Skip to main content

Case Record For:

03-1238-EL-CSS

File a Public Comment
Case Title: CITY OF HURON VS OHIO EDISON COMPANY
Status: AR-Archived
Industry Code: EL-ELECTRIC
Purpose Code: CSS-Complaint on service or safety
Date Opened: 5/28/2003
Date Closed:
Printable Docket Card Service List
View per page
Date FiledSummaryPages
06/29/2006Service Notice2
06/28/2006Entry on rehearing ordering that the City of Huron's application for rehearing be denied.9
06/19/2006Memorandum of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company in opposition to the City of Huron's application for rehearing filed by H. Liebman.9
06/09/2006Application for rehearing filed by B. Singh on behalf on the City of Huron.34
05/10/2006Opinion and Order ordering that complaint be denied, as set forth in this order; that Huron's motion for expert costs be denied.15
05/10/2006Service Notice2
10/14/2005Post-hearing reply brief filed by B.Singh on behalf of The City of Huron.26
10/14/2005Reply brief of the Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and The Toledo Edison Company filed by A. Korkosz.21
09/22/2005Initial brief of Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company filed by H. Liebman.38
09/22/2005Initial Post-hearing brief of the City of Huron filed by B. Singh.52
08/25/2005Transcript and exhibits continued. (Part 3 of 3)187
08/25/2005Transcript and exhibits continued. (Part 2 of 3)184
08/25/2005Transcript and exhibits for hearing held on August 11, 2005 before G. Price and R. Gooden (AEs). (Part 1 of 3)161
08/24/2005Transcript for hearing held on August 10, 2005 before G Price and R Gooden, Attorney Examiners. (Part 1 of 2)122
08/24/2005Transcript continued. (Part 2 of 2)122
08/10/2005Verification to interrogatory responses filed by B. Morris on behalf of Ohio Edison.3
08/10/2005Errata sheets and executed acknowledgement of deponent regarding the depositions of David Straus and Christopher Norton filed by B. Singh6
08/09/2005Supplemental exhibit list for The City of Huron filed by B. Morris.4
08/08/2005Reply for motion for expert costs filed by B. Singh on behalf of City of Huron.17
08/05/2005Memorandum Contra Ohio Edison Company's motion to strike Mr. David Straus' pre-filed testimony filed on behalf of the City of Huron by B. Singh.13
08/05/2005Exhibit List filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Ohio Edison.5
08/05/2005List of exhibits intended to be used at the hearing filed by B. Singh on behalf of The City of Huron.3
08/04/2005Notice of filing depositions filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.3
08/04/2005Exhibits to deposition of David R. Straus. (Part 2 of 2)140
08/04/2005Exhibits to depositions of, J. Zimmerman, M. Tann and M. Spacek (Part 2 of 2).167
08/04/2005Deposition and exhibits of David R. Straus. (Part 1 of 2).111
08/04/2005 Exhibits to deposition of J. Zimmerman, M. Tann and M. Spacek (Part 1 of 2)200
08/04/2005Deposition of Michael E. Tann.124
08/04/2005Deposition of John A. Zimmerman.58
08/04/2005Deposition of Christopher J. Norton.55
08/03/2005Service Notice2
08/03/2005Entry ordering that the City of Huron's motion to compel discovery be granted in part and denied in part. (GAP)4
08/02/2005Entry ordering that the Ohio Edison Company 's motion to compel discovery be granted; that Ohio Edison's Company's motion for protective order be granted; that OE's motion for leave to file its pre-filed testimony one day out of time be granted. (GAP)6
08/01/2005Witness list filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.3
08/01/2005Memorandum contra, motion for expert costs filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.7
07/29/2005Motion to strike testimony of David R. Straub and request for expedited ruling, memorandum in support filed by H. Liebman on behalf of the Ohio Edison Company.15
07/28/2005Proof of Publication ( Defiance County.)1
07/28/2005Proof of Publication (Madison County).1
07/28/2005Proof of publication (Mahoning County)1
07/26/2005Notice of appearance of counsel of David A. Kutik of Jones, Day as additional counsel for this proceeding, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by H. Liebman.3
07/26/2005Motion for protective order, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by M. Whitt.3
07/26/2005Confidential reply memorandum in support of Ohio Edison Company's motion to compel, filed by M. Whitt. (FILED UNDER SEAL) (25pgs.)1
07/26/2005Reply memorandum to City of Huron's memorandum contra motion for leave to file one day out of time, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by H. Liebman.7
07/26/2005Memorandum contra motion to compel filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by M. Whitt.17
07/25/2005Confidential reply memorandum in support of Ohio Edison's Company motion to compel return of inadvertently produced documents, filed by M. Whitt. (25) (FILED UNDER SEAL)1
07/19/2005Motion for expert costs filed by B. Singh on behalf of The City of Huron.5
07/19/2005Memorandum contra to the Ohio Edison Company's motion for leave to file one day out of time filed by B. Singh on behalf of the City of Huron.27
