Skip to main content

Case Record For:

03-2144-EL-ATA

File a Public Comment
Case Title: FIRSTENERGY CORPORATION
Status: OPEN-OPEN
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: ATA-Application for tariff approval
Date Opened: 10/21/2003
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
01/17/2007Letter of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company (Companies) indicating that the Companies are extending the date for Commission action to address and acceptably resolve the issue on remand from January 15, 2007, the date set forth in the September 29, 2006 letter, to and including April 16, 2007. The Companies are also revising the effective termination date to a date to be specified but not before June 29, 2007 filed by J. Burk.1
01/16/2007Letter extending the date for Commission action filed by J. Burk on behalf of First Energy(FAX).2
10/19/2006Motion to withdraw on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by R. Pace.4
10/02/2006Letter to provide a notice of termination to the Commission of those provisions of there Rate Stabilization Plan subject to termination filed by J. Burk on behalf of First Energy.1
09/29/2006Letter stating that the companies are extended the date for Commission action to address and acceptably resolve the issue filed by J. Burk on behalf of FirstEnergy. (FAX)2
07/27/2006Service Notice11
07/26/2006Entry ordering that FirstEnergy file its plan for complying with the requirements of Section 4928.14, Revised Code, within forty-five days of this entry.4
07/24/2006Letter filed in support of the Remand Proposal put forth by the Ohio Consumers' Council allowing for a competitive billing process and for an opt in program for customers, filed on behalf of The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition by J. Meissner.1
07/21/2006Letter filed in support of the Remand Proposal put forth by the Ohio Consumers' Council allowing for a competitive billing process and for an opt in program for customers, filed on behalf of The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition by J. Meissner. (FAX)1
07/20/2006Request to initiate proceeding on remand, filed on behalf of the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, Ohio Edison Company and the Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk.12
07/20/2006Remand proposal filed on behalf of the office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel by K. Bojko and Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, filed by City of Toledo by L. Kovacik, on behalf of Lucas County by L. Keiffer, City of Northwood by B. Ballenger, City of Sylvania by J. Moan, City of Oregon by P. Goldberg, Village of Holland by P. Skaff, City of Perrysburg by P. Gwyn and City of Maumee by S. McAdams.15
06/14/2006Correspondence letter filed by S. Collins1
12/15/2005Revise PUCO tariff No.11 filed by Steven Ouellette on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.116
12/15/2005Revise PUCO tariff No.8 filed by S. Ouellette on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company.165
12/15/2005Revise PUCO tariff No.13 filed by S. Ouellette on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company.125
12/07/2005Finding and order approving the proposed tariff revisions of OE, CEI, and TE to the extent set forth in Finding (4).2
12/07/2005Service Notice10
11/01/2005Revised PUCO Tariff filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company. (part 1 of 3)149
11/01/2005Tariff continued. (part 2 of 3)148
11/01/2005Tariff continued. (part 3 of 3)148
05/31/2005Supreme Court Transmittal Papers.4
04/29/2005Notice of Appeal filed on behalf of OCC by J. Small ( S.C. No. 05-766)12
03/16/2005Entry denying OCC's application for rehearing.4
03/16/2005Service Notice11
03/14/2005Supreme Court Decision by T. Moyer.1
02/28/2005Memorandum contra The Ohio Consumers' Counsel's application for rehearing filed by D. Stinson on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company.9
02/28/2005Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company contra The Office of the Consumers' Counsel's application for rehearing filed by H. Liebman.8
02/18/2005Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by J. Small12
01/26/2005Supreme Court Transmittal papers.4
01/21/2005Joint Notice of Appeal of appellants, City of Maumee by S. McAdams, City of Northwood by B. Ballenger, City of Oregon by P. Goldberg, City of Perrysburg by P. Gwyn, City of Sylvania by J. Moan, City of Toledo by L. Kovacik, Village of Holland by P. Skaff, and Board of County Commissioners of Lucas County by L. Keiffer.11
01/20/2005Service Notice11
01/19/2005Entry ordering that the FirstEnergy returning customers pricing plan is approved as modified in findings (11) and (12).6
01/18/2005Service Notice for Supreme Court Transmittal Papers11
01/14/2005Supreme court transmittal papers.32
01/13/2005Service Notice12
01/12/2005Entry stating that the date for submission of contracts should be extended to January 31, 2005.3
01/12/2005Entry ordering that the findings in this entry be observed. (SL)2
01/10/2005Response to comments on return pricing filed by D. Stinson on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company's.9
01/07/2005Letter stating that NOPEC filed comments on return pricing, unfortunately, there was an inadvertent typographical error on page 7 under paragraph C, the word contracts should have been comments.1
01/05/2005Comments of Dominion Retail, Inc. concerning the pricing plan for returning customers filed by J. Sanders.5
01/05/2005Comments of The Dayton Power and Light Company filed by E. Rizer.5
01/05/2005Comments of WPS Energy Services, Inc. filed by B. Singh.10
01/05/2005Comments filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison.11
01/05/2005Comments filed by G. Krassen on behalf of the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council .11
01/05/2005Comments to FirstEnergy's proposed pricing plan for shopping customers returning polr service filed by D. Stinson on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company.34
01/05/2005Comments concerning provider last resort pricing plan filed by H. Petricoff on behalf of MidAmerican Energy Company and Strategic Energy LLC.16
01/05/2005Notice of appearance and request for service of papers filed by D. Stinson on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company.6
01/04/2005Motion for extension of time and memorandum in support filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company. 5
01/04/2005Service Notice12
01/04/2005Comments of the Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company's filed by P. Colbert.9
01/04/2005Comments of The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by C. Mooney.16
01/04/2005Entry ordering that the comments of FirstEnergy by filed by January 5, 2005. (SL)2
12/27/2004Service Notice12
12/22/2004Entry stating that comments to the FirstEnergy filed pricing plan, the alternatives raised in this entry as well as other proposals, should be filed by January 4, 2005; that applicability of any proposed pricing plan to other utility rate stabilizations plans may be also discussed(SL).3
12/15/2004Notice of Appeal(Corrected) by The Office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by J. Small.11
12/01/2004Tariff sheet, original Sheet No.49, 4th revised page 4 of 7 for The Toledo Edison Company reflecting the shopping credit value filed by S. Ouellette.2
11/30/2004Notice of appeal filed by J. Small on behalf of the Office of the Consumers' Counsel.11
11/24/2004Service Notice11
11/23/2004Third Entry on Rehearing is denied; that the Motions to Strike is denied.3
11/15/2004Service Notice11
11/12/2004Service Notice11
11/08/2004Tariff sheets reflecting the shopping credit values filed by S. Oquellette on behalf of FirstEnergy.23
11/08/2004Complaint in Mandamus filed by K. Bruce for the City of Toledo, by L. Keiffer for the Board of County Commissioners of Lucas County, by P. Gwynn for the City of Perrysburg, by B. Ballenger for the City of Northwood, by P. Goldberg for the City of Oregon, by S. McAdams for the City of Maumee, by P. Skaff for the Village of Holland, and J. Moan for the City Sylvania.17
11/08/2004Tariff sheets for The Ohio Edison Company reflecting shopping credit values filed by S. Ouellette.17
11/08/2004Tariff sheets reflecting the 2005 shopping credit values filed by S. Ouellette on behalf of FirstEnergy.28
11/05/2004Motion to strike, or, in the alternative, memorandum contra FirstEnergy's rehearing application, memorandum in support, filed on behalf of OCC by C. Mooney.15
11/04/2004Memorandum contra to the rehearing application filed by H. Perticoff filed on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company.8
11/03/2004Service Notice11
11/03/2004Finding and Order stating that the proposed tariffs of Toledo Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company are accepted.2
