DIS - Case Record for 04-0221-GA-GCR Skip to main content

Case Record For:

04-0221-GA-GCR

File a Public Comment
Case Title: COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO INC
Status: CL-CLOSED
Industry Code: GA-GAS
Purpose Code: GCR-Gas adjustment clause
Date Opened: 1/2/2004
Date Closed: 7/28/2009
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
07/27/2009Case action form closing case effective 7/27/09.1
04/20/2009Tariff PUCO No. 2 electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.21
04/08/2009Service Notice4
04/08/2009Entry ordered that the proposed tariffs filed on March 6, 2009, be approved. 3
03/27/2009Revised tariff pages, PUOC Tariff No. 2 electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.8
03/06/2009Revised tariff pages PUCO tariff No. 2 filed by L. Martin on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio.45
01/20/2009Correction to January 16, 2009 filing regarding the CHOICE Program Sharing Credit for PUCO Tariff No. 2 electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.5
01/16/2009PUCO No. 2 Tariff pages electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.6
10/31/2008Revised tariff sheets for PUCO Tariff No. 2 filed by D. Creekmur on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.11
09/24/2008Entry ordered that the final revised tariffs filed by Columbia on February 22, 2008, be approved, ordered that the new tariffs shall be a date not earlier than November 1, 2008. 3
09/24/2008Service Notice4
08/19/2008 Joint notice of agreement as to implementation of proposed tariffs electronically filed by Howard Petricoff on behalf of Ohio Gas Marketers Group.5
05/02/2008Comments of the Ohio Gas Marketers Group filed by M. Petricoff.13
04/03/2008Tariff PUCO No. 2 electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.8
02/22/2008Revised tariff pages, PUCO Tariff No. 2, filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc. by S. Seiple. 45
01/28/2008Tariff PUCO No. 2 electronically filed by Ms. May L Battig on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.8
01/25/2008Transcript with exhibit for hearing held on Friday, January 11, 2008 at the offices of PUCO before Gregory Price, Attorney Examiner.26
01/23/2008Opinion and order ordering that the 2007 stipulation of the parties be adopted and approved; Concurring Opinion of Commissioner Paul A. Centolella.17
01/23/2008Service Notice4
01/22/2008Letter with revisions for the joint stipulation and recommendation filed by S. Seiple on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.4
01/11/2008Notice of the withdrawal and substitution of counsel filed by J. Bentine on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.3
01/11/2008Motion for intervention and memorandum in support on behalf of Integrys Energy Services, Inc. filed by B. Singh.7
01/07/2008Letter stating that Commerce Energy, Inc., Direct Energy Services, LLC, Hess Corporation, Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. and Vectren Retail LLC wish to add their names to the signatory parties supporting the stipulation filed by H. Petricoff.2
01/07/2008Additional information filed by B. Singh on behalf of Integrys Energy Services, Inc.1
12/31/2007Service notice4
12/31/2007Entry ordering a hearing be scheduled for January 11, 2008, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio, 43215. (GP) 2
12/28/2007Joint stipulation and recommendation filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, S. Seiple; Staff, A. Hammerstein; Ohio Consumers' Counsel, L. Sauer; Bay Area Counsel, G. Krassen; Ohio Farm Bureau; Ohio Hospital Association, T. O'Brien; Ohio Manufacturers' Association, T. O'Brien; Honda of America Mfg., Inc.J. Airey; Industrial Energy Users-Ohio, S.Randazzo; North Coast Gas Transmission, LLC, W. Newcomb Jr.; Ohio Gas Marketers Group, H. Petricoff; and Dominion Retail, B. Royer.60
05/09/2007Reply brief of OCC filed by L Sauer.48
05/09/2007Reply brief of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by S. Seiple.43
05/09/2007Reply brief of PUCO filed by Staff.20
05/09/2007Reply brief of Dominion Retail, Inc. filed by B. Royer.7
05/09/2007Reply brief of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed by G. Hummel.12
05/09/2007Post-hearing reply brief of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. filed by B. Singh.19
05/09/2007Post-hearing reply brief of Honda of America MFG., Inc. filed by W. Airey.17
05/09/2007 Reply brief of the Ohio Marketers Group filed by M. Petricoff.15
04/18/2007Letter stating that IEU-Ohio gives notice that it will not file an initial brief, however, IEU-Ohio reserves the right to file a reply brief, by G. Hummel.1
04/18/2007Initial post-hearing brief on behalf of Honda of America MFC., Inc. by J. Airey.6
04/18/2007Notice regarding post-hearing briefs on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. by B. Singh.5
04/18/2007Post-hearing initial brief on behalf of the Ohio Gas Marketers Group by H. Petricoff.4
04/18/2007Post-hearing brief on behalf of OCC by L. Sauer.70
04/18/2007Initial brief on behalf Dominion Retail, Inc. by B. Royer.11
04/18/2007Post-hearing brief of staff of PUCO by S. Reilly.32
04/18/2007Post-hearing brief on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.79