07/15/2005Memorandum Contra Ohio Edison's Motion to compel discovery related to return of alleged inadvertently disclosed documents and request for expedited ruling filed on behalf of City of Huron by J. Bentine.7
07/15/2005Confidential Memorandum filed on behalf of City of Huron, by B. Singh.1
07/14/2005Motion to compel discovery filed by B. Singh on behalf of the City of Huron.77
07/13/2005Notice of appearance of additional counsel filed by B. Singh on behalf of City of Huron.4
07/13/2005Supplemental responses to Ohio Edison Company's discovery request filed by B.Singh on behalf of the City of Huron.2
07/05/2005Direct testimony of Thomas A. Clark, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by H. Liebman.20
07/05/2005Motion for leave to file one day out of time and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by H. Liebman.5
07/05/2005Direct testimony of William R. Ridmann, filed on behalf of FirstEnergy Service Co. by H. Liebman.5
07/05/2005Direct testimony of Robert M. Martinko on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, filed by H. Liebman.122
07/01/2005Testimony of David R. Straus on behalf of The City of Huron, filed by B. Singh.132
07/01/2005Testimony of Christopher J. Norton on behalf of The City of Huron, filed by B. Singh.71
07/01/2005Testimony of Michael E. Tann on behalf of The City of Huron, filed by B. Singh.131
07/01/2005Testimony of John A. Zimmerman on behalf of The City of Huron, filed by B. Singh.29
06/27/2005Motion to compel discovery and memorandum in support, filed on behalf of Ohio Edison Company by M. Whitt.87
06/15/2005Notice to take depositions upon oral examination and request for production of documents, filed on behalf of The City of Huron by B.Singh.5
06/13/2005Application for subpoena and subpoena duces tecum filed by M. Whitt on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.6
05/23/2005Transcript held May 16, 2005; attorney examiner G. Price.6
05/16/2005Proof of Publication (Sandusky Co.)1
05/02/2005Proof of Pub. (Lake Co)1
04/21/2005Service Notice1
04/20/2005Entry stating that the Ohio Edison Company's request for an extension of procedural schedule be granted and the procedural schedule set forth in finding (5); that the public hearing be held on May 16, 2005 at 10:00 a.m., for the purpose of taking public testimony then continued until August 10, 2005 at 10:00 a.m., hearing room 11F, at the Commission offices. (GP).3
04/20/2005Proof of Publication (Portage Co.) (FAX)1
03/30/2005Reply to Ohio Edison's expedited motion for extension of the procedural schedule filed by J. Bentine on behalf of the City Of Huron.5
03/29/2005Motion for extension of the procedural schedule and request for expedited ruling, memorandum in support filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison Company.7
02/07/2005Service Notice1
02/04/2005Entry ordered, that the Ohio Edison Company's request for an extension of the procedural schedule is granted and the procedural schedule set forth in finding (4) be observed; that the public hearing in this matter commence on Monday, May 16, 2005, at 10:00 a.m., in Hearing Room 11-F, at the offices of the PUCO; that notice of the hearing be published in accordance with finding (6). (GAP)3
01/28/2005Letter agreeing with the procedual schedule filed 1/27/05 filed by B. Singh on behalf of the City of Huron.1
01/27/2005Motion for extension of procedural schedule filed by H. Liebman on behalf of Ohio Edison Company, respondent.3
11/05/2004Service Notice1
11/04/2004Entry stating that the parties request is granted and hearing be held on 4/11/05, at 10:00 a.m., Hearing Room 11-F, at the Commission offices. (RG)2
10/14/2003Additional Information filed by H. Liebman.1
09/23/2003Letter stating Ohio Edison Company and the City of Huron collectively requested that the procedural schedule set forth in September 5, 2003, entry be extended by two weeks, filed by B. Singh.1
09/05/2003Entry ordering that the parties' request is granted and the procedural schedule set forth in finding (4) be observed. (RRG)2
09/05/2003Service Notice.1
08/13/2003Entry ordering that a prehearing conference should be scheduled for Wednesday, September 3, 2003, at 10:00 a.m., in Hearing Room 11-E, at the offices of the Commission, 180 E. Broad Street. Columbus, Oh 43215-3793. (RG)6
08/13/2003Reply memorandum to the Ohio Edison Company's memorandum contra motion to intervene and memorandum contra motion to consolidate, filed on behalf of The City of Huron by J. Bentine.13
08/05/2003Ohio Edison Company memorandum contra City of Huron's motion to consolidate, filed by H. Liebman.5
07/21/2003Motion to consolidate and memorandum in support, filed on behalf the City of Huron by J. Bentine.7
06/30/2003Answer filed on behalf of respondent Ohio Edison Company by H. Liebman.7
06/18/2003Letter regarding an extension of time until June 30, 2003, to file Ohio Edison's answer, filed on behalf of respondent, Ohio Edison, by H. Liebman.1
05/29/2003Complaint and complaint letter sent to Leila Vespoli of Ohio Edison and Helen Liebman, attorney at law.1
05/28/2003In the matter of the complaint of the City of Huron vs. Ohio Edison Company, request for declaratory judgement. 16