11/03/2004Original action relator's verified complaint in mandamus filed by OCC.10
10/26/2004Rehearing application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company filed by H. Liebman.9
10/04/2004Joint notice of appeal of appellants, City of Maumee, City of Northwood, City of Oregon, City of Perrysburg, City of Sylvania, City of Toledo, Village of Holland and Board of County Commissioners of Lucas County filed by K. Bruce.10
10/01/2004Notice of withdrawal of counsel, Bruce J. Weston for Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.4
10/01/2004Notice of appeal filed by J. Small on behalf of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel. (04-1641)10
09/29/2004Entry ordering that applications for rehearing are denied, in part, and granted, in part as set forth.4
09/29/2004Service Notice11
09/20/2004Reply Comments filed on behalf of Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates filed by J. Meissner. (FAX)10
09/20/2004Reply comments on the competitive bid process of the FirstEnergy Companies and request for PUCO hearing filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition The Empowerment Center of Graeter Cleveland, and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner. (FAX)10
09/17/2004Reply comments filed on behalf of OCC by C. Mooney.14
09/16/2004Service Notice11
09/15/2004Entry granting OCC's application for rehearing.3
09/15/2004Letter of support of application for rehearing and motion for consideration filed by P. Vento on behalf of City of Euclid.2
09/15/2004Proposed pricing plan filed by H. Liebman on behalf of FirstEnergy.4
09/13/2004Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Company and the Toledo Edison Company contra applications for rehearing and/or motions for clarification by K. Kolich, P. Ruxin, H. Liebman.17
09/13/2004Memorandum in response to WPS and Cleveland's application for rehearing and to FirstEnergy's motion for clarification by Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.7
09/13/2004Comments filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel by C. Mooney35
09/09/2004Letter of support for the WPS Energy Services, Inc.'s second application for rehearing and motion for reconsideration filed on behalf of the City of Euclid by Mayor, B. Cervenik and P. Vento, Law Director. (FAX)2
09/07/2004Motion for clarification and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.7
09/03/2004Motion for clarification filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and the Ohio Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.(FAX)7
09/03/2004Motion for clarification of applicants by H. Liebman.6
09/03/2004Motion for extension of time filed on behalf of applicants by H. Liebman.5
09/03/2004Application for rehearing of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition filed by L. Kovacik.16
09/03/2004Motion for clarification of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy filed by D. Rinebolt.15
09/03/2004Application for rehearing or clarification filed on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio by S. Randazzo.5
09/03/2004Application for rehearing and motion for clarification filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and Consumers for Fair Utility Rates and memorandum in support by J. Meissner.7
09/03/2004Service Notice10
09/02/2004Correspondence in regards to FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed on behalf of various consumers.76
09/02/2004Motion for clarification of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy by D. Rinebolt. (FAX)14
09/02/2004Application for rehearing and motion for clarification and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner. (FAX)7
09/02/2004Second application for rehearing, motion for reconsideration and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. filed by J. Bentine.18
08/31/2004Correspondence in regards to the FirstEnergy rate plan filed on behalf of various consumers.42
08/30/2004Memorandum Contra applications for rehearing and motions for clarification of August 4 entry of the office of The Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, CEI, and Toledo Edison Company.13
08/30/2004Various correspondence filed by consumers.35
08/30/2004Memorandum Contra OCC'S Application for Rehearing by Green Mountain Energy Company filed by E. Robinson.12
08/24/2004Supplemental application for rehearing and motion for clarification of August 4 entry of the OCC, filed by K. Bojko.37
08/23/2004Tariff sheets for The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., reflecting the 2005 shopping credit values, filed by S. Quellette.28
08/23/2004Tariff sheets for The Ohio Edison Company reflecting the shopping credit values, filed by S. Quellette.18
08/23/2004Tariff sheets for the Toledo Edison Co. reflecting the shopping credit values, filed on behalf of applicant by S. Quelletette.24
08/19/2004Service Notice10
08/18/2004Entry ordered, that Charles River is hereby selected to perform the consulting activities set forth above, that the FirstEnergy and Charles River shall observe the requirements set forth in this entry.4
08/18/2004Application for rehearing and motion for clarification of August 4, 2004 Entry, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.20
08/17/2004Various correspondence filed by consumers.126
08/17/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers.283
08/12/2004Notice of public hearing for August 19, 2004, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the PUCO , Room 11-C, the purpose of the meeting is to allow FirstEnergy to present its competitive bid proposal, and to further allow interested parties to discuss the proposal prior to the filing, filed on behalf of applicant by J. Burk. (original)2
08/11/2004Notice of public hearing for August 19, 2004, at 10:00 a.m., at the offices of the PUCO, room 11-C, the purpose of the meeting is to allow FirstEnergy to present its competitive bid proposal, and to further allow interested parties to discuss the proposal prior to the filing, filed on behalf of applicant by J. Burk.1
08/06/2004Notice of acceptance of the rate stabilization plan as modified by the Commission in its Order of June 9, 2004 and Entry on Rehearing of August 4, 2004, filed on behalf of applicant by R. Marsh. (original)2
08/05/2004Letter to Commission stating that the Companies accept the Modified Plan, however, the Companies reserve the right to withdraw the Modified Plan should any subsequent adverse action be taken by the Commission or a court, filed on behalf applicant by R. Marsh.(FAX)1
08/04/2004Entry ordering that the applications for rehearing are denied, in part, and granted, in part, as set forth in this entry; that FirstEnergy's proposed methodology for the pricing and distribution of the MSG is reasonable and is approved; that the revised kWh sales targets included in Exhibit 1 to the rehearing application are approved, that FirstEnergy file with the Commission the details of its CBP for Commission approval and that parties wishing to comment on that filing will have 10 days from that filing to file their comments.11
08/02/2004Various correspondence letters opposing the FirstEnergy rate plan. 72
07/29/2004 Letter to solicit bids from consultants to assist in a review of FirstEnergy's competitive bidding process and bid results filed on behalf of PUCO staff.17
07/28/2004Service Notice10
07/28/2004Entry ordered that the Commission staff distribute the requests for proposal to various consulting firms, that FirstEnergy and the consultant shall observe the requirements set forth herein.3
07/23/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate plan.213
07/22/2004Various correspondence letters opposing the FirstEnergy rate plan.139
07/22/2004Correspondence letters filed by various consumers opposing FirstEnergy rate plan.136
07/22/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers the FirstEnergy rate increase.37
07/19/2004Memorandum contra applications for rehearing filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and the Toledo Edison Co. by H. Liebman.38
07/19/2004Letter to Commissioner regarding certain Intervenors raising concerns on rehearing regarding the Commission's modifications to FirstEnergy's Rate Stabilization Plan set forth in its 6/9/04 Opinion and Order (6/9/04) that are incorrect and unsubstantiated by the record in this proceeding, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.2
07/19/2004Memorandum contra application for rehearing filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.34
07/16/2004Correspondence in regards to FirstEnergy's pending rate plan filed by various consumers.89
07/14/2004Updated replacement tariff PUCO No.13 filed on behalf of applicant by S. Ouellette.2