04/13/2007Service Notice3
04/13/2007Entry ordering that the revised briefing schedule set forth in Finding (5) be adopted. (GP)2
04/09/2007Motion for indefinite extension to file initial post-hearing briefs and request for expedited ruling and memorandum in support by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by L. Sauer.6
04/03/2007Service Notice3
04/03/2007Joint motion for extension to file initial post hearing briefs and request for expedited ruling be Interested Stakeholders filed by J. Sauer on behalf of OCC.10
04/03/2007Entry ordered that the joint motion for extension of time to file initial post-hearing briefs be granted and filed by April 10, 2007. (GP)2
03/12/2007Transcript w/exhibits of proceedings before Hearing Examiners S. Lesser and G. Price on February 26, 2007. (Volume V)115
03/06/2007Transcript w/exhibits cont'd (Part 2 of 2)80
03/06/2007Transcript w/exhibits of proceedings before Hearing Examiners Steven Lesser and Gregory Price at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 on February 20, 2007. (Part 1 of 2)201
02/22/2007Prepared surrebuttal testimony of Stephen E. Puican filed by S. Reilly.7
02/22/2007Surrebuttal testimony of Michael P. Haugh filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.9
02/20/2007Return of service subpoena stating that Dale Arnold is hereby required to appear on February 26, 2007, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the PUCO 180 E. Broad St, 11th floor Columbus, Ohio 43215.2
02/15/2007Transcript and exhibits for hearing held February 1, 2007, before G. Price, Hearing Examiner. (Volume III)162
02/15/2007Transcript and exhibits for hearing held January 31, 2007, before G. Price Hearing Examiner. (Volume II)219
02/15/2007Confidential documents: Exhibit 1, 9 pages, and Exhibit 5, 17 pages. filed with the transcripts on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio.1
02/15/2007Subpoena stating that Dale Arnold is hereby required to appear on February 26, 2007, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, 180 E. Broad Street, 11th Floor, Columbus, Ohio 43215.1
02/15/2007Service Notice5
02/15/2007Motion for subpoena and memorandum in support filed by L. Sauer on behalf of the OCC.6
02/15/2007Entry ordered that the hearing in this matter will be rescheduled for rebuttal testimony for February 20, 2007, at 9:30 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, 11th floor, Hearing Room 11-C, Columbus, Ohio 43215-3793 and for February 21, 2007. (GAP)2
02/13/2007Confidential Excerpt from Volume 1 (35 pgs) Exhibit 2 (28pgs) and Exhibit 3 (42pgs) (OCC), filed under seal.1
02/13/2007Transcript w/exhibits of hearing held before Hearing Examiners Steven d. Lesser and Gregory Price at the offices of the Commission on January 30, 2007. Volume 1132
02/12/2007Notice regarding its intent to cross examine rebuttal witnesses and its intent to file surrebuttal testimony, filed on behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio staff by S. Reilly-Attorney General Section.6
02/08/2007Prepared rebuttal testimony of Michael D. Anderson on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.21
02/08/2007Prepared rebuttal testimony of Larry W. Martin on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.59
02/08/2007Prepared rebuttal testimony of Scott D. Phelps on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.36
02/08/2007Prepared rebuttal testimony of Thomas J. Brown, Jr., filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.9
01/30/2007Motion for protective order, memorandum in support filed by S. Seiple on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.15
01/30/2007Motion and memorandum in support to quash the Office of the Consumers' Counsel subpoenas of Columbia Gas of Ohio Inc., filed by S. Seiple on behalf of OCC. 11
01/30/2007Confidential document; Revised response to data request #12, attachment 2, part 2 filed by S. Seiple on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.1
01/29/2007Memorandum contra to the motion for continuance of Columbia Gas of Ohio, filed by L. Sauer on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. 12
01/29/2007Return of service, served on S. Zurbrick of Energy Gateway LLC.1
01/26/2007Motion for continuance and memorandum in support on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., filed by S. Seiple. 6
01/25/2007Service Notice2
01/25/2007Entry ordering that the motions to intervene filed by Ohio Gas Marketers, Dominion Retail and OFBF be granted.2
01/25/2007Return of service Energy Gateway filed by W. King.1
01/25/2007Return to service filed by W. King.1
01/25/2007Return of service filed by W. King.1
01/25/2007Motion for subpoena duces tecum, memorandum in support filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.12
01/25/2007Motion for subpoena, memorandum in support filed by L. Sauer on behalf of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.8
01/24/2007Motion for limited intervention, memorandum in support filed by W. Newcomb on behalf of North Coast Gas Transmission, LLC.5
01/22/2007Motion to intervene and comments filed by D. Arnold filed by The Ohio Farm Bureau Federation.7
01/19/2007Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by B. Royer in behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc.8
