX)9
08/29/2007Comments of the Cleveland Foundation filed by R. Stuebi.11
08/27/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by T. O'Brien on behalf of The Ohio Manufacturers' Association.5
08/24/2007Memorandum contra Citizen Power's motion to intervene filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk. (original)8
08/23/2007Memorandum contra motion to intervene of Citizen Power filed by J. Burk on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company. (FAX)8
08/20/2007Motion to Intervene by the Ohio Environmental Council electronically filed by Mr. Nolan M Moser on behalf of The Ohio Environmental Council6
08/16/2007Service Notice40
08/16/2007Entry ordered that comments and alternative proposals to application be filed by September 5, 2007, that Commission staff comments be filed by September 14, 2007, and any interested persons may file comments by October 5, 2007. (KWB)2
08/16/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company filed by M. Resnik. 9
08/10/2007Motion Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc, Motion for Leave to Intervene and Preliminary Comments electronically filed by Stephen M Howard on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc.9
08/10/2007Motion Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc., Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Cynthia A. Fonner and Divesh Gupta, electronically filed by Stephen M Howard on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and Constellation Energy Commodities Group, Inc.6
08/10/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of the communities in the Northwest Ohio aggregation coalition filed by L. Kovacik counsel for Toledo, L. Keiffer counsel for Lucas County, S. McAdams counsel for Maumee, P. Goldberg counsel for Oregon, P. Gwyn counsel for Perrysburg, T. Hays counsel for Lake Township, B. Ballenger counsel for Northwood, J. Moan counsel for Sylvania and P. Skaff counsel for Holland. 7
08/08/2007Motion of Citizen Power to intervene and memorandum in support filed by W. Ondrey Gruber. 8
08/06/2007Motion to intervene, motion for hearing and memorandum in support filed by G. Krassen on behalf of the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council. 8
08/06/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Cleveland Foundation R. Stuebi. 15
08/01/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by J. Clark.6
08/01/2007Motion for leave to intervene and memorandum in support filed by R. Fronek on behalf of Utility Workers Union of America, local Number 270.5
07/30/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by R. Giannantonio on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.7
07/27/2007Motion to intervene of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. and memorandum in support filed by R. Giannanotonio. (FAX)8
07/26/2007Motion to intervene, memorandum in support and motion to practice Pro Hac Vice before the Commission filed by D. Rinebolt on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy.9
07/20/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of the Ohio Hospital Association by R. Sites.16
07/17/2007Service Notice38
07/13/2007Motion for leave to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Ohio Energy Group, by M. Kurtz.5
07/12/2007Letter filed on behalf of FirstEnergy to serve as notification to the PUCO that it is being served upon all persons that were parties in the companies electric transition plan ("ETP") cases and upon all certified suppliers that are currently registered to provide competitive retail electric service in the companies' service territories, by J. Burk. (FAX)1
07/12/2007Entry ordered that a technical conference be held at 9:30 a.m. on Thursday, August 16, 2007, in hearing room 11-E at the Commission's offices. (KB)2
07/12/2007Service Notice2
07/11/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of OCC by J. Small.8
07/10/2007Application continued. (Part 3 of 3)170
07/10/2007Application continued. (Part 2 of 3)186
07/10/2007In the matter of the application of the Ohio Edison Company, the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company for approval of a competitive bidding process for standard service offer electric generation supply, accounting modifications associated with reconciliation mechanism and phase in, and tariffs for generation service. (Part 1 of 3)223