07/13/2004Revised Tariff PUCO No.11 filed on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company in compliance with the second ordering paragraph in opinion and order dated July 7, 2004 filed by S. Ouellette.3
07/13/2004Revised Tariff PUCO No.8 filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company in compliance with the second ordering paragraph in opinion and order dated July 7, 2004 filed by S. Ouellette.3
07/13/2004Revised Tariff PUCO No.13 filed on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company in compliance with the second ordering paragraph in opinion and order dated July 7, 2004 filed by S. Ouellette.3
07/12/2004Memorandum Contra to the application for rehearing of the Industrial Energy Users-Ohio filed on behalf of NOAC by L. Kovacik.5
07/12/2004Correspondence filed on behalf of various consumers.23
07/12/2004Memorandum contra to the application for rehearing of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio by Calpine Corporation, Constellation Power Sources, Inc., Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., MidAmerican Energy, and Strategic Energy LLC by H. Petricoff and J. Condo.13
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen.20
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.30
07/09/2004Application for rehearing and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by B. Singh.27
07/09/2004Application for rehearing and request for clarification of Dominion Retail, Inc. filed by J. Sanders.21
07/09/2004Application for rehearing and motion for clarification of the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel filed by K. Bojko..37
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition by L. Kovacik.33
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.20
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of MidAmerican Energy Company, Constellation NewEnergy Inc., National Energy Marketers Association, Constellation Power Source, Inc., Reliant Resources, Inc., PSEG Energy Resources & Trading LLC and Calpine Corporation by H. Petricoff, C. Goodman, S. Leyden, and J. Condo.14
07/09/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of MidAmerican Energy Company, Strategic Energy LLC, Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and National Energy Marketers Association and The Ohio Manufacturers' Association by H. Petricoff, C. Goodman, and S. Bloomfield.18
07/08/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers.38
07/08/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland and The Ohio Consumers for Fair Utility Rates filed by J. Meissner.19
07/08/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers.101
07/07/2004Correspondence commending Commissions decision to hold a competitive solicitation process to determine standard offer generation rates and suppliers for the FirstEnergy operating companies for the 2006 through 2008 time period and informing intended participants in the stakeholder process.6
07/07/2004Service Notice10
07/07/2004Finding and Order stating that the applications of The Toledo Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Ohio Edison Company are approved as filed.2
07/07/2004Entry on applications for rehearing filed by FirstEnergy and IEU-Ohio are granted.3
07/07/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.56
07/02/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio by S. Randazzo.7
06/30/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.113
06/30/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.17
06/30/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.91
06/28/2004Memorandum contra FirstEnergy's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.19
06/28/2004Memorandum contra to the application for rehearing of the Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and the Toledo Edison Co., filed on behalf of NOAC by L. Kovacik.12
06/28/2004Responses to rehearing application of Ohio Edison Co., Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and Toledo Edison Co., filed on behalf of MidAmerican Energy Co., Strategic Energy, LLC, Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., Constellation Power Source, Inc., National Energy Marketers Assoc. and Reliant Resources, Inc. by H. Petricoff and C. Goodman.18
06/28/2004Memorandum contra the rehearing application of Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and the Toledo Edison Co., filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by B. Singh.24
06/28/2004Memorandum contra rehearing application of the Ohio Edison Co., Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co, and the Toledo Edison Co., filed on behalf of NOPEC by G. Krassen.16
06/28/2004Memorandum contra FirstEnergy's rehearing application, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Co. by B. Weston.15
06/28/2004Memorandum contra of the application for rehearing of Ohio Edison Co., The Toledo Edison Co., and the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. filed on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc. by J. Sanders.10
06/24/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.58
06/24/2004Revised tariffs to comply with Commission order of 6/9/2004, related to the implementation of approved and modified Residential Customer Charge Credits and the 5% Residential Generation Rate credits, filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Co. by S. Quellette.2
06/24/2004Revised tariffs to comply with Commission order of 6/9/2004, related to the implementation of approved and modified Residential Customer Charge Credits and the 5% Residential Generation Rate credits, filed on behalf of CEI Co. by S. Quellette.2
06/24/2004Revised tariffs to comply with Commission order of 6/9/2004, related to the implementation of approved and modified Residential Customer Charge Credits and the 5% Residential Generation Rate credits, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Co. by S. Quellette.2
06/24/2004Tariffs filed on behalf of The Toledo Edison Company by S. Ouellette. (FAX)2
06/24/2004Tariffs filed on behalf of The Ohio Edison Company by S. Ouellette. (FAX)2
06/24/2004Tariffs filed on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company by S. Ouellette. (FAX)2
06/23/2004Letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.85
06/21/2004Various correspondence letters opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.16
06/18/2004Application for rehearing filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company filed by H. Liebman.24
06/18/2004Correspondence in regards to FirstEnergy's rate plan increase filed on behalf of various consumers.41
06/15/2004Service Notice10
06/15/2004Entry Nunc Pro Tunc Ordered, that the Opinion and Order of June 9, 2004, is amended, to provide for the revised sentence as set forth in Finding 2.2
06/11/2004Correspondence letters concerning FirstEnergy's rate plan filed on behalf of various consumers.41
06/10/2004Service Notice10
06/09/2004Opinion and Order, ordered that FirstEnergy undertake a CBP consistent with this order and schedule a meeting with our staff and other interested parties in this proceeding to establish further requirements of the CBP, that FirstEnergy's RSP is approved, to the extent and subject to the modifications and conditions set forth above, that FirstEnergy's request to adjust the 2005 shopping credits is denied; Concurring Opinion of Commissioner Judith A. Jones and opinion of Commissioner Clarence D. Rogers, Jr., Dissenting in Part and Concurring in Part.)61
06/08/2004Correspondence letters opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase. (Part 2 of 2)17
06/08/2004Correspondence letters opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase. (Part 1 of 2)200
06/03/2004Resolution No. R-28-04 filed on behalf of the City of Avon objecting to FirstEnergy rate increase, filed by G. Heyden-Clerk.3
06/02/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.131
05/27/2004Response to correspondence letter filed by Ms. Young, filed on behalf of PUCO staff by D. Gnann, Director of Policy-Consumer Services Dept.2
05/24/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase.69
05/13/2004Letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate plan, filed by H. Kuncha.1
05/07/2004Response letter sent to Jerald F. Clark, Atlas Industries, Inc., filed on behalf of the PUCO by D. Gnann.3
05/05/2004Letters in opposition of application filed by various consumers.3
05/04/2004Transcript of proceedings before Alan R. Schriber, Chairman, Commissioners' and Attorney Examiners R. Gooden and S. Lesser held on April 21, 2004 at the offices of the Commission.104
05/03/2004Correspondence letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate plan, filed by T. Martin.1
04/29/2004Letter stating that the companies will not withdraw the Rate Stabilization Plan as of April 30, 2004 as previously stated in a letter filed March 16, 2004, but reserve the right to withdraw the Plan at any time, filed by A. Alexander on behalf of the companies.1