01/17/2007Staff's notice of withdrawal of the prepared testimony of Stephen E. Puican filed December 13, 2006 filed by S. Reilly.3
01/11/2007Motion for limited intervention by Commerce Energy, Inc. Direct Marketing Limited, Hess Corporation, Interstate Gas Supply, Inc., MxEnergy, Inc. and Vectren Retail LLC, (Ohio Gas Marketers Group), memorandum in support filed by M. Petricoff.8
12/29/2006Service Notice2
12/29/2006Entry ordered; that the motion to strike filed and the motion to limit the scope of cross-examination filed by Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., be denied, that a hearing be scheduled for January 30, 2007, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio 43215. (SDL)6
12/29/2006Transcript of proceedings held before Hearing Examiner Steven Lesser at the offices of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio on December 15, 2006. (concluded)19
12/28/2006Reply memorandum to the memoranda contra of the Ohio office of the Consumers' Counsel and the PUCO staff, filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. by S. Seiple.13
12/22/2006Memorandum contra to the motion to strike and to limit the scope of cross examination filed by L. Sauer on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel.23
12/21/2006Memorandum contra to the motion of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. to strike the testimony of the office of Consumers' Counsel, and the PUCO staff, and to limit the scope of cross examination, filed on behalf of the staff of the PUCO by S. Reilly-Attorney General Section.6
12/21/2006Prepared supplemental testimony of Stephen E. Pucian, filed by PUCO.16
12/19/2006Proof of legal notice on behalf Columbia Gas Co. filed by S. Seiple.37
12/14/2006List of exhibits on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by S. Seiple.3
12/14/2006Motion of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc to strike the testimony of OCC and of the PUCO staff and to limit the scope of cross-examination, memorandum in support filed by S. Seiple.20
12/14/2006Motion of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. for a continuance, memorandum in support filed by S. Seiple.7
12/14/2006Memorandum in support of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.'s motion for continuance and motion to strike the testimony of the OCC and to limit the scope of cross-examination filed by G. Hummel.8
12/14/2006Comments of Honda of America MFG. Inc. in support of motion to strike OCC testimony filed by J. Airey.4
12/14/2006Comments of Honda of America MFG., Inc. in support of continuance filed by J. Airey.3
12/14/2006Memorandum contra to the motion to intervene and comments of Honda of America MFG. Inc. and the motion to intervene of the Industrial Energy Users-Ohio on behalf of OCC filed by L. Sauer.12
12/13/2006Prepared testimony of Stephen E. Puican on behalf of the PUCO staff filed by S. Reilly.8
12/12/2006Deposition of Michael D. Anderson, filed on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.66
12/12/2006Deposition of Heather Bauer, filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.58
12/12/2006Deposition of Larry W. Martin, filed on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.55
12/12/2006Deposition of Thomas J. Brown, filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.57
12/12/2006Deposition of J. Michael Ripley, filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.27
12/12/2006Deposition of Scott D. Phelps, filed on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by L. Sauer.104
12/11/2006Motion to intervene and comments of Honda of America filed by J. Airey.9
12/11/2006Motion to intervene, memorandum in support filed by G. Hummel on behalf of The Industrial Energy Users-Ohio.6
12/08/2006Prepared testimony of Michael P. Haugh on behalf of The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel.27
12/08/2006Prepared testimony of Bruce M. Hayes on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel.79
11/29/2006Prepared direct testimony of J. Michael Ripley of behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by S. Seiple.7
11/29/2006Prepared direct testimony of Thomas J. Brown, Jr. on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by S. Seiple.7
11/29/2006Prepared direct testimony of Scott D. Phelps on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio , Inc. filed by S. Seiple.11
11/29/2006Prepared direct testimony of Larry W. Martin of behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filed by S. Seiple.12
11/29/2006Prepared direct testimony of Michael D. Anderson of behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. filled by S. Seiple.20
11/13/2006Service Notice1
11/09/2006Entry ordering that staff's request to continue the hearing date is granted in accordance with finding (2). (SDL)2
10/25/2006Motion for continuance of the staff of PUCO, filed by S. Reilly.2
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Michael D. Anderson and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Thomas J. Brown and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Heather Bauer and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Larry W. Martin and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of J. Michael Ripley and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