04/29/2004Letter encouraging the PUCO to allow testimony concerning the First Energy request for rate increases filed on behalf of Ottawa County Commissioners by C. Koebel, J. Papcun, and S. Arndt.1
04/28/2004Letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase, filed by consumer M. Fanelli.1
04/27/2004Correspondence letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase, filed by G. Ferrara.1
04/26/2004Exhibits that Joint Movants displayed and referred to during oral arguments before the Commission, filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine.10
04/26/2004Correspondence letter filed by OCC on behalf of N. Setteur by K. Bojko.3
04/26/2004Correspondence letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase filed by E. Chase.1
04/26/2004Correspondence letter opposing the FirstEnergy rate increase, filed by R. Lorenzo.1
04/23/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed by L. Gourley.3
04/23/2004Response to Mr. Ruggles regarding letter concerning the FirstEnergy Corp. application, filed on behalf of PUCO Staff by K. Lambeck.2
04/22/2004Resolution No. 2004-6 objecting to FirstEnergy's proposal to extend it's current rates filed by Wickliffe City Council by C. Theophylactos.3
04/22/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed by M. Hilty.1
04/22/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed by J. Robbins and the Waldorfs.1
04/22/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed by Portage Township Trustees.1
04/21/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's Rate Stabilization Plan by L. Gourley. (FAX)1
04/21/2004Correspondence letters filed by various consumers in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate plan.5
04/20/2004Correspondence in support of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan filed on behalf of the Greater Akron Chamber filed by D. Colantone. (FAX)1
04/20/2004Correspondence in support of FirstEnergy Rate Stabilization Plan filed by C. Rinehart.1
04/19/2004Resolution 37-04 unanimously adopted April 12,2004 objecting to FirstEnergy Corporation's proposal to extend its current rates filed on behalf of The City of Brunswick by B. Ortiz3
04/19/2004Correspondence letters filed by various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy's rate increase.6
04/15/2004Correspondence letters filed by various consumers opposing the FirstEnergy's rate increase.3
04/15/2004Motion for oral arguments before the Commission and memorandum in support of joint motion or oral arguments and for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, the Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, filed by J. Meissner and for Citizen Power, Inc. by W. Gruber.(original)9
04/15/2004Response to Ms. Molly Brudnick letter to Commission regarding FirstEnergy's rate increase, filed on behalf of PUCO Staff by D. Gnann, Director.2
04/15/2004Service Notice11
04/14/2004Entry ordered that the joint motion for oral arguments is granted, that the oral arguments be scheduled as set forth in finding (4). (RG)2
04/14/2004Correspondence in opposition of First Energy increases filed by various consumers.10
04/14/2004Motion for oral arguments before the Commission and memorandum in support of joint motion for oral arguments and for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner and Citizen Power, Inc. by W. Gruber. (FAX)8
04/13/2004Memorandum contra joint motion for oral arguments and for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of FirstEnergy Service Company by H. Liebman.8
04/13/2004Various correspondence letters from consumers opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase.4
04/13/2004Memorandum contra joint motion, filed on behalf of IEU-Ohio by S. Randazzo.4
04/12/2004Letter to Ms. Budreo concerning FirstEnergy's application filed on behalf of PUCO Staff by K. Lambeck.2
04/12/2004Letter to Mr. Holbrook concerning FirstEnergy's application, filed on behalf of PUCO Staff by K. Lambeck.2
04/12/2004Correspondence letter from consumers opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase.8
04/12/2004Joint motion for oral arguments before the Commission and for expedited ruling and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine and I. Henderson, for OCC by K. Bojko, Green Mountain Energy Co. by E. Robinson, Ohio Markets Group and Constellation Power Services, Inc. by H. Petricoff, Reliant Resources, Inc. by W. Newcomb, Jr., Dominion Retail, Inc.by J. Sanders, NOPEC by G. Krassen, for Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition by K. Bruce and for The Ohio Manufactures' Assoc. by T. O'Brien.15
04/12/2004Various correspondence letters opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase.13
04/12/2004Letter to Mr. Cardenas concerning FirstEnergy's application filed on behalf of PUCO Staff by K. Lambeck.2
04/09/2004Various consumer letters opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase.9
04/08/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate increase filed by various consumers.26
04/08/2004Resolution No. 2356-03, adopted by Cleveland City Council, November 24, 2003, filed on behalf of City of Cleveland, Ohio by V. McCall.2
04/07/2004Correspondence letters from various consumers opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase.24
04/06/2004Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase filed by M. Well.1
04/06/2004Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase filed by M.J. Leber.1
04/06/2004Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase, filed by E. Boitel, Jr.1
04/06/2004Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase, filed by M. Sagraves.1
04/06/2004Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase, filed by P. Burns.1
04/05/2004Consumer letter opposing FirstEnergy's rate increase filed by R. Balker.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan filed by B. Epstein.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan, filed by Richard & Charlotte Moon.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan filed by L. Hoag.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan filed by J. Junga.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan filed by G. Fedorovich.1
04/05/2004Correspondence letter opposing First Energy's rate plan filed by R. Finley.1
04/02/2004Letter in opposition of FirstEnergy and Ohio Edison increases filed by M & R Spall.1
04/02/2004Letter in opposition of FirstEnergy increases filed by T. Schneid.1
04/02/2004Letter in opposition of FirstEnergy and Ohio Edison increases filed by D. Davis.1
04/01/2004A letter in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan.1
04/01/2004Letter in opposition of FirstEnergy Corp's rate stabilization plan.1
04/01/2004Reply Brief filed on behalf of NOAC by L. Kovacik.24
03/31/2004Reply Brief filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates. and Citizen Power, Inc. et al. filed by J. Meissner and W. Gruber.16
03/31/2004Letter in opposition of FirstEnergy-Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. increases filed by M. Bordman.1
03/31/2004Letter in opposition of the increase of FirstEnergy or Ohio Edison filed by F.Eddinger.1
03/31/2004Reply Brief filed on behalf of the staff of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.7
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Ohio Energy Group by D. Boehm.6
03/31/2004Reply Brief of MidAmerican Energy Company , Strategic Energy LLC, Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., National Energy Marketers Association and Constellation Power Source, Inc.36
03/31/2004Reply Brief of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company by K. Kollich, P. Ruxin, and H. Leibman.72
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc by W. Newcomb, Jr.12
03/31/2004Post hearing reply brief in opposition to FirstEnergy's proposed competitive bid process and rate stabilization plan, filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services Inc. by J. Bentine.41
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen.44
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of The Ohio Manufactures Association by S. Bloomfield.13
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers Counsel by K. Bojko.30
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of The Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition by L. Kovacik for City of Toledo, by L. Keiffer for Lucas County, by S. McAdams for City of Maumee, by B. Ballenger for City of Northwood, by P. Goldberg for City of Oregon, by P. Gwyn for City of Perrysburg, by J. Moan for City of Sylvania, and by P. Skaff for Village of Holland,.23
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio by L. McAlister.30
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of PSEG Energy Resources & Trade LLC by S. Leyden.14
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc. by J. Sanders.23
03/31/2004Reply brief filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.27
03/30/2004 Emergency Resolution No. 30-2004 filed on behalf of City of Macedonia, Ohio objecting to the FirstEnergy Corp. proposal to extend its current rates for an additional three years filed by Mayor D. Kuchta.1
03/29/2004Correspondence in opposition of FirstEnergy's rate stabilization plan in the form of a newspaper clipping explaining the plan filed by M. Calander.1
03/29/2004Correspondence in opposition of the rate stabilization plan by First Energy.1
03/25/2004History and pending report with customer statements on Ohio Edison rate increases filed by G. Harriston.1
03/25/2004History and Pending report with customer statement on Ohio Edison rate case filed by E. Blahut.1
03/19/2004Letter to Commission stating that the companies will again extend the decision date and hold open the option of approving the Plan until April 30, 2004, so as to provide the Commission with sufficient time to consider these briefs and render its decision filed on behalf of FirstEnergy by A. Alexander.1
03/18/2004Letter regarding the request by FirstEnergy Companies to approve a rate stabilization plan to govern rates for electric service in the City of Cleveland and the FirstEnergy service area from 2006 through 2008, filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland, Ohio by Mayor Jane L. Campbell.2
03/18/2004Post hearing brief filed on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy by D. Rinebolt. (original)7
03/17/2004Initial brief of PSEG Energy Resources & Trade, LLC by S. Leyden.28
03/17/2004Post hearing brief submitted on behalf of the PUCO by W. Wright.21
03/17/2004Brief filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson and B. Weston.55
03/17/2004Post hearing brief filed on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy by D. Rinebolt.(FAX)7
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of The Kroger Company by M. Kurtz.9
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of Ohio Energy Group, Inc. by M. Kurtz.11
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition and The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland by J. Meissner, and for Citizen Power by W. Gruber.19
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of MidAmerican Energy Company, Strategic Energy LLC, Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. National Energy Marketers Assoc. and Constellation Power Source, Inc. by W. Airey and C. Goodman.54
03/17/2004Post hearing brief filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.59
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc. by W. Newcomb, Jr.26
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of Ohio Manufacturers' Assoc. by S. Bloomfield.17
03/17/2004Initial post hearing brief of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition filed on behalf of City of Toledo by L. Kovacik, Lucas County by L. Kniffer, City of Maumee by S. McAdams, City of Northwood by B. Ballenger, City of Oregon by P. Goldberg, City of Perrysburg by P. Gwyn, City of Sylvania by J. Moan,and Village of Holland by P. Skaff,89
03/17/2004Initial brief of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen.49
03/17/2004Initial Post Hearing Brief in opposition to FirstEnergy's proposed competitive bid process and rate stabilization plan filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine.55
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and The Toledo Edison Co. by H. Liebman.41
03/17/2004Post hearing filed on behalf of Industrial Energy Users-Ohio by L. McAlister.30
03/17/2004Initial brief filed on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc. by J. Sanders.25
03/15/2004Letter filed on behalf of Middlefield Industrial & Commercial Assoc. with view of the rate stabilization plan filed by FirstEnergy, filed by M. Brakey.3
03/15/2004Transcript cont'd (part 2 of 2, Vol. XI)156
03/15/2004Transcript of proceedings held before Attorney Examiners R. Good and S. Lesser on March 1, 2004. (Vol XI, Part 1 of 2)191
03/10/2004Transcript and exhibits, cont'd (Vol. X, Part 2 of 2)110
03/10/2004Transcript and exhibits of proceedings held before Attorney Examiners R. Gooden and S. Lesser on February 25, 2004 at the Commission. (Vol. X, Part 1 of 2)175
03/09/2004Transcript and exhibits of proceedings before Attorney Examiners: R. Gooden and S. Lesser at the Commission on February 23, 2004. (Vol. VIII)69
03/09/2004Transcript of proceedings before Attorney Examiners: R. Gooden and S. Lesser held February 24, 2004 at the Commission. (Vol. IX)7
03/05/2004Transcript for proceedings for Friday February 20, 2004 at 9:00 AM in hearing room 11-B and C. (VOLUME VII)154
03/04/2004Confidential Exhibits and testimony. (FILED UNDER SEAL)49
03/04/2004Transcript and exhibits Cont'd (VOLUME VI) (PART 3 OF 3)270
03/04/2004Transcript and exhibits Cont'd (VOLUME VI) (PART 2 OF 3)201
03/04/2004Transcript and exhibits for Proceedings held Thursday, February 19, 2004 at 9:00 AM in hearing room 11-B and C at the offices of the Commission. (VOLUME VI) (PART 1 OF 3)201
03/03/2004Transcript continued (PART 3 OF 3)47
03/03/2004Transcript Continued (PART 2 OF 3)201
03/03/2004Transcript for proceedings held February 18, 2004 at 9:00 AM in hearing room 11-B and C at the offices of the Commission. (PART 1 OF 3)201
03/02/2004Transcript cont'd. (Vol. 4) (Part 2 of 2)140
03/02/2004Transcript of hearing held February 17, 2004 before hearing examiners R. Gooden and S. Lesser. (Volume IV) (Part 1 of 2).139
03/01/2004Transcript and exhibits continued of hearing held February 13, 2004 at the PUCO before hearing examiners R. Gooden and S.Lesser. (VOL. III) (Part 3 of 3)150
03/01/2004Transcript and exhibits continued of hearing held February 13, 2004 at the PUCO before hearing examiners R. Gooden and S. Lesser. (VOL III) (Part 2 of 3)151
03/01/2004Transcript and exhibits of hearing held February 13, 2004 at the PUCO before hearing examiners R. Gooden and S. Lesser. (VOL. III)(Part 1 of 3)151
02/27/2004Surrebuttal testimony of Jeffrey P. Geisler on behalf of WPS Energy services,Inc. to FirstEnergy's revised application.10
02/27/2004Transcript Continued. (VOLUME II) (PART 2 OF 2)128
02/27/2004Transcript for hearing held February 12,2004 at 8:30 AM in hearing room 11-E. (VOLUME II) (PART 1 OF 2)150
02/27/2004Surrebuttal testimony of Jeffrey D. Merola, filed on behalf of The Ohio Marketers Group and The Ohio Manufactures' Association by H. Petricoff.24
02/27/2004Prepared surrebuttal testimony of Mark Frye, President of Palmer Energy, filed on behalf of The Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by L. Kovacik.20
02/27/2004Surrebuttal testimony of Randell J. Corbin, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.13
02/26/2004Transcript and exhibits Continued. (VOLUME 1) (PART 2 Of 2)94
02/26/2004Transcript and exhibits for hearing held on February 11, 2004 at 10:00 AM. (VOLUME 1) (PART 1 OF 2)151
02/24/2004Rebuttal Testimony of Anthony J. Alexander filed by H. Liebman.44
02/20/2004Withdrawal of motion for protective order for the testimony of Craig R Roach PhD; direct testimony of Dr. Roach filed on behalf of Constellation Power Source, Inc. and Reliant Resources, Inc by H. Petricoff.12
02/20/2004Letter supporting the applicants proposed rate stabilization plan and encourages the Commission to promptly approve the plan filed on behalf of Greater Cleveland Growth Association by S. Millard.1
02/18/2004Letter to Commission opposing the FirstEnergy application filed by R. Capella2
02/18/2004Letter to Commission strongly urging the halt of expedited schedule for FirstEnergy's rate stabilization case and conduct the same full nine month review any other case would get, filed on behalf of Ohio General Assembly members with constituents who are FirstEnergy customers by J. Himes.5
02/10/2004Errata sheets for the depositions of Anthony J. Alexander, David M. Blank, and Harvey L. Wagner filed by H. Liebman.9
02/09/2004Memorandum contra the motion to intervene of St. Charles Mercy Hospital, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Co., CEI and Toledo Edison Co. by H. Liebman.5
02/09/2004Notice that the Ohio Energy Group will not file direct testimony, but reserves the right to file rebuttal, filed by M. Kurtz. 4
02/09/2004Objection filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and the Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.28
02/09/2004Objections of Citizen Power, Inc. filed by W. Gruber.9
02/06/2004Certificate of Service, filed on behalf of the National Energy Marketers' Assoc. by S. Howard.5
02/06/2004Response to the Commission's request for information dated December 9, 2003 filed on behalf of the Midwest Independent Power Suppliers by F. Greenberg.101