10/02/2006Amended notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Scott D. Phelps and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer.3
09/25/2006Notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Michael D. Anderson and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.3
09/25/2006Notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Scott D. Phelps and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.3
09/25/2006Notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Larry W. Martin and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.3
09/25/2006Notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Thomas J. Brown and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.3
09/25/2006Notice to take deposition upon oral examination of Heather Bauer and request for production of documents filed by L. Sauer on behalf of OCC.3
09/15/2006Report on the management/performance audit of the gas purchasing practices and policies of Columbia Gas of Ohio filed by the McFadden Consulting Group, Inc.87
11/17/2005Service Notice1
11/17/2005Entry granting OCC's requests to intervene in both cases; that IGS' motions to intervene in both cases are granted. (GLP)2
10/12/2005Entry ordered that management / performance audits of the gas purchasing practices and policies of the companies be conducted in accordance with the provisions of RFP No. U04/05-GCR-1 and the findings of this Entry; that each Company enter into a contract with its designated auditor to perform the work required to conduct the management / performance audits pursuant to RFP No. 04/05-GCR-1 and the findings of this Entry, ordered that the cost of the audits be paid by the Companies pursuant to the findings of this Entry.3
10/12/2005Service Notice1
09/30/2005Motion for intervention and memorandum in support filed by B. Singh on behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.6
09/26/2005Transcript for proceedings before hearing examiner Stephen Lesser, at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, commencing at 10:05 A.M., on Thursday, September 15, 2005 in hearing room 11-F, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215.5
09/14/2005Entry ordering that public hearings shall be conducted in these matters consistent with the findings herein, each company to cause publication between fifteen and thirty days prior to the date set for the hearings which are as follows; The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, June 20, 2006 at 10:00 A.M. ; The East Ohio Gas Company, July 18, 2006 at 10:00 A.M. ; Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, October 17, 2006 at 10:00 A.M. and Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc., November 14, 2006 at 10:00 A.M. all to be held at the offices of the Commission, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215.6
09/14/2005Service Notice1
08/24/2005Entry ordering that public hearings shall be conducted in these matters consistent with the Findings herein at the time specified in Finding (3); that the audits for Reporting Quarters pursuant to Finding (6), herein, shall be filed with the Commission; that the Commission Staff submit the Request For Proposal for conducting each management/performance audit to various auditing and consulting firms, as required under Chapter 4901:1-14, Ohio Administrative Code, and Findings (8) and (9); that the Companies bear the cost of the management/performance audit as provided in Finding (10); that the notice required in Finding (4) shall be published in substantially that form, as individually applicable, and shall be published in a section of the newspaper other than the legal notice section; that the Companies and the auditors shall observe the requirements set forth herein.6
08/24/2005Service Notice1
07/15/2005Independent Accountants' report on applying agreed-upon procedures for uncollectible expense recovery mechanism and accounts receivable regulatory asset balance filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio by the Board of Directors.3
07/15/2005Annual examination of the financial procedural aspects of the uniform purchased gas adjustment for the twelve months ended October 26, 2004 filed on behalf of Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc.3
03/30/2005Motion to intervene on behalf of The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by L. Sauer.5
02/18/2005Service Notice1
10/06/2004Entry stating that public hearings be conducted in these matters consistent with the findings at the time specified in finding (3); that the notice required in Finding (4) be published in a section of the newspaper other than the legal notice section; that the audits for the Reporting Quarters be filed with the Commission pursuant to Finding (6); that the auditors provide the documentation necessary to support their conclusions and recommendations as specified in Finding (13).6
10/06/2004Service Notice1
01/02/2004In the matter of the regulation of the purchased gas adjustment clauses contained within the rate schedules of Columbia Gas of Ohio and related matters.1