02/06/2004Objections to the application filed on behalf of the Ohio Marketers' Group by H. Petricoff.7
02/06/2004Motion for a protective order, filed on behalf of Constellation Power Source, Inc. and Reliant Resources, Inc. by M. Petricoff.7
02/06/2004Objections to the application on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc.filed by W. Newcomb.7
02/06/2004Prepared testimony of Mark Frye, President, Palmer Energy filed on behalf of The Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition and The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council.62
02/06/2004Objections to the application and testimony of FirstEnergy filed on behalf of The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen.27
02/06/2004Motion of the Ohio Marketers Group for a protective order filed by M. Howard. Petricoff.7
02/06/2004Objections filed on behalf of The Ohio Manufacturers' Assoc. by T. O'Brien.5
02/06/2004Objections to FirstEnergy's post market development application filed on behalf of NOAC'S by L. Kovacik and L. Keiffer.8
02/06/2004Testimony of F. Ross Pultz, filed on behalf of Ohio Consumers Counsel by K. Bojko.81
02/06/2004National Energy Marketers Association's objections to FirstEnergy's applications filed by C. Goodman.8
02/06/2004Testimony of Randell J. Corbin, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.27
02/06/2004Direct testimony of Craig R. Roach, PhD. on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc. and Constellation Power Source42
02/06/2004Direct testimony of Jeffrey D. Merola, filed on behalf of Ohio Marketers' Group.43
02/06/2004Testimony and objections of Jeffrey P. Giesler, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc. by B. Singh.27
02/06/2004Testimony and objections of Michael G. Konicek, Director of Public Utilities, filed on behalf of The City of Cleveland by B. Singh.16
02/06/2004Objections to FirstEnergy's application, filed on behalf of The Ohio Consumers Counsel by K. Bojko.11
02/06/2004Testimony of Thomas J. Butler on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc.28
02/06/2004Comments and objections on behalf of Dominion Retail, Inc. by J. Sanders.8
02/06/2004Testimony and objections of Kevin C. Higgins, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Service, Inc. and the City of Cleveland by Bobby Singh.35
02/06/2004Direct testimony of James A. Ajello, filed on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc.9
02/06/2004Objections filed on behalf of Citizen Power, Inc., David Hughes, Kelli O'Neill, and Ron O'Connell by W. Gruber.9
02/06/2004Testimony and objections of Phillip M. Mikulsky, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc.22
02/06/2004Direct testimony of Guy Sharfman, filed on behalf of Ohio Marketers' Group.39
02/06/2004Response of PSEG Energy Resources and Trade LLC to Commission order dated December 9, 2003 filed by S. Leyden.13
02/06/2004Objections to the application filed on behalf of Constellation Power Sources, Inc. filed by J. Airey.6
02/06/2004Direct testimony of Paul Chernick on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company.148
02/06/2004Affidavit of Joseph D. Condo, Senior Counsel of Calpine Corporation filed by J. Condo.6
02/06/2004Objections to the application and testimony of FirstEnergy filed on behalf of applicant by Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.30
02/06/2004Objection to the market-based approach of default Option 1 filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.1
02/06/2004Objections filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition the Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and the Consumers for Fair Utility Rates filed by J. Meissner and A. Kovalchik.28
02/06/2004Direct Testimony of Jeffrey D. Merola filed on behalf of the Ohio Marketers Group. (FILED UNDER SEAL) 19
02/06/2004Confidential Testimony of Craig R. Roach, PhD filed on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc. and Constellation Power Source. (FILED UNDER SEAL)13
02/05/2004Deposition Transcripts of Anthony J. Alexander, David M. Blank, and Harvey L. Wagner, Exhibits A, B and C, respectively, filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland, WPS Energy Services, Inc., Green Mountain Energy Company, The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council ("NOPEC"), the Ohio Marketers Group, consisting of MidAmerican Energy, Strategic Energy LLC, and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition ("NOAC"), and the Ohio Consumers' Counsel ("OCC") filed on behalf of FirstEnergy by S. Chandra, J. Bentine, E. Robinson, B. Weston, G. Krassen, H. Petricoff, L. Kovacik, L. Kieffer, E. Stephens, and K. Bojko. (PART 1 OF 2).285
02/05/2004CONTINUED - Deposition Transcripts. (PART 2 OF 2)285
02/04/2004Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company contra NOPEC and NOAC motion for leave to file joint reply instanter and joint reply filed by H. Liebman.8
02/03/2004Motion for leave to file joint reply instanter and joint reply of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition ("NOAC") and the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council ("NOPEC") to memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company contra the joint motion for a show cause order filed by L. Kovacik, G. Krassen, and L. Keiffer.12
02/02/2004Service Notice6
02/02/2004Entry ordering that the interlocutory appeal not be certified to the Commission. (RG)2
02/02/2004Memorandum of Ohio Edison, Cleveland Electric Illuminating and Toledo Edison contra NOACS's motion for review of transition charges and request for expedited review filed by H. Liebman9
01/30/2004Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company contra the joint motion for show cause order filed by H. Liebman.7
01/30/2004Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company contra the joint interlocutory appeal and motion for certification filed by H. Liebman.8
01/29/2004Letter stating that in order to accommodate the Commission's revised schedule for this case, the companies will hold open the option of approving the plan until March 31,2004 filed on behalf of Anthony Alexander.1
01/27/2004NOAC's motion for a review of FirstEnergy's transition charges and supporting memorandum, and request for expedited review filed by L. Kovacik, L. Keiffer, J. Moan, P. Goldberg, S. McAdams, P. Skaff, B. Ballenger, and P. Gwen. Bruce Weston filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Co..12
01/26/2004The City of Cleveland's notice of appearance of additional counsel and substitution of counsel filed by J. Bentine.7
01/26/2004NOAC's motion for review of transition charges and supporting memorandum, and requests for expedited review filed by L/ Kovacik. (FAX)13
01/26/2004Joint Interlocutory Appeal, Motion for certification to full Commission and request for expedited ruling of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel, City of Cleveland, Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, The Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council, Green Mountain Energy Company, WPS Energy Services, Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates and Citizen Power,Inc. filed by K. Bojko, L. Kovacik, G. Krassen, L. Keiffer, S. Chandra, E. Robinson, J. Bentine, B. Weston, J. Bentine, and J. Meissner.21
01/26/2004Motion to Intervene filed on behalf of St. Charles Mercy Hospital by T. O'Brien.5
01/23/2004Joint motion of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition (NOAC) and the Northeast Ohio Public energy Council (NOPEC) to require Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company to show cause why they are not in violation of the hearing examiners orders and Commission entry compelling discovery, motion for sanctions request for expedited ruling and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition by L, Keiffer and Northeast Ohio Public Energy by G. Krassen.14
01/23/2004Service Notice6
01/23/2004Entry ordering that the schedule set forth in finding (3) be observed. (RG)2
01/23/2004Proof of publication (Williams Co.)1
01/23/2004Proof of publication. (Henry Co.)1
01/23/2004Proof of publication. (Ashland Co.)1
01/23/2004Proof of publication. (Sandusky Co.)1
01/23/2004Proof of publication. (Portage Co.)1
01/23/2004Proof of publication (Stark County)1
01/22/2004Letter stating concern for FirstEnergy's request to extend the standard cost payment plan thru 2008 filed by R. Capella.1
01/21/2004Responses to the Interrogatories of Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co., and The Toledo Edison Co., filed on behalf of the Ohio Hospital Association (OHA) by R. Sites.8
01/20/2004Proof of publication filed. (Wood County)1
01/16/2004Letter to Commission relative to the support for the Commission's effort to proactively address the uncertainty related to the scheduled end of the Market Development Period at a time when may of the expectations associated with Ohio's electric restructuring legislation are still a work in process, filed on behalf of The Ohio Home Builders Association, Inc. by V. Squillace.2
01/15/2004Response to interrogatories of First Energy operating companies, filed on behalf of Kroger Company by M. Kurtz.7
01/14/2004Resolution No. 2-04, opposing the changes in the electricity restructuring law proposed by FirstEnergy; and declaring an emergency, filed on behalf of The City of Alliance, Ohio by V. Marion, Director.3
01/12/2004Letter in support of FirstEnergy's proposed plan, filed on behalf of the City of Akron, Ohio by D. Plusquillic, Mayor.1
01/12/2004Various correspondence letters opposing FirstEnergy's proposal currently before the Commission.45
01/09/2004Memorandum contra Green Mountain Energy Company's motion to require FirstEnergy Solutions to respond to the PUCO's entry of December 9, 2003, and request for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. by A. Korkosz.6
01/08/2004Service Notice6
01/07/2004Letters opposing FirstEnergy's application to extend it's market development period.5
01/07/2004Entry ordering that the interlocutory appeal filed by FirstEnergy is denied.3
01/07/2004Testimony of J. Edward Hess on behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.13
01/07/2004Testimony of Robert B. Fortney on behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.16
01/07/2004Testimony of Richard C. Cahaan on behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.21
01/07/2004Testimony of Raymond W. Strom on behalf of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.10
01/07/2004Service Notice6
01/06/2004Reply memorandum in support of motion to order FirstEnergy Solutions to submit Generation Services Market-related information and request for expedited review, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine.12
01/05/2004Notice of Deposition schedule of Green Mountain Energy Company's (GMEC) served 11/24/2003, to begin on Tuesday, January 13 at 10:00 am filed by B. Weston.3
01/05/2004Motion and Memorandum in support to require FirstEnergy Solutions to respond to the PUCO's entry on December 9, 2003 and request for expedited ruling by Green Mountain Energy Company filed by E. Robinson.7
12/31/2003Letter in support of the rate stabilization plan of FirstEnergy Corp., filed on behalf of Ohio Schools Council by K. Neal.1
12/30/2003FirstEnergy Solution Corp's memorandum Contra WPS Energy Services, Inc.'s motion to order FirstEnergy Solutions to submit generation services market-related information filed by A. Korkosz.7
12/22/2003Correspondence opposing FirstEnergy's proposal currently before the PUCO, filed on behalf of Champion Local S.D. by B. Gillespie.1
12/22/2003Correspondence letter opposing the FirstEnergy proposal currently before the PUCO, filed on behalf of Sheffield-Sheffield Lake City S.D. by R. Lindsey, Supt.1
12/22/2003Amended motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Midwest Independent Power Suppliers by J. Migden and F. Greenberg.6
12/22/2003Correspondence opposing FirstEnergy's proposal currently before the PUCO, on behalf of Beaver Local S.D. by W. Adkins.1
12/19/2003Motion to order FirstEnergy Solutions to submit generation services market-related information, memorandum in support of motion, and request for expedited review filed on behalf of WPS filed by J. Bentine.10
12/17/2003Correspondence letter opposing FirstEnergy's proposal, filed by B. Griffith, Mansfield City Schools.1
12/17/2003Transcript with exhibits for proceeding held on Wednesday, December 3, 2003 at 2:30 PM at the offices of the Commission.219
12/16/2003Memorandum Contra to First Energy's Interlocutory Appeal from the communities of Maumee, Northwood, Perrysburg, Oregan, Sylvania, Toledo, the village of Holland and the Board of Lucas County Commissioners filed by L. Kovacik.16
12/16/2003Proof of Pub. (Richland County)1
12/15/2003Memorandum contra to interlocutory appeal of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. and the Toledo Edison Company, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine.12
12/15/2003Memorandum contra, filed on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., MidAmerican Energy Company, Reliant Resources, Inc. and Strategic Energy, LLC by H. Petricoff.11
12/15/2003Memorandum contra to FirstEnergy's interlocutory appeal, filed on behalf of the communities of: Maumee, Northwood, Perrysburg, Oregon, Sylvania, Toledo, the Village of Holland and the Board of Lucas County Commissioners by L. Kovacik.16
12/15/2003Memorandum contra of FirstEnergy's interlocutory appeal, filed on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krasson.8
12/15/2003Memorandum contra, FirstEnergy's Interlocutory Appeal, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.15
12/11/2003Resolution No. 2003-31 filed on behalf of the Village of Bentleyville.2
12/11/2003Proof of publication filed. (Columbiana County)1
12/09/2003Entry requesting all intervening parties intending to provide generation services to retail customers after 2005 file market-related information as part of their testimony due on January 21, 2004.3
12/08/2003Memorandum contra FirstEnergy's application for rehearing, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.11
12/08/2003Interlocutory appeal, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company by H. Liebman.161
12/08/2003Memorandum Contra of WPS Energy Services, Inc. filed by H. Petricoff.9
12/08/2003Letter filed in support of the "Companies" proposed rate stabilization plan (the "Plan"), filed on behalf of OCMR by J. Mahaney, Jr.2
12/05/2003Transcript for hearing held November 25, 2003 held in Kent, Ohio in Kiva Auditorium.32
12/04/2003Transcript of the public hearing held November 24, 2003 in Cleveland, Ohio.111
12/04/2003Proof of Publication (Erie County)1
12/03/2003Motion for admission pro hac vice of Joseph D. Condo and memorandum in support, filed by S. Bloomfield.4
12/03/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Calpine Corporation by J. Condo.6
12/03/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Cargill, Inc. by C. Smith. 5
12/03/2003Motion to admit Freddie L. Greenberg Pro Hac Vice before the Commission by J. Migden.3
12/03/2003Motion to admit Shawn P. Leyden Pro Hac Vice before the Commission by J. Migden.3
12/03/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of Midwest Independent Power Suppliers by F. Greenberg.5
12/03/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support on behalf of Reliant Resources, Inc. by W. Newcomb.8
12/03/2003Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in support on behalf of PSEG Energy Resources & Trade LLC by S. Leyden.6
12/03/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Ohio Hospital Association by R. Sites. 10
12/01/2003Letter regarding the joint motion for oral argument on discovery filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by B. Weston.43
12/01/2003Letter regarding Green Mountain Energy Company's Notice to Take Depositions filed by B. Weston.3
12/01/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support of Local 270, Utility Workers union of America, AFL-CIO filed by R. Fronek.12
11/26/2003Application for rehearing of Ohio Edison Co., The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. and The Toledo Edison Co. filed by H. Liebman.12
11/26/2003A letter asking to halt the expedited review of FirstEnergy's application for a rate stabilization plan and to order a full review based on the normal timeliness and processes established for rate cases filed on behalf of Ohio Citizen Action by S. Weir. (Fax)3
11/26/2003Service Notice5
11/26/2003Motion to intervene, memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Local 270, Utility Workers Union of America, AFL-CIO by R. Fronek.(fax) 19
11/25/2003Entry ordering that the interlocutory appeals and the motions discussed are granted to the extent set forth in findings (7), (8) and (9), ordered the 03-1966 et al. applications are no longer consolidated with the 03-2144 application and the above revised procedural schedule applies only to case 03-2144.4
11/24/2003Notice to take depositions upon oral examination, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.6
11/24/2003Notice to take deposition upon oral examination and request for production of documents, filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko.5
11/21/2003Brief filed on behalf of the PUCO Staff by W. Wright.9
11/21/2003Brief filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company by H. Liebman.20
11/21/2003Brief filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.29
11/20/2003Motion for admission pro hac vice of Peter J.P. Brickfield and Malcom A. Burke to appear as counsel for Vallourec & Mannesmann Tubes Corporation, filed by S. Bloomfield.4
11/20/2003Motion to intervene, memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Vallourec & Mannesmann Tubes Corporation by S. Bloomfield. 5
11/20/2003Proof of Publication filed (Clinton Co.)1
11/20/2003Motion to intervene, memorandum in support and motion for David C. Rinebolt to practice pro hac vice before the Commission, filed on behalf of Ohio Partners for Affordable Energy by D. Rinebolt and M. Smalz-Ohio State Legal Service Assoc. 11
11/19/2003Memorandum in support of motion for oral argument on discovery and request for expedited ruling by Green Mountain Energy Company, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council and Communities in the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc. by J. Bentine.6
11/19/2003Direct testimony of Anthony J. Alexander, David M. Blank and Harvey L. Wagner, filed on behalf of applicant by H. Liebman.48
11/18/2003Proof of Publication filed. (Ashtabula, Ohio)1
11/18/2003Motion for oral argument on discovery and request for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy by E. Robinson and B. Weston, Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen and Communities in the Northwest Ohio Aggregation Coalition by L. Kovacik and NOAC by L. Keiffer.9
11/17/2003Motion for fairness and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of The Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates, by J. Meissner.15
11/17/2003Memorandum contra to the requests for certification of Interlocutory Appeals filed by the NOAC Group, Green Mountain, and WPS Energy, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk and H. Liebman.7
11/17/2003Memorandum contra to the Ohio Marketers' Group's motion to alter and extend the procedural schedule, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company by J. Burk and H. Liebman. 6
11/17/2003Memorandum contra Green Mountain Energy Company's application for rehearing filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and the Toledo Edison Company J. Burk and H. Liebman.7
11/14/2003Proof of publication filed. (Sandusky County)1
11/13/2003Application for review through interlocutory appeal and memorandum in support filed on behalf of interveners by City of Toledo, L. Kovacik; City of Perrysburg, P. Gwyn; City of Maumee, S. McAdams; City of Sylvania, J. Moan; City of Northwood, B. Ballenger; Village of Holland, P.Skaff; City of Oregan, P. Goldberg; and Lucas County, L. Keiffer.18
11/13/2003Proof of publication (Huron County).1
11/13/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the Neighborhood Environmental Coalition, The Empowerment Center of Greater Cleveland, and The Consumers for Fair Utility Rates by J. Meissner.9
11/12/2003Application for review through interlocutory appeal and the memorandum in support filed on behalf of the communities of Maumee, Northwood, Oregon, Sylvania, Toledo, the village of Holland and the Board of Lucas County Commissioners by L. Kovacik. (FAX)20
11/12/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the City of Cleveland by F. Lewis. 10
11/12/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Constellation Power Source, Inc by J. Airey.9
11/12/2003Interlocutory appeal: Motion for certification to full Commission request for expediting ruling application for review filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.15
11/12/2003Interlocutory appeal of procedural schedule and memorandum in support of WPS Energy Services, Inc. filed by J. Bentine.23
11/10/2003Motion Pro Hac Vice filed on behalf of intervenors by H. Petricoff.3
11/10/2003Motion to Intervene of the National Energy Marketers Association by C. Goodman.9
11/07/2003Entry ordering that the applicants testimony will be due by 11/19/2003; that all interested parties will have until 12/3/2003 to file to intervene in this proceeding, file written objections to applicants applications and file testimony. An evidentiary hearing will be held on 12/3/2003 at 10:00 am in hearing room 11-D at the offices of the Commission.Oral arguments for case # 03-1966,1967,1968 will be heard at the Commission meeting scheduled for 11/13/2003 at 10:00. ( SL )3
11/07/2003Motion to alter and extend the procedural schedule and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., MidAmerican Energy Company, Strategic Energy, LLC and WPS Energy Services, Inc. by H. Petricoff.14
11/07/2003Entry ordering that oral arguments will be heard 11/12/2003; FirstEnergy will be provided 30 minutes to present its arguments in favor of the applications; those parties in support or opposition to the applications will be provided an opportunity to present their arguments in response. Opposing parties are encouraged to combine arguments to reduce redundancy. Parties will have until 11/19/2003 to file briefs on the issues argued at the oral arguments. (RG) (Filed November 5, 2003)3
11/07/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Ohio Manufactures Assoc. by S. Bloomfield. 6
11/07/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Citizen Power, Inc. by W. Gruber. 7
11/06/2003Motion to continue and to order a staff investigation, request for an expedited ruling, and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc. by B. Singh.17
11/06/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.9
11/06/2003Application for rehearing of the 10/28/2003 Entry of the PUCO filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson. 14
11/06/2003Proof of Pub filed. (Lucas County)1
11/06/2003Motion to Intervene and Memorandum in support filed on behalf of Citizen Power, Inc., David Hughes, Kelli O'Neil, and Ron O' Connell filed by W. Gruber. 7
11/05/2003Service Notice34
11/05/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the cities of Maumee, Northwood, Oregon, Perrysburg, Sylvania, Toledo, The Village of Holland and The Board of Lucas County Commissioners by L. Kovacik, P. Gwyn, S. McAdams, J. Moan, B. Ballenger, P. Skaff, P. Goldberg, and L. Keiffer.7
11/05/2003Entry ordering that oral arguments and procedures be established as set forth in Finding (6). (RG)3
11/04/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of the city of Toledo, Perrysburg, Maumee, Sylvania, Northwood, Oregon, Lucas county and Village of Holland filed by L. Kovacik,P. Gwyn, S. McAdams, J. Moan, B. Ballenger, P. Skaff, P, Goldberg, L. Keiffer. (FAX)7
11/04/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support filed by J. Bentine on behalf of WPS Energy Services, Inc.9
11/04/2003Application for rehearing or, in the alternative, motion for extension of time filed by K. Bojko on behalf of Ohio Consumers' Counsel. 12
11/03/2003Motion to intervene and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of IEU-Ohio by S. Randazzo. 8
10/31/2003Motion for enforcement and other relief, and request and memorandum in support for expedited ruling, filed on behalf of Green Mountain Energy Company by E. Robinson.11
10/31/2003Motion for clarification and motion for stay, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company by H. Liebman.12
10/31/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council by G. Krassen.9
10/29/2003Service Notice29
10/28/2003Entry stating motions to intervene set forth in finding (2) be granted, with the exception of 02-1944,the captioned cases are consolidated for purposes of hearing, the schedule for filing intervention and objections will have until 11/19/2003, technical procedural conference will be held 11/5/2003 at 10:00 am at the offices of the Commission in hearing room 11B, Applicants testimony will be due on 11/12/2003,all other testimony due by Weds. 11/19/2003. Evidentiary hearing held Weds. 12/3/2003 at 10:00 am at the offices of the Commission in hearing room 11D.Public Hearings to take testimony from public will be held 11/20/2003 at 5:00 pm, Seagate Convention Centre 401 Jefferson Ave, Room 104, Toledo, Ohio and 11/24/2003 at 4:00 pm at the Frank J. Lausche, State Office Building, 615 W. Superior Ave, 6th and Superior, 2nd floor auditorium, Cleveland, Ohio and 11/25/2003 at 6:00 pm at Kent State University, Student Center, Kiva auditorium,Kent Ohio. 7
10/28/2003Motion to Intervene and memorandum in support filed on behalf of The Kroger's Co by M. Kurtz. 5
10/28/2003Motion to Intervene filed on behalf of the Ohio Energy Group by D. Boehm. 3
10/22/2003Motion to Intervene with Memorandum in support filed on behalf of OCC by K. Bojko. 4
10/21/2003In the matter of the application of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company for authority to continue and modify certain regulatory accounting practices and procedures, for tariff approval and to establish rates and other charges including regulatory transition charges following the Market Development Period. 50
11/06/1999Service Notice34